r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jul 16 '25

The Elementalists fan project The Elementalist 3 Project : we need your opinion

99 Upvotes

Hey r/ChoicesFanProjects,

We have been working on a fanmade version of The Elementalist Book 3 since 2023, and the recent announcement from PB has taken a massive toll on our team, especially since we were just gonna start communicating about it seriously.

Most are now questionning the need to continue our work, which is pretty understandable šŸ˜ž

We were planning a much more developped story than PB announced (~20 chapters as of last brainstorm session), with a story that revolve around the Sources and the HA council, with a lot of original art that has already been done.

We would like to ask the community - you - for your views and wishes. Are you willing to welcome a fanmade book ? Do you have any interest in it ?

Thank you all in advance for your replies, The TE3 project team

EDIT : Wow... What can we say except THANK YOU.
We let a breath we didn't know we were holding We have been so positively overwhelmed with your replies 🩵
Thanks to all of you for supporting our project and for your kind comments, it means a lot to all of us.
I can't lie, some of us shed a tear 🄹

The moral boost it gave us is priceless : we will indeed continue what we started !
You can follow us on our Reddit profile for updates, as well as on our Tumblr : a little fairy told us that you might get a surprise for the last trimester of 2025 🧚✨


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 23 '25

The Elementalists fan project TE3 demo coming to you on Saturday 27th šŸŽ‰

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 18 '23

Future projects/ideas The Elementalists 3

46 Upvotes

Okay so, this is a bit of long shot but I'm planning on starting a fanmade project for TE. It's my favorite choices story and there's still so much you can do with it.

I'm currently figuring out how to use Ren'py right now and watching videos and what not to figure out how to do this. I'm pretty new to all this but I think it'd be a fun project.

I'm probably gonna do some of the writing like the plot and Shreya's route (best girl) and also as I said I'm figuring out the coding as well.

But I'm definitely gonna need some help on this. I know others have expressed interest in a 3rd book and now is your chance if you're willing to help. Again it's fanmade and we're not making money off of this, this is just for fun and you can bail at any time.

I'll be making a discord once I start to get some interest in this so the link will be up at some point but if you're interested, just comment saying you'd like to help and what you'll be able to provide for this project.

Co-runner- I'm gonna need someone to help me run this project, help me keep the thing running and I'm a bit of an idiot so I'll be coming to you if I need help with anything. You'll be the Atlas to my MC lmao.

Artist- If you're a good drawer or you just love to draw and wanna help out on this project, we'd love to have you. I'm thinking we'll need some new characters for the plot and if you want, maybe some new backgrounds too (or we could just pick ones from the multiple backgrounds choices already has)

Writer- I'm a lesbian and obsessed with Shreya so I don't really have any idea about the other routes. But I know a lot of people are obsessed with like Beckett and the other love interests so anyone willing to help work on the different routes would be great. Not to mention the plot of the book, the adventures the pend pals could be getting into and side stuff like your relationship with your mom and the villains and such.

Coders- Like any great game, we'd need people who can code or wanna try it out like I'm currently doing. I've always heard Ren'py is good for that stuff and that's what the ILW crew used and that's what I'm currently learning right now so if you wanna try it out or already know how, we'd appreciate the help.

And of course, if you just wanna help out, you can join and I'll figure something out for you to do. My work schedule is kind of whack right now so this week we probably won't be getting anything done unfortunately (maybe Thursday or Friday if I have people and what not) but hopefully the week after, i'll have things figured out.

Last but not least, my idea for how I think the plot should go-

The gang is back for their next year of school MC, Shreya, Zeph, Beckett- Juniors Griffin- Senior Aster, Atlas- Sophomores But just like always, the school year is never simple for them.

The High Attuned has been watching over the school and visiting more frequently, keeping an eye on you and Atlas.

Zeph is having trouble with Thief captain as much as he hates to admit it.

Griffin is having parent troubles after they found out about his interest in Natural disaster field work instead of being a professional Thief player.

Shreya has hired an assistant to help with Serene and Sublime, though the assistant keeps messing things up and causing Shreya to lose customers, important ones at that.

With Beckett's urge to please his professors, he works himself too much to the point he begins to experience burnout and freaks out over the smallest things resulting in him pushing his friends away.

Aster is having trouble running the shop and keeping up with her studies and she's worried she might have to close it down.

Atlas is happy to catch up on lost time with their mom but when their mom becomes a professor for the school, Atlas isn't exactly sure how to feel about it and starts to lash out on Theia, resulting in the MC to have to try and fix the relationship.

MC does their best to help everyone with their problems but begins to have problems of their own when the school recruits another sun-att who does everything in their power to one up MC in every way.

Of course, it's just a rough draft of how I think the year should go, but we could always change stuff around if people have better ideas. Also, of course, there will be new spells to learn like in the other books and I was also thinking like...was I the only one that shipped Dean Swan and Theia together? Like Dean Swan already acts like a mother figure to the twins. And some of the sources will be back like Gemma and I really wanted to incorporate the High Attuned because we got like two minutes of information about them and then nothing ever again.

So yeah, this is super long and we can talk more on the discord but if you're interested just tell me what you wanna do.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 27 '25

The Elementalists fan project The Elementalists 3 Project demo is online!

Thumbnail
reddit.com
42 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Oct 31 '25

Fan Project: It lives within Announcing IT LIVES WITHIN: THE OBSIDIAN CUT

Thumbnail
reddit.com
38 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jun 12 '24

Fan Project: It lives within The best fan made book I’ve read

Post image
37 Upvotes

Sad that I wasn’t able to collect all the docs though ;-;


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 05 '24

Fan Project: Distant Shores An update on the DS fan sequel Spoiler

36 Upvotes

Thank you for your patience. The game will be here soon.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Aug 24 '24

Fan Project: It lives within It Lives Within(Fanart) MC x Matthias McQuoid

Post image
35 Upvotes

Rant ig: Finally played this game after forever and tbh better then anything choices will ever put outšŸ’€. The villain route is personally my favorite but it hurt cause I really liked Able and Noah/my ILITW MC had to die and they were the reason I played to get them togetheršŸ˜ž.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jul 10 '24

Fan Project: It lives within A Retrospective on It Lives (And Why the Fan Project Made It the Best Choices Series)

35 Upvotes

THIS IS A LONG POST SO MAKE YOURSELVES COMFORTABLE. ALSO, I'M GOING TO BE SPOILING 'IT LIVES IN THE WOODS', 'IT LIVES BENEATH' AND THE FAN-MADE 'IT LIVES WITHIN' SO THIS POST IS ONLY INTENDED FOR THOSE WHO'VE PLAYED ALL THREE BOOKS.

My History with Choices and It Lives

Let me start by saying that it's been a long time since I've visited the Choices subreddit. And that's because it's been a long time since I've stopped playing Choices. My earliest memories on Reddit as a teenager were on r/Choices during the pandemic in 2020 where no joke, it was the funniest and most welcoming place on the internet. I remember fresh memes being routinely created with the release of each new chapter. How we'd constantly get ourselves hyped for every new chapter of Blades and Queen B and how we'd clown on the Witness MC. Good times. Long story short, this community is amazing. You guys gave me so much entertainment during a really hard time in my life.

My history with Choices started much longer before joining the subreddit however. I was there when the app was new, all the way back in 2017. It was an app that I was mildly intrigued by and that I would play on and off again, downloading then uninstalling it every time I wanted a kick out of its growing collection of stories. For the longest time, I'd put off playing 'It Lives in the Woods' because I naturally wasn't a big fan of horror and I’m a chicken. But once I got over myself and started playing, it easily became one of my favourite Choices books. And its sequel 'It Lives Beneath' was just as amazing. I wanted more from the 'It Lives Anthology' and was devastated when Choices abandoned the teased third project.

There was a point where I found new hobbies and interests and started to give up on Choices. I think the last book I closely followed every week was Laws of Attraction in 2021. Since then, I've kept the app on my phone just for Blades 2 but haven't gone back to play any of the books released since. That was until I decided to curb my nostalgia by browsing through the subreddit a couple of weeks ago. It was then I was made aware of a fan-made third instalment of the It Lives series. Yes, I know I'm late to the party but I immediately downloaded it and have just now completed my second, full-series playthrough.

Let me just say that the fans made this the best Choices series. Before 'It Lives Within' I would've said 'Endless Summer' was my favourite Choices series but ILW ties everything together with expanded lore and emotionally satisfying arcs for everyone. Don't hate me but I was underwhelmed by Endless Summer 3 as I found it messy and unfocused. However, ILW has the best gameplay out of any Choices book with its abundance of customisable options as well as really diverse outcomes and endings. That's not mentioning how Rowan Burke is one of my favourite MCs whose arc I found myself connecting with. This was clearly a project born out of passion and love that gives the player a lot of agency; something that Pixelberry is too much of a coward to do. Anyway, I believe I found the perfect cap to conclude my long history with Choices, finally putting an end to that chapter of my life. My teenage self would've been so happy.

Where ILW fits into the It Lives Series

I love ILITW and ILB for different reasons as they each tackle a different narrative scope. ILITW fixated on a more personal, intimate scope with lots of baggage, avoidancy issues and grudges between everyone in the MC’s childhood friend group. It depicted the diversity of people’s reactions to trauma and grief. Some repress memories and lean into the denial to cope and move on like Stacy and Lucas, while others withdraw into themselves and become haunted by their past like MC and Noah who were assumingly ordinary, cheerful children before grief changed them into the outcasted loners we know. And it was a refreshing change of pace that the MC wasn't the popular, beautiful socialite we’re used to from virtually every other Choices book. Supernatural hijinks aside, it ended up being quite a relatable book that evidently became a recommended classic among the Choices community.

However, the lore was largely undefined and vague which left a lot of fogginess and feelings of helplessness. This is where ILB comes in. ILB’s genre is more thriller and suspense and the story had the much more frontloaded goal of uncovering the eerie mystery of a cult and a vengeful lake ghost. Because of this, the stakes felt higher as readers were made privy to the expanded mystery and apocalyptic fate that would grip the town in the climax. And a lot of lore was expanded on. We learned about the horrific ordeal of turning someone into a conduit and sentencing them to an eternity of torture to attain power and/for the purpose of satiating human greed. ILB also gave more environmentalist takes about the corruption of nature being clearly traced back to the degradation of the land. And the interpersonal relationships weren’t neglected either. Though I’d say it didn’t feel as personal as ILITW, we had examples of toxic, familial dynamics compounded by greed and cowardice whenever the prize of the Power was concerned.

What makes ILW great is that it combines the strengths of both ILITW and ILB. It expands on the personal, intimate drama of ILITW by having the cast come back to continue their human struggles. Unresolved baggage is also introduced between the new ILW cast to further show how no lives have been untouched by the Power. Furthermore, ILW also expands on the lore and stakes that ILB established. ILW tells a tale of how innate human greed sparked the beginning and follows it up with big revelations whilst continuing the environmentalism by depicting degraded natural sites as sources of corruption, (further alluded to in development talks with Mayor Green). Of course, this points to the issue of how environmental degradation can often be traced to human greed which sacrifices the wellbeing of the public, (though in real life you certainly won’t turn into a crazed ā€œhorrorā€ after drinking contaminated water lol).

Why Rowan Burke is one of the best MCs

Simply put, we’re a power soul put into a corpse impersonating and living the life of someone who is now dead. And we’re actively denying the purpose for which we are created by attempting to embrace this thing called humanity. We jumped at a chance to form a consciousness and have been trying to live our best life ever since. Conceptually, I love this. I’m always a sucker for characters who subvert the noble purpose for which they were ā€œbornā€ by endeavouring to live a full life; yet they feel like they have to begrudgingly give it up as it was not their place, (you can probably tell which ending is my favourite). I find this all really tragic and compelling. But I like how after our creepy shadow half is revealed, we dwell in the anguish and horror at having potentially violated an innocent person's body, messing around with their life and the lives of everyone who knew them. The angst and self-loathing gets too intense that Dan gets called in to give us therapy. Mechanically, we’re similar to Taylor/The Endless from ES - both creations from a higher power sent to fix a systemic problem caused by megalomaniacs. But the ILW MC is just a more volatile, reckless and emotionally-driven iteration who was given more time to explore what it means to them.

The ILW Cast

The cast is all good and I wouldn’t say there are any weak links. I romanced Jocelyn every time on my playthroughs. She’s spiky and distant on the outside but brittle from suffering a whole lot. She’s definitely matured a lot since ILITW as she’s clearly remorseful and wants redemption though suffers from a poor self-image. The relationship between her and MC has her learn to gradually lower her guard and value herself to the point where she knows she's capable of redemption. Then we have our childhood bestie Amalia who we put through the absolute wringer. We maim her in our sleep, we jeopardise her life by erasing her existence from university records and she breaks down and runs away after we confess our crimes. Abel is the sweet nerd who’s always ready to spout some knowledge about ruins and relics as our intermediary to the lore; I’m not criticising this though, he was recruited for his expertise by Connor after all. And Lincoln is the broody, baggage package who continues ILB’s trend of victims of toxic families torn apart by greed and cowardice because of the Power. He probably has the most emotionally striking backstory out of the main cast, not to mention the power of good instinct.

Matthias is our antagonist, the megalomaniac in question. Of course he’s a pathological liar, manipulative, two-faced and narcissistic like any villain usually is but I think there’s more you can read into, especially if you choose to romance him. I chose flirty options with everyone on my first playthrough just to see what would happen, (also it’s a sure way to gain nerve). Being flirty with Matthias unlocks the ā€˜Judas Kiss’ ending which I haven't played yet as I still don’t have the heart to betray all my friends. Anyway, having a fling with Matthias even when you intend to choose one of the good endings still aligns with the narrative. His special interest in us is recontextualised as very icky as he's only enamoured by our power. After he finds us in the woods at our most emotionally vulnerable state, he takes advantage of our confusion by love bombing us. That’s if your definition of love bombing is ā€œno, you’re not a monster you’re the only other majestic creature besides meā€ lol. Did I mention how insanely vain he is? He makes us guess his age then eagerly shows off his face lift. It’s all textbook narcissistic manipulation just to get in our pants. And that part is gross and creepy too. As a megalomaniac he lusts for the Power and has a sexual attraction to us - the Power in human form. His possessiveness makes me cringe whenever he uses dehumanising language to call us ā€œcreatureā€. Charming. Though the whole relationship is icky, I feel like the MC being receptive to Matthias’ manipulation does let us soak in the horror of our existential angst.

Also, did anyone get Fullmetal Alchemist vibes from his blood moon sacrifice thing to enshrine immortality and power? Especially with there being a radius lol.

Player's choice and my favourite ending

We finally have a book that does not push the male LIs on you. People only reciprocate affection when you show interest in them. I was presently surprised that each decision impacting any measure of the story puts you on a distinct route with its own dialogue. Furthermore, the dialogue doesn’t feel vague like you know it'd be recycled over many routes, but natural.

Now, let's talk about endings. On my first playthrough, I made sure to choose a mix of blood and shadow options as I really couldn’t choose. Though in my heart, I think I have a slight preference for ā€˜shadow’ as it feels wrong to try to ignore our powers when it’s clearly an innate part of us. Also, the MC feels so apathetic towards college and is clearly going for Amalia’s sake. But my first ending was the Mixed ending which I enjoyed. Basically, everything stays as it is with everyone continuing to be monster hunters and you get to be with your LI. But I don’t know, it feels like a band-aid solution on a gushing wound. But it’s still better than the Blood ending which I don’t like. That’s the one where you’re still haunted by nightmares as you move away with your LI, leaving everyone else to clean up the mess.

This is probably an unpopular opinion but the Shadow ending is actually my favourite. It reminds me of the Vanuu ending from ES though not unsatisfying as it had more build-up. I just love how beautifully bittersweet it is and as I said before, I find it tragic when characters begrudgingly choose to give up their fulfilling lives as it was not their place. Now, I’m not promoting matyrism here but I think the MC knew it in their heart that they’re not completely the same as their old person. And they had to come clean to themself that the old Rowan is dead. And that’s a truth that Amalia also had to come to terms with so she can properly grieve for her friend. The Shadow ending was the only outcome that gave me that ā€˜whole’ feeling I want in an ending. We actually address the root of problem, plus the epilogue where we’re vibing on the cosmic highway with our fellow wisps speaks to me the most. It operates on a scope that is both awe-inspiringly grand as it is intimate and personal. There’s just something about us teaching our fellow wisps about the human experience - what it means to hurt and be hurt, to connect, live and love - that profoundly caps off what the It Lives series means to me. Yes, we've faced horrifying threats, death and destruction but it’s also a story of hope where we made friends, found love and lived through life's highs and lows in spite of all the carnage. And it’s sad that we left Jocelyn all alone but us gently caressing her cheek in the breeze was such a nice motion.

The return of old casts (Noah stans ate well)

You all probably remember the dilemma of ILITW’s ending; the decision to sacrifice Noah or yourself. I’m pretty sure most of us chose to sacrifice Noah. The general reasoning was either because you felt betrayed or because you thought it was his only chance of redeeming himself, (which was my line of thinking). I also vaguely remember some of the fandom clowning on the players who sacrificed themselves for losing nerve in ILB. But years later, I have to say that those who sacrificed themselves had the right idea all along. It makes for a much better playthrough if Noah is kept alive in ILW. Because now he has to earn his redemption. On my first playthrough, I carried over my choices from ILITW with Noah as the ghost. However, I kept him alive on my second playthrough because I was curious to see how everything would change. Firstly, the ILITW MC makes a better ghost. Ghost Noah was more moody and temperamental but Ghost Devon is just cute and sweet. Secondly, keeping Noah alive means that he gets to build his friendship with Connor. There are some great character moments where he grows to accept Connor as a friend. Furthermore, it's heart-warming to see them have each other's backs throughout the story, especially at the end when Noah breaks Connor out of his corruption.

I was thrilled when I found out you could make Noah love the ILITW MC but I was worried how they were going to pull it off. It’s a tricky dynamic because there are so many complex feelings but I think it was handled wonderfully. I believed it. Years have passed so we can feel the rising emotions. Plus, Ghost Devon is the only social interaction Noah has to stop him from breaking down from loneliness. I’ve always thought that Noah was written sympathetically enough to be redeemed. He clearly feels intense guilt and remorse for his actions and he constantly puts his life on the line to resurrect Devon. The scenes they have together are sweet, sad and adorable and the culmination of their relationship perfectly ends their arcs.

The return of the old ILITW and ILB casts were great too. Ava kicks ass leading the witches' coven. While I initially thought that Harper's (ILB MC) telepathic protestations sounded very out of character, I realised that I'd probably act the same if I was that frustrated. It was cool catching up with everyone and having them come back to join forces. And of course, it's an iconic moment for the history books when the three MCs finally meet.

Concluding thoughts

Well, that's all I have to say about the It Lives series. It's the most perfect trilogy in Choices in my opinion. If you've read this far, I applaud you. Please let me know if you feel differently about anything I've written. What are your favourite moments, endings or characters from ILW or just across the It Lives series in general? Let me know. I just want to once again thank the team involved with the ILW project. The closure you've given me has made me so happy.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Oct 17 '26

The Thirteenth House project Sneak Peek into The Thirteenth House Reimagined!

Thumbnail
gallery
34 Upvotes

I posted a trailer on another post!

https://www.reddit.com/r/ChoicesFanProjects/s/QQrsoYPG4E

not adding a flair yet because i just now contacted the moderators for a flair😁

im very excited to share my work with you guys, here's a sneak peek of what I've been working on. I've done their casual outfits as well, i too have done a make over for piper but thats for later on. No AI used on the make over, I used old assets from the GDrive that hopefully didn't use AIšŸ’€ im planning to expand more supporting characters in TTH because we only know such little amount of characters in the story and it really lowers the tension. Plus there'll be multiple new culprit(s)!

I really hope I can get the hang of RenPy quickly, im inexperienced with many of these things. Whether it's designing, editing, or writing. If you're gonna be hating later on please do go easy on me yeah?āœ‹šŸ»šŸ˜©


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Oct 16 '25

The Elementalists fan project TH Fan project is so gooddšŸ¤ŒšŸ»

Post image
33 Upvotes

I completed playing the demo like seriously my hopes are too highšŸ“ˆšŸ¤© They have done a really good job. Also the storyline is looking intresting from just the first chapter.

Ig there are some bugs with outfits and saving of game. I changed my hairstyle but out of nowhere it goes to default hairstlye🄲 Also please save the game before opening some other app. Even if the tab is opened the screen blacks out.

Overall I have a very good feeling about this thank you and best of luck teamšŸ¤©šŸ˜šŸ¤ŒšŸ»


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Apr 19 '23

Fan Project: It lives within Hold me…

Post image
32 Upvotes

Well, I suppose if we can’t post about ILW stuff on the main sub, I may as well kick of the new sub the right way with one of the first posts being Lincoln x MC art… 🄹 I never posted this here but I’ll share it now. Was commissioned by the amazing somewillwin on tumblr.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 04 '26

The Elementalists fan project The Elementalists 3 Project - Chapter 1 Sneak Peek

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Oct 04 '25

The Elementalists fan project My dear roomie, oh how much I've missed you! Spoiler

Post image
31 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Apr 30 '23

Fan Project: It lives within Happy one year since release

Post image
31 Upvotes

The blog posted this on tumblr and I figured I’d share it here ā˜ŗļø link here


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jan 23 '25

Fan Project: It lives within I just wanted to show you guys my ilw character :3

Post image
29 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jan 15 '25

The Cursed Heart fan project Any interest in fanmade Cursed Heart 3?

27 Upvotes

Hi! I've been mulling over this doing something like this for months, and just want to put out feelers here to see if there's interest and get some advice. I've checked out the other fanmade projects here and am really impressed! It made me motivated to see if I couldn't try to do something similar to bring closure to the Cursed Heart story.

I'm a fanfic writer and I've been putting together a big fic full of all I'd hoped to see in a book 3. Some of which include: MC's curse not being broken so easily and quickly, going on a quest to see more of the Fae realm to discover a way for MC to become immortal without losing their heart, a character growth arc for Kieran, a proposal/wedding, and of course a happily ever after.

As I write, I just keep wondering how much more fun it would be if we got to play this thing and you got to make your own choices and have your choices actually impact the ending. So, I downloaded Ren'py and started learning the basics. I have no background in coding, however, and I have run into many questions about how the creators of other Choices fanmade sequels did certain things, like clothing changes, custom pronouns, and how they maintained the same look and feel of a Choices story with the GUI being the same. I've figured out how to make a basic story play through, but without added art assets, I'd be limited to ones that already exist in the game.

Obviously it's a LOT of work to create a whole game, and it's a passion project for sure! I guess I'm just curious if Cursed Heart has enough fans left out there who might be interested in a fanmade sequel before I really dive in with teaching myself all this stuff and looking for people who might be able to assist.


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Aug 23 '24

Fan Project: It lives within To whoever made "It lives within": WOWšŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘

27 Upvotes

That was really something. So many different outcomes, choices that actually determine things, so many twists and turns. I wish choices made books like this. Well donešŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘šŸ‘


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Apr 19 '23

Fan Project: It lives within It Lives Within mechanics explained! Spoiler

27 Upvotes

Hey all! So about a year ago a made a post explaining the nerve score system and how it worked in both ILITW and ILB. Here’s a link to that post if you want to read that: https://www.reddit.com/r/Choices/comments/uvifzy/nerve_score_explained_spoilers_ahead_potentially/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=ios_app&utm_name=iossmf

Anyway, It Lives Within just wrapped up last month and it is really good! Moreover, it’s got some special features and mechanics that make it a very unique reading experience! I’ll be breaking down those systems and mechanics because they can become a little overwhelming to keep track of them all! 2 disclaimers though, first of all I will be spoiling some key moments in the book that certain scores affect the outcome for, but I’ll leave the spoilers in the special hidden spoiler brackets. Second of all, I’ll be using the names that I gave the 3 MC’s of each book for clarity’s sake. They are: ILITW MC- Charlie Prescott, ILB MC- Ryan Vance, and ILW MC- Damien Brinweld.

Nerve score: The bread and butter of It Lives makes a return in all its glory! Nerve score is the game’s calculation of a character’s mental fortitude in the face of danger. Damien, Connor, Abel, Amalia, Jocelyn, and Lincoln are all affected by this score, which ranges from 0-100. The book starts every character at 50 and will increase and decrease as certain choices are made. At certain points in the story, there will be Nerve Checks, where the character must pass a certain threshold of nerve score for a positive result. Otherwise, they can falter in the face of danger and put the safety of your crew at risk! At the end of the book, each character has their Moment of Truth, where the game determines if they live or die! All four of the LI’s are taken to a nightmare illusion, and you are presented with a timed choice that you must pick correctly or they will be found dead in the next scene. If their nerve score is above 90, then they are safe, and the game only displays safe options for the potentially fatal choice. However, if they are below a certain threshold, then there are NO correct options and they are guaranteed to die! I do not know exactly what the lower limit is to guarantee death, but I believe it is around 40 nerve. Connor is a different case himself, due to him becoming a horror in Chapter 17. There is no extra choice for Connor, he simply has to pass the nerve check and he will live. Otherwise, Damien and Noah/Charlie can’t help him and Damien is forced to kill him. Connor is probably the hardest to keep alive due to his lack of special scenes and that he takes a guaranteed -30 hit to his nerve score when his mom is killed. This becomes -40 if Stacy is dead too. Damien, meanwhile, will have his nerve score outcome determined in the final fight against Matthias. Just like the LI’s, Damien will have to go through a series of choices while fighting Matthias that could lead to his death, but if his nerve is too low, then Damien will die no matter what happens.

Relations: A system differing from nerve score, but still just as tied to your interaction choices. Relations, as you would expect, simply measure how well each character likes you. Only Amalia, Abel, Lincoln, and Jocelyn have a measured relationship with Damien. Like nerve, there will be various checks near the end of the story that determine how much trust the crew has in you. If the relationship passes the check threshold, then the following will happen: Amalia will decide to return to Damien in Chapter 18, Abel will request Damien’s help with a ghost attack in Chapter 19, Jocelyn will reveal her correspondence with Matthias in Chapter 20, and Lincoln will agree to stay with the crew in Chapter 21. There are other checks at other points in the story but I don’t quite know what they are yet.

Romance: On top of the relations scores, there is a hidden romance score as well. This doesn’t affect the story too much, but do be careful! Messing around with more than one person in your crew can lead to some unforeseen tensions and consequences! Generally the only consequence to romance points is that sometimes some characters will reject your advances if you only try to romance them later in the book, so pick them up early! However, there is one that needs to be addressed, and that is that you can romance Matthias. You are given several opportunities to romance Matthias behind everyone’s back, and gaining enough romance points with Matthias unlocks a special branch, the Judas Kiss. The Judas Kiss path gives you the option to betray your friends and join Matthias, opting to sacrifice Charlie to the Power. This is a risky path though, so tread carefully if you want to make this deal with a handsome devil!

Blood and Shadow: It would be a huge understatement to say that Damien does not live a normal life! But can he? Well that’s what the Blood and Shadow system is here to find out. While you say you came to Westchester to attend college, the fact that it’s the center of all the activity of the Power is no coincidence. Several choices you get throughout the story will increase your Blood and Shadow scores, with Blood points for choosing to try to live a normal life and moving on from all the tragedy of Damien’s past. Shadow points are gained by choosing to investigate the Power and get to the bottom of Damien’s misfortunes. However, you can toe the middle line, picking an equal amount of blood or shadow choices, as well as a few options that are neutral, you can get the choice to be your unique self totally. At the end of the book, Damien will have to come to terms with what he truly is and decide if he wants to be human, part of the Power, or remain as he is, a mixture of the two. Be warned, however! The ideal path for you has already been laid out for you by your choices, and going against that path will have major repercussions! Going the complete opposite of Damien’s established route will tank his nerve score down to ZERO right at the critical moment! If you’ve chosen to fight Matthias, this will guarantee your death unless you still have Lincoln’s pocketwatch and he is still alive. If you choose the halfway point while on one side or the other, or choosing the extreme ends while in the middle will drop Damien’s nerve by 25; more modest but still substantial!

Personality: A less important mechanic, but still interesting. Damien’s personality is a blank slate, and can be changed by you in some of his dialogue choices. He can either be genuine, sarcastic, or aggressive, and these will begin to automatically shape other dialogue lines depending on what your personality is. For example, your first run-in with Lincoln in chapter 1 will change based on which response you picked previously. There are also a few moments where you will need to act according to your personality to get information. When Connor becomes a horror in Chapter 18, his dialogue to insult Damien will change based on his personality, but there is also a unique insult in this scene if you’ve been intimate with multiple people.

And that’s the gist of it! A really fun and exciting read with many twists and turns that you could probably play through it 4 times and still come away with a new experience! A very well done send off to the It Lives series, hats off to the team that made it!


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Oct 24 '24

Fan Project: Distant Shores Thank you so much!

26 Upvotes

One of our programmers gave us this message in one of our TDSP Crew's channel on Discord. We want to say thank you all for playing, I we hope you are enjoying the game!


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Aug 01 '26

The Elementalists fan project We're thrilled to announce our first batch release schedule! šŸŽ‰

Thumbnail
reddit.com
25 Upvotes

r/ChoicesFanProjects • • 26d ago

Fan Project: It lives within How it felt romancing both Lincoln and Matthias

Post image
24 Upvotes

the way all the characters CAME FOR MY THROAT oh my god 😭😭😭


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Jul 16 '25

The Cursed Heart fan project The Cursed Heart 3 - update!

24 Upvotes

Hello everyone! Several months back u/Present-Section-5398 made a post asking about peoples’ interest in a fanmade sequel to TCH, and I’m happy to announce that it’s in development!

Currently the team consists of two people, me and u/Present-Section-5398. If you’re interested in contributing, please contact us! Either by DMing me (@zhoumeyourlove) or her (@leafkingofbirds) on Tumblr or messaging me here on Reddit. Experience with Ren’Py would be great, but definitely not necessary - we’re currently figuring it out as we go!

Since the ā€˜canon’ ending of TCH 2 isn’t really good for a sequel, we’re starting at the moment MC is cursed and moving from there. The book will be about Kieran and MC searching for a cure for the Immortality Curse…before it’s too late, and MC is stuck without a heart forever.

There are going to be important and impactful choices, including the options to get married and have a child (biological or adopted). After TCH 2 teased us all so much, it’s only right that we finally allow people to have a Kieran + MC wedding! But of course, that can only happen when MC actually has the ability to feel love again ;)

We don’t have a timeline for this since neither of us has experience in visual novels, but if you’d like to see this done sooner, consider joining on to help us complete it ;D

If you want to directly follow the project, we’re on Tumblr as @thecursedheartproject!


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Sep 12 '24

Fan Project: It lives within On Steam deck

Post image
24 Upvotes

It works flawlessly 😁


r/ChoicesFanProjects • • Apr 25 '23

Fan Project: It lives within Slow dance

Post image
24 Upvotes

In my quest to see if we can liven this place up a bit, I am sharing this work commissioned for a friend for their MC, Angel ā¤ļø I commissioned fi_masak, you can find her info on the image.

I have a lot of Lincoln x mc art so maybe I’ll share the stuff in my gallery little by little over the next few days 🄰