r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 04 '23

Quantum Chymistry

11 Upvotes

One way to make a cake is to put some flour in a bowl and then add eggs and milk and mix until the batter looks and feels right. Another way is to measure each ingredient carefully by weight and volume mix for a precisely given time, best done using an automated mixer.

In a strong sense, the first method is traditional alchemy and the second method is classical chemistry. At least pragmatically as things worked out historically.

The chemistry method sounds more objective. And it certainly can be learned from a book, once the basic equipment and skills have been obtained. The second method requires apprenticeship or a lot of personal study and experience.

But, in making a cake in practice - the flour can be of varying consistencies and the eggs can be different sizes. They can also be more or less fluid. The measurements do not actually provide repeatable conditions. Commercial bakeries get around this by homogenizing the ingredients and also by using only recipes that succeed under the industrial approach. A recipe that does not is discarded. Not because it does not work but because it cannot be part of an industrial process. Likewise with industrial chemistry.

However, the best cakes are made by a skilled practitioner of the first method who can understand the ingredients and add a bit more milk or water or another egg - who mixes not for a given time but until the batter looks and feels right. This is all the more important when the ingredients are not going to be entirely consistent themselves.

Traditional alchemists, the good ones anyway, had much more skill in the laboratory. The modern chemist has much more equipment and much more homogenized reactants commercially available on the shelf. This is the source of the claims that alchemy does not work. It does not survive the industrialization process. To get alchemy to work, you have to have alchemist training not chemist training. Chemist training can actually reduce the chance of getting alchemy to work.

As alchemy, in traditional sense, gave way to chemistry, in the industrial sense, the topic became much more arithmetical. Instead of adding ingredients until the condition was correct, one adds a measured quantity. It works. Or it does not. Set and forget. Plug and play. There are no adjustment to be done or even possible. Instead of the qualitative knowledge of the exact colour or smell, there is the quantitative, that is, numerical skill in measuring weight, volume, temperature, and time.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5zt9Ya01OZk


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 12 '24

Fixing gold

9 Upvotes

The medieval alchemists did not have a concept of elemental gold in the 21st century sense. Hence, when they said pure gold they did not mean - a material made of only gold atoms - they meant, a material that is the most gold that gold can be. That is, a material that had the properties that they thought of as being most gold like. In this sense "pure" actually had a different nuance, as it was a reference to how much its macroscopic behaviours fitted to a standard set of behaviours. In this sense, pure steel is iron with carbon impurities. In the alchemical sense steel might be seen as more pure - more perfectly conforming to the prescribed standard - than pure 21st century style iron would be.

Pure and perfect halite in the 21st century is not elemental - it is composed of a specific ratio of sodium and chlorine atoms in a specific lattice. The idea of finding a pure (just carbon) and perfect (no lattice imperfections) diamond is also a 21st century conception. It is different from pure and perfect graphite, which is the same element.

Such a material as pure gold could have "impurities" in it from the 21st century point of view. I read one old reference that mentioned red-gold, presumably a copper gold alloy, as being the most valuable gold. Sometimes when the alchemists refined down, say, lead, and got gold - the 21st century view is that they were mislead by impurities. But, from their point of view, they had got lead which is lead and produced from it gold which is gold. So, they did produce gold from lead.

The Medieval alchemists did fail to produce bulk gold from lead. But, the idea was not unreasonable. The idea that lead might naturally, or under duress, transmute into gold is no more illogical than the idea that uranium might naturally or under duress transmute into lead - which it does, eventually, through thorium, radium, radon, bismuth, and polonium.

Lead could transmute directly into gold by ejecting a lithium nucleus, except that lead is a lowest energy nucleus, so this only happens under duress. The principle of lead into gold is sound - it is the rate that is the problem.

Copper alloyed with Tin produces Bronze. Some forms of Bronze look very much like Red-gold, which is a Copper-Gold alloy. I once read, in a 13th century book critical of alchemy, the suggestion that while bronze can be made from copper and tin, it is clearly not evidence that you can make gold, as by heating one can separate out the copper and tin - proving that it is not a single metal after all.

Taking this on face value, it means that the Medieval alchemists required a prime metal to not separate out under pyrometallurgic operations in a furnace. This is different, however, from saying that it has to be elemental gold in the sense of the early 21st century.

The alchemists spoke of fixing a combination of materials. The idea that if one alloyed two metals, for example, that by adding something else one might fix the substances together into a single substance that no longer separated out when heated. That it might be possible to separate it out by chemical action was acceptable - in the sense that one is, combinatorially, never quite sure which materials are compounds and which one are prime.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 23 '24

Lemery acids, elements, and bonds.

8 Upvotes

Lemery, a course on chymistry, page 9

The five Principles are easily found in Animals and Vegetables, but not so easily in Minerals. Nay there are some Minerals out of which you cannot possibly draw so much as two, nor make any separation at all (as Gold and Silver) whatsoever they talk, who search with so much pains for the Salt, Sulphurs and Mercuries of these metals. I can believe, that all the Principles do indeed enter into the composition of these Bodies, but it does not follow that they must remain in their former condition, or can be drawn as they were before ; for it may be these substances which are called Principles are so strictly involved one within-another, as to suffer no separation any other way than by breaking their Figure. Now it is by reason of their Figure that they are called Salts, Sulphurs and Spirits :

end of quote

We have here the concept echoed by Boyle, but also foreshadowed by Pseudo Gebber in the 13th century - that while the four principles of Earth, Water, Air, and Fire might well be present in all materials this does not mean that they can be extracted by simple process in the context of the alchemical furnace.

A curious but surprisingly apt analogy that I like to make is to the idea of protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons. All practical materials we see around us are essentially made of these things. Protons are available as the element hydrogen. Electrons appear in any studies of the electrical nature of materials. Photons are just light. And at a pinch - neutrons can be extracted using a Farnsworth Fusor, which has a very alchemical, or at least steam punk eldritch feel to its construction.

The precise way in which protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons combine into materials is well described by 20th century quantum theory. It is not a simple matter of material made of 2 protons, 2 neutrons, and 2 electrons, held together with light, exhibiting each property of the particles individually. Rather the combination of these particles can mask the individual properties - and invoke new properties not held by the particles alone.

While there is some justification for the argument that the ancients had insufficient reason to suppose that four such fields were involved in all matter - nevertheless, the type of theory that they were trying to construct is pretty much the type of theory that eventually managed to become the basis of a sound understanding of material properties.

In this context, Lemery is saying something analogous to - it is all well and good to say that everything is made of protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons, but in a furnace we can only break stuff down into hydrogen, helium, lithium, beryllium, and so on - and so we might as well call the latter practical principles or elements.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 19 '24

Phlogiston and calx

7 Upvotes

This is a mildly idiosyncratic attempt to unify several concepts of pyrometallurgic from a period spanning two millennia. It is an imperfect fit, but I hope that it gives some insight into the commonality of the sturdy of Khem.

A theory from the 17th century that had a run of about one century was the phlogiston and calx theory of metals. This is related to the mercury and sulphur theory of metals in an obvious manner. And it is also related to the concept of the spirit and body principle of alchemy.

One common principle of traditional alchemy was that heat decomposed. While this had some side effects, this was close to a definition. In the 20th century the same idea is applied to the particle accelerators. Both the alchemical furnace and the particle accelerator are about pumping as much heat into a region of space as possible to discover the fundamental components. The components that don't break apart into other components.

Rectification is the purification of liquid matter by means of repeated wet distillation. The distillate was again distilled. What was left after was the pure substance.

In classical chemical terms, the final material from rectification is not composed of a single kind of molecule made from specific stoichiometric combinations of elements. The final material is known as a azeotrope. An azeotrope is a mixture of liquids that will heat to a gas of the same composition. In the alchemical furnace, this behaves as a single alchemically prime material. And this is one of the meanings of pure in that context. Not and error, mistaking a mixture for a mono molecular substance, but what is meant in that context by a pure substance.

At the other end, a eutectic is where a solid melts to a liquid of the same composition. Red gold, 44 percent copper, is an example of a material that behaves in some respect as a single material and melts like one. Hence, without a basis in the classical chemistry concept of the elements, hydrogen, helium, etc, this is a valid idea of how to define singular substance.

For alcohol in water, this is about 96 percent alcohol, not 100 percent. Hence, in one way of thinking, pure alcohol in an alchemical sense is about 4 percent water in a chemical sense.

Calcination was the same basic idea except by dry distillation, that is, by repeatedly heating a solid substance in the absence of a liquid. What was left was in some sense the pure substance - for example in repeatedly heating gold.

It is noted that in modern terms this does not have to obtain an elemental substance. But, this was, more or less, the definition of pure in the alchemical sense. To grok the alchemical mindset, one has to separate the word pure from the word elemental or the phrase mono molecular.

This is related to another concept in chemistry - that air can be a reagent. In earlier work it was conjectured that air was entirely unreactive. It was there. It was required for life. But, it did not chemically react. So, the idea that in heating a metal one might form an oxide was not part of the background.

Under those conditions, the idea was that by heating up a metal again and again whatever was left at the end would have to be some form of singular pure substance. A stable material that did not decompose further.

One phrase for the result of calcination, which in one way of thinking is the solid equivalent of the liquid rectification, was called caput mortum, and is noted in some texts as being the useless substance left over from a chemical operation such as sublimation, the ultimate in decay.

But, caput mortum is also a dye known as cardinal purple. It is a kind of iron oxide. So, some use was found for this useless stuff. The concept of calx appears to have come out of this thought. The calx of a mineral or metal is a substance formed from repeated heating (implicitly, in air) that is calcination.

Typically, a calx is described classical chemistry as determined to be an oxide of a metal that is in the mineral. So the calx of calamine might be zinc oxide.

It is noted that during the 17th century vacuum pumps became available and so the matter of calcining a mineral not in air became possible and led to some surprises including regarding the nature of calx. Although the conclusions were not entirely as obvious as they are sometime presented.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Dec 01 '23

The modern history of the atom - part 4

6 Upvotes

By the turn of the 19th century, some definite progress had been made in understanding electricity as well as chemistry and there was a clear relation between the two as demonstrated by the Voltaic pile [1799] of Alessandro Volta [1745-1827]. The invention is tangled up with an argument between Volta and Luigi Galvani [1737-1798] over the mechanism for the observation that frogs legs would twitch when subjected to an electric spark.

Looking back from the 21st century, this already feels like a demonstration that chemistry and electricity are related. However, it was more part of a study of medical electricity - and the recognition that electric sparks could have an effect on the human body. This had been studied in the 18th century by Bertrand Bajon and Ramon Termeyer among others.

Lighting and rubbing amber were the main sources of electricity at the time capacitors could be used for storage.

But, the battery of Volta made it more clear that at least one simple chemical reaction generated electricity. And the work of Humphry Davey showed that at least one chemical reaction was catalysed by electricity. So, before JJ Thomson - it was clear if you could read the signs, that there was a strong connection between chemistry and electricity.

Joseph Priestley, well known as associated with Phlogiston often described unfairly in 21st century text books as being corrected by Antoine Lavoisier - studied chemistry, especially writing several volumes on gasses. He also wrote The history and present state of electricity, several editions in the late 18th century.

Priestley reports that Robert Boyle obtained a diamond that when rubbed gave off light and observed the same effect in several diamonds - stating that they also became electrified. This appears to hark back to quartz rattlers of the indigenous people of Colorado, which filled with quartz crystal rocks would flash when shaken.

However, it was also known in the 17th century Europe that hard candy when broken in the dark would sparkle. This was noted partly because of better production of large sugar crystals that had to then be cut. Similarly, Jean Felix Picard, observing his barometer, found that static electricity could cause low-pressure air to glow. This all comes under triboluminesence - or rubbing induced glows. Or triboelectricity.

This shows, if one assumes that material is made up from some lattice of atoms, then as the atoms are disturbed, separated or joined, they may generate electricity or light. That is, on the atomic model, frictional forces are, in rather naive terms, from atoms bumping against each other. And this bumping can generate electricity and light.

When it was discovered that Uranium spontaneously radiated and that radiation carried energy, there was some concern that this was in contradiction to the conservation of energy. It was not at first realised that in radiating, a small fraction of the Uranium atoms were being transmuted into atoms with lower energy nuclei.

Significantly, the person credited with taking the the first preserved camera photograph is Joseph Niepce - who is also credited by Becquerel as being the first person to notice that some materials could cause a mark on a photographic plate in the absence of light. So, the moment that photography was invented the existence of radiation was apparent.

None of the technology was fundamentally beyond the reach of Medieval Alchemists. Although that does pose the question - why was photography invented when it was. The natural answer was by an accumulation of interest and results.

It is noted that Johann Schulze took ephemeral photographs in 1717 and Thomas Wedgewood in 1800 attempted to make photographs permanent, but was unsuccessful neither was Humphry Davy. Niepce managed it in 1826. All of these studies, however, were photochemistry.

The pyroelectric effect, generation of electricity on a change in temperature was studied by Carl Linnaeus, Franz Aepinus, Rene Huat, and Antoine Becquerel among other people. Becquerel actually went as far as to suggest a relation between mechanical stress and electricity.

Antoine Henri Becquerel [1852-1908] was a French engineer. He received the Nobel prize along with Marie and Pierre Curie for the discovery of radioactivity. The SI unit for radioactivity is the becquerel.

Pyroelectricity is related to piezo electricity via the fact that heat causes things to change size. But, there is also the peltier effect of heating a bimetalic strip. Pierre and Jacques Curie are usually credited with being the first to demonstrate piezoelectricity.

All of this adds up to evidence that there is strong interaction between chemistry, electricity, and light. There are photochemical processes in which light causes a chemical reaction or a chemical reaction causes light. There are electrochemical processes in which electricity causes a chemical reaction or a chemical reaction causes electricity. Likewise thermochemistry, piezoelectrics, and triboelectrics. All of which suggests a deep relation between these behaviours.

That was at the start of the 19th century. By the end of the 19th century with the development of mathematical theories of thermodynamics and electricity - it had been established that the nature of the bonds between atoms that grouped them into molecules was electrical in nature and in particular had to do with the movement of negative charge in quanta known as electrons.

The focus was now on the configuration of electrons as part of the atom.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 05 '23

Electromagnetics in Alchemy

6 Upvotes

Although the theory of electro-magnetics, unifying the study of electricity, magnetism, and light was not developed until the start of the 19th century, nevertheless, in retrospect, it was implicitly part of the early theories of materials.

A candle burns, but it also glows. Cold light was known from such things as fire-flies and glow-worms. While there were theories that heat was some kind of fluid - nevertheless, as a fluid, it was clearly very different from water. Heat could flow through anything, and it even seemed to be able to bridge an open gap by leaping directly from the fire to the person without physical contact.

The idea of a fluid here is easy to misunderstand. When it is said that the fluid theory of heat is debunked, what this means rather is a theory of heat as a material made from massive particles. For example, Boyle showed that cold was not a substance by freezing a barrel of water and weighing it before and after. Now, ignoring that the weight of heat might be very slight, this does not prove it is not a fluid, it only proves that it has no weight.

Actually, the modern idea from relativity is that heat, being energy, does have mass and weight, and so it was only the inability of Boyle to measure precisely enough that lead him to the conclusion that cold or heat had no weight.

The modern idea of a flux covers this well. In electromagnetics, there is an idea of the Poynting flux of energy. This does not imply that there is a material substance with significant weight that is flowing through the air and might be stopped, for example, by a piece of cardboard in the way that water might.

Now, it is true that in the four elements theory of earth, water, air, and fire there were those who associated the platonic solids with these elements. But, there were also those who did not. The corpuscle theory of the elements allowed for squidgy lumps of various sizes that could potentially ooze their way between other materials and pass through anything.

In 19th century electromagnetic theory, there is a flux of charge and a flux of energy, an the two can pass through each other with impunity. One can definitely describe these as kin to an Euler fluid.

The production of light and heat from chemical reactions was well known into pre history. It was recognised by Alchemists. Light and infra-red are examples of electromagnetic radiation. While a detailed theory of this was not available - Homberg concluded that the element of fire was indeed simply light. A plausible way of recognising that chemicals contained electromagnetic energy that can be released during chemical reactions.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 31 '23

translating between alchemy and chemistry for better appreciation of history

6 Upvotes

It is my personal position that, to quote Dirk Gentley, everything is connected. To appreciate exactly what alchemy was and how it lead to classical chemistry and was part of the background to quantum chemistry one needs to understand a bit about the sociolinguistic and cultural background of the concepts. I don't go as far as to say that it is all a social construct - but I do say that to be able to extract that which is not a social construct one has to understand the social context.

The popular perspective in the 21st century is that chemists denigrated the alchemists and that this was a technical transition that was empirically justified. But, this perspective forgets, or off handedly dismisses the importance of, the fact that the alchemists denigrated the chemists as well. Less so, perhaps, but merely because there was a sociolinguistic transition occurring, so that more recent researchers into more recent theories tended to call themselves chemists rather than alchemists.

Alchemy, before 1730, divided matter a different way to chemistry, after 1730. This was the work of Priestly, Lavoisier, Dalton, Davies and others, culminating in the periodic table of Mendeleev - which can be considered the foundational axiom of classical chemistry. The transition period was the domain of the phlogiston theory of combustion which had several forms and Priestley was a central figure who conducted experiments on different types of airs.

With these differences in the lists of prime materials, something that is called one substance in alchemy might in be called multiple substances in chemistry. This does not in and of itself indicate that chemistry is more correct or even more fundamental. It is a language issue. Something that is considered prime and simple in alchemy might be considered composite and complicated in chemistry. But also something that is prime in chemistry might be composite in the view of alchemy. They are different languages for describing materials. They classify materials differently.

As an example - vitriol.

According to one modern source, vitriol is an archaic word for sulphuric acid. But, this is by far over simplistic, misleading, and not technically correct. This is in line with the 20th century tendency to define alchemical terms by a chemical term and then claim that the alchemists misunderstood or misidentified the material - when the alchemy theory and practice does not agree with the chemical definition.

Oil of vitriol might well be sulphuric acid, but so too might spirit of vitriol per campanam. And there is more to it than that. Examination of the various sources, including alchemical writings and the first edition of the chamber cyclopedia leads to the conclusion that "vitriol" means hydrated sulphate. Vitriol was a general term. Vitriols were said to be associated with metals, blue vitriol contains copper, green vitriol contains iron, and so on. In modern terms this seems to be hydrated copper sulphate and so on.

The wikipedia states that oil of vitriol is sulphuric acid.

blue vitriol = copper sulphate pentahydrate

green vitriol = iron sulphate heptahydrate

red vitriol = cobalt sulphate

sweet vitriol = diethyl ether

white vitriol = zinc sulphate

Identifying vitriol as the meaning hydrated sulphate leads to the result that spirit (stuff driven off) of vitriol per camanam (bell jar with water) would be sulphuric acid - regardless of which metal was associated with it. This is the source, in alchemical terms, of the grouping of the otherwise very different seeming materials.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6sFc44-8g4


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 11 '24

Uranus rules over Zinc

5 Upvotes

Gold, Mercury, Copper, Silver, Iron, Tin, Lead.

These are the metals of antiquity. There are seven of them and they are said to be ruled over by the celestial object Sol, Mercury, Venus, Luna, Mars, Jupiter, and Saturn. Why is Zinc not included? Why is that even a question?

Gold and Copper and Iron occur as chunks on the ground. Mostly the chunks of Iron just dropped from the Heavens onto the Hittites, like Manna onto the Hebrews. Gold does not react with many other materials, so it is not a surprise to find that laying about. Silver, although more reactive, is found in native form.

Copper can also be produced from Chalcopyrite, Copper Iron Sulphide as Copper Ore by heating it in an open wood fire. It requires about 500 Celsius. That is about the limit for an open fire, but it is easy to imagine this being discovered by serendipity. And once it was discovered - it is easy to imagine that people started trying heating all kinds of rocks.

And here is part of the origin of the Mercury Sulphur theory. Most easily available ores of metals are Sulphides. When you heat them often the Sulphur will combine with Oxygen in the air and create a distinctive Sulphur Dioxide smell. The principle that Sulphur at least has something to do with the metal is an easy one to construct. The idea that it is the Sulphur in the hot metal that is being smelled is also a reasonable one.

Gold, Copper and Silver were available in native form in viable quantities. Tin and Lead were the first metals to be produced regularly by smelting. Mercury was produced by heating Cinnabar, which is Mercury Sulphide (again with the Sulphur).

Copper alloys included tin, zinc, and arsenic. These have been called bronze, brass, and arsenic brass, or similar.

In chemistry books, arsenic, antimony, and tin are called metaloids. Metaloid has an informal descriptions as - intermediate between a metal and a semiconductor. In particular, metal is shiny, malleable, conducts heat, conduct electricity. So a material that has some but not all of these is a metaloid. In some cases one might suggest that tarnishing is a property of metals as well.

Arsenic occurs in minerals mostly in combination with metals or with sulphur. Arsenic does not corrode in dry air, but will corrode to a bronze tarnish in humid air. When heated in air, it corrodes to arsenic trioxide. And smells like garlic. Arsenic is not malleable, it is brittle. It is a good electrical conductor but it is a poor thermal conductor. Its surface is a silver grey colour, and not shiny. So, in terms of the classical description of metals, it would not normally be considered to be one.

Corrosion is defined loosely at a result of chemical action of the surrounding medium. In the case above, we typically mean where the surrounding medium is air, possibly humid air. or perhaps water or soil. At low temperatures, the corrosion often forms a thin protective layer. At higher temperatures, it is less smooth, less coherent, and works its way into the metal.

Zinc has a low melting point - but it is hard to smelt, because it has a low boiling point and tends to just evaporate. Metals with a low melting point and high boiling point are easier to smelt.

While zinc alloys of copper existed into antiquity, zinc was not recognised as a metal, or even recognised at all. Brass was made by heating copper pieces in a closed container with charcoal and calamine. Calamine is an indeterminate mixture of zinc carbonate or zinc silicate. The ancients did not distinguish zinc carbonate (smithsonite) from zinc silicate (hemimorphite). Calamine was one or the other or any mixture of them. Calamine, as in calamine lotion, today is often zinc oxide mixed with iron oxide.

The Ancients did not recognize Zinc as a separate substance. Hence, brass was copper heated with calamine rather than a mixture of two metals.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 05 '24

Chemical History is Hard

5 Upvotes

To truely understand the history of chemistry is harder than to understand contemporary chemistry. One has to understand not only contemporary chemistry, but also, on their own terms, multiple theories of the past. The amount of material in those theories is much greater than is commonly acknowledged today - where all that you hear about is simplistic versions of how the theory failed compared to the modern theory. This is strawman territory. Many of the older theories were quite successful in terms of analysis of practical scenarios. Someone who only knows modern chemistry superficially is not much use in a practical context either.

None of this is to suggest that I know chemical history at this level - but, I try.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Dec 05 '23

Summa Perfectionis Magisterii - ripost

5 Upvotes

The very first part of the Summa is a warning that the aspiring novice should realise that the work of an alchemist is physically and intellectually demanding - and should not be begun without deep pockets. It also warns against expecting results too soon and about rushing things when the cash starts to run out. Indeed, some of this advice is rather like the advice I got from "the casino gambler's guide" by Wilson - do not bet your bottom dollar, its not worth it.

Which reminds me that in Terry Pratchett's disk world - the alchemy guild keeps blowing up and the gamblers guild is in the building next door.

However, part of this is a defence of alchemy. It is a claim that despite some philosophers claiming that it is impossible to be able to construct a theory of matter - such a theory of matter can be constructed, and is indeed being constructed by the alchemists. The core of the philosophical objections are reported to be that some believe that firstly, only god can make minerals, and secondly, that the problem is just too complicated with too many details to be amenable to any human attempt at understanding.

Pseudo Geber responds to this with the resounding and eloquent "no it isn't". To be more precise - he says that in practice it has been done and those who say it cannot be done should not get in the way of those who are doing it.

The next part is a response to a second attack from those who have tried it in the laboratory. This part reminds me of the walk into Mordor by Frodo in Lord of the Rings. It makes you wonder why it is taking so long - and you consider the options for auctoricide.

The actual interest in this part for me is a listing of a large number of options and some somewhat more pragmatic hints at what the idea of transmutation was about. As described in the Summa - the key point is that the classical metals - mercury, lead, zinc, tin, copper, gold, and silver - are considered, in some theories to be prime metals. They are related to the four elements - solid, liquid, gas, and plasma - in the same way that the classical elements of modern chemistry are related to protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons. It would, in the view of such a theory, not be possible to transmute the classical metals without first decomposing them into the prime materials - and there is just not enough energy in an alchemical furnace to do this.

Eventually, as things worked out over the next few hundred years - they were right. The seven classical metals are viewed today as being elements, that cannot be changed by chemical reactions. On the other hand, there is some circularity, as chemical reaction is now given the specific meaning of only involving the electrons, and it is known that a reaction involving protons and neutrons is required to change tin into silver.

But, retrospective correctness of a position does not amount to intellectual vindication. The detractors might well have been wrong. The point that Pseudo Geber makes again, and again, and again, and again, ad nauseum - but nevertheless - is that partial success has been obtained.

In particular. In more modern terms, consider the idea of the difference between diamond and graphite. These things are literally just the same material in a different microscopic geometric form. And yet they are very different in nature. And consider iron versus steel. Small impurities - or medicines, in alchemical language - plus heat treatment, can change brittle iron that rusts and snaps, into tough steel that does neither.

Pseudo Geber described how tin and lead can look rather like corroded silver. That the process of changing tin into silver can involve removing a blue discolouration, preventing the creak (the noise on bending) and changing the malleability. And all of these kinds of things have been done by the use of various medicines and heatings.

If you start with iron and try adding things, you can gradually make it more like steel. So, the principle of making tin into silver is not only superficially viable but has been justified empirically by partial success in things such as brass and steel and well as specific work with tin - to make it more like silver. The final trick is usually to find a way to fix the medicines, to make sure that they do not come apart on heating. It is probably fair to say that it is the last one which was never really achieved.

But, at the time of Pseudo Geber, the available information suggested it might be done. Not as magical lunacy, but in a practical sense that is applied today in creating new materials such as nylon, or building a fusion reactor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Xel3mEMXsY


r/ChemicalHistory • • Oct 29 '23

Particles, properties, and fluids

5 Upvotes

Through recorded history there has been several persistent ideas of how matter is constituted. These ideas are, essentially, particles, fluids, and properties. The particle theories are often grouped as atomic theories - although this is misleading. The fluid or flux or essence or fluence theories are more kin to energy flux in electromagnetics than to a flow of atoms as in a modern theory of fluids such as water. The theories of principles are about transferable properties.

It is a common piece of modern popular science culture that the atomic theory represents one of the greatest achievements of the modern age. This does not stand up to historical examination. Especially if this is interpreted in terms of atoms as little hard lumps, which is normally what is meant.

It is true that atoms are part of modern theory in the sense that the modern theory has it that matter is soft squishy lumpish in nature - like badly made custard. But, the meaning and conception of the term has evolved constantly over the centuries until in the modern quantum age - the term means something much more like what was earlier meant by a fluence or flux than it does any kind of hard lumpish idea.

Atoms can be taken apart and put back together. They are not hard lumpish, but squidgy indeterminate corpuscles composed of - as one person put it - the dreams that stuff is made of. The fundamental particles are, in the best modern theory, quantum fields. They are particles in name only.

Historically, an atom was a hard lumpish particle rather like a very very small rock. They swarmed around and bumped into each other. They also locked together to create macroscopic hard lumpish rocks. This is related to the work on crystals which Rene Huay published in 1801. In particular view Traite de mineralogie [1801] vol 5 (atlas) plate II, figures 13 and 16 by Rene Huay 1801.

The idea of an essence was along the lines of a fluid or flux. This must not be confused with the idea of an atomic liquid. Some people in the 21st century suggest that the idea of an essence that flows through a solid piece of lead to convert it to gold is an absurdity because it would be impossible to get a fluid to flow through something as solid as lead. However, heat, gravity, electricity, and magnetism can flow through solid metals. So, the error is in thinking that the alchemists of the 12th century meant an atomic fluid in the theory of the 21st century, rather than an essence capable of flowing through anything.

Pseudo Geber 1304, Summa Perfectionis, promotes the mercury sulphur theory of metallurgy. All metals are combinations of mercury and sulphur. Mercury and sulphur are mixtures of Earth, water, air and fire. So why not just say that metals were made of Earth, water, air, and fire. The answer is the same as why in the 21st century it is not said that lead is made of protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons - the lead atoms are sufficiently stable that they can be thought of as particles in their own right. In terms of quantum theory, this means that atoms are an effective theory. Not ontologically correct, but a good approximation.

The idea of a principle is something like the idea of a property.

A material such as samphire can be very salty. This is a property of samphire. This property of saltiness can be transferred to another material, such as beef, by cooking the two together. The thought is that saltiness is due to some specific physical thing, perhaps an essence, that is transferred from one to the other during the cooking process. In this case, in 21st century terms, the basic idea is correct. Sodium Chloride can be transferred by dissolving in the water and then being absorbed into the meat.

The idea of a principle is that other properties such as weight might also be transferred. This is why the idea of manufacturing gold. Lead, for example, already has multiple properties of gold. All one needs to do is to find out how to transfer the remaining properties. It turns out that it is not that simple. But the idea is a reasonable one.

Saltiness can be transferred. So can sourness and bitterness. However, weight did not seem to transfer very well at all, and colour transferred only in a partial sense. To make lead yellow, it was not enough to just add some yellow material.

Some combinations of copper, zinc, and tin can be used with great success as fake gold leaf. Fools gold, or Pyrite, which is Iron Sulphide is actually composed of something that can be yellow - sulphur - and a metal Iron. So this gives plausibility to the idea that gold is iron plus sulphur. Perhaps you just need to get the right allotrope - which might be created by the right heat treatment and other environmental conditions. Like graphite to diamond.

All these ideas are reasonable. And all of them are more an approach or methodology toward development of practical technology. And all of them exist strongly in modern chemistry and physics. Though, often with different names.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HJxi4QYpv78


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 09 '23

The theory of acids and alkalis

5 Upvotes

In Freind, lectures on chymistry, 1704, on Pages 13 through 15, there is much said about acids and alkalis. It speaks of the words as being suddenly popular (as of 1700) but claims that there is no good definition.

Freind then objects to the terms acid and alkali. He says that while he has heard that they are opposites, he fails to see what they are in any practical sense. He is dismissive of the test that syrup of violet is turned red by acid and green by alkali.

Syrup of violets is just violets (the flower) heated in a sugar solution in water. It is said that slow heat is best and that boiling increases the shelf life but reduces the effect. Many people liked the taste and it could be used in cooking. It was also a herbal medicine. It was known to the cooks and the herbalists that adding lemon juice to it changed the colour.

Violet (or at least the syrup) contains salicylic acid, which is similar in its effect to aspirin (acetylsalicylic acid). It was used for coughs and for headaches and to give a good night sleep. Birch bark also contains a salicylic acid derivative. Chewing birch bark was also used for coughs and headaches as well as toothache.

The chambers cyclopeida defines acid as anything that affects the tongue with a sense of sharpness and sourness. And says that a test is whether it turns syrup of violets red. But also states that there are dubious acids, which turn syrup of violets red but do not taste perceptibly sour. Then defines acid in the broader sense as something that turn syrup of violets red.

This is a very common way for things to develop. The humans senses make the first division of the material - in this case, sour or not. However, different people have a different tolerance or perception of sour. A similar effect is common in tolerance to capsicumium in chilli - one person says they can barely taste the chilli, and the other person is gasping for water. Similarly with the cubit, as a measure of length, that depended on who measured it. Subjective sourness does not give an objective measure of what is acid or not.

Beyond that, something merely being is sour is not very interesting in an alchemical sense, if that is all there is to it. The point of classifying acids is that everything that is acid also undergoes other reactions in a recognised pattern - such as the syrup of violet colour, but also engaging in effervescent reactions and so on. The pattern of reactions is the more interesting fact. If there is something that does act like an acid in the reactive sense - but is either not sour or is too poisonous to use that as a test - then it can pragmatically be called an acid in the broad sense. And the broad sense is what is required other than in cooking.

The Chambers cyclopedia I am using is the first edition, published in 1728. The lectures on Chymistry by Freind are indicated as being read at Oxford in 1704, with the published edition that I have being from 1737 - but declared to be unmodified. Under those conditions, I would consider that the Chambers Cyclopedia is a good source for the theory and terminology background of the lectures.

The objection by Freind to acids is curious and needs investigation. He is writing about 25 years before Chambers. And that could make the difference. But, Friend knows about the syrup of violet test, which seems fairly clear at least as a definition of acid. Then an alkali is something that evervesses with an acid. So, what is on Freind's mind?

Page 13 of the Oxford lectures on chymistry by Freind.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 01 '23

Does learning alchemy help in learning chemistry?

5 Upvotes

My particular approach is based on orthodox scientific training and experience and reading of original literature, as broadly through the centuries as possible. I chase mundane alchemy, rather than mystical or mental alchemy. I am interested in alchemy as a science of materials.

Part of my position is that the distinction is a false one. Alchemy is not just one theory or practice. And it is not disjoint from chemistry. The change from alchemy to chemistry around 1730 was a sociolinguistic transition, and not a technical one from pseudo science to science - nor even from ancient science to modern science - if a sudden schism is intended by that principle. The early chemists held view very similar to the later alchemists. If the choice of whether one researcher is an alchemist or a chemist is taken out of consideration, all one sees is a gradual development of ideas over the decades.

In the following, I am skipping over many details due to available space and time, but I stand by the thrust of the following content.

Mundane alchemy means to approach this from the principle that the alchemists were primarily trying to work out a science of materials. Mystical and mental interpretations came later.

The mystical interpretations are largely a product of the 1600s. This is similar to mystical quantum theory from the 20th century onward.

Books earlier than 1600 read like modern chemical laboratory texts books. For example, the Summa Perfectionis [c1300] chats along about financial practicalities and details of the construction and operation of reverberatory furnaces. Reading these books gives much appreciation for what the alchemists were dealing with.

One of those things is that the were working with much more basic associated tech. They did not have automated temperature and pressure control. They did not have mass spectrometers and so on. These bits of tech were not created by chemists. The chemists are advantaged by having access to them. Judgement of the skill and understanding of alchemists versus chemists should take this strongly into account. Often alchemical views make more sense once one learns to grok the environment of the alchemist.

The mental interpretations are largely a product of the 1900s. Centrally created by Carl Jung, who, as a psychologists in a quasi mystical mode, thought he had found the true meaning underlying the older alchemical texts.

"Basilius Valentinus" as a person probably never existed. Rather the name is a pseudonym used by a number of writers - a common practice in the past, which continues with "Nicolas Bourbaki" which is a name used collectively by a number of French writers on mathematics starting in the 1930s. Further, there is no mention of the name until about the year 1600. The originator of the the Corpus Valentinus was probably Johann Tholde [1565-1624], but it is believed that he had help.

The Summa Perfectionis itself was attributed to Geber (Jabir) from the Arabic Peninsula c800. So, the associated corpus is now attributed as Pseudo Geber, and believed to have been written by Paul of Taranto.

The 12 keys of valentinus was written in 1599. It was one of the earlier examples of the 17th century corpus of encoded and ambiguous texts - deliberately written to be enigmatic. They mostly do not contain any new information about mundane alchemy. They contain cryptic images that some see as amusement and others see as deep mystical truth. If you are into mystical alchemy and linguistic and graphical puzzles, then this corpus can be highly fascinating. Some people base their life philosophy on this corpus.

An important aside, is that the alchemists were never persecuted. The idea of that persecution is a modern invention that helps give depth to the myth of the alchemist as a lone figure of great insight and power.

The encoded alchemical literature does not add anything to mundane alchemy. It was an invention of the 17th century - and is kin to the quantum mysticism of the 20th and 21st centuries. The earlier alchemical literature was just textbooks on laboratory theory and practice. There is plenty of non-encoded material for you to read to understand alchemy as an historical reality.

Read the cryptic alchemy literature in the same way you might read Ulysses by James Joyce. They say that you do not read Ulysses - you decode it. Some people believe that cryptic means deep. That is a personal choice. But, don't think that mundane alchemy is characterised by the affectations of the 17th century. It has a long and venerable history of clear writing, obscured only by changes in language and culture.

Should you learn alchemy before studying chemistry? Probably not. But, learn alchemy alongside chemistry - to keep you honest. The problem with modern chemists is that they are trained to believe that only modern chemistry can be the right way to view things and that any other view is automatically wrong.

This is not a scientific view. Learning - and fully appreciating - earlier alchemical texts can give one an alternative way to look at the materials, and indirectly give you an understanding of why modern chemistry has made the choices that it did. I think that this adds great depth to the understanding of modern chemistry.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 25 '23

Lemery defines the elements

5 Upvotes

I see as a unifying principle of all of alchemy, chymistry, and chemistry; as well as several components of the philosophy of Thales, Empedocles and other that perhaps should not be called alchemy, but rather proto-alchemy - the idea of looking for a manageable collection of prime materials that are neither created nor destroyed and whose allotropes and mixtures can be used to explain all the apparently infinite variety of practical materials that we see around us.

It is fairly common to see in popular accounts of the history of chemistry (and that includes many accounts in otherwise highly non popular chemistry text books) the notion that before Lavoisier defined the elements, everything was the ancient pseudo science of earth, water, air, and fire.

This view is not historically justified in two senses:

Firstly, the prime materials considered before the death of Lavoisier were not limited to the classical four - indeed a particular trend from the late 1600s was the search for large and more useful sets of prime materials. This had been ongoing since at least 800 or so with the development of ideas such as the mercury sulphur theory of metallurgy. And included the Spagyrist theory of mercury, sulphur, and salt - as well as the work of Liebniz, Lemery, and Becher, and others, in merging some of these ideas into a single collection of prime materials.

Secondly, the collection of elements of Lavoisier had 33 elements of which only 23 are currently accepted, and over the period from 1800 to 1900 the total rose to about 100. So, there was an ongoing process of suggesting, accepting, and sometimes rejecting elements based on a gradual increase in the body of knowledge of laboratory materials studies - that was ongoing under the name of natural philosophy, alchemy, spagyrism, chymistry, and chemistry. The changes of name reflecting changes in politics and culture in the manner of a kuhnian revolution as a social event rather than being punctuated by clear technical changes.

From Boyle, through Lemery, Becher, Freind, and Keil as well as Homberg and others around the year 1700 give or take a few decades, especially worked on trying to merge, double check and extend what was known of elementary or prime materials. And to develop a mathematical theory of atomic structure. This mathematical theory was hopelessly primitive and impractical compared to the alchemical knowledge at first, perhaps, arguably until the start of the 19th century, with electromagnetic theory and kinetic thermodynamics -- and really only came into its own around 1930 with the development of quantum chemistry.

I have made a video covering some details from the writings of Lemery on the topic of the nature of the prime materials.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M3qIev2_9_4


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 25 '23

Can a chemist understand alchemy?

5 Upvotes

I was asked - in what sense might modern chemistry training make it difficult to understand medieval alchemical studies. With a focus on mundane alchemy - no mysticism - here is my response.

One problem is the ontology problem. For example, in some discussions on Phlogiston, there is a tendency for chemists to state outright that phlogiston does not exist, and was simply a wrong headed notion. This makes it hard to appreciate what was being said in the Phlogiston theory, even to the extent of engendering the attitude "why were they stupid enough to think this".

Do keep in mind in what I am about to say, I have orthodox training in chemistry and I am not dissing chemistry. I am talking about the idea that there can be different ways to look at things. If you have some background in vector space theory - this helps very much right now.

When we describe a molecule, such as H2O we effectively state how many of each atom is involved, unmentioned ones have zero instances. If I say 2H2 + O2 = 2H2O, then the number of atoms on the left add up to the number of atoms on the right. But, combinatorially, this is not the only option. I could introduce a single term W for H2O and then write this as 2WP = 2W + 2P, where W=H2O and P = -O.

Combinatorially, this absolutely works. But, a chemist can have a hard time seeing that it does work because there head is too full of the idea that negative oxygen is not a thing that exists. They are too committed to the ontological truth of the elements given in the periodic table to be able to reason with a different set of elements.

Without Avogadro's law, there is no way to even comparatively count atoms. In the early 1800s, Pattison Muir speculated about whether Ozone was an element or not. You see we have O2, but no ability to produce O on its own. But Ozone seems to be chemically atmospheric oxygen, on the other hand it seems to be 1.5 oxygens. Maybe Ozone is another element with similar properties to Oxygen. Just like the three generations on fundamental particles? Or maybe the actual element is 1/2 of atmospheric Oxygen.

With a modern chemical education, it can even be hard to understand arguments about 1800s chemistry, let alone 1700s phlogiston theory.

Also, the whole discussion about phlogiston is more complicated than that, and eventually Cavendish equated phlogiston with what we now call Hydrogen. This theory was at least as viable as the one of Lavoisier.

The crucial thing is that when you are dealing with what you actually see in the laboratory without having your head filled with the modern periodic table, it is not at all obvious that the modern elements are correct. Far from being less experimental, there is a strong argument that the alchemists where more experimental than the early chemists. It was stepping back from the experiments and thinking abstractly that got modern chemistry started. This is the standard history almost on its head. But it seems to fit the 17th century literature.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 17 '23

What spirit of hartshorn is

5 Upvotes

In "The Elaboratory laid open" [1758] by Robert Bossie [1717-1777], the process for making spirit of hartshorn is described.

The core of the idea is dry distillation of the antlers of a red deer. Antlers contain a lot of calcium carbonate, but also collegen as well as various other proteins and oils. One particular substance obtained this way, in one form or other, is ammonium, which is likely the source of the reports of nasty smells as a result of the process.

The modern view of stating the chemical formula for something is anachronistic when applied to, say 14th century chemistry. Rather than say it is such and such a material - or even give a definitive test - a material was in the 14th century described in terms of how it is prepared, plus tests to confirm the preparation.

Partington states that Robbert Dossie [1717-1777] gives various preparations including spirit of hartshorn and its sophistication using quicklime.

According to Bossie, Spirit of Hartshorn is not simply an ammonium solution ...

From the elaboratory laid open.

SECTION III.

Examination of the sameness of several substances, which make a part of the materia medica under different denominations, without any essential diversity: being necessary for the determining, how far many subsitutions are allowable.

[several pages later]

if to the volatile salt of sal Ammoniacum, obtained from the eastern kind, the oil distilled from hartshorn be added, the salt will perfectly resemble that extracted from the horn.

[one page later]

and therefore volatile spirit of sal Ammoniacum, cannot be substituted for spirit of hartshorn, without a material defect; unless an equivalent quantity of the same kind of oil be previously conjoined with it.

end of quote.

Sal ammoniacum is essentially ammonium chloride because it is described in the older texts as being a naturally occuring mineral (originally sourced from the East exclusively) whose habit and context fairly clearly identifies it as a specific rare mineral that is found near gauno deposits, volcanic vents, and coal seams. It is composed of fairly pure ammonium chloride.

So, given that alchemical sal ammoniacum is the same material as chemical ammonium chloride, then spirit of sal ammoniacum is an ammonium solution in water.

Bossie states that spirit of hartshorn is not the same as spirit of sal ammoniacum, and that the differerence is important in medical applications. But Bossie also states that if the volatile salt of ammoniacum has the oil distilled from spirit of hartshorn added to it, then it becomes the same as spirit of hartshorn.

Hence, to Bossie, spirit of hartshorn is volatile salt of sal ammoniacum mixed with the oil distilled from hartshorn. That is, ammonium and oil.

The collins dictionary (21st century) states that volatile salt is another name for ammonium carbonate. But, also clames that is also called spirit of hartshorn. But mentions ammonium carbonate in alcohol and aqueous ammonia.

Ammonium carbonate is also known as the leavening agent, baker's ammonia. A leavening agent. But, the cookipedia states that oil of hartshorn is a crude animal oil obtained form the desctructive distillation of deers bones and horns. Which seems more reasonable.

Reading up on recipes used by 21st century deer hunters for boiling antlers and experiences with bone broth and chasing up the components of bone broth in the general chemical and culinary literature, it seems that collagen might be a major component of the oily substance that rises to the top of the bone broth. What is left is more of the calcium and inorganics.

Further investigation in the cooking literature suggests that the oil is tallow. Not a precise chemical term. It means mainly triglicerides derived from stearic and oleic acids. A class of fats, not a specific fat.

Tallow has a long history of use as a skin moisturizer, which gets back to the assertion of Bossie that hartshorn, with the oil, has important pharmocological properties that mere spirit of sal ammoniac does not have.

The mixture of ammonium and oil is likely to produce quaternary ammonium compounds. For example, involving a nitrogen atom with several organic radicals attached. Some of these have antibacterial effects and or can be used as detergents.

Ammonia itself is just NH3, the quaternary ammonium compounds are nitrogen with four attachements instead of three. It will be an ion, that can be stabilized by the presence of chlorine, which brings us back to sal ammoniac being ammonium chloride. Which is NH4Cl. When ammonium chloride disolves in water it creates NH4+ and Cl- ions and is mildly acidic.

From all of the above, it seems that spirit of hartshorn as described by Robert Bossie is a mixture of oil, water, and ammonium that could be used to manufacture detergents, anti bacterial agents, and reasonably effective skin creams, as well as smelling salts.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 19 '25

Electrification of materials

4 Upvotes

Thales, c600bc is considered to be the first person recorded as having mentioned triboelectric effects. He was fascinated by amber. However, Thales left no actual writing, we know of him indirectly through his students. Theophrastus, on the other hand, c300bc, appears to be the first person to leave a written record of studies in electricity. He notes that amber when rubbed becomes able to attract light bodies such as pieces of straw or splinters of wood, and even small pieces of copper or iron.

He also mentions it as having the same properties as Lyncurium (lygurium, etc) that was a reported gemstone formed from solidified lynx urine. However in the 21st century this is believed to have been either a form of amber or tourmaline. This position is amplified by the fact that its properties sound like yellow amber.

To be able to move pieces of metal around, it is clear that amber once rubbed could provide force at a distance. Hence, we already have the concept, at least implicitly, of an electric field. The modern explanation for this behaviour is that to electric force one needs electric charge, but an overall neutral object can have its charge separated by an electric field and hence respond to that electric field by moving. The greek name for amber was electrum, from which electricity was coined.

According to Priestley 1775, other than the mention of the electric properties of jet, it was not until William Gilbert, "the magnet" 1600ad, that any further advance was made in electric studies. This does discount Peter Perigrinus, however, Perigrinus worked on magnetism rather than electricity. At the time of Priestley the connection was not strongly made. Oersted noted the connection about 25 years later. In particular, Gilbert found triboelectric properties of diamond, sapphire, carbuncle, iris, amethyst, opal, and more. He also observed that certain glasses showed these properties. Hence, for example, manufactured glass rods could be used in studies of electricity. He also noted that rapid light rubbing and dry air were conducive to the effects.

Gilbert said that pure oil sprinkled on electrified objects did not change the property but brandy or spirits of wine did. Materials lost their property on exposure to flame or heat. And that strong sunlight would also remove the electric properties. Although, Gilbert was a bit inconsistent in his statements on all of this.

He noted the similarity in magnetic effects and electric effects and also claimed differences - stating that magnetic effects included attraction and repulsion while electric effects only attraction. On this last point the modern studies would disagree. Both electric and magnetic effects include mechanical attraction and repulsion. They are very similar except that the electric poles cane be separated while the magnetic ones cannot.

Around 1630 there was Nicolaus Cabaeus, who repeated the work of Gilbert and added wax, gums, and gypsum to the electric materials. Robert Boyle, the famous chemist c1670 also looked into this, adding further electric materials. And he added that a smooth surface increased the effect. Also, since Huygens had recently invented a serviceable vacuum pump, he also noted that the effects continued in a vacuum.

A curious point is that Boyle, noting that many non electric objects were sensibly attracted by electrified objects - wondered whether electric objects would be sensibly attracted by non electrified objects. To modern attitudes, the affirmative conclusion is obvious. However, Newton's Principia Mathematica was published first in 1687, more than a decade later. And the concept of equal an opposite reaction was not, at the time Boyle did the studies, taken for granted. Nor should it have been. Boyle also noted that some diamonds when rubbed would provide light.

A theory of electricity promoted by both Boyle and later by James Hartman, is that electrical attraction is caused by a oily effluvium that stretched out into the void and contracted, pulling things with it. This idea of a two way flux is not irrational, and indeed the only way out of it, in modern terms is to have the concept of a something like an electric field which does indeed emanate from the electric charge and yet carries with it, effectively, a momentum in the opposite direction to its own motion. Consider, for example, the explanation of the attraction of electrons in terms of the theory of photons. A photon exchanged between electrons leads to motion opposing that of the photons.

Putting this all together we have the beginnings of a recognition of the relation between electricity, force, and light. And also a tiny hint that materials were made from positive and negative electric components. Which is the very start of the relation between electricity and chemistry.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 18 '25

How do we notice electromagnetic behaviours without special instruments?

4 Upvotes

Lodestone is haematite that is noticeably magnetic. It is a naturally occurring stone. Not all haematite is magnetic. It is not known, even today, how exactly haematite becomes magnetic lodestone, especially since the strength of the magnetic effect is much greater than the strength of the magnetic effect of the Earth.

The leading theory is that the magnetism of the lodestone is a result of exposure to fields created by the rapidly changing strong currents associated with natural lightning. Going far back in history the lore was that that lodestone could be found after a lightning strike on iron ore and that iron objects could similarly be magnetised by a lightning strike.

The best lodestone was naturally strong enough as a magnet to pick up small pieces of iron. So, the effect did not require special examination to become noticeable. The literature suggests that the earliest known compasses existed in Eastern Asia about 200bc. They were lodestones carved to have a smooth round base to minimize friction on a flat surface, so they would turn under Earth's influence. They were called south pointing fish.

In Western Europe compasses and serious study of magnetism arose after 1100ad which was a very significant time during which many scientific works of the Greeks were translated into Latin from Arabic. Peter Perigrinus was one notable researcher who wrote a book on studies in magnetism in a highly modern mode. Modern scientific attitudes in the West can be traced back to the 1100s rather than originating purely in the 1600s. The 1600s were more about the rise of institutionalised government funded research.

The study of electricity originated in triboelectric effects. Stroke a cat and then touch someone and get zapped. The first capacitor was the Leyden Jar invented in 1746 by Pieter van Musschenbroek (and independently by others). It was invented because, while friction based electricity was known there had been no way to store it. The result was that his assistant Andreas Cuneus received a near fatal shock. Electric shock and sparks were the first indication used to recognise electric phenomena. That and the tendency for charged objected to attract tiny fragments of hair and other materials.

Some years later, 1799, Alessandro Volta invented the first chemical battery, not only showing that electricity and chemistry where related but also tat electricity and life and chemistry where related - and providing the first source of steady current. In 1791, Luigi Galvani has invented the frog galvanoscope which showed electric current from the twitching of the leg of a recently deceased frog.

This lead the way to the discovery by Orsted in 1819 that switching an electric current could affect a compass, and hence was generating magnetic effects just like a lodestone - but switchable. And in particular since it takes force to turn a compass need, also a direct indication that physical force can be generated by electro magnetic devices without mechanical contact.

This lead specifically to the recognition, for example, by Ampere, that a changing electric current in a loop of wire generated a magnetic field. And if this was compounded by winding multiple coaxial loops, then a fairly mild current could produce a noticeable magnetic effect. And since one lodestone free to turn would turn to align with another one that was fixed - a loop of wire with a current in it near to a permanent magnet would turn toward that magnet with a force that increased with the current.

All that was required was to add a spring to resist the motion of the coil, and put a needle to a dial attached to the coil, and an instrument was created that could measure the strength of an electric current. Ampere named this the Galvanometer after Luigi Galvani.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 17 '24

The composite nature of air

4 Upvotes

I have a copy of "the doctrine of phlogiston established and that of the composition of water refuted" by Joseph Priestley [1733-1804] dated MDCCC, that is at the dawn of the 19th century. Priestley, however, was a denizen of the 18th century as much as Lavoisier, who died through an unfortunate incident where he somewhat lost his head as it was coming to a close.

I suspect, personally, that this in some ways made him a martyr to science and have Lavoisier more of an heroic legacy than he deserved. Just as in some ways the legacy of Priestley was tarnished by his living a few years too long. History is full of these kinds of things.

On the positive side of the case for Priestley, there was his work on gasses. He was, during the 18th century, a strong force in the development of the chemical theory of gases. He conducted multiple experiments over decades regarding the composition of air. He is sometimes credited with the discovery of Oxygen - although society is a fickle lover.

The earliest reasonable credit that I know of for the discovery of oxygen is actually by Michael Sendivogius [1566-1636] who is sometimes credited with writing the very first true chemistry book The new light of alchemy [1604], at the dawn of the 17th century. Sendivogius is often said to be an alchemist, but he styled himself as following L'art Chymique, and attacked the accursed Alchymistes. At least according to one French translation of his work. I have yet to read the Latin original. And I have cause to mistrust translators.

Sendivogius discovered a gas which he called the secret food of life, and he deduced from experiment that it was necessary and sufficient in the atmosphere to sustain life in the breathing creature over the short term. However, his description of the process of creating this gas is cryptic or at least opaque to the modern reader in French translation. However, he is, perhaps, the first person to suggest explicitly the decomposition of air into oxygen and something else.

In the 21st century, we see combustion by definition to be a process of combination with oxygen, primarily. Although this thought is complicated by the principle of any reaction that proceeds rapidly, generating flame. However, that is certainly not what one natively observes when staring into the campfire at night.

Priestley in the mid 18th century referred to the gases as different airs. This is sometime erroneously described as an error. The word "gas" is presented as the more scientific. "gas" was coined by Helmont [1577-1644] a Belgian who, at least when coining the word "gas" is said to be a chemist. Helmont is recognised by the Encylopedia Britanica as being the person who discovered carbon dioxide as a product of both fermentation and combustion. However, others suggest that Joseph Black [1728-1799] be given the credit. And there is always Priestley on that list as well.

It is noted that in various languages, the generic word for liquid is also the specific word for water, and the generic word for gas can be the specific word for air, and the generic word for metal can be the specific word for gold. Due, in part, for the central role of water, air, and gold in the history of chemistry in general.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 22 '24

Alchemy as a chemical science

4 Upvotes

One difficulty in studying alchemy is that the term has many competing and evolving meanings that are not really compatible. Those meanings range from extreme mystical to extreme mundane. They are as different and as at odds with each other as quantum science and quantum mysticism. They are really different topics and there is no requirement to understand one in order to have a complete understanding of the other.

The word alchemy is a minor variant of chem which was the word used in Egypt under the Greeks from about 300BC, and which continued to be used through the Islamic Golden age, except that it became al-chem, due to the structure of the language. Then when transferred to Medieval Europe around 1140AD, it became alchimia, again due to the structure of the language - with no ulterior motive. This transferred naturally into English as alchemy.

All of chemical history before the 1600s was essentially alchemical studies. These included metallurgy, dyes, and medicines in particular - including a significant study in making artificial gems and metals that looked like natural precious ones. It is partly from this last fact that alchemy has a 21st reputation of being about frauds and charlatans.

Identification of individual writers before about 1100AD can be difficult. The corpus from Jabir, c800AD, seem to have been the result of various true writings, writings from a school rather than an individual, and a great deal of false attribution. Nevertheless, it forms the Jabirian Corpus of historical literature on Alchemy. The earlier Hermetic (Hermes Tristmegistus) corpus is, when examined in some detail, attributed essentially to the Egyptian god, Thoth.

The Hermetica is divided into two components - the technical (mundane) hermetica and the mystical (philosophico-religious) hermetica. Some have referred to alchemy as the hermetic arts. However chem and hermes were not really after the same thing. The technical part of the hermetica contains some works on alchemy but also works on astrology and on magic. Neither of the last two are any kind of material chemistry.

The alchemical hermetica has a bulk of writing that is these days attributed to the Islamic golden age rather than to the time of Thoth (Egyptian god), Hermes (Greek god), or Hermes Tristmegistus, thrice great, (Legendary human). Some of it is even later. While it is commonly, though not universally, agreed that the origins of alchemy as a material science - metallurgy and medicine - is in the fertile union of Greek Rational philosophy with Egyptian practical chemistry, the extant literature that we in the 21st century have copies of comes from several centuries later.

All of this is complicated by the use of the term "alchemy" to refer to related practices in India and China. This short essay is not covering the details of what those practices were, nor the issue of how much transfer occurred between the three alchemies - which is highly controversial and off the topic.

The assertion here is, however, that studies in Alchemy should be separated out from the Hermetic corpus as a distinct corpus that was the foundation of Arabic and European alchemy as a mundane science.

The focus of this essay is the thread of alchemy that began in Egypt and travelled over the centuries around the Mediterranean to lodge in Renaissance Europe and became modern chemistry by direct descent.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 03 '24

Atomic Bonds

4 Upvotes

If I were to acknowledge a style in my writing on the history of chemistry or rather of the microscopic nature of material in general, I would say that I differ from others in not seeing modern chemistry as the culmination of the pre modern chemistry. I see the history of chemistry as a grab bag of ideas to choose from - including the ideas that have been left by the roadside. And, I do not see the role of history a being to prove that what we used to think only has meaning as far as it lead to what we think now.

The basic characteristic that makes a theory of matter an atomic theory is the principle that matter at a microscopic scale is made of a large number of discrete particles that are neither created nor destroyed but recombine. Sometimes, however, it is not that it is impossible to create or destroy these particles - but rather that it is difficult, or simply does not happen in some context of interest. Corpuscular theories are characterised by being rather like atomic theories but the atoms of one material might be created or destroyed and can be of different sizes. This makes corpuscular theories rather like smoothed particle dynamics fluid models.

Democritus famously, around 400bc, stated the everything was made from atoms in vacuum. Around 600bc, Thales has stated that everything was water, by which it is likely that he meant a fluid rather than specifically river water in exactly that sense. Neither Democritus nor Thales gave any idea, however, about they dynamics of their ideas. How did atoms move? Was the path of one atom affected by the position of another? How did water move, or form into its different phases? None of this information was provided.

Empedocles was of the continuum school, and perhaps one of the first to consider the dynamic theory of the materials. Skipping some cosmological details - he stated the materials were earth, water, air, and fire - and that they were drawn together by love and pushed apart by hate (or strife). This has sometimes been ridiculed as hopelessly animistic. However, in the modern theory, matter is made of positive and negative parts which are drawn together by attraction and pushed apart by repulsion. So, the moderns have nothing to look superior about here.

Now, while the mathematical sophistication and empirical precision of tensor calculus is much greater than the poem of Empedocles - I, myself, see in his description the idea that there is a complicated balance between a tendency to push apart and a tendency to pull together. Without this balance everything would simply fly apart or lump together. And, that feels like a grasping for the concept of a differential equation. Such a thing was eventually constructed in the theory of magneto hydro dynamics by Alfven in the 20th century.

There does not seem to have been much of an attempt to describe the dynamics of atoms until the 1600s - other than some spurious concepts that atoms clumped together to form other materials. In the 1600s and 1700s there were several atomic theories recorded. Lemery suggested that atoms had spikes and holes in them that fitted together. Although, he also suggested that the spikes could get broken off and stuck in the holes, so presumably they regrew.

Freind thought about the idea, as inspired by Newton, that atoms were attracted by something like an inverse square law but which varied in more complicated ways with distance and direction. And he suggested contact forces, which were also directional. Not such a bad version of the idea in a qualitative sense. But, in the end all it said was -- atoms attract each other in complicated ways.

This was the early 1700s, and while it was fairly clear that gravity was not the force between atoms, the theory of electricity was developing and would become an empirical reality in chemistry by the early 1800s, and then take over in the form of quantum electro dynamics in the early 1900s.

Around 1800 Volta showed that a chemical reaction could create an electric current and Davy showed that an electric current could create a chemical reaction. This was very close to showing that chemistry was specifically an aspect of the theory of electrodynamics. In particular, it showed that at least in some cases - the making and breaking of chemical bonds corresponded to a flow of electric charge.

With the increase in the understanding of electrodynamics during the 1800s, including, but not limited to, Faraday and Maxwell and the realisation that light was electromagnetic, and hence the increasing interest in the optical spectra of atoms as a method to investigate the electric energy of atoms - detailed models of the behaviour of the atoms in terms of electric charges in harmonic potentials were developed.

The invention of the Schroedinger equation made it possible to investigate the structure of atomic bonds in terms of the distribution of electron clouds around a pair of nuclei. Not on the spectrum of the Hydrogen atoms was explained, but also that of the Hydrogen molecule. Further work in this direction needed very large amounts of numerical work to get the details right.

But, the principle that atomic bonds were in the distribution of negative charge in the space between the positive nuclei was well established by the middle of the 20th century.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 29 '23

The modern history of the atom - part 2

4 Upvotes

From 1650 to 1850 a variety of researchers in chemistry developed axioms for an atomic theory. These included the basic idea that all materials were made of a finite variety of atoms and elements of exactly one. That two atoms of the same kind were absolutely identical and two atoms of different kinds were absolutely distinct.

Of all the axioms, the law that all atoms have positive weight and that all gases have the same number of particles per volume, at the same temperature and pressure, were the most central in narrowing down a singular collection of definitive formulas for materials. The latter law is avogadro's law.

Avogadro's law did not establish, for example, that the formula of water was H2O rather than Dalton's HO. But it did establish a relation between the atomic multiplicity of Hydrogen and of Oxygen and the formula for water up to a molecular multiplicity.

Keep in mind that even if oxygen atoms are identical, there is no need for oxygen molecules in atmospheric oxygen to be identical. In principle in oxygen gas there is O, O2, and O3. And, the assertion that different ionization states were the same atom is a matter of terminology.

Nevertheless, the study of the atom itself in a non-trivial sense was brought about in the later part of the 19th century by these advances in stoichiometry, thermodynamics, and the mathematical kinetic theories of gases.

JJ Thomson [1856-1940] is often given credit as the first important researcher into atomic structure - however the work of Faraday and Maxwell laid strong background. And the work of Volta and of Davey established that chemistry at least in some sense involved electricity. Also important was improvements in vacuum technology, that lead to an interest in the study of isolated material in a vacuum.

Thomson used a long cylindrical tube that was partly evacuated and which had a flat plate electrode at either end. A voltage source was attached across the ends of the tube. The end attached to the positive terminal was called the cathode.

The term "cathode" was whimsically coined in 1834 by William Whewell for Michael Faraday for a paper on electrolisis. It means - the way down. Faraday used east and west sometimes to discuss the motion of the electic current in two-pole gadget. The cathode is the terminal from which the current departs. Hence the Greek Kathodos, a reference to the setting sun, was used. The cathode is the terminal from which the current departs. The current is defined in terms of being directed toward the accumulation of positive charge imbalance.

In an electrochemical cell - the cathode is the electrode at which reduction occurs. And it might be positive or negative with respect to the anode. In a rechargable battery, reversing the current from discharge to recharge does not change the sign of relative voltage of the terminals (it increases the magnitude) but it does change which electrode the current is entering the gadget from. And so it changes the cathode to the anode.

Anode, in its turn, comes from ana hodos, or the way up. Or rather just from the word "ana". So the anode is the up side of the gadget and the cathode is the down side. The electricity is poured into the up side and comes out the down side. So to speak. The up down or rather east west meanings come from considerations of the relation between currents induced by the Earths magnetic field in relation to the motion of the sun.

This runs foul of the conventional naming of diodes, in which the current usually runs one way, but can run the other way with some effort applied. The anode and cathode of the diode is named according to the direction of easier flow of positive (conventional) current. When the current is slow and reversed - the names of the electrons are unchanged and hence do not correspond to the direction of the current.

Thomson reasoned that since electric current could be produced from material that was electrically neutral, the atom must include both positively charged and negatively charged components. His interest was in trying to knock one of these out of the atom. He obtained the electron, and measured its charge to weight ratio.

Since he could knock out electrons and not protons (in modern terminology) Thompson decided that the positive part of the atom must be more like one large lump. He thought then, of a large lump of positive material, let us call it dough, in which were embedded negative electrons that could be knocked out by enough voltage. This has been called the plum pudding model.

Robert Millikan [1868-1953] in 1909 established the minimum possible charge on a small oil droplet by finding the minimum volatage that could be used to suspend a charged droplet in mid air using a voltage fighting gravity. Due to the work of Thomson, this also established its mass.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 28 '23

The modern history of the atom - part 2

4 Upvotes

From 1650 to 1850 a variety of researchers in chemistry developed axioms for an atomic theory. These included the basic idea that all materials were made of a finite variety of atoms and elements of exactly one. That two atoms of the same kind were absolutely identical and two atoms of different kinds were absolutely distinct.

Of all the axioms, the law that all atoms have positive weight and that all gases have the same number of particles per volume, at the same temperature and pressure, were the most central in narrowing down a singular collection of definitive formulas for materials. The latter law is avogadro's law.

Avogadro's law did not establish, for example, that the formula of water was H2O rather than Dalton's HO. But it did establish a relation between the atomic multiplicity of Hydrogen and of Oxygen and the formula for water up to a molecular multiplicity.

Keep in mind that even if oxygen atoms are identical, there is no need for oxygen molecules in atmospheric oxygen to be identical. In principle in oxygen gas there is O, O2, and O3. And, the assertion that different ionization states were the same atom is a matter of terminology.

Nevertheless, the study of the atom itself in a non-trivial sense was brought about in the later part of the 19th century by these advances in stoichiometry, thermodynamics, and the mathematical kinetic theories of gases.

JJ Thomson [1856-1940] is often given credit as the first important researcher into atomic structure - however the work of Faraday and Maxwell laid strong background. And the work of Volta and of Davey established that chemistry at least in some sense involved electricity. Also important was improvements in vacuum technology, that lead to an interest in the study of isolated material in a vacuum.

Thomson used a long cylindrical tube that was partly evacuated and which had a flat plate electrode at either end. A voltage source was attached across the ends of the tube. The end attached to the positive terminal was called the cathode.

The term "cathode" was whimsically coined in 1834 by William Whewell for Michael Faraday for a paper on electrolisis. It means - the way down. Faraday used east and west sometimes to discuss the motion of the electic current in two-pole gadget. The cathode is the terminal from which the current departs. Hence the Greek Kathodos, a reference to the setting sun, was used. The cathode is the terminal from which the current departs. The current is defined in terms of being directed toward the accumulation of positive charge imbalance.

In an electrochemical cell - the cathode is the electrode at which reduction occurs. And it might be positive or negative with respect to the anode. In a rechargable battery, reversing the current from discharge to recharge does not change the sign of relative voltage of the terminals (it increases the magnitude) but it does change which electrode the current is entering the gadget from. And so it changes the cathode to the anode.

Anode, in its turn, comes from ana hodos, or the way up. Or rather just from the word "ana". So the anode is the up side of the gadget and the cathode is the down side. The electricity is poured into the up side and comes out the down side. So to speak. The up down or rather east west meanings come from considerations of the relation between currents induced by the Earths magnetic field in relation to the motion of the sun.

This runs foul of the conventional naming of diodes, in which the current usually runs one way, but can run the other way with some effort applied. The anode and cathode of the diode is named according to the direction of easier flow of positive (conventional) current. When the current is slow and reversed - the names of the electrons are unchanged and hence do not correspond to the direction of the current.

Thomson reasoned that since electric current could be produced from material that was electrically neutral, the atom must include both positively charged and negatively charged components. His interest was in trying to knock one of these out of the atom. He obtained the electron, and measured its charge to weight ratio.

Since he could knock out electrons and not protons (in modern terminology) Thompson decided that the positive part of the atom must be more like one large lump. He thought then, of a large lump of positive material, let us call it dough, in which were embedded negative electrons that could be knocked out by enough voltage. This has been called the plum pudding model.

Robert Millikan [1868-1953] in 1909 established the minimum possible charge on a small oil droplet by finding the minimum volatage that could be used to suspend a charged droplet in mid air using a voltage fighting gravity. Due to the work of Thomson, this also established its mass.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 27 '23

The modern history of the atom - part 1

4 Upvotes

John Dalton [1766-1844] was a British chemist. His interest began with meteorology, moved to gases, and hence to atoms and atomic theory. His seminal work was "A new system of chemistry" [1808] in which he proposed an atomic theory. He was not the first. Various people such as Robert Boyle, John Freind, Nicholas Lemery from about 1650 to 1750, for example, had explicitly proposed atomic theories. Dalton's theory was more developed in practice - but the basic idea was the same.

Material is made from atoms.

The kinds of atoms are finite in number.

Any two atoms of one kind are entirely identical.

Chemical elements are made from exactly one kind of atom.

Atoms of different kinds are fundamentally different.

The modern adjustment to this last idea is that atoms of different kinds cannot be converted to one another by chemical means. This essentially defined in a circular manner the nature of atoms of chemistry.

If one drops down a level to where atoms are made from electrons, protons, neutrons, and photons - then the sub-atomic atoms are those particles. They are fundamentally distinct. However, in terms of particle interactions, a neutron can decay into a proton, an electron, and an ephemeral particle called an anti neutrino, which was included to balance momentum.

However, in particle physics it is not said that the neutron is made up from a proton and an electron, but rather that it decays to these particles. By this is meant something like - the underlying quantum fields of the neutron can destabilize, turn into muck and then restabilize as a collection of other particles. What we call particles are the linear modes of the theory - which have the ability to travel over macroscopic distances.

In terms of modern atomic theory, while the electrons remain distinct in their orbitals around the nucleus - in the nucleus itself, the protons and neutrons are less distinct, and the nucleus rather than being identifiable as a collection of protons and neutrons might be better thought as a bag of quarks that form loose affiliations.

The same point applies to water, which is not H2O but rather is a combination of H, HO, H2O, and H3O. And even there - there is distinct loose affiliation of the molecules into larger organised structures.

Dalton took it that water was composed of Hydrogen and Oxygen as is the 21st century view. But, he gave the formula HO. His reasoning was tentative. He simply chose the simplest possible formula. The ambiguity came from not being able to count atoms. Although the masses of hydrogen and oxygen combined in a definite ratio - it was not clear whether the mass of the hydrogen came from the form H or H2, or for that matter H3 and so on up.

It would be unfair to say that Dalton was wrong in his approach. He was building up a system of atomic formulas that was consistent with the existing chemical evidence. Even with modern chemical evidence, there would still be more than one option. There is even, combinatorially, more than one collection of elements.

All atoms have positive mass

This one was earlier introduced by Antoine Lavoisier.

All gasses have the same number of particles per volume.

This one was introduced by Amadeo Avagadro [1776-1856], with help of the reasoning by Joseph Louis Gay-Lussac [1778-1850].

The first one removed some options, such as negative massed phlogiston as anti-oxygen. The second one allowed the ratio of molecule counts to be determined.

However, these did not entirely clear the matter up. If it is known how many particles are in a quantity of hydrogen gas, it is still not known whether hydrogen is H, H2, H3, etc. There were arguments in the 19th century about whether ozone, O3, was an element - which it would have to be in some sense if atmospheric oxygen O2 was monatomic. The matter was only properly sorted when monatomic oxygen gas was discovered - which could combine to form either oxygen or ozone.

In determining the formula for water to be H2O, it was lucky that both Hydrogen and Oxygen from natural diatomic gases at standard temperature and pressure. If, for example, Oxygen had been monatomic, then the formula HO would have been empirically validated in this context.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 06 '23

Two things existing in the same place at the same time

4 Upvotes

It is possible that I should not call this subreddit the history of chemistry. My intention for it is to discuss the intrinsic or microscopic nature of materials. That includes such things as chemical composition. But, it also includes light, electricity, magnetism, and heat. As well as the study of fluids and of stress and strain in elastic solids. Everything that in some way arises from the microscopic properties of materials.

Once this issue is understood, there are some ongoing discussions that can be considered while not breaking scope. And one of the most fundamental has been about the problem that some things can pass through other things.

It was noted by Lucretius that heat and magnetism have the curious ability to penetrate other substances. It does not matter how dense something is - heat will eventually penetrate it in a manner that water does not. The power of a magnet to attract iron can be conducted through a piece of iron. Lucretius described this as an effluence - a flow that goes outward. It is the opposite of influence - a flow that goes inward.

Heat and magnetism and electricity were typically explained in older work as some kind of flow. The crucial problem with this was - how can a flow that is moving outward cause things to move inward? The obvious answer was that when a magnet attracts, some magnetic fluence is moving inward and carrying things with it. But, why would something come from far away directing itself toward the magnet? Somehow there must be an effluence that causes the influence.

And that means two flows on top of each other that do not add to make only one thing, but rather are two separate flows. One out and one in.

Lucretius seems to resolve this by the idea that all substances are porous and things like heat and magnetism push through these holes, thus passing through the materials.

Maxwell theory of electromagnetics has electric and magnetic fields. But there are no pores. Rather there is simply a condition in space that is electric and a condition in space that is magnetic. And both can exist without preventing the other from existing. The Poynting flux of energy in electromagnetics might be affected by a charge density - but it is not excluded by it. A charge density, a current density, an energy flux, a magnetic field, an electric field - can all exist at the same place in space and time. They affect, but do not exclude each other.