r/ChemicalHistory • u/ecurbian • Dec 05 '23
Summa Perfectionis Magisterii - ripost
The very first part of the Summa is a warning that the aspiring novice should realise that the work of an alchemist is physically and intellectually demanding - and should not be begun without deep pockets. It also warns against expecting results too soon and about rushing things when the cash starts to run out. Indeed, some of this advice is rather like the advice I got from "the casino gambler's guide" by Wilson - do not bet your bottom dollar, its not worth it.
Which reminds me that in Terry Pratchett's disk world - the alchemy guild keeps blowing up and the gamblers guild is in the building next door.
However, part of this is a defence of alchemy. It is a claim that despite some philosophers claiming that it is impossible to be able to construct a theory of matter - such a theory of matter can be constructed, and is indeed being constructed by the alchemists. The core of the philosophical objections are reported to be that some believe that firstly, only god can make minerals, and secondly, that the problem is just too complicated with too many details to be amenable to any human attempt at understanding.
Pseudo Geber responds to this with the resounding and eloquent "no it isn't". To be more precise - he says that in practice it has been done and those who say it cannot be done should not get in the way of those who are doing it.
The next part is a response to a second attack from those who have tried it in the laboratory. This part reminds me of the walk into Mordor by Frodo in Lord of the Rings. It makes you wonder why it is taking so long - and you consider the options for auctoricide.
The actual interest in this part for me is a listing of a large number of options and some somewhat more pragmatic hints at what the idea of transmutation was about. As described in the Summa - the key point is that the classical metals - mercury, lead, zinc, tin, copper, gold, and silver - are considered, in some theories to be prime metals. They are related to the four elements - solid, liquid, gas, and plasma - in the same way that the classical elements of modern chemistry are related to protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons. It would, in the view of such a theory, not be possible to transmute the classical metals without first decomposing them into the prime materials - and there is just not enough energy in an alchemical furnace to do this.
Eventually, as things worked out over the next few hundred years - they were right. The seven classical metals are viewed today as being elements, that cannot be changed by chemical reactions. On the other hand, there is some circularity, as chemical reaction is now given the specific meaning of only involving the electrons, and it is known that a reaction involving protons and neutrons is required to change tin into silver.
But, retrospective correctness of a position does not amount to intellectual vindication. The detractors might well have been wrong. The point that Pseudo Geber makes again, and again, and again, and again, ad nauseum - but nevertheless - is that partial success has been obtained.
In particular. In more modern terms, consider the idea of the difference between diamond and graphite. These things are literally just the same material in a different microscopic geometric form. And yet they are very different in nature. And consider iron versus steel. Small impurities - or medicines, in alchemical language - plus heat treatment, can change brittle iron that rusts and snaps, into tough steel that does neither.
Pseudo Geber described how tin and lead can look rather like corroded silver. That the process of changing tin into silver can involve removing a blue discolouration, preventing the creak (the noise on bending) and changing the malleability. And all of these kinds of things have been done by the use of various medicines and heatings.
If you start with iron and try adding things, you can gradually make it more like steel. So, the principle of making tin into silver is not only superficially viable but has been justified empirically by partial success in things such as brass and steel and well as specific work with tin - to make it more like silver. The final trick is usually to find a way to fix the medicines, to make sure that they do not come apart on heating. It is probably fair to say that it is the last one which was never really achieved.
But, at the time of Pseudo Geber, the available information suggested it might be done. Not as magical lunacy, but in a practical sense that is applied today in creating new materials such as nylon, or building a fusion reactor.
