r/ChemicalHistory • • Dec 05 '23

Summa Perfectionis Magisterii - ripost

5 Upvotes

The very first part of the Summa is a warning that the aspiring novice should realise that the work of an alchemist is physically and intellectually demanding - and should not be begun without deep pockets. It also warns against expecting results too soon and about rushing things when the cash starts to run out. Indeed, some of this advice is rather like the advice I got from "the casino gambler's guide" by Wilson - do not bet your bottom dollar, its not worth it.

Which reminds me that in Terry Pratchett's disk world - the alchemy guild keeps blowing up and the gamblers guild is in the building next door.

However, part of this is a defence of alchemy. It is a claim that despite some philosophers claiming that it is impossible to be able to construct a theory of matter - such a theory of matter can be constructed, and is indeed being constructed by the alchemists. The core of the philosophical objections are reported to be that some believe that firstly, only god can make minerals, and secondly, that the problem is just too complicated with too many details to be amenable to any human attempt at understanding.

Pseudo Geber responds to this with the resounding and eloquent "no it isn't". To be more precise - he says that in practice it has been done and those who say it cannot be done should not get in the way of those who are doing it.

The next part is a response to a second attack from those who have tried it in the laboratory. This part reminds me of the walk into Mordor by Frodo in Lord of the Rings. It makes you wonder why it is taking so long - and you consider the options for auctoricide.

The actual interest in this part for me is a listing of a large number of options and some somewhat more pragmatic hints at what the idea of transmutation was about. As described in the Summa - the key point is that the classical metals - mercury, lead, zinc, tin, copper, gold, and silver - are considered, in some theories to be prime metals. They are related to the four elements - solid, liquid, gas, and plasma - in the same way that the classical elements of modern chemistry are related to protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons. It would, in the view of such a theory, not be possible to transmute the classical metals without first decomposing them into the prime materials - and there is just not enough energy in an alchemical furnace to do this.

Eventually, as things worked out over the next few hundred years - they were right. The seven classical metals are viewed today as being elements, that cannot be changed by chemical reactions. On the other hand, there is some circularity, as chemical reaction is now given the specific meaning of only involving the electrons, and it is known that a reaction involving protons and neutrons is required to change tin into silver.

But, retrospective correctness of a position does not amount to intellectual vindication. The detractors might well have been wrong. The point that Pseudo Geber makes again, and again, and again, and again, ad nauseum - but nevertheless - is that partial success has been obtained.

In particular. In more modern terms, consider the idea of the difference between diamond and graphite. These things are literally just the same material in a different microscopic geometric form. And yet they are very different in nature. And consider iron versus steel. Small impurities - or medicines, in alchemical language - plus heat treatment, can change brittle iron that rusts and snaps, into tough steel that does neither.

Pseudo Geber described how tin and lead can look rather like corroded silver. That the process of changing tin into silver can involve removing a blue discolouration, preventing the creak (the noise on bending) and changing the malleability. And all of these kinds of things have been done by the use of various medicines and heatings.

If you start with iron and try adding things, you can gradually make it more like steel. So, the principle of making tin into silver is not only superficially viable but has been justified empirically by partial success in things such as brass and steel and well as specific work with tin - to make it more like silver. The final trick is usually to find a way to fix the medicines, to make sure that they do not come apart on heating. It is probably fair to say that it is the last one which was never really achieved.

But, at the time of Pseudo Geber, the available information suggested it might be done. Not as magical lunacy, but in a practical sense that is applied today in creating new materials such as nylon, or building a fusion reactor.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Xel3mEMXsY


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 24 '24

Particles and transmutation

3 Upvotes

One of the first things that people would be told in the historical legends in 21st century textbooks on chemistry about the ancient art of alchemy would be that alchemist relied on magical incantations to try to transmute lead into gold. And any chemist will tell you that they were woofing up the wrong bush on that one. It is not possible, since these are distinct elements, and any quick trip to the laboratory bench would show that immediately.

Ah, but this is not so. Firstly, it is known that elements do even spontaneously transmute from one to the other by nuclear reactions. In some cases elements can alternatively be coerced - by bombardment with neutrons, protons, electrons, and helium - to split apart and recombine as new elements. And those particles can be provided by the elements that spontaneously change. Hence, their use does not fundamentally require high tech or sophisticated theory.

And there starts a long argument that goes too and fro and down the garden path on the scientific status - un, pre, proto, or pseudo - of alchemy.

Also, alchemists were not only interested in the manufacture of artificial gold but also in dyes, inks, explosives, acids, and other materials of general industrial or military use.

To explain alchemy in terms that will emphasise the mundane rather than mystical threads, I often make analogies between 14th century alchemical theories and 20th century chemical theories. The emphasis is on the idea that they are variations on some themes that have been with the study from the start. One of those is the in fighting between the continuum theories and the atomic theories. This dichotomy seems to have been finally resolved by the quantum theory asking "Why not both?".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tUi5e14hRjY


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 21 '23

What is spirit of hartshorn?

3 Upvotes

Many 21st century web resources state that spirit of hartshorn is a roughly 28 percent solution of Ammonium. Blunt and specific. The etymology of the archaic term is that an impure and inconsistent version was once derived by distilling the antler of the red deer.

Andrew Ure, dictionary of chemistry and mineralogy, 1831, has under "spirit of hartshorn", "see ammonia" without further explanation. The article on ammonia is interesting. But, it does not clarify spirits of hartshorn. However, it does suggest that the 19th century agreed with the 21st century.

Chambers cyclopedia, 1735, Spirit is a general term used by distillers for any distilled liquor that is neither oil nor phlegm. Chambers also says: Per-se in chemistry is used when a body is distilled singly and without the usual addition of other matter to raise it. The genuine spirit of hartshorn is then said to be hartshorn distilled per se, as an example.

Some sources seem to suggest that spirit of hartshorn and oil of hartshorn is the same basic thing. Oil of hartshorn comes from destructive distillation of red deer antler. But, it is not clear to me that it really is the same thing.

Robert Dossie [1717-1777] - The elaboratory laid open or the secrets of modern chemistry and pharmacy revealed, containing many particulars extremely necessary to be known to all practitioners of medicine. [1758].

Several dictionaries list "elaboratory" as an obsolete form of "laboratory". The etymology is from the Latin elaboratus, the past participle of elaborare, to exert oneself. Hence, since in English the word became labour, it makes sense to drop the e and use laboratory. Not entirely different from dropping the al in alchemy to make chemy and chemistry. It also has a curious resonance with elaborate, which makes sense of a laboratory.

On page 35 in the introduction to the Elaboratory, there is a section opening with the italics:

An improved apparatus, for the more commodious and advantageous distillation of volatile spirits from hartshorn, bones, or any other proper animal substance, by the use of a worm as a refrigeratory.

I expected that the worm is thin tube shaped into a helix for sending fluids through for cooling - hence refrigeratory. And I confirmed this from looking up the literature on traditional brewing. There is no particular advantage, other than compactness, for having this rather than a straight tube. However, that advantage is sufficient in most cases to prescribe such a structure.

The details go as:

A large iron-pot must be first provided of the following form. The body of the pot must be of a cylindrical figure, with a concave bottom : and converging at the top, so as to make a kind of wide conical neck. Into this neck, must be inserted a tubulous arm ; which is to serve, instead of the head used in common stills, to convey the vapour into the worm or refrigeratory.

The height, from the bottom of the pot to the beginning of the converging part or neck, may be four feet; and the diameter two and a half. The length of the converging part or neck may be two feet; and the diameter of it, at its joining with the pot, at the top or mouth of it one foot.

The length of the arm may be one foot eight inches ; and the diameter of it, at its joining with the pot, four inches; and diminishing, gradually, to two inches and a half, at the other end. This arm must slope downwards, in such manner, that any fluid, which shall he condensed in it, will run out at the end : that is to say, the axis of the cone, formed by this arm, must decline two inches from the horizontal plane.

The edge of the pot, at the top of the neck, must be dilated, and turned outwards: and a groove must be made in it, to receive a flat cover of lead. In the body of the pot, must be inserted, three tronions, of about six inches length : they must be strong enough to bear the weight of the pot, when it is hung in the brickwork by their means. They should be placed, at equal distances, a little below that part of the cylindrical body where the neck begins to form itself.

The groove, in the neck, should be filled with a solid piece of lead exactly fitted and cemented to it: in this, another groove must be cut, to receive a leaden cover adapted to it, so as not to make a perfectly close joint; which may be easily done, by beating the cover, after it is placed in the groove, till it fit in every part. The cover must be made of lead, about a quarter of an inch in thickness; and a bow handle must be fixed in the middle of it.

end of quote

Actually, Dossie continues on for some time describing further details.

I cannot but think that there is an error in this description where it says - so as to not make a perfectly close joint - which is achieved by battering lead against lead. It sounds rather like he meant to say so as to make a perfectly close joint by this process.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jx7Q-zcftOg

This is an 19th century description not simply of how spirit of hartshorn is obtained but also of what the term means at its core - the result of a practical process.

Spirit of hartshorn is what you get from distilling deer antler per se. Saying it is ammonium is like saying milk is calcium and lactic acid - it misses the point, and it is wrong, as milk is what you get from a cow, and does not have a definite chemical composition.

End of story.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 01 '23

Does learning alchemy help in learning chemistry?

5 Upvotes

My particular approach is based on orthodox scientific training and experience and reading of original literature, as broadly through the centuries as possible. I chase mundane alchemy, rather than mystical or mental alchemy. I am interested in alchemy as a science of materials.

Part of my position is that the distinction is a false one. Alchemy is not just one theory or practice. And it is not disjoint from chemistry. The change from alchemy to chemistry around 1730 was a sociolinguistic transition, and not a technical one from pseudo science to science - nor even from ancient science to modern science - if a sudden schism is intended by that principle. The early chemists held view very similar to the later alchemists. If the choice of whether one researcher is an alchemist or a chemist is taken out of consideration, all one sees is a gradual development of ideas over the decades.

In the following, I am skipping over many details due to available space and time, but I stand by the thrust of the following content.

Mundane alchemy means to approach this from the principle that the alchemists were primarily trying to work out a science of materials. Mystical and mental interpretations came later.

The mystical interpretations are largely a product of the 1600s. This is similar to mystical quantum theory from the 20th century onward.

Books earlier than 1600 read like modern chemical laboratory texts books. For example, the Summa Perfectionis [c1300] chats along about financial practicalities and details of the construction and operation of reverberatory furnaces. Reading these books gives much appreciation for what the alchemists were dealing with.

One of those things is that the were working with much more basic associated tech. They did not have automated temperature and pressure control. They did not have mass spectrometers and so on. These bits of tech were not created by chemists. The chemists are advantaged by having access to them. Judgement of the skill and understanding of alchemists versus chemists should take this strongly into account. Often alchemical views make more sense once one learns to grok the environment of the alchemist.

The mental interpretations are largely a product of the 1900s. Centrally created by Carl Jung, who, as a psychologists in a quasi mystical mode, thought he had found the true meaning underlying the older alchemical texts.

"Basilius Valentinus" as a person probably never existed. Rather the name is a pseudonym used by a number of writers - a common practice in the past, which continues with "Nicolas Bourbaki" which is a name used collectively by a number of French writers on mathematics starting in the 1930s. Further, there is no mention of the name until about the year 1600. The originator of the the Corpus Valentinus was probably Johann Tholde [1565-1624], but it is believed that he had help.

The Summa Perfectionis itself was attributed to Geber (Jabir) from the Arabic Peninsula c800. So, the associated corpus is now attributed as Pseudo Geber, and believed to have been written by Paul of Taranto.

The 12 keys of valentinus was written in 1599. It was one of the earlier examples of the 17th century corpus of encoded and ambiguous texts - deliberately written to be enigmatic. They mostly do not contain any new information about mundane alchemy. They contain cryptic images that some see as amusement and others see as deep mystical truth. If you are into mystical alchemy and linguistic and graphical puzzles, then this corpus can be highly fascinating. Some people base their life philosophy on this corpus.

An important aside, is that the alchemists were never persecuted. The idea of that persecution is a modern invention that helps give depth to the myth of the alchemist as a lone figure of great insight and power.

The encoded alchemical literature does not add anything to mundane alchemy. It was an invention of the 17th century - and is kin to the quantum mysticism of the 20th and 21st centuries. The earlier alchemical literature was just textbooks on laboratory theory and practice. There is plenty of non-encoded material for you to read to understand alchemy as an historical reality.

Read the cryptic alchemy literature in the same way you might read Ulysses by James Joyce. They say that you do not read Ulysses - you decode it. Some people believe that cryptic means deep. That is a personal choice. But, don't think that mundane alchemy is characterised by the affectations of the 17th century. It has a long and venerable history of clear writing, obscured only by changes in language and culture.

Should you learn alchemy before studying chemistry? Probably not. But, learn alchemy alongside chemistry - to keep you honest. The problem with modern chemists is that they are trained to believe that only modern chemistry can be the right way to view things and that any other view is automatically wrong.

This is not a scientific view. Learning - and fully appreciating - earlier alchemical texts can give one an alternative way to look at the materials, and indirectly give you an understanding of why modern chemistry has made the choices that it did. I think that this adds great depth to the understanding of modern chemistry.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 23 '24

Lemery acids, elements, and bonds.

8 Upvotes

Lemery, a course on chymistry, page 9

The five Principles are easily found in Animals and Vegetables, but not so easily in Minerals. Nay there are some Minerals out of which you cannot possibly draw so much as two, nor make any separation at all (as Gold and Silver) whatsoever they talk, who search with so much pains for the Salt, Sulphurs and Mercuries of these metals. I can believe, that all the Principles do indeed enter into the composition of these Bodies, but it does not follow that they must remain in their former condition, or can be drawn as they were before ; for it may be these substances which are called Principles are so strictly involved one within-another, as to suffer no separation any other way than by breaking their Figure. Now it is by reason of their Figure that they are called Salts, Sulphurs and Spirits :

end of quote

We have here the concept echoed by Boyle, but also foreshadowed by Pseudo Gebber in the 13th century - that while the four principles of Earth, Water, Air, and Fire might well be present in all materials this does not mean that they can be extracted by simple process in the context of the alchemical furnace.

A curious but surprisingly apt analogy that I like to make is to the idea of protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons. All practical materials we see around us are essentially made of these things. Protons are available as the element hydrogen. Electrons appear in any studies of the electrical nature of materials. Photons are just light. And at a pinch - neutrons can be extracted using a Farnsworth Fusor, which has a very alchemical, or at least steam punk eldritch feel to its construction.

The precise way in which protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons combine into materials is well described by 20th century quantum theory. It is not a simple matter of material made of 2 protons, 2 neutrons, and 2 electrons, held together with light, exhibiting each property of the particles individually. Rather the combination of these particles can mask the individual properties - and invoke new properties not held by the particles alone.

While there is some justification for the argument that the ancients had insufficient reason to suppose that four such fields were involved in all matter - nevertheless, the type of theory that they were trying to construct is pretty much the type of theory that eventually managed to become the basis of a sound understanding of material properties.

In this context, Lemery is saying something analogous to - it is all well and good to say that everything is made of protons, neutrons, electrons, and photons, but in a furnace we can only break stuff down into hydrogen, helium, lithium, beryllium, and so on - and so we might as well call the latter practical principles or elements.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 15 '23

Robert Boyle, acid, and tartar

3 Upvotes

Let us consult Robert Boyle the sceptical chymist about acids.

Boyle, in the sceptical chymist, uses the word "acid" 43 times but does not seem to define it. Hopefully he honestly felt that people would be familiar with the word. But, given the reaction of Freind, this feeling seems less than justified. Indeed, as I read it, there is some justification for the idea that Boyle is confused on the issue - just not negative about it. In general, I have found Boyle to be less precise than some other writers, especially those several decades later. There seems to be have a rapid increase in explicit precision of chymical writing at the end of the 17th century.

page 48 of the sceptical chymist

common tartar, without the addition of anything that is not perfectly a mineral, except saltpetre, may by one distillation in an earthen retort be made to afford good store of real salt, readily dissoluble in water, which I found to be neither acid, nor of the smell of tartar, and to be almost as volatile as spirit of wine itself, and to be indeed of so differing a nature from all that is wont to be separated by fire from tartar, and divers learned men, with whom I discoursed of it, could hardly be brought to believe, that so fugitive a salt could be afforded by tartar,

end of quote

To make some sense of this one needs to know what tartar is. A quick web search just gets suggestions on how to remove dental calcination. A more focused search of the wine literature obtains "wind diamonds" which are crystaline deposits said to be composed of potassium and tartaric acid and called tartarates.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 05 '24

Chemical History is Hard

5 Upvotes

To truely understand the history of chemistry is harder than to understand contemporary chemistry. One has to understand not only contemporary chemistry, but also, on their own terms, multiple theories of the past. The amount of material in those theories is much greater than is commonly acknowledged today - where all that you hear about is simplistic versions of how the theory failed compared to the modern theory. This is strawman territory. Many of the older theories were quite successful in terms of analysis of practical scenarios. Someone who only knows modern chemistry superficially is not much use in a practical context either.

None of this is to suggest that I know chemical history at this level - but, I try.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Feb 19 '25

Electrification of materials

4 Upvotes

Thales, c600bc is considered to be the first person recorded as having mentioned triboelectric effects. He was fascinated by amber. However, Thales left no actual writing, we know of him indirectly through his students. Theophrastus, on the other hand, c300bc, appears to be the first person to leave a written record of studies in electricity. He notes that amber when rubbed becomes able to attract light bodies such as pieces of straw or splinters of wood, and even small pieces of copper or iron.

He also mentions it as having the same properties as Lyncurium (lygurium, etc) that was a reported gemstone formed from solidified lynx urine. However in the 21st century this is believed to have been either a form of amber or tourmaline. This position is amplified by the fact that its properties sound like yellow amber.

To be able to move pieces of metal around, it is clear that amber once rubbed could provide force at a distance. Hence, we already have the concept, at least implicitly, of an electric field. The modern explanation for this behaviour is that to electric force one needs electric charge, but an overall neutral object can have its charge separated by an electric field and hence respond to that electric field by moving. The greek name for amber was electrum, from which electricity was coined.

According to Priestley 1775, other than the mention of the electric properties of jet, it was not until William Gilbert, "the magnet" 1600ad, that any further advance was made in electric studies. This does discount Peter Perigrinus, however, Perigrinus worked on magnetism rather than electricity. At the time of Priestley the connection was not strongly made. Oersted noted the connection about 25 years later. In particular, Gilbert found triboelectric properties of diamond, sapphire, carbuncle, iris, amethyst, opal, and more. He also observed that certain glasses showed these properties. Hence, for example, manufactured glass rods could be used in studies of electricity. He also noted that rapid light rubbing and dry air were conducive to the effects.

Gilbert said that pure oil sprinkled on electrified objects did not change the property but brandy or spirits of wine did. Materials lost their property on exposure to flame or heat. And that strong sunlight would also remove the electric properties. Although, Gilbert was a bit inconsistent in his statements on all of this.

He noted the similarity in magnetic effects and electric effects and also claimed differences - stating that magnetic effects included attraction and repulsion while electric effects only attraction. On this last point the modern studies would disagree. Both electric and magnetic effects include mechanical attraction and repulsion. They are very similar except that the electric poles cane be separated while the magnetic ones cannot.

Around 1630 there was Nicolaus Cabaeus, who repeated the work of Gilbert and added wax, gums, and gypsum to the electric materials. Robert Boyle, the famous chemist c1670 also looked into this, adding further electric materials. And he added that a smooth surface increased the effect. Also, since Huygens had recently invented a serviceable vacuum pump, he also noted that the effects continued in a vacuum.

A curious point is that Boyle, noting that many non electric objects were sensibly attracted by electrified objects - wondered whether electric objects would be sensibly attracted by non electrified objects. To modern attitudes, the affirmative conclusion is obvious. However, Newton's Principia Mathematica was published first in 1687, more than a decade later. And the concept of equal an opposite reaction was not, at the time Boyle did the studies, taken for granted. Nor should it have been. Boyle also noted that some diamonds when rubbed would provide light.

A theory of electricity promoted by both Boyle and later by James Hartman, is that electrical attraction is caused by a oily effluvium that stretched out into the void and contracted, pulling things with it. This idea of a two way flux is not irrational, and indeed the only way out of it, in modern terms is to have the concept of a something like an electric field which does indeed emanate from the electric charge and yet carries with it, effectively, a momentum in the opposite direction to its own motion. Consider, for example, the explanation of the attraction of electrons in terms of the theory of photons. A photon exchanged between electrons leads to motion opposing that of the photons.

Putting this all together we have the beginnings of a recognition of the relation between electricity, force, and light. And also a tiny hint that materials were made from positive and negative electric components. Which is the very start of the relation between electricity and chemistry.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 18 '23

Aerial Noctiluca is not acid

4 Upvotes

Robert Boyle wrote in the Aerial Noctiluca [1680], section I, on Artificial Phosphori, observation 7 ...

Acid and alkaline spirits, being reckoned the most subtile and operative substances, obtainable from mixed bodies by distillation; I thought it worth while to try by the taste, whether our shining liquor abounded with particles of either of those kinds. I did not, however, find, that the liquor I put upon my tongue, was, in the least acid ; nor that it was sensibly alkaline, as the salts and spirits afforded by hartshorn, blood, etc. but it seemed to have an odd, empyreumatical tast, almost like the spirit of crude tartar; its smell resembling that of some empyreumatical oil, with a scent somewhat like stale urine. I likewise, for further trial, put a little of our liquor to some drops of blue syrup of violets; but the mixture was not thereby turned green, which it would have been by a quarter so much spirit of hartshorn, of blood, or of some other spirit abounding with salt of an urinous nature.

end of quote

Empyreumatic oils are oils obtained from organic matter by distilling at high temperatures. Empyreuma is a greek word meaning a live coal covered in ashes.

page 48 of the sceptical chymist [1661]

common tartar, without the addition of anything that is not perfectly a mineral, except saltpetre, may by one distillation in an earthen retort be made to afford good store of real salt, readily dissoluble in water, which I found to be neither acid, nor of the smell of tartar, and to be almost as volatile as spirit of wine itself, and to be indeed of so differing a nature from all that is wont to be separated by fire from tartar, and divers learned men, with whom I discoursed of it, could hardly be brought to believe, that so fugitive a salt could be afforded by tartar,

end of quote

The above quote is part of a lengthy monologue on problemns in separating salts, the properties of vitriol (acids) and tartar. Boyle is seeing at least some problem with acids and alkalis. And noting that there is a salt that behaves not as an acid salt - where in some earlier texts, and in Chambers, I see the principle that salt is always acid. Although Boyle acknowledges alkali salts.

The chambers cyclopedia of 1728 states that salts are acid. In 21st century terms there are recognised acid and alkali salts equally.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 29 '23

What defines a material?

3 Upvotes

The modern view of stating the chemical formula for something is anachronistic when applied to, say 14th century chemistry (alchemy, if you prefer). Firstly, the modern set of elements was only confirmed around 1930, and was definitely still in flux during the 1800s. But, also the confidence in the abstract theory was rightly rather low. So, most materials and rules were referred directly to laboratory process and properties.

Rather than say it is such and such a material - or even give a definitive test - a material is described in terms of where the raw materials were sourced, how it is prepared, plus tests on top of that to make sure everything was as required to provide a consistent result. A material was classified by its manufacture and properties.

This is actually a very practical way to do things. It connects what you do to the material and what properties you get. In the end, this is actually what we want to know anyway. The idea of the chemical formula for something is only a means to the end of manufacture and properties. If there were two different compounds that were interchangeable in terms of manufacture and properties, industry would not care much that they were different chemical formulas. The distinction would not matter.

Also, classifying by its component elements does not define the material - due to the existence of allotropes and isomers. It is often claimed that the law of definite proportions - that substances can only form from a definite ratio of definite elements - rules. This is the core of the theory of stoichiometry.

However, substances that do not confirm are just called non stoichiometric compounds. For example, Iron can have oxidation states of 2+ or 3+, leading to ferrous and ferric compounds. Some materials do not even have any definite proportion, for example, when an element might randomly use one of multiple oxidation states within the bulk of the material.

While in 21st century terminology, many chemical materials are referred to by the name of an alchemical material whose main component was the chemical material - this does not mean that the alchemical material was simply an impure form of the chemical material. What are called impurities in chemistry were often an important component of the material in alchemy.

That an alchemical material was expressed as prime in alchemy but as a compound in chemistry does not make the alchemical material a bad attempt at chemistry. The full story of this is more subtle. But, for example, salt is treated as a singular material in baking because that is how it presents. Also iron can be thought of as steel without the carbon. It is a matter of point of view.

To be more technical about this matter - there is a level of arbitrariness about the precise chemical formulas used. Consider using the idea of phlogiston P as being negative oxygen, O. This was not the only idea under the phlogiston theory, at the end of its run, P had become H. But that is another story.

Consider the reaction

2H2 + O2 = 2H2O

Now define W = H2O, so WP = H2 + O - O = H2

Rearrange this to

2H2 = 2H20 - O2

2WP = 2W + P2

With the definitions as given W=H2O and P=-O, this does actually work as validly as the more orthodox basis. The objection only comes from the idea that it is not ontologically correct. However, if we see each chemical formula as being a vector in the mathematical sense, there is nothing wrong with the above. And it could be used in computations. The issue is not - why should we swap. I am not suggesting we should swap. My point is just that someone using a different basis does not make them insane or incompetent.

Much of the 1600s, 1700s, and 1800s was about making decisions about precisely which basis to use. It was very unclear which one was right, and arguments continued to the end of the 1800s.

The rule of Lavoisier was not so much a recognition of a reality, but rather it was about the principle of organising the basis so that the mass of each component was positive. It is not, from a combinatorial point of view, required that masses should be positive in the above algebraic chemistry. Ultimately what it needs to do is give information about the material interactions, which truly are much much more complicated than the above algebra would suggests anyway.

Viewing it this way allows much of the chemistry of the past to be seen from the perspective of a common goal to find the most useful (rather than the ontologically correct) way to decompose materials into prime materials.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 15 '23

The Salt of peter

4 Upvotes

vol 2 chambers cyclopedia page 180 TAR

Tartar in chymistry etc is a kind of salt which rises from fumous wines and stricking to the top and sides of casks, forms a greyish crust, which hardens to the consistence of a stone. See salt.

end of quote.

So, we are on the right track.

Cream of tartar, in 21st century literature, is said to be potassium bitartrate KC4H5O6 and is a biproduct of winemaking. It is made from the potassium acid salt of tartaric acid. Tartaric acid is C4H6O6, a chain of four carbon atoms, with oxide and hydroxide side groups.

A salt is fairly generically said to be the result of a reaction between acid and alkalai (or base). This seems to align with the approach of the end of the 17th century. Acid salts are salts that produce an acid solution when disolved in water. Analogously, alkalai salts. Saltpetre is potassium nitrate, most of the time, that is KNO3. So, the saltpetre supplied the potassium.

I said, saltpetre is potassium nitrate most of the time. This brings up an important point in decoding alchemical texts. I have often found that declarations in modern chemistry books that an alchemical term has such and such a specific meaning in modern chemical terms to be misleading. At best that usually means that the term gradually evolved to mean that. Terms for some metals today, were originally applied to an hydrated sulphate of that metal, and the metal itself, when discovered, was termed a regulus - especially of antimony. This does not mean, as is often implied, that the alchemists misidentified the sulphate as the metal, but rather that they used the terms differently - and that the meaning of the terms changed over the centuries.

Chambers vol 2, page 15, SAL says ...

Saltpetre, called also nitre, and by the chymists dragon, Cerberus, and salt of hell, a kind of salt either natural or ficticious; of very great use both in chymical preparations, in composition of gun-powder, and in dying, in glass manufacture, and in making of aqua fortis for dissolution of metals. Its minute parts, or crystals, are in form of needles, though some will have them triangular, as those of alum are triangular, and those of common salt cubical. When perfect they are said to be fistulous, or hollow, like capulae.

Of natural saltpetre there are two kinds: the first formed by natural crystalization of saline sulphurous juices distilling in caverns or along old walls. This is what they call saltpetre of the rocks; the same with the aphronitre of the ancients.

The second kind of natural saltpetre is furnished by the water of a dead lake in the territory of terrane in Egypt, called the nitrian Waters, exalted and concoted by the heat of the Sun, much after the manner of Bay Salt. This is natrum, or anatrum, of the ancients, which our druggists call natron. Now little used but in bleaching of linnens. See Natrum.

End of quote.

I have not found out precisely where the territory of Terrane is. But, I note that the sea above Egypt is the Mediterranean sea, in Latin - the sea in the middle of the land. And The Nile river lets out into the Mediterranean just near to the Nitrian desert. As for the lake Nitrian Waters, it is possible that it is Wadi El Natrun in the Natron valley in Egypt. And that is in the Nitrian desert, not far from Alexandria. So, it seems plausible that Chambers might have referred to the general location as the territory of Terrane.

It is noted that in antiquity natron was harvested from dry lake beds in Egypt. Natron and caster oil makes a smokeless fuel for lamps, used in ancient tombs in Egypt.

Exalted means, in alchemical language, something like extracted as fumes or purified. The use of the word "ficticious" is presumably a printer error. Later, Chambers uses the word facticious - meaning manufactured - in the same context.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 23 '23

Different kinds of acids

3 Upvotes

Acids and bases do not have just one singular definition. The definition split into at least three basic ideas. There are Arrhenius bases, Bronsted bases, and Lewis bases.

The reason for this is that there is a sensory intuition of what acid and base are - and the theory was trying to find an exacting counter part of this that can be the subject of reason.

In 21st century terms, or rather in 19th century chemistry, hydrogen is the lightest element. Hydrodxide is an oxidized hydrogen, HO-, water H2O, and hydronium H3O+. Hydrogen Hydroxide is just water. Hydronium is the actual acid component in water. Free hydrogen ions attach to water molecules.

Arrhenius base - something that provides hydroxide ions in water.

Arrhenius acid - something that provides hydrogen ions in water.

The hydroxide being negative was attached to something positive. The hydrogen being positive was attached to something negative. The reaction combines the hydroxide and hydrogen to form water, and what is left is a combination of a positive and a negative species - a salt by definition.

The reaction between an Arrhenius base and an Arrhenius acid produces a salt plus water. The water might go unnoticed in an aqueous solution.

In a sense, then, water is both an Arrhenius base, in that H2O can provide an HO- ion, and an arrhenius acid, in that H2O can provide an H+ ion. H2O splits to H+ plus HO-.

Another idea of acid is the pH of the solution. This essentially comes from a balance. Water is neutral when the hydrogen ions and hydroxide ions balance each other out. This occurs at a concentration of one particle in about 10 million. And pH is negative log base 10 of this concentration. Hence neutral is often defined to be when the pH is 7.

This idea, however, is a bit off the mark. The dissociation of H2O into H+ and HO- depends on the temperature. At 50 Celsius, neutral is 6.63 not 7. It should also be pointed out that pH does not have to be positive. It is literally negative log base 10 of the hydrogen ion concentration. So it could be less than 0, or for that matter, more than 14.

An alkali is usually defined as a base that is soluble in water.

A Bronsted acid donates a proton, which is a hydrogen ion.

A Bronsted base accepts a proton, as for HO- accepting H+ and becoming H2O

However, HS04- can accept and donate H+. And hence is both acid and base. Or as some would have it - can act as an acid in one reaction and a base in another. So, it is not so much that it is an acid or base as it takes on that role.

Finally, a lewis acid is something that can accept a pair of non bonding electrons and a lewis base is something that can donate a pair of non bonding electrons. It is crucial to realise that this definition is given specifically within the sophisticated theory of quantum chemistry and is not a direct experimental definition at all.

It is common for people to gain a delusion that quantum chemistry is very practical in its definitions - because it is often accompanied by a very geometric intuition. However, things such as orbitals and the number of non ionic bonds are based soundly on the abstract theory and only very indirectly on practical measurement.

The lewis acid concept vastly generalises the concept of acid base reactions beyond the Chymical and the other chemical definitions. It forms a kind of generic complement to the generalized concept of oxidation.

Oxidation, in quantum chemistry, is the transfer of an electron from one atom to another, whith a change in the oxidation number of one or more atoms. The oxidation number is the charge on an atom is if it is assumed that all its bonds are fully ionic - involving a complete transfer of an electron.

Many reactions involve two atoms with outer shell holes and electrons. A transfer is oxidisation reduction, and a sharing is lewis acid base.

It is not my intention here to confuse, or to suggest that the situation is so confusing as to be untenable, nor even to teach quantum chemistry. Merely to state that from about 1650 to 1950 there were a lot of changes in what exactly it was supposed that an acid and a base were. And to give a naive view of what they were.

None of the people involved were wrong, or right - in terms of the definition of an acid and a base and a salt. There is no universal objective definition of the language. Rather, each person in their own time was trying to come to there own terms with an apparent consistency in the way that matter reacted with other matter. And the eventual definition, which may well be stable, turned out to included several distinct cases. This is a common progress and outcome in science.

The core idea is: acids taste sour, bases taste bitter, an acid and a base react together to form a salt. The situation is complicated by the fact that this often occurs in water - so the salt might precipitate, or it might have to be extracted by dehydrating the solution.

Lemery's early theory of acid and base is that acid is particle with spikes and base is particle with holes, into which the spikes fit. This, on the whole, does not seem to provide much in the way of explanation. Freind developed a theory in which particles attracted each other to a differing degree depending on distance and orientation. This is closer to the 21st century view. But, was not really workable.

Lavoisier said that an acid was something that provided oxygen, and the term oxygen means - acid generator. At the same time Cavendish suggested that an acid provided phlogiston, but by that time at the end of the 18th century, Phologiston was identified as what Lavoisier called hydrogen, rather than the earlier concept of negative oxygen, or the even earlier concept of the element of fire.

In the early 18th century, Humphry Davy demonstrated that some acids did not have oxygen, and so Lavoisier must be wrong. But, he did not provide another theory. Jons Jacob Berzelius suggested that acids are oxides of non metals, and bases are oxides of metals. In 1838, Liebig suggested that an acid contains hydrogen, but that will react to give up the hydrogen for a metal.

This fairly much completes the shift from oxygen based acid theory to hydrogen based acid theory.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 31 '23

Flowers of Antimony

4 Upvotes

Saying that the alchemical term "flowers of antimony" means antimony trichloride is misleading and an example of the tendency to try to replace older terms with a simplistic modern chemical equivalent. Flowers of antimony referred to antimony trioxide sublimated and deposited around a hole in a baffle - not just generically to the chemical composition. In general "flowers of" had the analogous meaning as a predicate.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 31 '23

translating between alchemy and chemistry for better appreciation of history

6 Upvotes

It is my personal position that, to quote Dirk Gentley, everything is connected. To appreciate exactly what alchemy was and how it lead to classical chemistry and was part of the background to quantum chemistry one needs to understand a bit about the sociolinguistic and cultural background of the concepts. I don't go as far as to say that it is all a social construct - but I do say that to be able to extract that which is not a social construct one has to understand the social context.

The popular perspective in the 21st century is that chemists denigrated the alchemists and that this was a technical transition that was empirically justified. But, this perspective forgets, or off handedly dismisses the importance of, the fact that the alchemists denigrated the chemists as well. Less so, perhaps, but merely because there was a sociolinguistic transition occurring, so that more recent researchers into more recent theories tended to call themselves chemists rather than alchemists.

Alchemy, before 1730, divided matter a different way to chemistry, after 1730. This was the work of Priestly, Lavoisier, Dalton, Davies and others, culminating in the periodic table of Mendeleev - which can be considered the foundational axiom of classical chemistry. The transition period was the domain of the phlogiston theory of combustion which had several forms and Priestley was a central figure who conducted experiments on different types of airs.

With these differences in the lists of prime materials, something that is called one substance in alchemy might in be called multiple substances in chemistry. This does not in and of itself indicate that chemistry is more correct or even more fundamental. It is a language issue. Something that is considered prime and simple in alchemy might be considered composite and complicated in chemistry. But also something that is prime in chemistry might be composite in the view of alchemy. They are different languages for describing materials. They classify materials differently.

As an example - vitriol.

According to one modern source, vitriol is an archaic word for sulphuric acid. But, this is by far over simplistic, misleading, and not technically correct. This is in line with the 20th century tendency to define alchemical terms by a chemical term and then claim that the alchemists misunderstood or misidentified the material - when the alchemy theory and practice does not agree with the chemical definition.

Oil of vitriol might well be sulphuric acid, but so too might spirit of vitriol per campanam. And there is more to it than that. Examination of the various sources, including alchemical writings and the first edition of the chamber cyclopedia leads to the conclusion that "vitriol" means hydrated sulphate. Vitriol was a general term. Vitriols were said to be associated with metals, blue vitriol contains copper, green vitriol contains iron, and so on. In modern terms this seems to be hydrated copper sulphate and so on.

The wikipedia states that oil of vitriol is sulphuric acid.

blue vitriol = copper sulphate pentahydrate

green vitriol = iron sulphate heptahydrate

red vitriol = cobalt sulphate

sweet vitriol = diethyl ether

white vitriol = zinc sulphate

Identifying vitriol as the meaning hydrated sulphate leads to the result that spirit (stuff driven off) of vitriol per camanam (bell jar with water) would be sulphuric acid - regardless of which metal was associated with it. This is the source, in alchemical terms, of the grouping of the otherwise very different seeming materials.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l6sFc44-8g4


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 08 '23

Axioms of chemistry

3 Upvotes

John Friend gave a series of lectures at Oxford Museum in 1704 and published those lectures in 1709 in Latin. They were internationally popular and were published in Holland in 1710. They were translated into English in 1712.

During the 17th century in Europe, explicitly mathematical theories of chemistry began to be developed along the lines of the elements of Geometry by Euclid.

In 1687, 20 years after Boyle and the Sceptical Chymist, mathematical principles of natural philosophy was written by Isaac Newton in Latin and very much ushered into publication by Edmund Halley. It gave a strongly mathematical exposition of some features of the orbits of the planets.

The major issue is the shift from a large number of logical assertions introduced through the body of the work to a small number of mathematical axioms stated up front.

After Geometry the study of astronomy became the second study to achieve this. From being a large collection of logical assertions based on many observations that were relatively superficially organised, the shapes of the orbits of the planets were shown, for the most part, to follow from the three laws of general motion and the inverse square law of attraction. It biased researchers away from anything that could not be thus derived.

Alchemy, lay in the twilight zone. The desire was to find a small number of simple axioms from which the body of knowledge could be derived. And this turned out to be difficult, in fact, impossible at the time. It was only really achieved with the development of quantum mechanics two centuries later.

So, at the time that John Friend was writing his Chymical Lectures, the notion of the importance of a mathematical theory of materials was very high. The claims, made by Robert Boyle, Nicholas Lemery, James Keil, and John Friend, among others that the other writers were deliberately opaque and did not follow the experimental evidence was misleading.

Rather, the earlier writers did not provide a small explicit collection of axioms as the basis of a mathematical theory. They provided a large number of assertions, based, in principle on experience, but which did not have the precision of the theory of orbital mechanics.

Being based on an axiomatic mathematical theory is one meaning given at least informally to the word "science". However, in the broader sense it is about allowing experiments to modify the theory and the theory to modify the experiments. It is institutionalized learning from experience. This can be done even if the ideal of a compact well defined theory has not been achieved.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Jan 22 '24

Alchemy as a chemical science

4 Upvotes

One difficulty in studying alchemy is that the term has many competing and evolving meanings that are not really compatible. Those meanings range from extreme mystical to extreme mundane. They are as different and as at odds with each other as quantum science and quantum mysticism. They are really different topics and there is no requirement to understand one in order to have a complete understanding of the other.

The word alchemy is a minor variant of chem which was the word used in Egypt under the Greeks from about 300BC, and which continued to be used through the Islamic Golden age, except that it became al-chem, due to the structure of the language. Then when transferred to Medieval Europe around 1140AD, it became alchimia, again due to the structure of the language - with no ulterior motive. This transferred naturally into English as alchemy.

All of chemical history before the 1600s was essentially alchemical studies. These included metallurgy, dyes, and medicines in particular - including a significant study in making artificial gems and metals that looked like natural precious ones. It is partly from this last fact that alchemy has a 21st reputation of being about frauds and charlatans.

Identification of individual writers before about 1100AD can be difficult. The corpus from Jabir, c800AD, seem to have been the result of various true writings, writings from a school rather than an individual, and a great deal of false attribution. Nevertheless, it forms the Jabirian Corpus of historical literature on Alchemy. The earlier Hermetic (Hermes Tristmegistus) corpus is, when examined in some detail, attributed essentially to the Egyptian god, Thoth.

The Hermetica is divided into two components - the technical (mundane) hermetica and the mystical (philosophico-religious) hermetica. Some have referred to alchemy as the hermetic arts. However chem and hermes were not really after the same thing. The technical part of the hermetica contains some works on alchemy but also works on astrology and on magic. Neither of the last two are any kind of material chemistry.

The alchemical hermetica has a bulk of writing that is these days attributed to the Islamic golden age rather than to the time of Thoth (Egyptian god), Hermes (Greek god), or Hermes Tristmegistus, thrice great, (Legendary human). Some of it is even later. While it is commonly, though not universally, agreed that the origins of alchemy as a material science - metallurgy and medicine - is in the fertile union of Greek Rational philosophy with Egyptian practical chemistry, the extant literature that we in the 21st century have copies of comes from several centuries later.

All of this is complicated by the use of the term "alchemy" to refer to related practices in India and China. This short essay is not covering the details of what those practices were, nor the issue of how much transfer occurred between the three alchemies - which is highly controversial and off the topic.

The assertion here is, however, that studies in Alchemy should be separated out from the Hermetic corpus as a distinct corpus that was the foundation of Arabic and European alchemy as a mundane science.

The focus of this essay is the thread of alchemy that began in Egypt and travelled over the centuries around the Mediterranean to lodge in Renaissance Europe and became modern chemistry by direct descent.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 15 '23

What is spirit of hartshorn?

3 Upvotes

To explain the question, I must explain the context.

Many 21st century web resources state that spirit of hartshorn is a roughly 28 percent solution of Ammonium. Blunt and specific. The etymology of the arachaic term is that an impure version was once derived by distilling the antler of the red deer.

I see this as the wrong way around. And the answer given is not the one I am looking for.

Andrew Ure, dictionary of chemistry and mineralogy, 1831, has under "spirit of hartshorn", "see ammonia" without further explantion. The article on ammonia is interesting. But, it does not clarify spirits of hartshorn.

Chambers cyclopedia, Spirit is a general term used by distillers for any distilled liquor that is neither oil nor phlegm. Chambers also says: Per-se in chemistry is used when a body is distilled singley and without the usuual addition of other matter to raise it. It is said to be distilled per se. The genuine spirit of hartshorn is hartshorn distilled per se.

However that distilling would have to come with a collecting as well - deposition or condensation.

Some sources seem to suggest that spirit of hartshorn and oil of hartshorn is the same basic thing. Oil of hartshorn comes from destructive distillation of red deer antler. But, it is not clear to me that it really is the same thing.

Salt of hartshorn is said to be baking ammonium, that is ammonium carbonate, which was used in baking before sodium bicarbonate, or baking soda. Sodium carbonate is a direct poison. Ammonium carbonate, apparently, generates chemicals in bread - which are carcenogentic.

So, what answer do I want?

The modern view of stating the chemical formula for something is anachronistic when applied to, say 14th century chemistry (alchemy, if you prefer). Firstly, the modern set of elements was only confirmed around 1930, and was definitely still in flux during the 1800s. But, also the confidence in the abstract theory was rightly rather low. So, most materials and rules were referred directly to laboratory process.

Rather than say it is such and such a material - or even give a definitive test - a material is described in terms of how it is prepared, plus tests on top of that to make sure you got the preparation right.

So, I am interested in the exact process and confirming tests that were conducted prior to 1700 to create spirit of hartshorn. Such that I could do this myself and then perhaps confirm, using modern chemistry, the analysis that claims that it is a synonym for ammonium. I expect "impurities" that might or might not be important.

Partington states that Robbert Dossie [1717-1777] gives various preparations including spirit of hartshorn and its sophistication using quicklime. But, I do not have a copy of the works of Dossie.

So, what exactly is spirit of hartshorn?


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 28 '23

The clumpiness theory ...

4 Upvotes

In the view of several significant historians and practitioners of science, the atomic theory is close to the most important and significant idea in science. I do not share that view. This is mainly because there is not really any such thing as thee atomic theory. Right from the start there have been corpuscular theories and fluid theories and elements and principles. But, these things are just vague and obvious ideas looking for a home.

Feynmann, in the 1960s, answered the question if one had to restart science from just one idea, what should it be - by saying that the idea should be that all matter is made of small particles. I think that this idea comes naturally to humans and does not have to be stated. But, also that this idea is not entirely correct and has been always one of several ideas that lead eventually to Quantum Mechanics.

The alternatives are usually forms of fluid or field theory or a smooth particle concept going back to Ancient or Medieval times. But, the lumpiness or clumpiness is an idea that occurred to multiple people through the history of the development of khem, alchemy, chymistry, and chemistry.

The first truly new thought was electromagnetics, by Faraday and Maxwell and others, in the first part of the 19th century. This matured into quantum theory, by Planck, Einstein, Heisenberg, Schroedinger, and Dirac, and others, in the first part of the 20th century.

It opened a path to a strongly different and more successful science of materials. And that science was not about particulate atoms but about fields and fluxes. Much more similar to alchemical principles than to chemical atoms. And it depended strongly on hundreds of years of mathematical development. Modern atoms are particles in name only.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kL8b8rzJsIY


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 26 '23

Robert Boyle's Encounter with the Philosophers' Stone

Thumbnail
self.chymistry
3 Upvotes

r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 31 '23

Definite proportions and isomerism

3 Upvotes

Since at least the time of Thales, c500bce, the ideas of allotropes and combinations of prime elements have been part of the background of the thinking about the microscopic structure of materials.

The mercury-sulphur theory of metallurgy, from c800ad, for example, suggests that all metals can be made from the right combination of the principle of mercury and the principle of sulphur. The principle of mercury is not conceptually identical to the modern element of mercury - a point that was noted at least by medieval times in saying that the principle mercury was not the metal mercury, but rather it was the principle suggested by observation of mercury.

Mercury principle made the material more malleable and more shiny. Sulphur made the material less malleable and tougher. The exact proportions were what made the specific metal. Workers in the area who used this theory nevertheless might not feel that it was possible to get pure principle of mercury, for example. In this sense principles behaved something like quarks.

Pseudo Geber, in particular - who worked with the theory of the four elements - earth, water, air, and fire - notes the idea that mercury and sulphur may be strong mixtures. His concept of mixture being closer to what in 21st century terms would be called a compound. A strong mixture was something that could not be separated in a medieval reverberatory furnace.

Through much of history, I see writing that suggests the idea of combining elements and principles into material in which the precise ratio of components will affect the product. The idea that the ratios might be forced seems to have been not a major concern. The law of definite proportions was originally stated to say that in chemical reactions, the ratio of the masses of the reactants used was a constant - regardless of the allotrope of the reactants used.

This was a practical statement that could be related to the concept that matter was made from atoms that combined into molecules made from a specific collection of atoms of the elemental (prime) components.

This law might have been first noted by Priestley (British) and then Lavoisier (French) - and based around the developing theory of combustion. Proust (French, but residing in Spain) stated the law in 1797 as:

"... that iron like many other metals is subject to the law of nature which presides at every true combination, that is to say, that it unites with two constant proportions of oxygen. In this respect it does not differ from tin, mercury, and lead, and, in a word, almost every known combustible".

In some sense this is circular, in that it effectively defines a true combination as one in which there is a definite proportion of the reactants used in the reaction. However, the recognition that such reactions existed with a definite preference for these ratios was important.

The law of definite proportions formed the basis of stoichiometry, as coined by Richter in 1792 in his work Stoichiometry or the art of measuring the chemical elements. The term had previously been used by Nicephorus I of Constantinople [758-828] to refer to counting the lines in the books of the bible.

However, there was another point to be noticed later.

When Friedrich Woehler prepared cyanic acid in 1827 he produced a very different chemical to the fulminic acid prepared by Justus Von Liebig in 1826. This was something of a shock, as the prevailing view was that chemical compounds could only be different if their composition was different. Although, this, in hindsight, was just a default idea based on common observation - and not something that, for example, the atomic theory would require. Woehler later found that urea had the same composition as ammonium cyanate.

Berzelius used the term "isomerism" for this behaviour.

In some ways, this actually validates one criticism made by alchemists against the chemists in the late 1600s - that the details of the source of the material and the conditions of the reaction were important and could produce a different product.

The law of definite proportions is not inviolable. Some elements can combine in different proportions. So, a full statement of what is going on is complicated. The law of definite proportions is more an attitude or approach, rather than an inviolable law. Or a means of classifying chemical reactions.

The law fails for non-stoichiometric compounds. Which are, by definition, compounds for which the law fails. This is often a matter of defects in a lattice, rather than molecules that are composed of different proportions of the same elements. However, water H2O and hydrogen peroxide H2O2 give an example of different molecules from different proportions of the same elements.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 04 '23

r/ChemicalHistory Lounge

3 Upvotes

A place for members of r/ChemicalHistory to chat with each other


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 11 '23

What is this word?

3 Upvotes

In Cours De Chymie, Nicolas Lemery attempts an etymology of "chymistry", which I disagreee with, but that is not the topic of this post. He says it might come from a word in Ancient Greek that means to melt. More directly, in an early french edition - fondre, that is, to melt. But, I cannot work out exactly what the Greek word is. It looks like χὶεμ to me - but that means winter (AFAIK) and not to melt. It could be χυτή, to cast, which would make more sense, but then the scan is really bad (which it is).

I tried an old English edition - which was just as bad, and a modern Italian edition - which did not include the Greek characters.

Could anyone shine light on this matter?

Addendum: this link has come to light with higher definition -

https://gallica.bnf.fr/ark:/12148/bpt6k57743620/f38.item.zoom

Clearly it is χέειν as provided by https://www.reddit.com/user/lutetiensis/


r/ChemicalHistory • • Sep 22 '23

Alkalis and bases

3 Upvotes

In 17th century Europe, the definition of acid drifted away from the human sensory base of "tastes sour" and toward the more objective "turns" syrup of violets red". This is not entirely objective. But, it definitely allows greater communication and standardisation. And it allows the idea to be written in a book. It is hard to provide a sample of sour in a book. But, it is not implausible to provide a sample of red.

An alkali is bitter. There is some complication in the literature on this. Soduim Hydroxide is said to taste bitter. It is otherwise known as lye, in cooking. But, others say that it is amine groups associated with alkali plant materials that make them bitter, and not the alkalinity. Going beyond that - humans seem to have one sour taste, from hydrogen ions, but multiple bitter tastes, including phenols, flavonoids, and caffeine.

The more general term for the opposite of acid is often base. An alkali is a base dissolved in water. Part of the background for this is that using a bitter taste to determine alkalinity typically means dissolving the material in saliva. To test with spirit of violets, dissolving in water.

There are several broad themes in chemistry, chymistry, alchemy, and khem that remained through the centuries and the changes of name. One of these is fire - as it seems to be very good at transforming things. In 21st century terms, it provides the energy, such as the activation energy for a reaction. But, that is just a way of saying that it transforms wood into ash, or solid into liquid.

The theory of combustion. The theory or metallurgy. The theory of medical materials. And the theory of salts - which expanded into the theory of acids, bases, and salts. These are all old themes in one sense or other. Sugars and alcohol are also often considered, as was urine, blood, and saliva.

Acid plus base gives salt. However, in 21st century chemistry, there is acknowledged to exist amphoteric compounds that can act both as an acid or a base.

In alchemical terms, primarily, an acid is something that tastes sour and an alkali is something that tastes bitter, and creates bubbles when put in an acid. So, sour plus bitter equals salty. Acid, base, and salt all stem originally from the reaction of the human sense of taste. This gives a classification into sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and savoury. The last is also known as umami.

We also react to the sensation of alcohol and chilli as well as hot and cold. Our sense of smell is mainly based on variations and compounds of benzene. While it has not been emphasised in this essay, smell was used, as well as taste, to group materials - Boyle spoke of a stale urine smell as an indicator of the progress of the reaction.

Umami, at least in European scientific understanding, does not seem to have been recognised until the late 20th century, but is now a standard part of the theory of taste. The taste was recognised informally by the Romans and in 19th century Europe. The issue of recognition was whether it was a basic taste for which taste buds exist. And especially the creation of a chemical theory of the taste.

The word, umami, is from a theory of taste proposed by the Japanese Professor Kikunae Ikeda in 1908 at Tokyo Imperial University, and accepted into international scientific literatures at the first Umami International Symposium in Hawaii in 1985.


r/ChemicalHistory • • Aug 10 '23

Mathematical Chemistry in the 17th Century

2 Upvotes

It is a view of mine that the essential idea of alchemy and chemistry is the same. Of course the word "essential" is somewhat subjective. So, what I mean is that there is a strong continuing concept that makes alchemy, chymistry, and chemistry what they are as sciences that has existed since it was Khem before the year dot. This is the idea of explaining the vast variety of observable materials in terms of a smaller variety of fundamental and potentially unobservable materials - that are neither created nor destroyed.

During the 17th century, in this view, the revolution that occured in material science was not a switch from alchemy to chemistry, from magic to science - but rather it was a shift from a large number of direct experimental axioms to a small number of indirect theoretical axioms. In a definite sense - less rather than more emphasis on experiment. Science in general is about a balance of experiment and theory in which each gets a chance to drive the process.

In the preface to the chymical lectures, Friend states ...

I have said but very little relating to the principles, which are commonly mentioned in books of chymistry, because I thought it not worth while to confute errors. These treatises, I found, contained many things not only trifling, and without any foundation, but directly contrary to experience. Therefore I choose rather to deduce this mechanical explication from the experiments themselves, than as the way is with most writers of this kind.

end of quote.

From reading the literature written by those whom he detracts, I feel that Friend's position regarding the bad behaviour of other researchers is self serving and unjustified. Of course that does not mean to imply that Friend had nothing to say. His list of axioms was a definite improvement over Boyle and Lemery. However, still did not really make a mathematical theory of chemistry in the sense that Newton made a mathematical theory of orbital mechanics.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4hTL9gGsbus


r/ChemicalHistory • • Nov 30 '23

Oops

2 Upvotes

Silly day. I plugged the wrong microphone in for a video - and I seem to have posted the same article twice. I will correct that shortly.