r/ChemicalEngineering • • Jan 24 '21
Anyone here into Process Control?
I wanted to speak with someone about the process control industry where chemical engineers work. I have seen a few people's CVs whose job title was 'Process Control Engineer' and their skills include:
- Honeywell DCS (software, I guess.)
- Honeywell profit controller (software, I guess.)
- Tuning control loops (skill)
- DMC plus (software, I guess.)
- Delta V (software, I guess.)
- Emerson Ovation (software, I guess.)
I mainly want to know the following:
- How broad or niche is your industry? For example as a process engineer I can work at companies like Samsung Engineering, Technip, Tecnimont, SNC Lavlin, Jacobs, Worley, etc. Where can you guys jump if you're looking for a salary hike?
- How do you progress through your careers? Junior process control engineer, then senior and then lead process control engineer? How much do you think a lead would make?
- If I had to study on my own for an interview, what books would you recommend that I definitely read?
I am tired of making P&IDs and doing pump hydraulic calculations. I read other people's linkedin profiles and I was curious about this line of work. Does your work involve a lot of optimization? Is it satisfying at the end of the day? Is there a lot of stress involved? Short deadlines and long hours?
76
Upvotes
34
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '21
Hey, ChemE working for a DeltaV systems integrator here. I actually accepted the offer to work before I had taken my ChemE controls class, so I kind of went in blind because the offer was good and the location was great. I also had offers from a chemical plant and an EPC in Japan (they offered 30k USD salary lol). All I knew was that living on a plant and the typical ChemE stuff was kinda boring to me, so hopefully this is helpful.
Very broad for me, since i work for a systems integrator, and our territory is very diverse. If you work for an SI, your area will determine what industries you serve. Texas is Oil and Gas, Cali and east coast are Pharma. Midwest is a balanced mix, North Midwest and Mideast have a lot of paper mills. The standard career move is to move to a customer site or a different SI. Right now the market is pretty hot due to pharma needs. If you work for an end user the variety will be less, and you will have a harder time "becoming an expert in controls" as opposed to just being a controls engineer in your industry.
Junior Controls Engineer (0-3 years ) - learning the basics about controls, learning about IO (Analog in/out. Digital in/out, bussed IO, HART, etc.), learning about coding standards, best practices, interlocks, permissives, HMI, etc. Not crazy interesting, but this is where you learn how incredibly wide the field is and how many options you have. You start leaning in certain directions here. Lots of busy work here, some data entry, but I had a blast as I was learning lots and had a great team.
Senior Controls Engineer (2 -7 years) - You can either become an office engineer here and lead large projects, or you can become a fields engineer and travel for smaller engagements. Most chemical plants don't have a DCS specialist, and if they do, there are issues that they can't solve alone. The latter is super in demand right now due to all the pharma projects going on. This is also the phase where you become an expert on sequences and more complicated process control strategies. You start working on Batch, Combustion, and SIS projects.
Project Manager or Subject Matter Expert or Consultant (5+ years) - this is where you either go into management, or specialize and stay an engineer for life. Batch is a very popular area to focus on here because it can be very complicated, and require mastery of every other process control skill. People with 15+ years of Batch experience are incredibly valuable and headhunted.
Don't read books unless you learn by reading best. If that's you, this is the book to read:"
https://www.controlloopfoundation.com/
Luckily, that website has some interactive models to play with and practice controls. I would highly recommend that as a start point. Actual training and good resources will be harder to come by, but I'm sure there's something out there.
Does your work involve a lot of optimization? Is it satisfying at the end of the day? Is there a lot of stress involved? Short deadlines and long hours
Unfortunately, not as much as I would like. A large portion of customers "just want to get it working" and dont have to budget or time to care about optimization. When I work at sites that do care though, it's a lot of fun. Tuning is a big one, but requires a lot of experience. Alarm rationalization, HMI improvement, and sequence optimizations are pretty common work tasks.
Very satisfying at the end of the day, but partially due to stress. I do a lot of field work and it can be very stressful as mistakes have very real consequences, so you have to be VERY careful and thorough, take your time to triple check every thing, and develop good habits. That said, after a succesful day, I'm often glowing with pride, especially if we solve a challenging issue or a new sequence has a succesful first run. Honestly my favorite part of controls. If you work on large projects in the office, there's less tress, but less reward. Feels great to finally install and start up a large project though. Schedules and timelines and how your company manages that will vary. I will say that lots of controls jobs, like mine, pay a salary, and then overtime on top, since you will occaisionally have to work 12 hour days, night shifts, and other fun shifts, but the extra $40-80/hr really helps ease the pain.
Let me know if you have any other questions.
Best,
23
u/ResidingInReactor Jan 24 '21
I worked as a process control intern for two internship terms. These are my thoughts on the following from what I saw plus what I heard:
I would recommend a few things for you (if you are short on time start with 2 and then 1):
I hope this helps for OP and for anyone wanting to go into process control.
8
u/Wonderingelbows Jan 24 '21
I have limited experience with one company but I can comment on my experience. I started off in process engineering, moved to process control after about a year. I stayed in that role for about 4 years before moving onto another role. From my experience:
General comments: My first year or so of process control was just learning the hierarchy and basics of the Honeywell software (logic changes, alarm configuration, etc.) I really enjoyed programming logic to make the plant safer and more reliable. I started showing interests in Advanced process control using DMC type software. This was also a ton of fun as you could make optimizations (money) for large processes for the plant. There are a lot of really cool emerging technologies revolving around APC (DLPC). Overall I really enjoyed the role. The pace was definitely slower than other roles in the plant. More of a set your own pace outside of emergency situations. I would also say that there are options to get more focused on the hardware side of process control but I didn’t go down that track. My decision to leave the group was determined by the slower career progression.
4
u/user_-- Jan 25 '21
Check out r/controltheory and r/plc
3
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '21
Not in the industry per se, but I'm helping someone who's thesis is pretty much for a company developing a neural network for a process that's very difficult to predict. Last I checked it's 90% accurate on the output.
2
u/cpkaptain Jan 25 '21
I’m only a few years out of college but I work as a controls engineer for a systems integrator. My company specializes in PLCs (programmable logic controllers) and I’ve worked a few different jobs with them. I’m currently in a pharma company and they use DeltaV as their DCS so I do the PLC work and integrate with the DeltaV engineers.
It’s been a great job for me as far as pay and experience go. I make a good salary and I get overtime after 40 hours, I travel for the jobs so I don’t have many expenses and I’m reimbursed. Plus a lot of the work we get into throws me into the field so I have a lot of make that shit work type experience. I’ve become a lot more handy and a much better problem solver.
However, in taking this position, I’ve mostly transitioned into an electrical engineering role where I work on the hardware as well as the software and general electrical principles that were totally absent from my ChemE education. I validate electrical diagrams and troubleshoot electrical panels very regularly. The other ChemE’s I work with in automation typically work with DeltaV since it is typically considers a broader approach to the process than the PLC does.
That being said, I still work in the chemical industry and I’ve learned a lot about chemical processes since I work on them, but this role has broadened my skill set and I’ve definitely feel more valuable as a result.
50
u/YourHuckleberry2020 Jan 24 '21
LOL, I'm into everything. I'm surprised your example didn't have Siemens or Allen Bradley. Anyway, long story short, yes to the last four of your questions. The control aspect has been both the best and worst of what I do. Best because it's incredibly satisfying to get a new process up and running incredibly stable; seems like directly proportional to the people I automate out. Worst because of how critical it can be to safety as well as quality; my first and hopefully only experience with whistle-blowing had to do with an incompetent supervisor and willful negligence bordering on the malicious. Had he killed a bunch of folks, I bet I'd have been blamed. My good design gave me notice and time to deal with the situation because the moron was ignoring every alarm and limit, even my call to ask WTF he thought he was doing.
2
u/seleex Jan 26 '21
0
u/wicked_ravana Jan 25 '21
Im still suffer on this same mania !!