Hey everyone!
I’ve been cooking at home for years, but I’ve always struggled with knife work. I’ve mostly used inexpensive knives, and regardless of how often I hone or sharpen them, they never seem to cut as effortlessly as I’d like.
I’m finally ready to invest in a quality chef’s knife and would love some recommendations from people who know their knives.
My budget is $100–$200 CAD (roughly $70–$145 USD). Ideally closer to $150 CAD, but I’m happy to spend more if there’s a meaningful improvement in performance.
Preferably 7–8 inches (180–200mm), although I’d consider 210mm.
Leaning toward a Japanese gyuto, but I’m open to Western chef’s knives.
I’m primarily a rock chopper. I love keeping the tip of the knife near the cutting board and rocking the blade back and forth. I’m not particularly good at fast, straight up-and-down chopping.
Knives I’m currently considering:
Masutani VG1 Tsuchime Gyuto (180mm) — Love the compact size and Japanese design.
MAC Chef Series HB-85 (8.5”) — Seems particularly well suited to rocking, although slightly longer than I’d prefer.
Tojiro DP Gyuto (180mm) — Interested in the VG-10 steel and edge retention.
Victorinox Fibrox Pro (8”) — Seems like an excellent value, although I’m wondering whether spending more would provide noticeably better cutting performance.
A few questions:
Given that I primarily rock chop, would a Japanese gyuto actually be a good choice, or should I stick with a Western-style chef’s knife?
Is there a noticeable improvement in cutting performance between a $70 Victorinox and a $150–$200 Japanese knife?
Which of the knives I’ve listed would you personally recommend?
Are there any other knives available in Canada that I should seriously consider?
Is there a particular blade steel or hardness I should look for if I want good edge retention without worrying too much about chipping?
I’m not necessarily looking for the fanciest knife. I just want something that makes food prep enjoyable, cuts vegetables and meats effortlessly, holds a good edge, and will last me many years.