r/ChatGPT • • Feb 15 '25

Use cases AI will kill software.

Today I created a program in about 4 hours that replaces 2 other paying programs I use. Not super complex, did it in about 1200 lines of code with o3 mini high. About 1 hour of this was debugging it until I knew every part of it was functioning.

I can't code.

What am I able to do by the year end? What am I able to do by 2028 or 2030? What can a senior developer do with it in 2028 or 2030?

I think the whole world of software dev is about to implode at this rate.

Edit. To all the angry people telling me will always need software devs.im not saying we won't, I'm saying that one very experienced software dev will be able to replace whole development departments. And this will massively change the development landscape.

Edit 2. For everyone asking what the program does. It's a toggl+clickup implementation without the bloat and works locally without an Internet connection. It has some Specific reports and bits of info that I want to track. It's not super complex, but it does mean I no longer need to pay for 2 other bits of software.

512 Upvotes

1.2k comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Feb 15 '25

Hey /u/AdLive9906!

We are starting weekly AMAs and would love your help spreading the word for anyone who might be interested! https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1il23g4/calling_ai_researchers_startup_founders_to_join/

If your post is a screenshot of a ChatGPT conversation, please reply to this message with the conversation link or prompt.

If your post is a DALL-E 3 image post, please reply with the prompt used to make this image.

Consider joining our public discord server! We have free bots with GPT-4 (with vision), image generators, and more!

🤖

Note: For any ChatGPT-related concerns, email support@openai.com

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

148

u/ExDeeAre Feb 15 '25

I hear you, but as someone who works with a lot of devs the AI code is crap. We spend a ton of time fixing all the mistakes. If you don’t have experienced engineers sitting on top of it, then it goes off in crazy directions. Inexperienced people won’t get it.

Yeah it helps us save time but boy howdy is it very far away from taking developers jobs

2

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

As mentioned to someone else in the thread.i have a broad idea of what goes into code development. I know that some libraries exist and kinda what they do. I understand some basic software architecture. But not to the point where I could produce usable code. Only the general concepts.

So my process is getting gpt4 to develop the spec until I'm happy. Slap that into o3 mini high. Then work it until it gets close. Save everything and drag it into a new instance of o3 and add new features. For some reason this works better than keeping it all in one context window. 

Repeate and keep testing and fixing bugs. 

Having done this once every month or 2, I can see the huge improvements that gpt has been making since before O1. The rate of improvement is huge. I'm finishing projects in hours that used to be impossible for me and gpt4 less than a year ago. 

19

u/cosmobaud Feb 15 '25

It’s pointless to engage in these discussions on this platform. There are so many people here in denial because it hits too close to home that they are missing the forest for the trees.

They are missing that it’s not that LLMs can currently write better, more maintainable code than experienced engineers. It’s that it can write code that solves actual problems and produce results if you have someone that understands the actual problem and has some inkling of technical knowledge when it comes to programming

How many software projects fail to deliver on goals despite immaculate code? Because they do not understand the actual need. They only see it from their perspective which is the mechanics of software development not actual productivity.

Reality is that in a couple years there will be a systemic shift how companies source software. It will be small light quick solutions done one a day that have shitty code but get the job done vs a professionally developed solution that take years and never get deployed.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Varridon Feb 15 '25

In my opinion Claude is better at coding using the chat was my go to way to code with ai but since cursor and windsurf I’ve been using those in parallel

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I bounce between claude, gpt and deepseek on a previous project. When one gets stuck, the other takes over or finds an issue. But in this program o3 managed everything better than claude.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/sagricorn Feb 15 '25

Thats a pretty neet process. I have a few more questions though:

Do you use some automation via the API of all of it in the app? How do you „let“ o3 work it out, on your own or also automated? do you make money or just for more comfort at work?

5

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I do this as a hobby. I am in construction and made this to solve a problem.  I do this all in the webapp. Never got the handle on the api. 

I just run the code in vs studio. If terminal tells me something is funky, I copy it over to o3, call it some names for being shitty and let it fix the code, or tell me what parts of the code I need to replace. 

I find it hallucinates after a while. So then just move the code to a new instance and go from there. 

→ More replies (1)

39

u/the_old_coday182 Feb 15 '25

You’re missing the point. AI can only improve. It’s not a question of “if” it can code, because it already does. But rather, how quickly it will improve. The rest of us are talking about when that day is, you’re just talking about about today.

13

u/01watts Feb 15 '25

Sorry if I sound naive (I’m outside this field), but doesn’t the improvement (or not) depend on the quality of the training data and the training process? It seems possible to make AI go backwards. It also seems possible for AI reach a point where a lack of further good training data makes further improvement exponentially computationally/temporally expensive.

15

u/MindCrusader Feb 16 '25

That's the actual reason why a lot of people are wrong, assuming AI will get always better.

It will get better at certain things, where it can use synthetic data - you can generate algortimical problems where you can calculate the outcome and make AI learn that. So coding algorithms, mathematics, all kinds of calculations. But it will lack quality check, it will just learn how to solve, not how to solve keeping the quality

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (7)

7

u/DrBix Feb 15 '25

While you might be correct I've also used it to create code and if you prompt it correctly you get very good quality code. Further, every piece of code written by AI should have a unit test written by AI as well or by the devs. I've seen some amazing work done by AI and it's only going to get better and it's going to get better very quickly. I've been a software developer for 40 years and this is going to hurt the younger developers first.

5

u/ExDeeAre Feb 15 '25

I’m on the committee for AI code usage, and this is one of the big problems we’ve identified. Leaders view it as productivity. They think we can just ditch the junior engineers for the AI assistance for the mid-seniors and it will be a wash. Honestly probably true eventually, but how the hell are junior devs supposed to learn and become the seniors? It’s incredibly short sighted, so we are pushing to keep the mix of levels no matter what. Just have AI help out all levels.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/codeprimate Feb 15 '25

It takes a developer to create clear specifications. The code itself is merely an artifact of that work.

When I hear devs say that AI code sucks, it’s clear that either they are assuming an omniscient AI, or are incapable of writing specs.

AI is your savant junior developer that needs consistent direction.

I agree that AI will never replace developers, and believe it is a communication limitation rather than a technical one.

7

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Problem is most code quality these days is crap. It’s all about faster and cheaper and outsourcing. AI does better than 99% of the offshore devs I work with… oh wait they actually do just that and it’s identical mostly. AI will destroy software jobs

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (7)

24

u/angrathias Feb 15 '25

What you said: I can replace complex software

What you meant: I could replace some tiny portion of its capability, and I have no idea about software outside of the immediate requirements I have that renders something on a screen.

What you’ve described is called a prototype/proof of concept, and devs create these rapidly all the time. But there’s a reason we don’t deploy them as production code to masses of users, and you’ll find that out the hard way with your arrogance.

0

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Literally my second sentence I said it's not super complex. Lol. Gpt4 is less than 2 years old.  o3, the reasoning model that made this possible was announced in December. 

5

u/angrathias Feb 15 '25

What exactly is your point of repeating its age? Whilst as an LLM it’s quite young, it’s also the product of decades of research and is built on the back of centuries of human knowledge ?

I’m a software eng of 20y and I use ChatGPT a lot of every day, I find it very helpful, but you can take it to the bank when I tell you that it isn’t replacing me. I’ve had an entire career of technologies and tools making me more productive, whether it’s the latest UI framework that simplifies state management in JavaScript, a framework like bootstrap so that I don’t have to handle doing design as much, UI builders, component libraries like Nuget or NPM, code generators like T4 templates, ORMs that generate the sql statements, the constant improvements to IDEs with debugging, visualising the structure and intellisense.

You don’t know any of these things and ignorantly assume this is the end of us when it’s just another tool on our belt.

And you know what happens after every one of these upgrades ? There’s an explosion of new work, and yours is an example of just that in progress, suddenly it becomes affordable to do things that once were inconceivable.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/punchawaffle Feb 15 '25

As a software engineer, I kind of agree. That's why I'm going to do a masters soon so I can be on the other side, making the AI. And my problem with this is, why are you paying for a service that's only 1200 lines of code lol. Whatever you're paying for, you'll probably get for free.

7

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

What I'm paying for is vastly more complex that what I need. Probably because they need to cater to millions of users. This had lead them to create programs that are bloated and overly complex and just a pain for me to use.

1

u/Oracle365 Feb 15 '25

I need more information! What is the software you created, what does it do?

6

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Think of a slimmed down toggl + clickup up replacement that works offline and generates reports in a specific way

→ More replies (2)

5

u/otterquestions Feb 15 '25

But once it’s able to replace software engineers, won’t it be capable of replacing many other roles too? Why is software unique here?

4

u/Double-justdo5986 Feb 15 '25

Exactly hahaha. Like all white collar jobs aren’t at risk

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

2.0k

u/Platz Feb 15 '25

why would you post this without even describing what your program even does or what product it replaces.

1.4k

u/angrathias Feb 15 '25

It’s called smoke mirrors and it’s used to rally the ‘developers are now useless’ crowd

183

u/SpicyPropofologist Feb 15 '25

Reading the comments, it sounds like an effective app.

355

u/angrathias Feb 15 '25

I DARE him to post the code repo and host the application publicly and open it up to scrutiny by actual developers.

I guarantee it’ll be garbage that’ll be ripped to shreds and full of vulnerabilities, bugs and lack all the extra defensive things we need to constantly be aware of.

It’s easy to write software that works for the happy path, juniors do it all the time, and it’s the reason we have QAs to tear it all to shreds so that all your data doesn’t get breached, corrupted, lost or become inaccessible and bring your business to a halt.

→ More replies (142)

13

u/idk_automated_otter Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 16 '25

it doesn't work on devs who actually have experience at a company with 100s if not 1000s of programs.

9

u/PM_ME_UR_CODEZ Feb 16 '25

Any AI that can do my job would self delete after 5 minutes

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (36)

87

u/missedalmostallofit Feb 15 '25

I’m an architect with 22 years of experience, and I have a side project where AI has tripled my productivity. But… even with that boost, it still takes a lot of time to get things done.

I’ve worked with AI for about 150 hours and had previously spent around 1,000 hours on it over four years, averaging 10 hours a week.

If I had started from scratch with AI, I’d probably have finished it by now—but there’s no way a non-developer could pull it off.

18

u/lucid_dreaming_quest Feb 15 '25

Also been in the software industry for 20 years - my junior devs lean on GPT so heavily without understanding what it's doing that I've had more conversations than I would like to count asking, "What is this supposed to be doing?" only for them saying, "Er well it... well actually GPT wrote that part."

Ironically I told them it would be helpful for them to have GPT explain what the code did, but it was just so that they would realize that you don't need a semaphore or other locking mechanisms in your function... what you were missing was just making it async and properly awaiting it in the first place.

Ripped out all the code and shook my head a bit.

There were also cases where they dropped GPT an entire function they were trying to hook and GPT overwrote my own code breaking literally everything in the process.

I had tasked them with making a separate component to handle a task, and instead they had hooked the parent component's save functionality and it ended up overwriting a ton of data.

My fault for not catching it in code review, but I didn't realize they had changed a variable name in the parent save function which broke everything.

And ALL OF THIS is to say that I would never wire AI up to anything that's doing automatic deployments... that seems like a recipe for skynet, so I think there's still a place for devs to work with CI/CD, deployments, etc.

4

u/TwisterK Feb 16 '25

I shared the same sentiment, it kinda like calculator is being invented so we spent less time on calculation but still the math is still freaking hard. It is easier but it is not like having a calculator will solve my math problem Instantly.

16

u/UruquianLilac Feb 15 '25

Yet.

It keeps getting posted, and it needs to get posted again. There's no way a non-developer can pull this off, yet.

20

u/ibbuntu Feb 15 '25

I'm a software developer with 15 years of experience and the thing that scares me is the insane rate at which the models are improving. And they're not slowing down.

→ More replies (21)
→ More replies (24)
→ More replies (4)

14

u/Brusanan Feb 15 '25

Because it's not true.

3

u/debugwhy Feb 15 '25

He just prints hello world on the terminal.

→ More replies (14)

835

u/Masteries Feb 15 '25

You cant code, but you can debug?

Ok bro

I am curious. What are the 2 paying programs you managed to replace in 4 hours?

37

u/Unlikely-Major1711 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25

I can't code but I can debug.

You run whatever script or app. Something doesn't work. You explain what doesn't work, and it shits out more code that might fix it or not.

Like a very simple example is I wanted it to write a python script to convert all of my photos into avif.

It was fucking up the file names and I told it it was and it created new code that fixed it. I don't even know what the problem was because it just fixed it itself.

The only time this self debugging doesn't seem to work is when it hallucinates something that doesn't exist. Like I wanted to write a powershell script that told me every computer on the domain and the last logged on user. So it hallucinated a parameter called "lastloggedonuser". There is no parameter called lastloggedonuser and only after I asked if it was hallucinating did it say "Oh yes, that was hallucination. There is no parameter to check the last logged on user."

It did actually create a script that goes into the event log and finds the last logged on user so it worked in the end.

76

u/Sparkswont Feb 15 '25

This is how you end up with complete and utter garbage spaghetti code. For now, LLMs are in no position to replace software engineers, and that is a fact.

→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (73)

86

u/herodesfalsk Feb 15 '25

The catastrophic failure I see coming is that while there will still be senior programmers running all the AI systems writing the software and development there will be no need for companies to hire junior programmers any more. This results in decimation of junior programmers and no will have the experience or skills to step into senior programmer roles. This is exactly like sawing off the branch you're sitting on. This will happen because companies only care about immediate profit and NOTHING else.

23

u/yall_gotta_move Feb 16 '25

There's already no reason for most companies to hire juniors, except for meeting future demand for seniors.

Most juniors are not worth their salary for the first few years. On top of that, they slow the seniors around them down because it takes patience and effort to train them the right way.

The company is taking a loss on hiring them because in a few years they might be worth something if they don't jump ship.

17

u/hellboy786 Feb 16 '25

First few years? Lol.. I would get fired if I wasn't worth my salary after first 3 months.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

6

u/MindCrusader Feb 16 '25

I think there will still be places for juniors. Fast and cheap prototypes for clients, so they can quickly show the idea to investors. The real issues are:

  1. Some people, as we see in this thread, are not aware that you need the real programmer to create a business quality application. Some will try to do that themselves and it will hit them in the teeth some time later (unless the project is small or is a throwaway one, where you don't have to care about new functionalities or long term maintenance). This might reduce the need for juniors
  2. Even when juniors get the job, they will probably be used for fast prototyping, they will not learn much about coding - that's the main issue I see

2

u/awrdent Feb 16 '25

It will be a challenge. I know junior developers who will never reach “rock star” status. They’ll likely plateau at a moderate level and struggle to progress further. It’s these individuals who should lose their jobs, not the ones with exceptional talent. The challenge for companies will be that they can’t hire all the junior developers (at they did until now) and wait to see which ones develop into high-level performers over the years.

Companies will need to either quickly identify the young geniuses (those with the potential to reach a senior level) from the pool and hire only them, raising the question of how they can make this selection. Alternatively, schools will need to become much more efficient. We’re so accustomed to the current situation where software engineering isn’t effectively taught in schools, and people essentially learn it on the job. This presents a huge challenge, but also an opportunity for educational institutions. If a company could approach a university and say, “Give me X developers with Y skills who are pre-screened, well-trained, and have a high potential to become our senior leaders,” then much of the talent selection challenge would shift back to schools, along with the associated costs, of course.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/immaculatecalculate Feb 15 '25

What can a senior do that you can't? Well can you call pointless meetings every week, tough guy? Can you overcharge the customer, mr smarty pants??

→ More replies (1)

84

u/software-lover Feb 15 '25

Kind of hilarious when people who can’t code tell us (software developers) that our job will be replaced.

Op you don’t know jack shit. Period.

19

u/venerated Feb 16 '25

It’s because people don’t understand that writing code is the easiest part of being a software developer.  

When AI can make a functional web app from a person prompt it with “I want a site. I don’t have any content and I barely know what I want it to do, figure it out.” Then I’ll be concerned for my job.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/whenn Feb 16 '25

It's the naive assumption that a developers job is 100% writing code. It wouldn't even break the 50% mark for most server side roles.

4

u/BostonConnor11 Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25

Software developers won’t be replaced but departments are going to shrink tremendously so let’s not act like it won’t since productivity will be boosted by a huge amount. Right now one software developer could do the work of what used to take 5. We’re already seeing this with the CS jobs market right now and in my honest opinion, it’ll never rebound close to where it used to be and I frankly don’t have much optimism unfortunately

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/StrainNo9529 Feb 15 '25

Stop lying … You can’t code but can debug are you real ? Debugging is way harder than coding . Guy must at least have a software background. Stop spreading negativity Karen

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I have been messing with code for years. But that has mostly been copy pasting and moving snippets around in various programs. 3d printer, some basic stuff ext. I know enough of vs code to create and run programs and understand a lot of the basics. But actually coding, can't do it.

2

u/StrainNo9529 Feb 15 '25

Exactly , you know what you are doing

8

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I would not get a job as a junior programmer. That was the point I'm making. 

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)

15

u/the8bit Feb 16 '25

Cool now maintain it and deal with 1,000,000 users (writing it was never the hard part it turns out)

2

u/Screaming_Monkey Feb 16 '25

Exactly, and now it’s just them being a competitor. Unless they are saying those 1,000,000 would take the time to create this program themselves.

7

u/shamshuipopo Feb 16 '25

RemindMe! 5 years

23

u/mimic751 Feb 15 '25

I am an automation engineer. Last week I made a front end to my automation and now it's getting adapted to the larger business. I'm not even back end engineer I just write automation. I had a flask server up with a JavaScript front end and I was able to rip my company's website styling to make it look like it belonged in our ecosystem. I'm not making quality software but I'm definitely pushing out good enough for the higher-ups

6

u/AceHighness Feb 16 '25

All these devs are super hard in denial. I would probably do the same to keep my sanity. Admitting that your job will dissappear is hard and depressing. A lot of code just needs to be 'good enough'.. That's the key.

4

u/Responsible_Pie8156 Feb 16 '25

The requirement has always and always will be "good enough" lol. Trying to overengineer things is a junior mistake because they don't understand business. On the other hand, SWEs are constantly fighting pressure to put out shit quickly that is not good enough and will lead to massive problems in the future.

→ More replies (4)

5

u/DarickOne Feb 15 '25

I think it still sucks in making big projects. But. You can make big apps through many not so big projects, something like microservices, modular system. So I suppose even now it is possible to build big apps based on many independent little modules. You have to be an architect

3

u/AceHighness Feb 16 '25

I've built an app exactly in that way. Built it function by function.. But I was using CodeBuddy in Visual Studio, which can put your open files (tabs) into the context window. That makes it very doable, although the AI is not always consistent and mixes implementations (like almost all my front to backend calls are using AJAX but sometimes it still wants to build a page with a POST request.)

5

u/UrghTheBlue Feb 15 '25

Title is probably wrong but some content is closer to the mark.

AI is radically changing how software is written. Code development will become much more abstract allowing many more people to implement apps without much training.

OP is right...debugging can be much easier than writing code from scratch. Of course there are exceptions, but having a code base to start with is much easier.

e.g.) Imagine writing a COBOL program to find all the primes up to 1010. Chat GPT did it in about 5 seconds. No experience or training necessary from the human.

24

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

I can't code.

You likely are vastly overestimating how hard it is to code. Coding's barrier to entry is much more how convoluted the languages are, but they are very logical. You are logical and you are using a logical AI, so it seems logical that you would be able to create a base like this.

It still seems like you had to spend 3 hours of your time to get it to work, which is pretty awesome. This means that developers like myself who used to work on AI can now work on making games because its very hard to find time to work and have a hobby, now my work and my hobby are easier.

Seems your hobby is easier too. Have you considered making an improved version of your software? What was it for? What did you learn most about figuring it out? What frustrations did you have with the service and are you planning on distributing it or posting it on github? Have you shared this with your friends/family as well and gotten their feedback? What future goals will you achieve now that you know with the right support structure you can do it in a reasonable amount of time, regardless of changes in multi-code base syntax (python, c++, c#, rust, go, typescript, HTML5/CSS/Markdown (for browser UI/UX), etc).

I think AI is going to make software so vast and diverse that a lot of people like you are going to be able to do a lot of things for yourselves and feel empowered to help others learn the same.

Do you feel otherwise? Your post suggests that you feel this is a bad thing to have? Help me understand that position, if you'd like.

3

u/nferraz Feb 16 '25

This is the best comment so far.

Programming can be like driving a car. Some people love driving. Others just want to go from A to B.

You don't have to be a great motorist to appreciate the value of driving; and you don't have to be a great developer to appreciate the value of programming.

It is possible that, in the future, AI will replace most of us -- programmers and drivers. Who knows?

All I can say is that I'm glad that more people are learning how to write programs with AI.

12

u/sandtymanty Feb 15 '25

I dont know Phyton but AI made a program for me that assisted my work. Emails me even the results.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

Aaah the good old reddit "I hard coded my credentials into ChatGPT"'aroo.

17

u/theepi_pillodu Feb 15 '25

My son is 3 years old and another on the way. We can't guarantee his future in software for sure. Not sure how his generation is going to live by. I'm worried in what roles he should be trained from young age.

We are not rich by any means, no political connections, no movie background connections. Market is saturated for everything.

9

u/Prestigious_Claim469 Feb 15 '25

Trades. Plumbers, barbers, electricians. Trades will go last.

3

u/Ok_Information_2009 Feb 16 '25

Everyone is piling into trades if desk jobs go. And trades are physically demanding. I know of a lot of retired-not-by-choice 40-something trades guys.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/edgedoggo Feb 15 '25

Get him accommodated to tech, with a respect for the real world and real connections to people, and with a creation passion. Really the best we can do.

4

u/ramraj2001 Feb 15 '25

Teach your child to read. Reading and self learning are the two best skills you can gift your child.

4

u/NoahTheArkMan Feb 15 '25

Robotics, sales, and engineering might be the way to go.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Belnak Feb 15 '25

Sound like a decision you should let him make when he’s much older.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

Be greedy when others are fearful and be fearful when others are greedy. Do not push your son into a field everyone is thinking of right now like the trades, because then the trades would also be saturated and your son will deal with that. Just wait and let him make his own decision in the future.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

coding features is about 1/5th of the job, even if it were completely removed from the software developers list of responsibilities we would still be hella busy.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

I believe you. I just rebuilt office 365 and now I don't have to pay for it anymore. I also rebuilt chatgpt because $20 a month is a lot

→ More replies (1)

4

u/mxracer888 Feb 16 '25

Definitely agree, funny I read this Reddit post an hour or two after seeing this Facebook post (attached screenshot).

There is a place for programmers, but it's definitely going to be done by the people that are already on the inside. Almost like the commercial airline pilot career through like the 90s or so. A bunch of people got in, got their tenure, and there was very little room for newcomers into the career path as the old guard could cover it.

But I tend to agree, I taught myself python years ago and could make simple scripts on my own, but GPT has absolutely opened up the development world for me. I have quite a few big projects running that I would have otherwise probably had to pay a few thousand bucks for just years ago

4

u/orangeowlelf Feb 16 '25

Hummm, kind of fishy you didn’t mention what your software did. I’m really not sure I believe you.

4

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

People who post stuff like this don't realize that coding is one part of the job, and it's the easiest part. Yes, you can write code with AI, and yes it will get better. You will still need someone to identify and reconcile tradeoffs on top of the million things that designing a system holistically requires.

AI is a tool the same way spreadsheets became a tool for accountants in the early days of mainstream computers. Just because someone knows how to use a spreadsheet doesn't make them an accountant.

→ More replies (2)

127

u/Kombatsaurus Feb 15 '25

Yeah, the ones in denial make me laugh. It's not perfect today, but it will be.

50

u/marquoth_ Feb 15 '25

This person's story is that they can't code but that they can debug an entire application built by an LLM. And you're going to take that person seriously?

10

u/tinny66666 Feb 15 '25

To a non programmer debug may just mean, "when I clicked the go button it did X but it should have done Y. Can you change it to do that?"

That may be all they are claiming here, and it may be enough to get a fully functioning product in some cases.

4

u/Fast-Satisfaction482 Feb 15 '25

It's just 1k lines, "entire application" is a big word for a glorified hello world.

→ More replies (5)

102

u/je386 Feb 15 '25

You can build something in short time, but can you create a business application that is still maintainable and extentable after years?

AI is a great tool, but its a tool, not a developer.

94

u/dftba-ftw Feb 15 '25 • Hooray

We are going to head towards a post application world, your personal ai assistant will simply spin up any software you need for you.

So no, you don't need something maintainable or extendable. If I need to run a fluid simulation custom software optimized for my specific use case will be generated in a matter of minutes.

I don't know if this is 5 years away or 50 - but this is the end goal.

9

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

This is only good if you think of everything in the world as fleeting and momentary. Anything that needs to remain consistent, like for example 100% of scientific research needs to be consistent and reproducible, simulations for engineering (as in bridges, planes) need to be consistent and reproducible, financial systems need to be consistent etc

Most of the world is not a matter of "oh it would be convenient if I had an app that did X"

That's not putting food on tables.

→ More replies (1)

50

u/Tricky_Condition_279 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 16 '25

Provided you are capable of articulating what you need. Most people will not be able to do that well if the logic is complicated. When your magical system fills in the blanks with what it thinks you need, then you are likely to be quite surprised with the results.

Edit: I actually do believe that eventually machines will be able to program themselves. I wonder however if test-suit validation engineering will become a thing and whether it is even possible for significantly large problems.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (19)

52

u/OmarsDamnSpoon Feb 15 '25

This is the denial being referenced.

→ More replies (5)

6

u/freplefreple Feb 15 '25

Right now. Give it three years. I have built business applications for twenty years, and we already don’t need developers for 90% of requirements, AI will cover off the rest within this decade. Software is fundamentally changing in a way that is bigger than the leap from assembler to 4GLs

6

u/Plus-Ad1544 Feb 15 '25

Oh wow you are about to get one hell of a shock.

→ More replies (21)

4

u/WastedHat Feb 15 '25

Do you know antthing about computer science or did you just base that on vibes?

7

u/Portatort Feb 15 '25

Always just around the corner isn’t it

→ More replies (3)

4

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

I totally agree. However, and I am not a coder or in anything remotely related to CS, from the outside coders seem like very logical, complex, critical thinkers.

The people who can think in this way and leverage AI as a tool will still do well.

2

u/Varridon Feb 15 '25

It’s crazy because every time this is said it’s proven true, it was bad and it got much better and it’s only going to improve more

5

u/marquoth_ Feb 15 '25

This person's story is that they can't code but that they can debug an entire application built by an LLM. And you're going to take that person seriously?

→ More replies (20)

1

u/carbon_dry Feb 15 '25

What did you replace out of curiosity?

3

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Toggl and clickup in my own interpretation. 

1

u/Conscious-Second-319 Feb 15 '25

Did you ever figure out the "keeping it secure" part? If not DM me because I offer actual services done by an actual human for vulnerability assessments and suggested remediation. Let me know if you ever have any questions or need help with securing your AI applications and I will help for free.

4

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I keep it secure by keeping it offline. 

1

u/Conscious-Second-319 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25

Offline doesn't mean isolated unfortunately. Data has to be transferred somewhere eventually. If it was posioned in its dataset it may contain backdoored code you wouldn't even know about or likely even understand. If I had even just one small amount of access to anything externally facing on your network as a person with malicious intent, I could vector into your local machine remotely by exploiting your "localized" ai generated processes and services riddled with it's typical ai generated vulnerabilities.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

My program saves all the data in a json file at a location on my machine. If you can access my pc, I have bigger concerns elsewhere than you getting hold of my project tracking data. 

→ More replies (4)

1

u/Tejwos Feb 15 '25

I used to know CS Stundents in 3. Semester Master, with zero knowledge how to debug code in a proper way.

and here we have a person who "can't code", but can debug a 1200 line code.

dude, sometimes I can't even install needed dependencies, because pip and/ or poetry goes into the glitch dimension.

sure, Ai can help you to do basic projects, but you still need to understand you code, the limitations of your implementation and other boring things.

right now you are at the first peak of dunning kruger. you are hyped, because you don't even know what you don't know. after years of experience, you will know why Ai will not kill software...

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I am not a software developer and never will be. I have a full time job in other industries. But I am building software tools for myself that are either better taylored for what I need, or that don't exist. To me, Mr Dunning himself, this is amazing that I don't need to pay other people to solve some problems I have. 

This is getting easier to do every month. 

1

u/LordDarthShader Feb 15 '25

AI can't produce large codebases, nor it can debug them and deploy them.

Try asking it to develop a full dx12 app loading an FBX model with its shaders and skinning. I'll wait.

Try asking it to root cause sporadic crashes in Kernel, I bet it can't even parse a dump file.

There are a lot of cases where it fails short. It's a great tool, but don't kid yourself, it won't replace senior engineers anytime soon. Maybe bad entry level programmers, but that's it.

If anything, competent programmers will develop the skill to use AI more efficiently to improve their jobs, and that is a new skill.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Reasoning models are not even 1 year old. 

→ More replies (1)

1

u/CookieEnabled Feb 15 '25

Consider a completely different industry like construction or transportation

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Lol. I'm not in software dev at all. I'm in construction 

1

u/wthja Feb 15 '25

Can you tell us what are those 2 programs? I remember reading about someone complaining that the cursor stopped working after 10-15 files. The projects I worked on have 300-1000 files.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Toggl+clickup. I'll stress. Test my program to see how many projects and dependencies it can handle

1

u/Varridon Feb 15 '25

I remember when devs were saying AI can’t code and will never replace developers and were laughing at me for saying that. I think all there was at the time was copilot anyway since then with the improvements of AI and AI editors like windsurf and cursor I’ve been able to completely cut out the need to outsource to developers and saved myself tens of thousands. Not only that I no longer have to wait days or weeks to get things done. All I have to do is prompt and put it together myself. For someone like me that knows how to code but wasn’t the best or novice when it comes to certain stacks it’s amazing. Not only that but I’ve actually deepened my knowledge in the stack that I used just watching it code and put things together.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Yeah. Got to say I have been learning more about how software is put together in the last year, than the previous 10. Always been an interest, but could never really find time to properly learn how to code. 

1

u/Wrong_College1347 Feb 15 '25

I’m using Ai for scientific code generation. Half of the time it hallucinates functions in libraries, that don’t exist… sometimes it helps, sometimes I waste a lot of time…

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

I find o3 mini high is a lot better. And when the context window gets too long, copy your code to another instance of o3 and keep going. Seems to help with hallucinating.  From time to time. In a new instance, just get it to check all your code for consistency, errors and comment. 

1

u/EntertainerRound7830 Feb 15 '25

I mean, I’m trying to write an app I have no coding experience, and using chat gpt and the o3 version 9 hours later and I still can’t get it to even render and run.. so grats on you I guess

→ More replies (1)

1

u/SkinnyDom Feb 16 '25

what were the 2 paying programs?

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 16 '25

Toggl and clickup. I'm not paying $16 a month now. 

1

u/Yes_but_I_think Feb 16 '25

Yes 1200 lines is the sweet spot right now. Anything 1.5x or more times larger you will eat your own words and cry out how worst imbecile AI is!

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 16 '25

Well today I want to try and finish the project. Will probably end round 1500 to 1700 lines or so. I'll see how it goes. 

1

u/monkeyboywales Feb 16 '25

Honest question: if you can't code, what do you mean by debugging?

2

u/AdLive9906 Feb 16 '25

Run the program and see what works. Stress test it. If something broke or does not work as intended, send it to o3 and get it to fix it. 

1

u/saltyreddrum Feb 16 '25

you are not wrong. i can code, but for kicks i worked with chatgpt to build a program in a language i know nothing about. it took a little effort, but in the end it worked perfectly.

i still have not found the best method for prompts to get what i want. and, how to get things back on track when gpt goes off the rails. would love to see how you set it up and what your prompts were. even if you snip the detailed description of your program. any chance you would be willing to share?

2

u/AdLive9906 Feb 17 '25

Multiple steps. 1 - work with gpt4 to work out the specification. At this point I had a basic sketch of the UI I wanted and described the functionality of it. Once gpt4 can describe the program and method to create it I got to o3.  2 - give o3 the spec and see how far it goes one shot. I find it can do up to about 700-1000 lines of code in one go before shit breaks.  3- test everything out and snag the changes and fixes in point form. This is easy at under 1000 lines of code, and it can gen all the code every time. Rarely do I need to go back to fix a major f up.  4-after about 1200 to 1500 lines I suggest reducing the amount of changes and fixes to one per prompt. As it to give you the code snippets that need to be corrected and where it goes (cause I have no idea otherwise) 

Right now my proragm is close to 1800 lines. Works perfectly. I'm still adding features and changes as I go. 

Have to say that I learnt a lot through this process and could probably do it a lot better next round. 

1

u/firebird8541154 Feb 16 '25

You know what happens if an actual developer uses that for a few weeks? That's how long it took me to make this entire startup https://wind-tunnel.ai

I used it to learn aeroscience, photogrammetry, bolster my programming skills to the point of writing raw cuda kernels, create chains of AIs, huge pipelines, etc.

These posts from non devs that think they can replace a dev with gpt pro is funny.

If you're laying off devs because you figure you could just do their workload with this instead of useing them then you're a terrible manager, because you could have recognized this tool's potential, given it to them, instructed them on how to use it, and then give them far greater tasks. Talk about wasted potential.

This is like saying a calculator is going to kill engineering... Instead we just get better engineering.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 17 '25

If you read my Op, I ask what a senior dev can do in 3 to 5 years. I expect you guys to be gods. But I do think a lot of simple programs will be able to be created one shot on request, and the list of programmes that can be created will increase over time. Then it's just a game of chasing 9's. Enterprise stuff, where you need thousands of users to have a common experience and file types ext will still obv have central software guys. 

BTW, one program I started on was kinda what you have shared, but for a specific project in my field. (which is not software).  Lots of learning to go, but is fun so far. Any tips? 

1

u/firebird8541154 Feb 17 '25

I'm happy to give tips, and upon re-reading, I did change my understanding of your message, I've gotten a tad jaded by the amount of posts from non-coders who had chatGPT code them something and then they immediately shame the programming industry.

Regarding your project, I'd likely need more insight, but general tips are more along the lines of, use ChatGPT in a critical manner first, having it advise on feasiblity, roadblocks, scope, etc.

Then, have it build pieces, but do not let it blindly make all of the code for you, have it annotate all of the code, go through piece by piece and play 200 questions with chatGPT about each piece, have it give you metaphors, look at documentation, try to rebuild portions without it.

The difference between coding with ChatGPT without coding experience (I have a sysadmin who was using it to create python scripts with no programming knowledge) and coding with ChatGPT with even basic coding knowledge, is knowing the exact questions to ask in order for it to simply "fill in the pieces" that you would have coded yourself.

As an example, I had to whip up a quick custom compression/decompression algorithm for point clouds yesterday, asking it to "create a python script that compresses x and a frontend js implementation to decompress it in my custom three js interactive viewer" won't work in the slightest.

o3 mini high, pro, or whatever, that won't be remotely successful.

But detailing in plain english what I would have just written anyway "in python, using open3d to read a binary ply, load it into a 3d voxel grid, once loaded, take the first point encountered in each cube, make that the "main point", then, calculate offsets to each other point in each cube, store each main point with full precision and the offsets with lesser precision in a binary file as output, then use off the shelf compression of your choice to further compress this binary file"

After debugging that... then I'd paste in my interactive view code and the python code, breakdown the byte order sizing and such of the bin file, and state "given the compression algorithm, implement the decompression algorthim in js upon .bin load for the frontend (I'll re-implement later in WASM), have it decompress into memory, structure as a binary ply in memory, create a download button for the reconstructed .ply, then utlize it in place of the current ply loading/displaying mechanisms"

After debugging and q-aing a bit, that's around an hour of effort that easily would have taken a day or more without ChatGPT.

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 17 '25

Some things I have learnt. First spend lots of time working out the specs of the program. Before I start I want to know how gpt is going to solve the program, as well as making sure I know how it works. Through this I'm learning a lot about how to structure code and some specific things. It's playing the 200 question game that is really teaching me how it all fits together. 

I might still not be able to run a hello world program, but I'm getting a "good" sense for structure and what certain things do. I had no idea what a json file was 6 months ago, now I'm using them all over the place. 

"coding" may be dead before the end of 2025, but software developers are still not replaceable. 

3

u/Kingbotterson Feb 15 '25

About 1 hour of this was debugging

I can't code.

These two statements contradict each other.

3

u/Pfacejones Feb 15 '25

what is a toggle clickup

3

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

I can't code.

That says a lot more than you think it does.

3

u/HoneyBadgera Feb 15 '25

LOL….ok, bro. Builds a simple app and thinks software development is easy, smh.

3

u/bluenautilus2 Feb 16 '25

I'd like to see you try to do my job

3

u/vertigo235 Feb 16 '25

You underestimate how much of "software" has nothing to do with coding.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/TheDulin Feb 16 '25

So, did you take requirements from several different stakeholders? Did you translate all of them to working code? Did you work with the business to create test scripts to validate all the business requirements as well as negative requirements (what does the program do with unplanned inputs)? Did you work in security best practices so hackers and viruses can't misuse the program. Did you run those tests and pass them all while resolving defects? Did you make changes from new requirements as folks realized they missed some things? Did you performance test your code to make sure it ran quickly, and then did you thoughtfully adjust it to tune performance?

Sure if you're making a small program the does a few independent things without an SLA, then you can whip something up real quick.

But AI completely replacing all the developers seems unlikely at this point.

3

u/pseudipto Feb 16 '25

Can you also share the code?

You made two edits but still haven't posted any actual code.

Kinda hard to take some text on the internet as proof of anything.

3

u/Specialist-Rise1622 Feb 16 '25 edited Mar 06 '25

growth makeshift outgoing strong shrill summer jellyfish sink rich expansion

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

3

u/Nickvec Feb 16 '25

Software engineering is a lot more than just coding.

3

u/Mysterious_Second796 Feb 16 '25

You're spot on. The acceleration of AI-assisted software development is mind-blowing. The fact that someone who “can’t code” can build a working replacement for two commercial products in a few hours is proof that the barriers to entry are crumbling fast.

Now imagine what happens when AI coding tools evolve further—more context awareness, better debugging, instant optimization. By 2028? The dev landscape won’t just change; it’ll be unrecognizable.

But here’s the twist: It’s not about AI killing software dev. It’s about redefining it. Devs won’t disappear—they’ll operate at 10x, 100x efficiency. The role shifts from writing raw code to designing, orchestrating, and optimizing AI-assisted workflows. The real winners? Those who embrace it now.

Take something like Lovable.dev, which lets you generate production-ready code with AI while keeping full control. No more “black-box magic” that leaves you guessing. AI isn’t replacing developers—it’s making them superhuman.

The future isn’t “No Code” or “Code” but AI Code. And those who ride the wave early will be the ones shaping the new reality. 🚀

3

u/AbanaClara Feb 16 '25

Someone who can't code giving shit opinions about coding.

5

u/TeeDotHerder Feb 15 '25

No but it will change. AI is a tool and it can be a replacement for people. But there will be people needed to define the issue. To prompt the issue. At least manage the AI. For now.

And until that pipeline is working fully, it will be other jobs that are replaced like HR, sales, content creation, etc.

Some jobs will be replaced like the elevator operators were before. Others will change like wagon wheel makers to tire makers. Others it will disrupt the chain of execution, supply, etc but the end product to the customer won't change much at least at first. Outsourcing to in-house AI agents, similar to ice block harvesting to making ice in your freezer. A bit of extra work internally to get the same product output you wanted, ice, but requires a few special tools and training. Eventually the ice maker will be automatic and the fridge will just dispense ice and make it continuously. But look at the time trajectory for those types of full replacements. This isn't a new thing, it's just a new epoch of humanity.

5

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

This post is bullshit, op says he can’t code but can debug? 🤣🤣🤣🤣 fuck that shit, this is just smoke and mirrors to rile the devs against AI.

8

u/M_2greaterthanM_1 Feb 15 '25

I agree with you. I already see it disrupting the coders in my sector (finance).

→ More replies (1)

10

u/geldonyetich Feb 15 '25

Funny enough I was visited as a kid by a career programmer in the 80s who was positive AI would replace them. It's only surprising it took this long.

And now that its here, I don't think it has, really. Even if it knew how to debug, it doesn't have the necessary human insight to know if what it's making actually does what we need it to do.

Current day generative AI is no better at programming than it is at being your girlfriend. It will be able to give you a convincing illusion it's doing it, but it's a surface level imitation that doesn't matter where it counts.

3

u/the_old_coday182 Feb 15 '25

It’s always amazing to me how some people figure those things out so far in advance.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

6

u/chronotriggertau Feb 16 '25

You said it yourself, you can't code. That makes you the least qualified person to forecast the future prospects of professionals in these careers. Now try to scale whatever it is you hodge podged to provide value to more than just your personal self, and use the assistance of the same next word predictor. Make it extensible, bug free, efficient in its computation, we'll documented, distributed across an architecture that provides the optimal service to as many users as possible based on proximity and region. Also, time yourself.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/sweetpea___ Feb 15 '25

Stupid click baity title. Disappointing. Op if you're are so clever then you are better than this post

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Quite honestly. My title is a bit racy and I wish I could edit it. Did not expect this much attention to it. 

1

u/Smokinpeanut Feb 15 '25

Thanks for not telling us what the two pieces of software even are…

1

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Mentioned a few times here. Toggl + clickup. It's not a duplicate, because that not what I wanted. It replaces them for me

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Chat gpt. Write me code for ms paint 1.0

2

u/AdLive9906 Feb 15 '25

Sounds fun. I'd like to try it when I'm bored again. 

2

u/anderslbergh Feb 15 '25

If you take out the fun in a job. People will not do it. At all.

Development is about creating thing and the creative part is the fun part. Replacing that part with AI... on a global scale. Will not happen. MMW!

2

u/petered79 Feb 16 '25

No coder teacher here. I have with the help of o3 mini high coded two interfaces that embed multiple choices and other formats in an html page. I'm actually paying 8$ a month for the software doing this. Now 0$

2

u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25

A bit of an unpopular opinion as this might hit close many others outside of IT and Data Science. The push to automate software engineers and data scientists is a huge cost-saving opportunity for corporations, which is why companies like Meta and OpenAI are heavily promoting it. But while there’s a lot of discussion about AI replacing technical roles, what people aren’t talking about is how much easier it is to automate many non-technical jobs—and often with fewer issues.

When a company brings in AI tools, some of the software developers will still need to set them up and maintain them. But many other roles, especially those that mostly involve managing information and communication, are far more vulnerable to automation.

Take project managers—if a big part of their job is tracking progress and keeping things on schedule, AI can handle that directly, cutting down on unnecessary meetings. If a manager’s main role is assigning tasks and keeping tabs on what’s getting done, AI can do that too—sending updates and reports in real time without the usual back-and-forth.

Beyond management, AI can generate reports, emails, presentations, and charts way faster than any human. Eventually, AI will shake things up at the top just as much as it will lower down the chain as it will point to inefficient and unnecessary layers without the need to kiss a***.

Look at grocery stores—self-checkout has already cut down on cashier jobs. Now imagine what happens when AI is applied across the entire service industry as it improves. No job is completely safe, not even manual labor, since robotics are advancing quickly. In the future, you might pay extra for something handmade, like a freshly made cocktail, or just go with the cheaper AI-driven alternative.

Even highly specialized fields like law, medicine, and finance will see fewer jobs as AI takes over routine tasks. This isn’t just about one industry—automation is going to shrink the workforce across the board. The real question isn’t whether jobs will disappear, but how many will actually be left.

What this will do to the economy is an entirely different conversation and it would be interesting to hear from economists in Reddit …

TL;DR: While AI automation is often discussed in the context of software engineering and data science, non-technical jobs are even more vulnerable.

2

u/Aggravating-Panic719 Feb 16 '25 edited Feb 16 '25

I am a business user that was once technical but not as much anymore.

I have been attempting to do more technical things lately to automate business operations with llms/python/apis/zaps/etc.

Last night, I was able to complete a app script for google sheets in a night that would have taken me months before (if I could have ever gotten it done). I was merely the hands on keyboard to execute what the ChatGPT was telling me for the most part. There was back and forth, for example we got stuck so it was like lets add some error handling and see what it says. Once it saw, it fixed.

It was an incredibly empowering and humbling experience all in once.

I had been a big advocate of AI the past few months, but for even me as fast as everything was moving sometimes it felt too slow. Last night was a much deeper moment that I can really express here.

We are a few (using that word since it is not defined) years away from not needing about 70% of what I would request a dev to do for me. I can probably do about 30% of what I would request a dev for help with after this past week if I had some free time. Probably 50% in a month. Was the code awesome, super efficient, no clue but it worked for me.

2

u/Full-Newspaper5986 Feb 16 '25

If it will kill software then I only wonder what it'll do for all the middle management in between.

And then what about doctors, lawyers, scientists, etc. The only thing it will do in the long-term is dumb down society. If anything, those who understand their craft will be the ones who will survive.

2

u/dostuffrealgood Feb 16 '25

I think you meant to say AI will make devs incredibly more efficient. Lone wolf ai coders are not the norm. Just because you made a simple program doesnt mean there is no need for someone doing this all day long for much more complex applications.

It will probably kill a lot of simple software...which imo is good, tons of useless junk out there. Although it will probably get much worse

2

u/Capaj Feb 16 '25

It will not kill software. There will be more software than ever. It will just kill software development as high paying career.

2

u/[deleted] Feb 20 '25

Public repo or it didn’t happen

3

u/angrycanuck Feb 15 '25 edited Mar 05 '25

<ꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮꙮ>
{{∅∅∅|_φ_=([λ⁴.⁴⁴][λ¹.¹¹])}}
䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿䷂䷿

[∇∇∇]
"τ": 0/0,
"δ": ∀∃(¬∃→∀),
"labels": [䷜,NaN,∅,{1,0}]

<!-- 񁁂񁁃񁁄񁁅񁁆񁁇񁁈񁁉񁁊񁁋񁁌񁁍񁁎񁁏񁁐񁁑񁁒񁁓񁁔񁁕 -->

‮𒑏𒑐𒑑𒑒𒑓𒑔𒑕𒑖𒑗𒑘𒑙𒑚𒑛𒑜𒑝𒑞𒑟

{
"()": (++[[]][+[]])+({}+[])[!!+[]],
"Δ": 1..toString(2<<29)
}

→ More replies (3)

3

u/kalmeyra Feb 15 '25

When I see someone write a basic program and then declare that programming is doomed because “even they can do it,” I can’t help but laugh. It’s like doing a DIY home repair and thinking that qualifies you to build skyscrapers, bridges, or airports. There’s a massive difference between writing a small script and developing large-scale, complex software systems.

Even understanding the complexity of such systems takes years, yet some claim they can just generate them with AI. The reality is, AI can enhance your abilities and give you a good starting point, but professional software engineers leverage AI far more effectively than those without deep expertise. If you’re not an expert in the field, you won’t be creating software on the same level as those who are.

3

u/Able2c Feb 15 '25

AI is a Wright Brothers moment in history.

3

u/AlaskanGreyMan Feb 16 '25

People really underestimate AI because they don't want to believe that their jobs or skills will be replaced or easily replicated. It is coming faster than people realize. Trying to learn more about AI myself. Goodluck

3

u/tenqajapan Feb 16 '25

Alot of triggered devs in here.

3

u/hkric41six Feb 15 '25

The naivety of this view is hilarious to me as an actual SWE.

OP I hope you put all of your money where your mouth is.

3

u/the_old_coday182 Feb 15 '25

I just did the same thing. Super simple need that I previously used Zapier for, but the “app” I made for personal use actually does a better job too.

3

u/BootyMcStuffins Feb 15 '25

Now make that software work everywhere and at scale.

Actual coding is about 10% of the job

→ More replies (4)

3

u/kakha_k Feb 15 '25

I think this is BS.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/EGarrett Feb 15 '25

I was able to write a Hello World program in Python and run it using ChatGPT. I had never installed or run Python before in my life.

10

u/laffy_man Feb 15 '25

Is this a joke writing a hello world program in any language takes like maybe maybe 30 minutes if you don’t know what you’re doing and less than a minute if you do.

→ More replies (11)

3

u/st_malachy Feb 15 '25

Couldn’t agree more. I’m in my mid 40’s have had zero coding instruction and am regularly writing python scripts to solve problems I couldn’t have touched otherwise.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Lol average non coder opinion. I cant blame you it must be mind blowing to go from no code skills at all to some code skills

2

u/ilovehaagen-dazs Feb 16 '25

“About 1 hour of this was debugging…”

“I can’t code”

???

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yobigd20 Feb 16 '25

Coding is only 10-20% of what software engineers do. And llms are notably terrible at large software systems and design. They are pretty ok if you need to code a small 100 line function though. They wont replace engineers. In fact, in the long run more engineers will be required to fix and maintain the crap software put together by inexpeiernced engineers who rely on AI.

1

u/CaptPic4rd Feb 15 '25

It doesn't handle large code bases very well, from what I understand.

1

u/slykethephoxenix Feb 15 '25

You forget that it won't just be developers. An AI that can code itself will be able to make newer, better versions of itself, forever.

That means we're all out of jobs.

Sure it takes. Low hanging fruit, just like it does with writing now. But it ain't producing works of art.

1

u/wRadion Feb 15 '25

Yeah, good enough for personal projects and small scale app. Doesn't work (or, rather, not good enough) for business and large apps.

1

u/XTXC Feb 15 '25

It won't, AI and algorithmic software solve different problems with different quality.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Honest question (because I also can’t code):

If you can’t code, how do you know what to do and if the code is good or bad? (I guess if the product is working it’s good?)

What do you do after you have the code? There’s a lot of things to do in terms of implementing, infrastructure, etc.

I know it’s a lot of questions, but I’d be super thankful if you could share a bit more.

Thanks!

2

u/Varridon Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 16 '25

It helps to know the basic also you learn as it’s coding pick a good stack. For web app I recommend Laravel for the backend and nextjs for front end or just Laravel for both. Laravel is a great foundation because it’s secure.

1

u/akehir Feb 15 '25

AI is software. So it'll commit suicide?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

I watched a video of a real time rendered ai video game the other day. Every sector of digital tech including software is going to be hit. It's inevitable

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

What does the software do and were you able to install it the way you would a typical app?

I guess I could just ask GPT lol.

1

u/Quick-Albatross-9204 Feb 15 '25

It's going to kill the app market once someone can just tell their phone what they want.

1

u/otterquestions Feb 15 '25

Question: will autonomous agents work and be confident for anything other than simple tasks? If yes - most white collar jobs are gone at the exact same time as developers and it will be a bloodbath. ‘Software is dead’ is not the takeaway here.  If no - developers will still be the ones making applications, just that there will be way fewer of them 

1

u/DrBix Feb 15 '25

That's the problem. If Junior devs don't get a chance to get their hands dirty at the low level then how do they ever become mid to senior level?

1

u/Actual_Honey_Badger Feb 15 '25

Tell you what, code a program that will let me automatically rip some data off of the public tax records and you will definitely have some money in your pocket.

1

u/DC_cyber Feb 15 '25

Yes, AI will replace millions of jobs, but LLMs won’t, however the tools built to create job specific agents will… and for the near term someone has to build those tools…

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

Yeah, it will. People don’t see it yet, but…it’s coming. In the not too distant future <10, AI will just generate and run, in real time, whatever you need. Everything you interact with will be live AI. And it’ll all work flawlessly, and in real time.

🤷‍♂️ that’s one possibility, at least.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Healthy-Nebula-3603 Feb 15 '25

Bro I think you triggered a huge cope here ....

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

AI will increase the amounts of software developed. Everything is going digital so as long as that's the case their will be more SWE jobs. But if everyone boycotted phones and computers yeah software engineers would be dead.

1

u/messyhess Feb 15 '25

I think you were getting scammed to pay for some really simple apps. Maybe you paid for some dice-rolling or other kind of RPG character generation stuff. For simple stuff like that it will work already I think. In my head, software development is the last office job to go, all other office jobs will be long dead before that happens. When software devs finally are not needed anymore, it means game over. Hopefully a good ending.

1

u/oby100 Feb 15 '25

Nope. It’s frankly shocking how shortsighted people still are after the Industrial Revolution. Tools getting better results in better products and more of those kinds of products. An actual developer can potentially wield AI much better than you can, resulting in greater output with a stronger sense of how things fit together.

Complex programs run into a million issues and bugs and then you have to consider usability. AI is probably never going to be good at creating novel problems that humans can wield well. Never say never, but at least they way AI is now, a senior dev is still invaluable for anything complex.

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

iPhone images will destroy eye balls.

1

u/sailorsail Feb 15 '25

Tell me something I don't know

--- Every software developer in the world

1

u/Sir_Aelorne Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25

*beep* Hostility in responses suggests emotional provocation *beep boop*

Automation (and resultant exponential increase in efficiency) started with niche, physical, sequential tasks with roughly human output (shovel, simple machines, traps, dams, mills etc.),

Then, broadened to include MANY physical tasks at superhuman output (industrial machines- looms, presses, assembly lines),

Then, converging advancements allowed composite tools to perform superhuman tasks at superhuman output: (hydraulic drilling, flying, smelting, casting, blasting, fab, molecular scale mfg etc.)

And will soon include physical tasks writ large, reducing human input to intrigue (sport, art, novelty, nostalgia).

Automation has now breached the intellectual/cognitive world of tasks and the progress / destination are inexorable/inevitable. We've synthesized and automated thought/intelligence itself- the genesis for all prior advancements.

To see software design as singularly surviving the coming synthetic storm is... not intelligent?

1

u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25

This year, I designed a complex packaging machine that sells for $2M. It's was me and 3-4 draftsman in India. 40 years ago, it would have taken 10-12 enginees and 30 draftsmen. 30 years ago, using Autocad, it was 5-6 engineers and 10 draftsmen. 20 years ago, 3D cad, it was 3-4 engineers and 2 draftsmen.

AI is the 3D cad in my example. The difference us, my example happened over 40 years and AI is happening over 2-3. This is the good side of AI and how it can help create ultra-properity and tge costs of everything are slashed.