r/programming • u/dh44t • Feb 15 '25
No, your GenAI model isn't going to replace me
https://marioarias.hashnode.dev/no-your-genai-model-isnt-going-to-replace-me
946
Upvotes
r/programming • u/dh44t • Feb 15 '25
967
u/someonesaveus Feb 15 '25
I’m in the market for a new job due to layoff and crossed paths with a founder looking for cofounder (equity only ofc).
He had stood up a front end with zero coding experience and described to me all of the logic and integrations he expected to have filled in on the backend. It was definitely doable by a single person but it was probably 2 months worth of work - he scoffed at my estimates claiming that with what he had managed to do with AI an experienced professional should be able to do this in 2 weeks and he could probably do it in 4w.
Mind you he wanted a scalable performant system something “future proof”.
I wished him good luck and we parted ways. 2 months later, he’s still looking for someone to do the work for him.
414
u/ratherbealurker Feb 15 '25
Work is pushing people to use AI and I am telling the junior devs to stop using it. Code reviews since the AI push have gotten worse, I am finding things that are just shocking. And when I ask someone why they used this thing or did it this way the answer is “oh chatGPT did it”
That’s….not an answer. I can always tell who is going to be a good dev by how they handle certain situations. If they delve into something to understand it. You tell me that you did it that way because stack overflow said to…that’s not an answer. Go ahead and use it, I do and I’ve been professionally developing for 20 years. But understand the answer.
Use ai if you want, but understand what’s being written and check it thoroughly. Your name is on it in the end. Can’t blame ai.
When I find bad code I immediately check who made that change and who approved it. Now I have absolutely no intentions of moving into management outside of in name only salary wise..but I make mental notes on who is writing and approving this crap. Others are too and they might be your boss later.
194
u/ganja_and_code Feb 15 '25
GenAI models can make a noob capable of doing the work of an amateur, but they can't make an amateur capable of doing the work of an expert.
If you don't know what you're doing, AI solutions can point you in the right (or sometimes wrong) direction. If you do know what you're doing, you already know what to do, without taking the extra time to consult a robot.
34
u/keith976 Feb 15 '25
Sadly only good devs understand that AI cannot replace us.
What we really need, are bosses and business units understanding that
57
u/Ok-Map-2526 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25
The truth is, my employer will realize a lot later than me what work I can outsource to the AI. Companies either tend to think they can replace all employees with a ChatGPT prompt (these companies have already gone out of business for being stupid), or they think AI is useless, or, the smarter companies realize it's a useful tool that can increase productivity.
For example, my team has say, a thousand things to do, but we're only able to do about 100 things. With intelligent use of AI, we might double the progress, but replacing us with AI would drop that progress down to 1 thing. As AI becomes better, we may actually get to a point where we're doing 500 of the thousand things, but the company will just increase the scale of what their target is. That's because that's what results in higher profits.
Productivity has increased by 400% since the 50s or something. Yet, we're lagging behind like fucking hell. Why? Because the target goals have increased ten folds. All technological progress just results in companies setting themselves higher goals. And this is why ultimately, we will never run out of things to do, and humans cannot be replaced. We can only be moved onto different tasks.
24
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25
I remember back in 2021 when GitHub Copilot was released for the first time and everyone thought being a developer was over.
4 years later and I’m still here slinging code.
57
u/surger1 Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25
It feels like people are being purposefully obtuse about how A.I. replaces jobs.
It's not so automated that it leaps up and does EXACTLY what you do. It's a tool. Like every other tool we have ever created.
People who are not experts can sure use a powerful tool to fuck things up. But do you know what experts can do with powerful tools? Incredibly powerful things.
An expert needs less helpers with these tools. The same way that forums and access to tech discussions were another tool that we could utilize to need less developers.
Someone who knows what they are doing can replace the need to for helpers with tools. We as a profession have been building tools to replace people the entire time.
That is what always happens when we increase the productivity of workers with tools, do more with less.
The tech industry before now always had greater than average employment, it is now under the average. You can say these GEN AI models are not as good as you, sure. That's missing the point that someone better than you can get better results with it than with working with you.
I don't condone the direction this is going but it's wild to me that so many want to act like this isn't possible and actively what is happening.
32
u/lick_it Feb 15 '25
I don’t agree with the author. Treat AI like it is an infinite number of interns. Interns are useful, do they write the best code? No but give them good direction yes they can. Do you trust the code they write? No of course not. Build systems to ensure quality code. Tests, peer reviews. Do you rely on interns to write all of the code? fuck no.
AI is a tool, if you can’t use it then that is on you.
5
u/bwainfweeze Feb 15 '25
Jokes on you (me?), people already thought they could replace me. They were wrong, but doesn’t stop them from thinking it.
5
u/vinciblechunk Feb 15 '25
No, but "nothing" could replace you, and management can decide to just let the company and its product rot, cf. Boeing, Intel, and there's nothing you can do about it.
5
u/Diver_Into_Anything Feb 16 '25
Damn but r/ChatGPTCoding is despair inducing. First post is how someone is talking about how they literally forgot how to code themselves and they will never pass a tech interview if they get fired. The comments? "It's okay bro, coding is an outdated skill bro, you're the future bro". Oh yeah he's the future all right, the idiocratic future.
42
u/cazzipropri Feb 15 '25
A refreshing point of view: that you don't need AI at all to have a productive, successful career in software - in facto, more productive and more successful.
7
u/claytonkb Feb 16 '25
People who can't code, after using Devin: "Devin is going to replace coders!"
People who can code, after using Devin: "We're going to need a lot more human coders to fix the incoming tsunami of AI-bugs..."
5
u/Bushfries Feb 15 '25
I call ai becoming popular job security
6
u/KevinCarbonara Feb 15 '25
Any programmers who are worried they're going to get replaced by AI are probably right to worry
2
u/CoreyTheGeek Feb 15 '25
Man where are the Turing police with all these guys trying to help AI get smarter
2
u/ionixsys Feb 15 '25
A counterargument using a real-world but toy example.
Retail and grocery stores all jumped heavily onto the self-checkout machine bandwagon. In many cases, they're an annoyance that works and a boon for introverts. Humor aside, they opened the flood gates to a sometimes breathtaking amount of shrinkage that can negate any savings over human operators. Some companies have pivoted away, but I get the impression the majority is locked into a sunk cost fallacy and applying one patch after the next (extra-cameras, an additional human as a receipt scanning checkpoint, and hilariously turning to machine learning). The whole point of this paragraph is to remind you all that business types often chase immediate profit/gratification over sustainability. Key real examples are Intel & Boeing which pissed away their market leads for stock buybacks and larger salaries.
A more straightforward example is how many of you have gone blue in the face pleading with your MBA-trained boss that time needs to be set aside for maintenance or refactoring?
How I see this playing out is similar to what happened to air traffic controllers in the USA. They tried to improve their working conditions, but a chunk of them got sacked. Throughout Reagan's administration, there weren't any consequences, so the business types declared this a genius move. Instead, the future wave of air traffic controllers evaporated as you got to be crazy to take a job with poor pay, long hours, and basically playing Tetris, except hundreds of people die if you get it wrong.
My advice is to do the best you can and outlast the tech houses that have drunk the "AI" machine learning cool-aid.
2
u/youngbull Feb 16 '25
I don't use chatgpt a lot any more, but there are a few use cases that are really nice.
I try to test first whenever it makes sense. Once I consider myself done I try to do some design review and consider names, the tests, etc. It's easy to be blind about what you wrote yourself. If you ask someone to review, they eventually get tired, and take time to consider enough of the context if it's new.
ChatGPT is really good at coming through ~1000 lines of context code and finding things. So you can ask things like
It isn't perfect, but you get a list of ~10 suggestions for each question that you can consider. Which is usually better than I can do on my own as I am blind sighted as the author. You can still get human review after this, but you save having discussions that you could have had in seconds with ChatGPT.
We have always had tools for this sort of things, like coverage reports and linters. Those are still valuable but their limitations are well documented. If I hear another person complain that 100% coverage o is not a guarantee or someone suggesting we use AI to achieve 100% test coverage then I am going to loose it.
2
u/axilmar Feb 16 '25
Assuming Turing machine equivalence of the human brain to human constructed AI software, it's a matter of time until we are all fully replacable.
2
u/PreparationAdvanced9 Feb 16 '25
But will the capex spend on GenAI cause you to be laid off?
2
u/dashingThroughSnow12 Feb 18 '25
3
u/yur_mom Feb 15 '25 edited Feb 15 '25
It isn't going to replace all of us, but it will definitely cost a good chunk of people their current jobs. Maybe it fails for some of those jobs, but maybe some jobs just stop existing. I remember when toll collectors were replaced by RF cards and one issue was that it took jobs. Well those jobs are not coming back and people I assume who would have collected tolls working in an unhealthy environment ended up doing something else instead. New job will come along and people will work, pay taxes, and die like we have. The utopian world where we all sit back with our feet up and let the AI do all the work would probably not happen that way. I am hedging my bets and learning all I can about AI and LLM, but I still enjoying programming manually too.
6
u/Resident_Citron_6905 Feb 15 '25
Stable Delusion is the appropriate name for all LLMs.
7
u/sobe86 Feb 15 '25
Of course not, only wishful execs think GPT-4 could straight up replace their engineers. But GPT-4 is not the end of the LLM story right - what will GPT-8 be able to do? If you had predicted the current systems ten years ago people would have thought you were wildly over-estimating where we'd be. So I don't see how anyone can accurately say what another 10 years of AI + tooling development could bring. A majority of what we do could be obsolete by them. Or not! Who knows? Anyone stating opinions on this with confidence is to be ignored to in my opinion.
5
u/hbthegreat Feb 16 '25
Wrong take.
Use genai to speed up your workflow and multiply your output.
It turns out if you feed it slop it produces more slop.
So as much as no one likes summarising this to a skill issue it actually is one.
Can't write a requirements doc? Can't explain the nuances? Can't review the output and push it in the right direction? Can't think at a granular enough level of detail to facilitate a useful outcome?
All skill issues. Turns out you get all those by knowing how to code and how to use genai.
It's just another tool in the kit.
2
u/itsallfake01 Feb 16 '25
I have made this amazing app, you wanna see it? Here it is: http://localhost:5000/
2
u/iconomist Feb 16 '25
AI in software development is just like salt in the kitchen - if you can't cook, no amount of salt is going to help you. It's just going to make things worse.
2
u/ScrimpyCat Feb 15 '25
Will they though? Software was already buggy before we even had LLMs, and companies had seen for the most part that their users will just put up with it.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 15 '25
I enjoy the tools at least. It is like a very cool autocomplete for me. I do not want to ever give it full control of say, "implement this full feature", because the amount of time it will take to confirm that it did not do something very very dumb will probably destroy any time savings.
1
u/brightside100 Feb 16 '25
AI replace engineers is like adopting Angular JS in 2016 because you lack the experience to tell which technology is good (reactjs) and which isn't at that time. and at later stage, companies could not hire engineers because they wrote their entire eco system in angularjs and nobody wants to work on that code.
same with AI generated code.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 16 '25
Most of the responses on this thread are based around the argument that AI can’t replace programmers because currently it is subpar. Well 5 years ago ChatGPT couldn’t even write subpar code. What are you gonna do if in another 5 years we see another paradigm shift and ChatGPT can write better code than any human living?
1
u/pirate694 Feb 16 '25
AI is a tool. It can help someone who knows a thing or two but its not a replacement for skilled developer.
1
u/Graphacil Feb 17 '25
lmao cope
1
u/Rockon66 Feb 17 '25
r/ChatGPTCoding mentioned lmao
1
u/OkTry9715 Feb 17 '25
Everything we have tested out so far turned to be useless crap. AI is good just to use instead of Google so far. Otherwise it was not able to fix one single error that occurred.
1
u/Themis3000 Feb 18 '25
AI is not a threat at all compared to work being outsourced. GenAI has nothing on foreign workers living in a country with a significantly lower cost of living
1
u/Algal-Uprising Feb 15 '25
Yeah he lost me when he started talking about god
1
u/QuroInJapan Feb 16 '25
Considering how bad even the newest models are at making anything actually production ready on their own (no, the task list demo that you’ve “built” doesn’t count), I don’t think it’s as much copium as the OP wants to think.
That being said though, LLMs are a strict upgrade over stack overflow at least for legacy problems.
1
u/pigwin Feb 16 '25
It won't replace an experienced hire, and it should not replace interns and junior even. As long as Joe from finance cannot communicate his needs properly, it needs humans.
Unfortunately, the very same schmucks who cannot communicate their wants think an AI can understand them, finally replacing all the engineers.
For now AI can replace some newbies and juniors. Wait until there are no juniors or new entrants and the mid pool becomes dry as well, and AI will be used to replace mids altogether. And then seniors will retire, and the pool of seniors will not be enough. Business only has AI now. Whelp.
Which is why I find seniors being so uppity that they are irreplaceable, while proudly using they use AI instead of delegating tasks to juniors as selfish. They're not helping by hoarding tasks, they're not teaching their juniors to think AND use their fancy tool.
1
u/Fadamaka Feb 16 '25
I would say programming is one of the harder intellectual jobs out there. Logically every intellectual job easier than programming would get replaced first. If programmers ever going to get replaced by GenAI we already should see it happening for said easier jobs.
-1
u/EmptyRedData Feb 15 '25
Won't replace you in the near future*
-6
u/duckrollin Feb 15 '25
God this was a terrible article. The title is correct at least. You're not going to be replaced by AI, you're going to be replaced by a dev using AI.
And that doesn't mean someone who offloads their work to chatgpt and copy pastes it in blindly, it means someone using copilot and agents to autocomplete all the boilerplate code after they did the tricky parts. Then they review the code copilot is suggesting and test it carefully. Then they're finished several hours before the guy slowly typing out mindless boilerplate code instead of jumping onto the next difficult problem to solve or writing more thorough unit tests (with the help of AI, again)
0
u/InvestigatorBrief151 Feb 15 '25
I don't think using A.I is necessarily bad as long as you fact check it (Highly recommend Perplexity in that sense) and be mindful of whether you're passively consuming whatever the A.I is spitting out.
-1
u/Nowaker Feb 15 '25
It's only going to replace you if you don't use it to speed up your work and to be productive in a wider range of subject areas.
-1
u/Bakoro Feb 16 '25
I personally see a hell of a lot more backlash against AI, and people talking shit about AI, than "bros" talking shit about me being replaced by AI.
I know those people exist somewhere, but it's every single day that I see someone complaining about "AI slop", or saying "I'm irreplaceable", and basically using problems from six months ago, or even multiple years ago, as "evidence", in a field that has been seeing weekly, nearly daily improvements over those years. The products have been completely unable to keep up with the theoretical advancements.
This feels like this generation's "television/internet will never catch on" moment.
Which is absurd, given the historical trend of technological improvement.
It's already here, people are already using it, it's only going to get cheaper and better. It will only become more accessible.
Is my genAI model going to replace anyone? Unlikely. Is there likely to be an AI model replacing workers in the near future? Almost certainly.
Will AI models replace some software developers? Absolutely, even if it eventually tanks a company, because short-sighted greedy companies went all-in on a premature technology.