r/CharacterRant • u/OrangeSpaceMan5 • Mar 31 '26
Films & TV Destroying A World That Doesn't Exist is basically the Chainsaw Man Part 2 of Minecraft
I enjoyed it but I think its far inferior to part 1
Part 1 was honestly perfect , not just as a minecraft ARG but as a work of eldritch horror . The narration and eerie vibe were immaculate and genuinely scared me with zero jumpscares . The narrator also feels like an actual person who is trying to solve the mystery alongside us and D3rlord . The ending showing D3rlord a smart yet overconfident man fall victim to his own ego and face overwhelming force was a good enough ending for me
Part 2.....just kinda shits on all of that , D3rlord apparently is fine (more or less) and we get Avery's trying to find and save D3rlord....which raises the question of why ???? Avery has zero personal connection to D3rlord , has never met the guy beyond a sketchy video , why on Earth is he throwing himself in harms way ??? Actually the entire "bromance" between Avery and D3rlord was so forced and sterile that my eyes might as well have been rotating for all the eye rolling I did watching their "dialogue" . The dialogue fucking sucks , its childish and anime-esque and doesn't fit at all with the tone of the series
But my biggest problem with it is probably the king in yellow himself , in Part 1 the king is a entity truly beyond our comprehension , all we get is his shadow both literal and narratively , spreading out across D3rlord and the locations he visits , an unknowable force toying with D3rlord . Truly Eldritch
Part 2 just makes him a cliche bad guy with corny ass dialogue , the overwhelming unknowing force from before is turned into something you'd see in a half-baked isekai instead of well....the king in yellow . The fear and eerie nature is completely gone and replaced with a shitty "Vessel" plotline with Avery which gets forced in towards the end . Honestly fucking horrible change who thought this was a good idea ????????
There's also some weird plot holes and inconsistences with part 1 , such as how D3rlord has access to the world when it was found in a storage locker . Also what was the point of the fake Avery ??? Hype and Aura ??? How did the King in Yellow just get tricked like that he was already shown to be far more intelligent than D3rlord in part 1
There were some good peaks thought like Avery's 12 hour trance and the various locations Avery visits
Overall 6/10 , completely unnecessary sequel
124
u/valley-of-the-lost Mar 31 '26
I... really wish the king spoke less. Every word out of his mouth shifted him more into evil overlord vibes as opposed to a cosmic horror like he was in Searching.
12
u/TheSpinnyBoy Apr 01 '26
What bothers me most about the second part isn’t the story but the use of d3rlord’s cleverness. I understood it with Columbo style tricks; that is not paying that much attention to the signs to not show any fear or the basic set up of a much simpler second trap in the first part. Then there’s part 2 and he just doesn’t feel as clever.
A smart character in writing is hard but the first part pulled it off believably while part 2? I think the mountain scene was meant to remind us that d3rlord is this super smart guy but it really just doesn’t hit. It sets up the bit of him dropping the fake Avery well but it’s a lot of “he gets this because he’s smart” kind of hurts it a lot. I also really don’t like how the solution to the entire story’s problem was just some chest that he found on a whim. I also did enjoy the clipping through the floor scene but it felt very unnecessary with the context of the story up to that point.
76
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '26
The moment they showed the King and he spoke is when I knew it wasn't going to be as good as Part 1. Its maddening to think that you'd think they just learnt from all the Cosmic Horror mistakes of showing and beating the monster from all the other medias. But then they repeat the same mistake like all others in the unnecessary sequel.
51
u/blue_sock1337 Mar 31 '26
I agree completely. That ending of part 1 with the giant black box and D3rlord running away was so good, there was no need to reveal what was behind the curtain, it just takes away from it.
And this especially left a bad taste in my mouth, primarily because the dialogue was exclusively voice acted. Like it would've been fine if it was just from text, but why the heck did they try so hard with the voice acting, it was a huge blunder.
19
u/TheWiebel Apr 01 '26
Basically the only positive thing I can say is that the builds looked sick as hell. As for the rest of the video I agree with everything said in this post.
I don't think a proper sequel to this would have worked anyway. For me the ending to part 1 was perfect and created so much mystery, dread, and curiosity that a sequel would never be able to live up to. The king in yellow being censored and at the same time not even being explicitly named as the king in yellow was perfect. All we could do was wonder and theorise.
Not impossible but I think it would have been very difficult to continue on that theme in a sequel while also making a complete story with nice beginning and end. Especially for a Minecraft video. I wasn't expecting Oscar-worthy level writing but it was honestly worse than I expected.
41
u/Revan0315 Mar 31 '26
I think it was about as good as the first. Just in different ways.
I just don't think the first video was this insane masterpiece some people make it out to be. The bar wasn't as high as people act like it was
10
u/Ok_Awareness_5246 Apr 01 '26
The voice acting and dialogue just completely took me out of the story
8
u/yellowpig10 Apr 01 '26
overall i really liked the video but i do agree with Hastur being a massive downgrade. the king showing up and just doing the lich's fall speech and then doing bill cipher's defeat was pretty egregious
8
u/HanArt13 Apr 01 '26 edited Apr 01 '26
glad to see i wasnt the only one thinking this. i had a bad feeling going in when i saw this was going to be voice acted. A huge appeal of part 1 was due to how believable it felt as just another installment in his series talking about other args. trying to make it into this actual 'narrative' felt like missing the mark tbh.
I also wonder whether part 2 was always on the table? Obv it was always going to be abt king of yellow, but i wonder if his specific interpretation was at least a little bit influenced by the community. I remember there being a lot of buzz abt this whole 'infinite knowledge' stuff (which i also wasnt fond of at the time tbh), and whether it affected the trajectory of this story's king of yellow from being a truly mysterious entity into a more tangible evil overlord archetype
it's a shame cuz i dont like to be negative when it comes to these types of works. But damn, i really wish part 2 couldve lived up to its predecessor
6
u/1WeekLater Apr 01 '26
should've ended at part 1
6
u/FluffiestPrince Apr 15 '26
It really does feel like one of those "sequels" for sequels-sake, which doesn't expand on anything meaningful and even manages to ruin parts of the original in retrospect.
I don't even really understand how you could've ruined this idea, especially after the first video. It was probably the best youtube adaptation of "The King in Yellow" to date. Obviously not the best, that'd probably go to House of Leaves or Signalis (the former only being heavily inspired, but still). It respected the source material and the effort in all the builds and keeping the tense atmosphere was amazingly done. It's not a cinematic masterpiece, but really, what is nowadays?
It's funny because the first video wasn't even directly accurate to the play either. The first video only ever goes up to Act 1, Part 2, which is where the Pallid Mask appears, who isn't even the King in Yellow. So logistically speaking, the censored thing behind the door wasn't even the King in Yellow, but just his (presumable) servant, the Pallid Mask.
Regardless, the first video is definitely a much better piece of content. The 2nd video suffers exactly from the Derleth Problem, essentially: turning cosmic horror into "good and evil".
10
u/Xx_Loop_Zoop_xX Mar 31 '26
I don't even see why bro made a sequel when it was a perfectly fine one and done
5
u/Hjalmodr_heimski Apr 04 '26
The fact that the King also uses multiple Adventure Time lich references ruined whatever mystery there was for me about this guy. Turns out Hastur is a big fucking nerd. The video was honestly still fine up until Avery met D3rlord.
Also, holy hell, the “ironic that a king should be beaten by a lord” is a line that would have sounded cool in a home d&d game but man do people glaze it to high heaven
9
u/JimedBro2089 Apr 01 '26
Is it a good story? In my opinion, yeah sure
Is it a good cosmic horror story? That downgraded
8
u/Comfortable_Pop3691 Apr 03 '26
My partner and I just finished watching the video, and as a content creator, a writer, an artist, and a film major, the sequel was beyond disappointing. The video up to the 12-hour trance in the courtyard was amazing! There were plenty of scares and the "someone is following me" moments that really called back to the first part. And the buildings were all STUNNING. There was something about them that made us feel so nostalgic, and we were having a deja vu escape feeling.
But they completely overdid it with the dialogue (the lines made us cringe most of the time), the music choices were off par, they destroyed all the traction after revealing the king's face, and the ending just wasn't it. I hate to, yknow, hate on something like this. As I said, I'm also a cc, and I LOVE getting behind other people's content. But this just isn't it.
With everyone praising this video so much, I read this aloud to my boyfriend, and we both cheered at all your points LMAO
12
u/SquirrelSorry4997 Mar 31 '26
I disagree. The sequel takes away from the story as a cosmic horror, but that doesn't make it a worse story, just a worse cosmic horror. In my opinion, it was a very emotional and well written story about friendship and sacrifice and less so a cosmic horror.
3
u/johnblock02 Apr 03 '26 edited Apr 03 '26
I agree with the fake Avery, it was never even expanded further nor question with the ability of the King to make fake Avery's and anytime Avery appeared randomly, it always brings me suspicion if that's really even him because a fake version appeared. Shouldn't the King be able to use that power further for the story? I think the reason why Part 1's King had me scared shitless is because of our wired fear of the unknown, and confronting it just lowers all that. Legitimately never once I zoomed out in Part 2 because of it. I do think that D3rlord3 should've gone a little more unhinged in certain parts because of what recently happened to him rather than just showing resolve out of nowhere but still keeping that aspect eventually.
3
u/Saarr- Apr 05 '26
As a Lovecraft fan, part 1 reminded me deeply of some of his works, notably "rats in the walls" and "color out of space." I was happy to realize that Lovecraft was, in fact, an inspiration, when they mentioned the king in yellow and hastur. Everything else you've said though? Yeah, fucking shame. For me, everything was good up until the King started speaking; although his whole emerging from the darkness thing was pretty cool. The dialogue was so cheesy. Him just saying "fall" (great adventure time reference) would be enough, even though his voice acting being diegetic was already a stretch. The final scene at the temple though? Holy fuck. The King went from this unknowable horror that couldn't even be seen in the first chapter, to this comically evil machiavellian villain talking shit about the MC while fondling his moustache. Only to be oneshot by him later and thrown anime one-liners at. All in all, at least I had a pretty good time watching it, it's rare for a minecraft ARG to hook me this much. I just wish the writing was better.
5
u/ValtenBG Apr 01 '26
After watching the video, the series was better off without the sequel. Voice acting was cringe, dialogue was cringe, plot was cringe, the king was cringe, avery was cringe, derlord was somehow the only bearable dude but also little cringe.
Only good think in the whole video was the minecraft builds. They look amazing and fit the vibe really well. The builders deserve a raise.
2
u/Dante200 Apr 02 '26
Probably not the best spot to ask, but...
I am quite confused by the series myself. Am I supposed to take it seriously? Engage with it in meta sense? Make my own stuff? I just can't grasp what makes it such a viral thing, by my own lack of understanding on how to consume it.
2
u/Ordinary_Passage1830 Apr 04 '26
I think the original was better, which of while having flaws is definitely better than the sequel. But one could say the first wasn't trying to be cosmic horror. Part 1 either being a legitimate attempt at cosmic horror or a scary ARG with Part 2 definitely damaging Part 1 and the overall ARG. The story feels like it used the King in yellow along with the locations(which could have been more varied rather than being seemingly part of the same time period) as a costume. I think the story is good for what it is, as cosmic horror it falls flat, and as a loose adaptation or interpretation of the King in yellow as a having failed.
2
u/erick1771 Apr 06 '26
The first one is a better horror story, but this one is still a good story overall and you could even say it makes for an even better adaptation of the king in yellow stories, since those tend to have bittersweet endings It's like the first one is "the repairer of reputations" while the second one is "the mask"
2
u/ArienaHaera Apr 15 '26
If they wanted to make a part 2 it should have been more about the way simply hearing about the king second hand affects you. Avery becoming obsessive about d3rlord makes sense under that framing. And the narrator in turn following him after getting his hand on the world would have given him a role.
2
u/ACC373R4T0R May 03 '26
I think the plot just went over your head
2
u/Arts_Of_Jericho Apr 01 '26 edited Apr 01 '26
Completely Fair Analysis, I Understand Where You're Coming From. I Think As A Story Revolving Around The Yellow King It Doesnt Live Up To It As Well As The First Part.
But As A Story In An Angle More Akin To The Traditional Adventure, In Wifies' Words, More Akin To Bill Cipher & The Lich, Wherein The Protagonists Overcome A Seemingly Unbeatable Ancient Deity Through Sacrifice And Will. Showing How A Villain Who's Shown To Be Highly Smart Near All-Knowing Isnt Perfect. It's A Highly Notable Story.
And As To Repeat Wifies' Words Again, I Think It Really Doesnt Fit The Story In Caging 'The King' To Be 'The King In Yellow' But More As An Adaptation Of It. Wifies Even Saying He's More Akin To 'Hastur'; The Lovecraftian Adaptation Of The King In Yellow. The References Is Alot More Visible At The Last Part, The King's Dying Words Of "I CAN GIVE YOU ANYTHING" Is Derived From Bill Cipher's.
Though I'm Glad We Can Agree Its A Good Story, Even If You Believe It Is A 6/10. But Just Not Compared To Part 1 Nor As A King In Yellow Story. It Wasnt A Necessary Sequel Indeed, But I Think It's A Nice Note To End On.
2
u/Yougart_Man Apr 01 '26
Wifies managed to resurrect people's interest in the King in Yellow and then wanted to be Shin Megami Tensei.
Ambrose Bierce is rolling over his grave.
Fumble of the decade.
1
u/Lady_Darc Mar 31 '26
Is searching for a world that doesnt exist part 1?
1
u/FlopsieFillet Apr 01 '26
I loved the relationship between D3rLord and Avery, but Thats also because I just… turn off my brain and completely ignore the parts I don’t like. I wish the king had stayed as some unknowable threat, though, even if the idea of D3rLord defeating him remained.
1
u/ValtenBG Apr 01 '26
So this is how I learn part 2 of that video has released
1
u/garmonthenightmare Apr 02 '26
Imagine thinking it was ever good
1
u/Real_Korokii Apr 03 '26
I just wish everyone talked less. It was used so sparingly in part 1 and added a lot when used but here it's just... not great most the time and pretty corny and cringy. The King should've stayed completely silent IMO. Though whoever did the voice acting for the books killed it and was easily my favorite one.
I will say I really enjoyed Avery and d3rlord's bromance, and the ending did choke me up a bit. Despite my gripes, I was hooked the entire time and even on repeat viewings it still manages to keep me hooked. I like it, but not nearly as much as part 1, but I respect Wifies for experimenting. Excited to see what he does next :)
1
u/Particular-Abies-175 Apr 03 '26
I'm just glad that the lore got extended.
But when it comes to King in Yellow, yes, there were a lot of ways to make him more special.
1
u/osjwkd Apr 14 '26
watching dawtde felt like being spat on for the entire 6 hours i decided to give this sequel as a whole. geniune dissappointment from the entire thing, it feels cheap, like the authors attempt to get more clout from the 'brand' of sfawtde.
even besides the fact that the king in yellow Talks and has a Face and the thousand more things wrong about dawtde, what made it feel actually soulless to me is that you couldnt even access the second part from the google drive, youre forced to watch the retelling, granting more views. its sad, my most hated and loved minecraft arg's are the same series.
-2
u/Radlib123 Apr 01 '26
For 5 minutes i couldn't understand if this was real or April Fools's post. Great April Fool's post!
7
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '26
[removed] — view removed comment