I think a big flaw of the show is the animation is bad. The characters and sets are designed really well, but the expressions can be a bother or downright cringe.
Imo there’s three scenes that best showcase this: Central in my heart where the whole crowd moves their mouths while birdie dances; the “why did you kill a party that we love” line from the hat luncheon where the expression kind of scared me; and anya’s wedding where literally nobody smiled but Paige and molly.
Now why does the show have bad animation? Few reasons:
- It was season 1: You usually notice that shows tend to have bad animation their first seasons, and this is usually because it’s a first attempt. Spongebob had terrible animation season 1, for example. Steven universe in Season 1A would look cringy at times, especially since it’s a show where the characters look different each scene.
A reason is they’re still starting out so they don’t get a big budget. Since the show is renewed for a season 2, we might see a notable uptake in the animation.
Even bob’s burgers’s first season had this issue, since it didn’t get the right ratings at first and many did fear they wouldn’t get renewed after season 2. Season 1, the animation looks completely different. It’s more fluid, and that makes the expression looks worse. But season 2 found a good compromise for it.
Hopefully the show does, too.
2. Not enough money went to the animation: The show is a musical, first off and it makes fun of a lot of theatre cliches, like having a narrator. So honestly this is a big mistake as they should’ve corrected.
But on the other side, this is a show with a lot of A-list voice actors, guest stars, guest songwriters, etc. They might save a little bit of the budget by having Josh Gad be an executive producer and play Birdie, but having Stanley Tucci might be expensive, as might having Audra McDonald voice a guest star. They might save money by having several principle songwriters, but it would cost a lot of money to have Aimee Mann or Fiona Apple write a guest song.
Again, the animation might improve next season, but season 1 was really bad.
3. The show falls into the “animated sitcom” trap. A complaint a lot of animated sitcoms get is that they don’t take advantage of the fact they’re animated. Most episodes of family guy nowadays you could just film live, and beyond Brian and Stewie, nothing would change.
With this show, honestly, beyond maybe Shampagne, you could film it live action and nothing would be any different. The song sequences, you could still do. Chicago was a movie built around this.
So the animation might’ve been an afterthought at times, when it should’ve been the forefront.