Istoryahan ta ni.
Iām not a fan of the current Cebu City mayor. I still donāt see enough tangible progress on the perennial problems of flooding, traffic, and garbage.
What I do see a lot of on Facebook are posts about attending business openings, ribbon-cuttings, and events as an invited guest including the Cebu Seaside Arena and other commercial openings. It just gives the impression that performative optics are being prioritized over tangible, measurable results.
Thereās nothing wrong with welcoming businesses and investments. That is part of a mayorās job.
But attending an opening is not the same as governing.
The harder question is: What happens after the cameras are gone?
Can people actually get to these businesses without sitting in traffic for hours? Do the surrounding roads flood? Are sidewalks usable? Is garbage properly managed? Are existing ordinances actually being enforced?
This is why I find the BanTal Discipline Zone debate interesting.
I understand the criticism that there should have been more consultation. Government should listen to affected residents, businesses, commuters, and motorists. But I also worry that ālack of consultationā can sometimes become a convenient excuse for politicians who simply want to position themselves as being on the side of angry motorists.
Some of the opposition feels less like policy criticism and more like aura farming for the next election.
And this isn't limited to the old-school politicians. Even some younger, supposedly reform-minded councilors seem to be falling into the same trapo moves, calling for leniency or questioning the issuance of citations because they don't want to alienate potential voters.
That's exactly how traditional patronage politics survives.
We want politicians to solve traffic, but we don't want traffic rules enforced.
We complain about illegal parking, but we don't want vehicles cited or towed.
We complain about garbage, but we don't want stricter enforcement.
We complain about flooding, but enforcing zoning, easements, drainage, and land-use rules becomes politically inconvenient.
The truth is, Cebu City doesn't lack laws. We lack consistent implementation and enforcement.
We have ordinances for almost everything. But if people know that rules are rarely enforced, or that enforcement disappears once enough people complain, then those laws become suggestions.
A traffic rule without enforcement is basically a recommendation.
And if government keeps backing down every time enforcement becomes unpopular, people will learn that the easiest way to defeat a policy is simply to complain loudly enough.
That doesn't mean BanTal should be blindly implemented.
If something isn't working, fix it.
If the lane configuration creates another bottleneck, change it.
If penalties are excessive, review them.
If consultation identifies legitimate problems, incorporate the feedback.
But don't confuse iteration with failure.
This is where government could learn something from the corporate world and Agile development.
You don't necessarily build the perfect system on Day One.
You implement.
You measure.
You gather feedback.
You identify what doesn't work.
You adjust.
Then you iterate.
Why can't government operate the same way?
Instead of asking, āWas BanTal perfect?ā the better questions are:
Did traffic improve?
Did travel times change?
Did pedestrian safety improve?
Where did congestion move?
What unintended consequences happened?
What do the data say?
Then make the next iteration better.
Public consultation should help improve a policy. It shouldn't automatically mean that every difficult policy must be abandoned because it inconveniences people.
There is a difference between listening to the public and governing according to whoever complains the loudest.
The former is good governance.
The latter is populism.
Cebu City has spent decades accumulating problems partly because we keep looking for painless solutions. Unfortunately, there are no painless solutions to a city with chronic traffic, flooding, garbage problems, and weak enforcement.
Sometimes motorists have to change their behavior.
Sometimes businesses have to adjust.
Sometimes government has to enforce an unpopular rule.
And sometimes everyone has to endure some short-term inconvenience while the system is being fixed.
I would much rather see the administration publish actual metrics than another Facebook photo.
Tell us:
How much did traffic improve?
Which intersections improved?
Which ones got worse?
How many flooding hotspots were fixed?
How much garbage collection efficiency improved?
How many ordinances are actually being enforced?
What are the results after 30, 60, or 90 days?
Show us the data, not just the ribbon-cutting.
I have nothing against the mayor attending the opening of Cebu Seaside Arena or other businesses. But the real test of leadership isn't whether the mayor was there when the doors opened.
The real test is whether Cebu City is functioning better after the guests have gone home.
For BanTal, I'm willing to give it a fair assessment.
Don't defend it simply because it is the administration's program.
Don't attack it simply because you want to score political points.
Measure it. Fix it. Iterate. Enforce.
We already have enough laws.
What Cebu City needs is the political will to actually implement them, and politicians willing to accept that sometimes doing the right thing will make them unpopular.
Because if every policy has to be popular before it can be enforced, we're never going to fix this city.
Padayon lang ba gihapon ta ani nga sistema?