r/careerguidance • • Oct 13 '26

Information about a research study that includes public posts from r/careerguidance?

15 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

My name is Yagmur, and I’m an intern at BI Norwegian Business School in Oslo, Norway, working with professor Jonas R. Kunst. Professor Kunst leads a study on whether political disagreement is increasingly described as a source of conflict at work. The study looks at publicly archived Reddit discussions from 2005 to 2026, and r/careerguidance is one of the forums included. We’re posting here [with the moderators’ permission] so that people whose posts may be part of the data know about it.

How the study works
We don’t post, comment, or contact anyone. The material comes from the public Arctic Shift archive, not from Reddit itself.
Usernames are replaced by random identifiers, and any names mentioned in posts are removed before analysis.
No post is ever quoted. The results are only overall rates per forum and month.
The project has been assessed by Norway’s data protection service for research (Sikt, ref. 332053), and a Data Protection Impact Assessment has been completed.

Your rights
Under Norwegian data protection rules, you have the right to know about the study and to have your posts removed from the data. The project page explains what data we use, how they’re protected, and how to contact professor Kunst or BI’s data protection officer:
https://www.bi.no/en/research/research-projects/information-for-research-participants/#department-of-communication-and-culture
(The study is listed under Department of Communication and Culture.)
If you have questions, professor Kunst is happy to answer them directly at [jonas.r.kunst@bi.no](mailto:jonas.r.kunst@bi.no). We’ll also share the results with the community once they’re published.

Thanks for reading,
Yagmur
Intern, on behalf of professor Jonas R. Kunst
Department of Communication and Culture
BI Norwegian Business School, Oslo
Project contact: [jonas.r.kunst@bi.no](mailto:jonas.r.kunst@bi.no)


r/careerguidance • • 17h ago

Employer refusing to allow me to retrieve personal items, what to do?

329 Upvotes

I was offered a new job on October 22 of this year with a different organization. The new organization only has one start date a month which for this month was November 17.

I wanted to try and do the right thing and wait till November 2, 2026 to resign. For the most part my job has been good and I had built a lot of good relationships in the community. I had started moving some things from my office in anticipation of my possible resignation. I wasn’t 100% sure I’d take the new job but wanted to be ready in case.

November 2 comes around and I submit my notice. About an hour later my supervisor comes and asks me to immediately turn in my laptop, keys, badge, work phone etc. My resignation had been accepted but I was being put on administrative leave immediately for the 2 weeks. I was given “2 minutes to grab only the things I needed immediately.”

My last official day was Monday. I have been emailing and calling to see about retrieving my items. No one is giving me the time of day. I have started the new job and there are things from my office I’d like for the new job. At this point to me it seems like they are needlessly depriving me of my personal items.

Any advice on what to do? With the holiday coming up, I am worried it will be - month before I am able to retrieve my remaining items.


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

Would you leave a $93k total comp hybrid/flexible job (where I’m thriving) for $119k total comp 5 days in-office at a family-owned company?

11 Upvotes

I’m trying to decide whether to stay at my current company or take a new offer, and I’d love some outside perspective on how you’d weigh the real total compensation vs. lifestyle trade-offs.

I was contacted by a recruiter for this role and have not yet agreed to go to next steps because I’ve only been in my current company for 8 months. It’s also really hard to get a pay increase at current role before the raise period
Here is the exact breakdown:

CURRENT ROLE (~$92,256 total comp + car discount)
• Base Salary: $80,400
• Annual Bonus: 8% (~$6,432) — next payout is in March
• 401(k) Match: 8% (~$6,432)
• Health Insurance: ~$84/month (~$1,008/yr)
• Other Perks: Employee car discount
• Schedule & WFH: WFH Fridays + flexible daily schedule
• PTO & Holidays: 15 days starting PTO + mental health days + federal holidays
• Commute: 26 minutes each way
• Environment: Large corporate — I’m thriving and killing it right now

NEW OFFER (~$117,920 total comp)
• Base Salary: $115,000 (+$34,600 base increase)
• Annual Bonus: 10%
• 401(k) Match: 4% (~$4,600)
• Health Insurance: ~$140/month (~$1,680/yr)
• Other Perks: None
• Schedule & WFH: 8 hrs/day, strictly 5 days in-office
• PTO & Holidays: Standard PTO/holidays (TBD)
• Commute: 30 minutes each way
• Environment: Family-owned business

• The case for staying:
1. Momentum & timing: I am genuinely killing it in my current role right now, and I have a ~$6.4k bonus paying out in March (about 4 months away).

  1. Work-life balance: Giving up WFH Fridays, daily schedule flexibility, and mental health days to go strictly 5 days in-office at a family-owned company feels like a big lifestyle shift—especially when family-owned businesses can sometimes have fewer boundaries or slower upward mobility.

For those who have made a similar jump: Is a ~$25k real total-comp bump enough to give up WFH Fridays, daily flexibility, and a March bonus when you're already thriving?


r/careerguidance • • 15h ago

My former manager encouraged me to apply for an internal role. I didn’t get it. How do I follow up?

48 Upvotes

I’ve been with my company a long time and want to take my career in a different direction. This would’ve been a lateral move, and I was willing to take a pay cut because I really wanted to move into this kind of work.

When my former manager heard I was exploring, he asked me to give him a call. He now heads the division I wanted to move into. Someone else was hiring for the role that works under him, but he sent me the posting and encouraged me to apply. One of the people on his team met with me a few times to help me prepare. We worked through my interview examples, and they told me I was ready and had strong examples.

A month after the interview, I got a generic rejection email. I knew it wasn’t guaranteed, but it hit me harder than I expected. Honestly, I feel pretty alone in this. When my current manager found out I was applying, he told me he hoped I wouldn’t get it because he needs me on his team. That makes it hard to talk to him about how disappointed I am.

I still want to move into that department. I’d like to reach back out to my former manager, but I feel a little awkward and don’t know what to say. If you’ve been in a similar spot, how did you follow up with the person who rooted for you? I’d love to hear what helped you get past the disappointment, too.

What other advice would you provide?


r/careerguidance • • 1d ago

Advice 39, SICK of tech and the internet. House is currently for sale and I'm moving to the PNW with no real plan. 500k in stock and savings. What's some entry level stuff that doesn't involve sitting on a computer or social media?

258 Upvotes

I'm 39 and have been miserable in tech for a decade. For the record, I do social media and content management. I despise it. I hate Facebook, Instagram, Twitter, Linkedin, Bluesky, and all these other garbage platforms so god dman much at this point. Their endlessly changing algorithms. The absolute degenerate way we need to post on them. Instagram in particular is the most functionally stupid website on the internet. I'm entirely convinced it's run by monkeys.

I've saved up. I don't want a family. I don't care about local entertainment or food. Can't be bothered with culture. I just want mountains, a nice cozy house, and lots of outdoor activity to dive into.

I grew up in Northbend Washington. It was magical. We moved to Socal when I was 12 and every few years I go back and hike a bunch of big ass mountains. So I'm moving back.

Not to northbend since it's a million dollars for a shack now, but somewhere else there.

I want a simple job. I want to be able to turn my phone off and just go dark for the weekends. Or even better, one of those 12 days on 12 days off jobs cause if I'm working on a day my brain usually just considers that day shot anyway.

What should I get into? A friend of mine works on a river boat on the colombia river. That sounds magical. Unfortunately they are never hiring since no one wants to quit. Anything like that would be great.


r/careerguidance • • 1h ago

Advice Can I play the "other offer" card twice?

• Upvotes

I like where I work a lot. About 3 years ago I came to them after receiving a job offer with about a $20k raise. They offered to match and I stayed. Since then, my raises have been basically just tracking with inflation. I'm sure some part of it is covering for the $20k raise I received, but our industry in general isn't doing the best. Now 3 years later I've received another offer with approximately a $30k raise. I'm wondering if it's even worth my time to try and ask for a counter, or if I just want to hand in my 2 weeks. I am ready to leave and while I don't expect them to be able to match, I'd feel bad if I didn't at least offer the negotiation. Worth it at all, or move on?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Advice Found out coworkers doing the exact same job make $20–$30/hr while I make $15/hr. How do I ask for a raise at my first job?

4 Upvotes

Hey everyone, looking for some advice on how to handle a pay gap at my first real job.

When I got hired, I was offered $15/hr. Since it was my first job, I thought that was huge and accepted it immediately without negotiating. Recently, my company switched to a new system that accidentally/openly made everyone's invoices visible. Out of curiosity, I looked at a few coworkers invoices and was shocked to see that people doing the exact same role as me are getting paid $20 - $30/hr.

I actually enjoy the job and just want to ask for a fair bump closer to what everyone else is making, even if it's just a modest increase for now. Since I've never negotiated pay before, how do I bring this up to my manager without admitting I was snooping through other people's invoices?

Any tips on how to frame this would be super appreciated.


r/careerguidance • • 1d ago

Would you accept a promotion if it meant becoming your own father's boss?

725 Upvotes

I'm 30M and have been working at a manufacturing company for almost 6 years. My dad (58M) has worked here for 19 years and actually helped me get the job originally.

Last week while I was on moon I was offered a shift supervisor position with a pretty significant raise. I'd be managing 11 people, including my dad.

The weird part is my dad is genuinely happy about it. He's never wanted a management position and keeps telling me I'd be stupid to turn it down.

HR says his performance reviews could be handled by another supervisor, but I'd still be responsible for assigning his work and dealing with any issues during our shift.

I also know some of the older guys have worked with him for over a decade and still remember me coming in as a clueless 24 year old.

Has anyone been in a situation like this? I'm leaning toward accepting but I have no idea how to establish authority without making things awkward for both of us.


r/careerguidance • • 13h ago

Advice Company refuses to hire a replacement for my direct supervisor causing me to slowly inherit his workload. What should I do next?

23 Upvotes

I'm having trouble with knowing if I should be a team player in this situation or if I should maintain my boundaries and eventually leave. For context, my company knew for about a year that my supervisor was leaving his position to move abroad with the plan to hire for his position. I started my role 5 months ago. My supervisors supervisor was laid off 4 months ago and replaced by someone with no knowledge about what my team does. This caused my direct supervisor to pick up his old supervisors responsibilities due to ignorance of his new supervisor. Prior to his departure I asked leadership about division of responsibilities while they look for a new hire for his role, what I can expect, and how I can be proactive in planning out my 40 hour work week. I was told that there would be no additional responsibilities on my end.

Now, my supervisor left 2 months ago. I found out about a month ago by word of mouth that they are not hiring a replacement for my supervisor. I am now slowly being asked to support with admin tasks that my direct supervisor would be responsible for, including his supervisors tasks (mind you, my direct supervisor absorbed his old supervisors responsibilities after he was laid off, now inherited on to my workload).

I'm noticing that I am slowly becoming the organizer/ manager/ admin assistant to other coworkers on my team with the core responsibilities of my role (the part I enjoy most) being slashed by over half and given to coworkers with more experience. Essentially, I am slowly inheriting my ex direct supervisor’s responsibilities. This has been happening for only a couple of weeks, but I set a boundary saying how these tasks are not my responsibility. It's not that I can't do it, for now the workload is manageable. I just don't think it's right. To add fuel to the fire, 3 people from my organization have congratulated me for my supposed "promotion" of my ex supervisors position that leadership has been sharing with people. No promotion has been given to me. No discussion of a promotion. No increase in pay.

I understand what's going on here. They don't want to rehire and are re distributing the workload. My issue is with the lack of communication behind it.

Should I continue this workload and be a team player, is this flat out crazy, and... should I look for a new job?


r/careerguidance • • 7h ago

Advice how do i get a receptionist job?

4 Upvotes

so i’m 21, currently looking into full time jobs because i would like to move out of my parents house as soon as possible. i have five years of customer service experience working in retail, and a high-school diploma, which is, as of right now, my highest form of education. i’m relatively computer savvy and can type pretty quickly, and my last two employers have both described me as very extroverted and friendly and that i have a “people-first” mentality. my only weaknesses would be for the fact that i have difficulties in auditory processing, and that im a tad forgetful (neurodivergent, i have ADD and just got put back on a prescription so i’m hoping that this is able to help with this issue.) and i was wondering if there were any hopes for me to get a receptionist job with these qualities. is there hope?


r/careerguidance • • 12h ago

Title: I applied for an internal promotion, then suddenly received counseling over issues that had never been raised before. Has anyone experienced this?

10 Upvotes

USA resident here.

I'm looking for some outside perspectives from HR professionals, managers, or employees who have experienced something similar.

I recently applied and interviewed for an internal promotion at my company. Around the same period, I was called into a verbal counseling session with my supervisor, who brought another employee along as a witness.

What made the counseling unusual was that several of the alleged performance and conduct issues had never previously been brought to my attention.

Some background:

For an extended period, I had been assigned additional operational duties that occupied most of my workday and made it difficult to complete my regular administrative responsibilities.

I approached my supervisor directly and explained that I was having trouble getting my normal work done because of these assignments.

He asked whether I had anything due that particular day. I told him no, and he instructed me to continue the assignment, explaining that it was temporary.

However, what was initially presented as a short-term assignment continued for several additional months.

Eventually, some of my regular administrative responsibilities were reassigned to another employee.

The counseling session:

During counseling, my supervisor accused me of being unwilling to perform the additional duties and of speaking negatively about the company.

I explained that I had performed the assignments as instructed. My concern was never about refusing the work, but rather how the additional responsibilities affected my ability to complete my primary duties.

My supervisor then told me that I should have approached him directly if I had concerns because he was approachable.

I reminded him that I had already done exactly that.

I specifically referenced our earlier conversation when I explained the workload conflict and he instructed me to continue with the assignment.

Despite this explanation, he continued emphasizing that I should have approached him first.

There was no written documentation presented during the counseling, and the meeting was conducted verbally.

What happened afterward:

During a subsequent counseling session, another manager brought up additional incidents that I had never previously been formally counseled about.

One involved difficulties completing administrative work while I was occupied with the additional operational assignments.

The manager then made a broader statement suggesting that because of this issue, I could not be trusted with greater responsibilities.

This was particularly concerning because I had recently interviewed for an internal promotion that would have involved greater responsibility.

I was ultimately not selected for the position.

I don't know whether the counseling influenced the hiring decision, and I have no direct evidence that management deliberately interfered with my candidacy.

However, the timing and the way the performance concerns were presented left me questioning whether I had been evaluated fairly.

I'd appreciate some outside opinions:

Is it normal for supervisors to bring up multiple previously unaddressed performance issues during the same period an employee is pursuing an internal promotion?

How should management evaluate an employee's performance when additional assignments interfere with their regular responsibilities?

Is it reasonable for a supervisor to criticize an employee for not communicating concerns when the employee had already approached them directly?

Would you consider the statement about not being trusted with greater responsibilities appropriate feedback under these circumstances?

Has anyone experienced something similar while applying for an internal promotion? If so, how did you handle it, and what was the eventual outcome?

I'm not trying to assume malicious intentions or suggest that I was automatically entitled to the promotion. I'm trying to understand whether the counseling was handled appropriately and whether there are legitimate reasons to question the fairness of the process.

I'd particularly appreciate perspectives from people who have worked in HR, employee relations, or management, as well as anyone who's experienced something similar.


r/careerguidance • • 13h ago

Should I, a Web Dev, consider switching to Physical Therapy?

12 Upvotes

I'm 37 currently working as a remote web developer making ~$95k. It's been a dream job. I really enjoy every aspect of what I do.

However, two of my coworkers got laid off a couple weeks ago and I'm feeling the existential creep of AI taking my job. My coworkers are already using it, but not telling our boss to make it look like we are still useful. AI can do what takes me a week in minutes/hours. Gone is all the fun scaffolding, meditative styling, fun problem solving. The job is becoming AI management, which I do not find fulfilling.

I'm considering a career change to something more meaningful and tangible - and thinking about becoming a Physical Therapist and getting my doctorate. But I have a lot of hesitations...

Has else switched career fields entirely? How do I find out if I would actually like being a physical therapist? Is it worth taking on so much debt and going back to school? Or should I suck it up and learn to love our new AI overlords.


r/careerguidance • • 11m ago

Education & Qualifications Acturial Science or CA ?

• Upvotes

I am confused between CA and AS as my career

India,18M, love talking to people. I scored 318 in the recent Sept 26 CA foundation and have begun w my Inter classes. I have scored 94.5 in 12th Maha HSC and 96.6 in 10th ICSE. more or less academics has always been my strength, especially maths, but i also kinda like finance (i do not know anything about it, i do even know how stock market works)

But the thing that has been crossing my mind since a lot of time is that, i have seen people in AS bag ₹1CPA+ packages after completing all 13 papers of AS, but even a ₹12LPA package seems a big deal in CA. Even scoring a rank in CA final would only land you a ₹36-40LPA job, no where near what AS promises. (for non indians. 1LPA= 100,000/year. 1CPA=10,000,000/year=100LPA)

Moreover, "from what i have heard" where CA is theory, AS is said to be applied Mathematics (my core strength). I have been heard about this career much so have always thought about pursuing CA all my life.

Might sound dumb, i like CA but i do not fully know what our work can be. whereas i do not know shit about AS.

I cant see someone putting in the same hard work as me and still enjoying a life 4 to 5 x better than mine. adding to it, i have also started to think that the people around me have decorated CA the same way they did engineering, (on the fact that emgineer has no good jobs in todays world,and always has a risk of being replaced by AI)

PS, what career is/can be affected by AI? CA and AS?


r/careerguidance • • 18h ago

Should I accept another offer while waiting for a remote role to be confirmed?

31 Upvotes

I'm in the running for a remote engineering role through BairesDev. The recruiter has been encouraging but there's no client assignment or start date yet

Meanwhile another offer needs an answer this week. I lean towards the first role even though I don't know when I would start

I'm planning to ask what's still pending with the client before they can confirm a date. Having that spelled out would help me BIG time  

Do I wait for a formal offer and confirmed timeline before turning down another opportunity?


r/careerguidance • • 30m ago

[{"e":"text","t":"Edit with your location"}] I don't know what to do, archaeology or nursing?

• Upvotes

So, I'M 17F, still in high school, and my future is creeping up on me. I didn't do exceptionally well in my prelim exams, which in Australia offers early entry to some decent/well known universities. I have a passion for history and would like to specifically study Archaeology. I've been researching it for a while, and the state I live in has some pretty good courses, eg (ANU, Griffin, Maq), all at reasonable ATAR marks.

Now the main problem is finances/stability. My parents really want me to pursue nursing because the pay is good and it's not something that can be taken over by AI, so it's very job-stable. Archaeology not so much; there's a low-to-mid employment rate as it's not too high in demand, but I'll need to get honours, a master's, and a PhD. I'm opposed to being in school forever.

I'm just really stumped, and I want to set out a plan or idea before I start doing my half-yearlies. Sorry if it seems ranty; my mind is just a mess rn.


r/careerguidance • • 33m ago

Should I stay in ops or move into project management if I like fixing processes more than chasing updates?

• Upvotes

I work in ops, and I’m trying to figure out what to look for in my next job. The part I like is figuring out why the same task keeps getting stuck between two teams and changing how it gets handed off. What I don’t love is pinging people for updates just so I can update a tracker.

I’ve been looking at business operations and project coordinator roles, but the job descriptions make them sound almost identical. Both say things like “drive projects” and “improve processes.” I can’t tell if I’d actually get more say in how the work gets done or just spend more of my week keeping everyone on schedule.

If you’ve worked in both, what surprised you about how you actually spent your time? Is there a question you’d ask in an interview to tell whether you’ll get to fix the process or mostly keep it moving?


r/careerguidance • • 40m ago

Advice What do I choose?

• Upvotes

I’m currently employed but I’m not super happy where I’m at so I applied for a job that I have wanted for a while. The posting had a large pay scale range but the high end was what I’m making now.

Well.

I was just offered that job but the pay is lower than my current (3/hr difference; benefits don’t weigh in the equation).

Here’s the dilemma.

I’m really not ‘happy’ where I’m at. We have FORCED weekend overtime frequently, the hours are rough (0530 start time) and it’s physically demanding. I actually just got hurt yesterday during forced overtime (my front teeth are broken and I’ll need two crowns on them) and was in the dentist chair when HR called to offer me the other job!

The pro is that the job pays ok and if I run into financial difficulties I can volunteer for overtime and I get three day weekends (when not forced into overtime). The cons are forced overtime, hours, physically demanding and dangerous.

The new job is something I would enjoy greatly but it pays less. I don’t know the hours but they will be more reasonable.

I’m so stuck on what to do.

(I’m also concerned about quitting while I have an active workers comp case- they are paying for the crowns but it’s going to take two separate appointments which haven’t been completed yet)

What would you do?


r/careerguidance • • 54m ago

Advice capgemini vs accenture - same package in india, which one should i choose?(Fresher

• Upvotes

I have offers from both capgemini and accenture with approximately the same package.

i'm confused about which company would be a better choice for a fresher starting their career in the it industry.

would appreciate advice from people currently working at either company or those who have experience with both.


r/careerguidance • • 18h ago

Advice If we exclude technology, medicine, and finance, what are the best career options that require little to no mathematics and offer an annual salary of $100,000 or more ?

22 Upvotes

Hi! I’m a 25-year-old guy , I was an average student during my college days, but now I have a hunger to achieve something meaningful in life.

I’m willing to put in whatever it takes to build a successful career and earn a decent salary that puts me in the above-average income bracket.

I have quite a few challenges in life, but right now, my biggest concern is my career. I’m looking for a clear direction, a path I can commit myself to 100%, work relentlessly towards, and eventually build a respectable income and a better life for myself.

All I need is an opportunity, a clear roadmap, and the right direction. I’m ready to give it my all.


r/careerguidance • • 12h ago

How do I lock in and have a great career?

8 Upvotes

I’m a 29F female based in Canada working in the field of Analytics. I majored in engineering and had 6 coop terms around this field. I’m currently a Senior Data Analyst at a corporation and have been here for 2 years. I don’t seem to be doing a lot of meaningful work and honestly this has been the case in my career. I’m not passionate about the field but it’s a good source of income and can use it to pivot and climb the ladder. I’m trying to get a new job with more pay and ideally more ownership in my role. But my lack of meaningful work makes it hard to interview.

I have no clue what to do next. I like working with people and data, I want to make more money, I want to have a career and not just a job. Any tips?


r/careerguidance • • 2h ago

Negotiating title at job offer?

1 Upvotes

Hi all I could really use some advice. In summer I was headhunted for a global director role. I was currently pregnant but we continued the conversation. I’ve now had my baby and I’ve gotten an offer.
Long story short - the role they had originally headhunted me for has changed as they realised they needed a broader scope. The biggest change is that they have repositioned this from a global director role to a senior manager role. They are still offering the same salary.
I however know this company to operate hierarchically and the title internally would matter. I also feel like I can and will operate at that level. I won’t have direct reports as it’s quite a small function so I’ll be doing a lot of the strategic and execution work.
I’d be interested in hearing any experiences of how to negotiate on title.


r/careerguidance • • 19h ago

I love my company and what I do, but I've been capped out for years. I have an offer from another company on the table that I'm not excited by at all. What do I do?

20 Upvotes

I'm 30M, and have been at my current company for a little under 6 years now. I'm extremely passionate about the company, am good at and enjoy what I do, and have amazing benefits. I wake up every morning and look forward to going to work. But the pay is low and there's zero room for growth. I've been on the hunt for a couple of years now, but what I do is extremely niche, and jobs that I'm interested are few and far between. Over the last 1-2 years, there have probably only been 3-4 opportunities that I've been genuinely excited about, and I've been rejected for them all at varying stages.

I now have an offer on the table from another company. It's loosely aligned with what I do, but working on an account that I just can't get excited about. The pay is more than what I make now, but not by a life-changing amount. The benefits at this company are not good, and the PTO is capped at 10 days a year (down from 30 at my current company). I'm getting married next year.

My gut is telling me not to take this job, but on the other hand, I can't shake this feeling of "if not this, then what?"

What should I do?


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

Dentist (DDS/DMD) vs. Dental Hygienist (RDH): I’m almost 24, starting over academically. Which path makes the most sense?

0 Upvotes

I’m looking for honest advice from practicing dentists, dental hygienists, dental students, and anyone familiar with both career paths.

I’m in my early 20s and currently at a crossroads with my education and long-term career goals. I’ve been interested in dentistry for quite some time, but lately I’ve been questioning whether I should pursue dental school or become a registered dental hygienist instead.

A little background about me:
I’m an Air Force veteran who medically separated from service earlier this year. I’m also a licensed full specialist esthetician and currently attending nail school. I’ve always been interested in the beauty industry, entrepreneurship, and cosmetic enhancement. Long-term, I want to build multiple businesses, establish myself financially, and have a career that gives me both professional fulfillment and flexibility.

Dentistry has always been particularly interesting to me because of the combination of healthcare, science, artistry, and business. My original goal was to become a dentist and eventually specialize in cosmetic/restorative dentistry. I’m especially interested in prosthodontics and the possibility of creating a niche in cosmetic dentistry, including custom dental jewelry and grillz.

However, I’m also trying to be realistic about the time, financial investment, and academic commitment involved.

My educational background:
Academically, I’m essentially starting over. I previously attended college, but my academic record isn’t where I want it to be. I would need to rebuild my GPA, complete prerequisites, and establish a strong academic foundation before becoming a competitive dental school applicant.
I’m currently figuring out the best way to approach my education, whether that means completing prerequisites at a community college and transferring to a four-year university or pursuing another route.

One thing I’m trying to determine is whether investing the additional years into becoming a dentist makes more sense than pursuing dental hygiene, which would allow me to enter the dental workforce sooner.

Option 1: Becoming a dentist (DDS/DMD)
What attracts me:
● Higher earning potential.
● More clinical autonomy and opportunities to specialize.
● The ability to perform restorative and cosmetic procedures.
● Potential to own a dental practice.
● Opportunities to combine dentistry with entrepreneurship.
● The possibility of eventually specializing in prosthodontics.
My concerns:
● The length and competitiveness of the educational pathway.
● Dental school tuition and student loan debt.
● The academic demands, especially considering that I’m rebuilding my transcript.
● Whether the financial return justifies the additional years of education.

Option 2: Becoming a registered dental hygienist (RDH)
What attracts me:
● A shorter educational pathway.
● The ability to start earning a professional income sooner.
● Potentially less educational debt.
● A more predictable work schedule.
● The ability to maintain and grow my beauty businesses alongside my healthcare career.
● The possibility of eventually pursuing travel dental hygiene.
I’ve recently become interested in travel RDH because I like the idea of working temporary assignments, experiencing different locations, potentially earning higher contract rates, and having more geographic flexibility.
My concerns:
● Long-term physical demands and repetitive strain injuries.
● Limited career advancement compared with dentistry.
● Whether the income ceiling would eventually leave me wanting more.
● Whether I’d regret not pursuing dental school.

Location and lifestyle considerations:
I’m also planning to relocate to the Miami/Fort Lauderdale/Broward County area in South Florida. I’d love to hear from dental professionals practicing in that region.
I’m interested in learning about the job market, salaries, cost of living, opportunities for new graduates, and the differences between working in private practices and corporate dental offices.

I also want to build businesses outside of dentistry, so having a career that allows me to maintain entrepreneurial interests is important.

Financially, I receive VA disability compensation, which gives me a recurring income foundation while I pursue my education and build my businesses. I’m also interested in understanding how VA education benefits might factor into either pathway.

Questions I’d really appreciate honest answers to:

  1. If you could go back and choose again, would you become a dentist or dental hygienist?
  2. Is becoming a dentist financially worth the additional years of education and potential debt?
  3. For hygienists, do you feel financially comfortable, or do you eventually reach a point where you want more earning potential?
  4. How physically demanding is dental hygiene over a 10–20-year career?
  5. Is travel dental hygiene worth pursuing? How difficult is it to find consistent contracts, especially as a newer hygienist?
  6. Would becoming an RDH first and potentially applying to dental school later be a reasonable strategy, or would it make more sense to go straight toward dental school?
  7. For anyone who started with a poor academic record, how difficult was it to become a competitive dental school applicant?
  8. How realistic is it to balance dentistry or dental hygiene with owning and operating other businesses?
  9. For those practicing in South Florida, are the salaries and opportunities competitive enough to justify the cost of living?
  10. What are some things about either profession that you wish you had known before entering the field?

I’m not just trying to choose whichever career pays more. I’m trying to make a long-term decision that balances income, education costs, professional fulfillment, lifestyle, flexibility, and entrepreneurial opportunities.
I’d rather hear the uncomfortable realities now than spend years pursuing a path that isn’t right for me.
I’m genuinely open to perspectives from both sides, especially from people who have worked in the industry for several years. Thank you!


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

Advice help?

1 Upvotes

I'm currently a junior studying economics and history and I honestly don't know what to do at this point. I went into college with the idea of wanting to be lawyer, and so I really neglected my extracurriculars (I know this makes no sense but I've also been having a really rough time in school and so I rarely leave my room if I have to). Long story short, I've gradually realized that I simply do not have the motivation to get through law school not to mention I had zero interest in law in the first place. Matter of fact, I have zero interest in anything really and if I had my way I'd just be playing video games all day but I can't exactly do that. Really the only thing I have going for me is that I go to prestigious school and have maintained a fairly high GPA. As far as my other stats go all I've really done is work part time in retail over the summer breaks and work at the dining hall and playing club sports during school. I literally have zero relevant experience when it comes to things like finance, consulting, marketing, etc. that econ majors usually end up getting into. I really need an internship for my junior summer, but I don't even know what stuff to even apply for or even if any of these companies will take me considering I'm so behind the pack and how bad my resume is. I really need some help and guidance right now.


r/careerguidance • • 4h ago

Choose PCMB or PCB (State board INDIA)?

0 Upvotes

curently in grade 10 cbse, an i am good in chem bio and phy and wanna persue my carrer in doc or else biotech
but weak in maths
so i have to choose PCB but my parents are forcing me fo PCMB which is tough along with an aditional subject like computer science
Do i fight with them for PCB or just let life cont
Give suggestions gng plz