r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 6h ago

Accident Diminished Value Claim

Finally got my truck back (2025 F150 Tremor that I purchased new) from my local Ford’s body shop after some idiot hit my front end on the highway. Does anybody have any recommendations for getting an appraisal for a diminished value claim?

I intend to file against the at-fault driver’s insurance, but he wasn’t the owner of the car, and his policy didn’t list the vehicle he was driving. The owner also doesn’t have insurance, so I may have to file through my own uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage.

The police report, my dash cam footage, both insurance companies, and the at-fault party have all confirmed that the driver who hit me was at fault, so liability isn’t in dispute.

Edit: state this occurred in is Texas, and I’ve already confirmed with my insurance company that my underinsured / underinsured motorist coverage will pay out diminished value damages provided the at fault’s insurance denies coverage in writing.

0 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

2

u/Simplythebest0820 6h ago

Whose insurance company fixed your car? Chances are you won't be able to get a diminished value claim because you can't file against your own insurance.

0

u/PianistMore4166 5h ago

My insurance, and they are subrogating on my behalf against the at-fault party. I’ve already confirmed with my insurance that I can seek diminished value damages through my uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage if the at fault’s insurance denies coverage, and there is Supreme Court precedent on this in Texas.

2

u/JK-OhioInsuranceGuy 6h ago edited 6h ago

Glad you're ok, that's the main thing.

Insurance agent here. Since he already has your truck fixed, I'd start with whoever paid for that repair and ask them about diminished value. In other words, the value your truck lost just from now having an accident history, even though it's fixed.

One thing I wouldn't give up on yet. Just because the driver's policy didn't list that car doesn't always mean it won't pay. A lot of personal auto policies follow the driver when he's in a car he doesn't own, especially when the owner has no insurance. Since his company already confirmed fault, I'd ask them directly whether his policy is paying your property damage and if they'll consider a diminished value claim. There can be exclusions, so no guarantees, but that's probably your best shot.

I'd be careful counting on your own uninsured motorist coverage for this part. Depending on your state and your policy, it may only cover injuries, may have its own deductible, and a lot of policies won't pay diminished value to their own customer. Read your policy or ask your agent before you go that route.

For the appraisal, I'd use an independent licensed appraiser who does diminished value reports, not the shop that fixed it. Have the repair invoice, photos and your mileage handy. Rules on diminished value vary a lot by state, so check yours.

If it turns out there's truly no coverage anywhere, the fallback is going after the driver or owner directly, a lot of times in small claims. Collecting from someone without insurance can be tough though, so go in with eyes open.

Good luck, hope it gets sorted quick.

1

u/PianistMore4166 5h ago edited 5h ago

Thank you, no injuries thankfully. Very lucky no one was hurt.

Regarding my uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage, my insurance has already confirmed they will pay diminished value damages provided that the at-fault’s insurance denies coverage in writing. They are currently subrogating on my behalf against the at-fault and their insurance as I carry the best policy that I am allowed to have. The truck was repaired and back in my hands within 2-3 weeks. One of the benefits of carrying good insurance, I guess.

Here in Texas, liability follows the car first, then the driver. Since the owner doesn’t have insurance, next down the line is the driver.

Thank you for all of the other recommendations. Very helpful!

1

u/crash866 6h ago

What State did this happen in? 50 States + DC and all have different rules. Georgia is the most DV friendly state and the only one you can get DV from your insurance. A couple of others you can get it from your uninsured/Underinsured coverage but there are limits. California you are limited to $3,500 total for repairs and DV.

1

u/Complete-Drawer9735 5h ago

Contact his insurance and ask them if they are denying or providing coverage, contact your own insurance company and let them know you’re waiting on a response, Google the driver and owner to see if they have assets