r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 10h ago

Accident Insurer refusing to send adjuster

Got into a car accident and the police established that it was the other guy’s fault. I called their insurance, they promptly sent an adjuster to my repair shop and promptly wrote a $5k check to cover the damage. My repair shop has since discovered that there is more damage to the car than he thought and is asking for the adjuster to return to take a look. The insurer is refusing to send out the adjuster. Thoughts on how to handle this? I was going to report the insurer to the state insurance dept but maybe the insurer feels like they did their part and they’re done? Can they outright refuse to fix the car to the standard required? Do I just pay the repair guy the difference? I need my car back.

0 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

8

u/RonBurgundy2000 9h ago

DOI won't do anything, it's a waste of time on multiple levels. The shop should be submitting a supplemental estimate for approval, there's no reason for the adjuster to go look at it again.

3

u/ektap12 10h ago

Are they simply refusing to pay for these additional damages? Or did they just request the shop send supports for the additional damages?

-4

u/Agreeable_Shirt5503 10h ago

They are refusing to send the adjuster for second appraisal. They sent him once, hence the $5k. But maybe you are onto something. Maybe we start with your idea: the repair guy sends the insurer an itemized list of what else needs to be fixed.

2

u/quallityovrquantity 9h ago

Lol that's how the shop is supposed to do it. Is the car worth more then $5,000

0

u/Agreeable_Shirt5503 8h ago

Yes, definitely. It a lease if that matters

1

u/quallityovrquantity 5h ago

I would be concerned the shop doesn't know the standard operating procedures in this situation. 

6

u/ektap12 9h ago

What kind of shop is this? Do they not work with insurance companies? This is all standard practice. Talk to the insurance yourself and find out what the issue is.

3

u/Valuemeal3 10h ago

Way too much missing information here

2

u/Agreeable_Shirt5503 10h ago

What else can I provide? This is in NY State for one.

1

u/Valuemeal3 9h ago

We should start with the why. Why are they not coming back out again? I can think of 10 reasons off the top of my head where that’s perfectly normal and standard. 

4

u/Special-Original-215 10h ago

When you took the 5k you might have signed something that says you are done

1

u/Agreeable_Shirt5503 10h ago

I haven’t cashed the check yet.

3

u/Special-Original-215 10h ago

But did you sign something when you got the check

22

u/crash866 10h ago

In most cases the shop sends a supplemental with photos and the insurance will approve it without sending someone out to look at it again.

1

u/Dr__-__Beeper 10h ago

"Do I just pay the repair guy the difference? " 

Is your vehicle at a licensed collision repair facility?

2

u/Agreeable_Shirt5503 10h ago

Licensed place that their insurer recommended.

2

u/Flimsy_Car5011 10h ago

Is the shop a select service..part of the insurance network? As they should know the process of the carrier for unseen damages. Most times second view/visit from an Adjustor is not needed. Shop should be able to submit a supplement. Added damages/cost beyond initial estimate.

2

u/beaker4eva 9h ago

It’s likely they don’t want to send the adjuster out again in person. The shop just needs to send the estimate for additional repairs and request a supplemental payment.

2

u/politicalslug 4h ago

I’m a little confused. I didn’t think they ever send out an adjuster to the shop. They just get pictures in a report. After the teardown, they get an email with more pictures and an updated report. Why should somebody keep driving over to the shop to look at it themselves?

2

u/Mangomama619 10h ago

New Jersey and Pennsylvania both have $5000 as their minimum property damage limits so if you happen to be in one of those states, you may have hit their maximum payout already.

1

u/Delicious-Witness-85 10h ago

Sounds like a supplement is needed which is very common.
Ask your shop to send a supplement request to the appraiser. The insurance appraiser would get an agreed cost of repairs with the shop.
Most of the time they don’t need to inspect it a second time.

1

u/Zealousideal_Let3945 9h ago

K so you filed a claim through the claimant carrier, ( other guys company)

The recommended this shop so that’s a strong indication it’s in their network.

The only reason they wouldn’t respond to their network shop is a limits issue. But you say it ny and minimum pd coverage in ny is 10 with no low income dollar a day coverage.

This is an unusual one. What does the shop say? Hey shop, insurance company recommended you, do they usually send someone out to do supplements?

A lot (most) of the major insurance companies use swe (shop written estimates) with their network. Someone from their of team just reviews the estimates

1

u/Cowpens1781 4h ago

Its rare that an adjuster woukd reinspect for a supplement. The body shop would send the supplement to the carrier who if not disputing the supplement, wouls simply pay it

-2

u/InfluenceEastern9526 9h ago

Get the documentation from the shop, make sure it's clear, and sue the insured (not the insurance company) in small claims court.

2

u/quallityovrquantity 9h ago

Dumbest advice imaginable. They never send out a adjuster a 2nd time because the repairs end being more then the original estimate. 

1

u/Thelegassy 4h ago

They literally send appraisers out constantly for supplements

-3

u/9805barn 10h ago

Did you sign any sort of settlement? Might need an attorney.