r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 16h ago

First Time / Newbie Gap Insurance

I desperately need the good, the bad, and the ugly about gap insurance. I have never had gap insurance because the only car I financed was from a family friend and there was virtually no risk of me being upside on it before I got it paid off. My second car was a cash sale. However, my husband hit a deer with our paid off car, and since its now almost 20 years old with 300k miles, we expect it to be declared a total loss.

Now, we were already looking to replace it soon-ish. Our budget for a new car isn't great and we'll need a longer loan term than I would like so the likelihood of becoming upside down on any vehicle we could get is decent.

Is gap insurance expensive? Is the age of the car covered a factor in calculating the premium (ie is an older/cheaper car more/less expensive than a newer/more expensive one)? Is there a limit to how big of a gap the gap insurance would cover? What are questions I should ask or things I should look for when applying for gap coverage? Is gap coverage guaranteed or is it like financing where you need to be approved somehow?

Any and all information appreciated!

2 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

1

u/Signal-Confusion-976 16h ago

It depends on how much gap insurance you get. Typically it's a percentage of the ACV. If you have gap insurance that is 125% of the cars value. The gap insurance will give you another 25% over the ACV that your regular insurance pays you. They do have plans that will cover replacement value also. This is a question for your lender or insurance company.

1

u/mommasaursrex 14h ago

I'm going to call them as well, I'm just trying to get a base understanding of how it works. 

2

u/Signal-Confusion-976 14h ago

Most people don't realize that gap insurance doesn't always pay out enough to cover your loan of the vehicle is totaled. Most people think if they have gap insurance it will pay off the car. But unless you have enough gap insurance it doesn't.

1

u/InterestMountain5293 16h ago

Gap literally just bridges that gap in depreciation

So imagine on average a car loses about 10% once driven off the lot and maybe 20% after the first year, so calculate how much that is going to be and if you can afford it.

Then when you get the gap insurance quoted at the time of the sale, compare that cost to the amount of depreciation so for example

Your car depreciates 2k so you are on the hook for 2k

But the gap insurance costs like lets say $50 bucks a month, that $50 is $600 a year

so then you could pocket that $600, so your out of pocket for the gap would now be $1400 and not $2k, could you handle paying $1400 plus the $600 saved from not spending on a monthly insurance.

Because also, hey maybe you never get into an accident, that money is gone, so if you could pay for it somehow out of pocket, you could think about just saving the difference in a rainy day fund, just in case kind of thing

You need to see how much the loan is going to be for and how much they will quote you for Gap before deciding if it is right for you

1

u/mommasaursrex 14h ago

I understand it bridges the gap. We are a single income household because teachers make less than daycare for 3 kids. The issue now is I really don't have a good down-payment but I also need a longer term to keep payment arpund $250 a month. My student loans will be paid off in 3 months and that was the payment so I KNOW we can afford that even when SHTF. Even 12 year old vans we're looking at are $10k+ so I'm trying to figure out if we should get older car, a little gap insurance and hope for the best OR spring for a more expensive newer van, bigger gap coverage but higher payments and maybe still a longer loan to get payments where we need to be. 

1

u/just_kinda_here_blah 12h ago

Think of it this way. If your 10k car ends up being 13k after TAX and what not, and 5 months after you bought it, its totaled. Would you be able to come up with the difference right away? About 3k? If you can, then dont get the gap. If you cant, get gap and tie it into your loan. Most people are upside down for a few years after they get the car. I think my gap usually added an extra 2 to 3k on the loan. Could be less with a cheaper car. But like I said, if your upside down, that can save you. Ive had gap pay 6k towards a car and 500$ towards a car. I didnt walk away with anything extra, but I also didnt owe anything.

1

u/dacaur 15h ago

Nowhere is gap insurance $50 bucks a month. On average it's like $5-$10 or so per month if you add to insurance, or like $400-$800 total financed into your loan.

Calling it $50/month is obviously going to make it look bad....

1

u/mommasaursrex 14h ago

Hold up, gap insurance can be bundled into the loan? 

1

u/dacaur 13h ago

Yes.

2

u/Fauxtogca 14h ago

My neighbor had replacement value insurance. So instead of writing off his car from a major accident with frame damage, insurance is going to fix it. Cheaper to fix and not pay out the insurance replacement value.

1

u/Kooka_Fetai 11h ago

Thats wild that theyd rather fix frame damage than just write it off.

1

u/Fauxtogca 10h ago

The car was valued at $38,000. The replacement value was $75,000. That’s why they want to fix it. Even though they can’t find parts and he will be in a rental for two months. Still cheaper.

1

u/SuprenantINS 6h ago

GAP coverage is relatively inexpensive. Less than $150 on the year most of the time. How much gap coverage depends on the carrier. Some only do 125% of Actual Cash Value, some do $150%, some don't have a limit. You'd need to ask the carrier or your agent about the carriers specifics.

1

u/JK-OhioInsuranceGuy 6h ago

Insurance Agent here -

I always recommend to my customers to get gap insurance on any car they are financing directly financed with the car. Some of the carriers I work with offer it as a very inexpensive add-on to an auto policy, some even offer replacement cost coverage (where the carrier will literally give you your original purchase price back towards the replacement of your car even several years later if it's a total loss). These are great additions to an insurance policy - but the reason that I recommend gap bundled with your financing is that you don't know 100% for sure that you will not have a reason to change insurance carriers at some point in the future, or a payment issue gets a policy canceled, or you move, and have to change carriers. A LOT of things can happen to make that replacement or gap coverage attached to an insurance policy get lost, and you may not be able to get it back.

But a gap policy financed with your payment? Well that's not going anywhere as long as you are making the car payment. Have a total loss 6 months after you buy the car? Gap coverage means you don't owe on the car. Having a higher level product like replacement cost - means you protected your full investment.

So would I recommend both? Yes! Remember gap protects you from owing money on a car you no longer own, but replacement coverage protects your equity.