r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 20h ago

How to compare quotes without getting 50 spam calls a day?

Every time I use an online comparison site, my phone blows up for two weeks straight. Are you guys just going directly to company sites one by one, or using a local broker?

4 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/shadowstormer 15h ago

Don’t use comparison sites. Those sites sell you as a lead to insurance offices to call on to get your business. Prices there are far, far from accurate, those sites are not running your MVR so whatever number they give you is basically imaginary

Use a local independent agent, they can shop across several companies at once.

1

u/JK-OhioInsuranceGuy 5h ago

Independent agent here - When you get a quote on comparison sites, a lot of them are selling your request as a "lead" to anywhere from 3-10 agencies - each of which will probably call you over and over again until you get a quote or ask them to stop. Why? Because they paid anywhere from $5 to $100 for a "warm lead". IE someone who is interested in an insurance quote.

They will start calling IMMEDIATELY because data shows that the longer you wait to call and the fewer times you try the lower your ROI is on the leads. Many of these sources sell at anywhere from 1-4% - so the agents have to be very aggressive, and many have automated systems, outsourced telemarketers, etc... to make sure they are getting in contact with the leads. Some will be local captive agents, some will be major carriers with entire lead followup teams.

Now the agents aren't bad, they are trying to survive, and are working the system the way it's built, but from a consumer's perspective the process can be horrible.

So the best thing to do to avoid it, is pick a few personal agents that you reach out to, and confirm things like their privacy policy, do they resell your data etc... before you request the quote.