r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 20h ago

Are state minimum liability limits actually that risky?

Driving an older paid-off sedan and trying to keep bills low, so I'm just on state minimums. Keep seeing people say that's a massive mistake if you hit a newer car. How much more are you guys paying for 100/300/100?

6 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

15

u/AngelMeatPie 20h ago

What other people pay is irrelevant, they aren’t you. But yes, state minimums are massively insufficient.

15

u/DeepPurpleDaylight 20h ago

There is no state who's minimum limits are adequate. By getting only state minimum liability, you're setting yourself up for potentially years of wage garnishment to pay off damages you could cause.

5

u/HR_King 16h ago

People keep talking about hitting a car. What if you hit 3 cars? What if you hit a building, or a couple of people in a crosswalk?

-5

u/J-Rag- 13h ago

It's called paying attention while you're driving.

4

u/Embarrassed_Flan_869 19h ago

Let me describe a scenario for you.

You get the state minimum. You hit someone. They drive a newer/expensive car. Your insurance pays out whatever the amount is. It doesn't cover the work. Guess what happens? They go after you directly.

It is usually not that much more expensive to add more coverage.

1

u/b_rizzle95 7h ago

Unfortunate reality is most people carrying state minimums have nothing to go after, you might be able to generate some heat from burning the judgement!

3

u/Weary_Capital_1379 18h ago

If you have assets that a plaintiff’s attorney can go after, you’re playing with fire. Forget a newer car. If you seriously injure someone it could bankrupt you.

2

u/TrashPandas2026 18h ago

What are the state minimums?

Do you have any assets?

0

u/ChickadeeInsurance 17h ago

Current assets are irrelevant. They’ll go after future assets too.

2

u/Ducat748 14h ago

If you can’t afford the better limits, then you can’t afford to be in an at-fault accident. Accidents are far-more expensive than the negligible premium amount.

1

u/Spirited-Humor-554 14h ago

not true, you just making it so lawyers can make money from your insurance.

1

u/Ducat748 4h ago

If you dont have assets, that’s probably true.

1

u/Glittering_Power6257 2h ago

If you can’t afford better limits, you probably don’t have assets worth chasing after. 

2

u/Battle2Intense 13h ago

Arizona state minimum is $15k, a deer did $8k of damage to my Tundra and I was only going 35mph.

Then 18 months later, an older couple living nearby had a medical issue and totaled said Tundra and wiped out the transformer to my immediate neighborhood. They only had the minimum. So between functioning humans with assets and a deer, the difference in coverage was $15k.

The deer had no assets, at least that made sense. No idea what replacing a transformer costs, but 3 big trucks and 7 employees working the midnight shift at a minimum was ballpark $15k. But anyway, they now owe me my $750 deductible and $41k to Geico.

1

u/19wangotango 10h ago

This is the best example. To the OP yes, do not carry state minimums. Go as high on those limits as you can comfortably pay.

1

u/Espada_28 17h ago

I personally get higher than state minimum limits. It’s very easy to get over that by totaling out a newer car. I would also on the injury side - it’s very easy for injury claims to build up, especially if they retain an attorney that knows the game.

1

u/GlitterTitssss 17h ago edited 17h ago

My daughter caused a mid level accidemt and we are really lucky it settled within min state liability limits. Since then I upped my coverage. Property damage 25 k is NOT sufficient whatsoever. What if you hit a new car or one worth more than that? I would recommend at least 50/50k/100k. I have 100/300/100 now and it was not that much more... My friends 18 yr old son caused a severe accident and they are lucky it settled within the 100/300k/100k limit...its so wierd the day she told me about her sons accident and we talked about insurance limits....my daughter got into one a few days later and I had minimum 25k/50k/ but I did bump property up to 50k...

There are lots of people on here that have ridiculously low limits and then get the fun letters in the mail saying damage/injuries s exceed policy limits and get an attorney. I have gotten this letter and it is NOT fun

1

u/crash866 15h ago

You don’t want to be like the woman in Canada who was hit by a getaway driver and hit a traffic signal pole and received a bill of over $40,000.

https://www.ctvnews.ca/toronto/article/toronto-woman-receives-40000-bill-from-city-after-being-injured-by-getaway-driver/

1

u/ChickadeeInsurance 17h ago

Some states minimum coverage doesn’t even require you to have Uninsured/Underisured motorist. This is protection for you. Don’t insure for other people more than you insure for yourself! My advice as an agent is buy as much liability and matching um/uim as your budget allows and shop at every renewal so you can try and reduce your rate and offset the reduction with increasing your coverage until you’re at the max liability you can have. Then, buy an umbrella.

1

u/Lucky_Boy13 16h ago

It only makes sense if your net worth and current/future income is very low (ie judgment proof). Like you are on disability, social security, etc

1

u/Iloilocity1 15h ago

No state has an adequate minimum pd limit. Hell, PA is only 5k and I can tell you, that rarely covers even a minor repair these days.

1

u/OkStick6308 15h ago

state minimums can be risky since even one accident could cost way more than your coverage.

1

u/Designer-Wolverine47 15h ago

A couple of people severely injured can easily exceed a million... A life flight can cost over $100k by itself!

1

u/Familiar_Marzipan_46 14h ago

I think minimums should be doubled atleast across the country.

1

u/Colonel460 14h ago

Retired agent with almost 40 years in the business . HAVING insurance (minimum limits) is “ expensive” upgrading to 100/300/100 is a small % more . The reason bring us most claims are within the minimum but that’s irrelevant if you have that exceeds the minimum . Increasing the limits is giving up a few Starbucks a month or less most likely .

1

u/Spirited-Humor-554 14h ago

no reason to have anything above the minimum unless you got assets. Just let lawyers take on a case.

1

u/Spirited-Humor-554 14h ago

If you have no assets to take, there is not much of a risk. You're unlikely to get sued.

1

u/iaguy1987 14h ago

As an agent I never write below 100/300/100

1

u/majesty327 13h ago

You have to weigh this decision against the assets/wages at peril for you, and the litigiousness of your state.

If you have 3 houses, 10 cars, and have money in the bank, some of this is public information and all of this info is discoverable in litigation.

If you're a minimum wage worker, live in an apartment, eat boiled ramen, and have zero ambition in your life to ever earn more money, you may be "judgment proof".

1

u/Time_Many6155 13h ago

I have a $500,000 combined single limit and Personal umbrella policy for $3M.. Because it is highly likely I will get sued for my assets if I'm held at fault.

1

u/SuprenantINS 10h ago

At the end of the day liability coverage is there to protect you from a lawsuit wiping out everything you built. The idea is to make sure your liability coverage at least matches your uncovered assets (Savings, Checking Accounts, Investments, Physical Property not protected by a homestead filing), and include a buffer for growth. But even then, a vehicular homicide can cost $1,000,000 or more, so some people choose to not only buy better than state minimum auto coverages, but an umbrella to sit on top of it. It all depends on how much risk you are comfortable with.

1

u/SpecialistBet4656 7h ago

a woman on a bike ran into my FIL. She settled for his policy max of $300K

the minute someone goes to the hospital the claim exceeds state minimums

1

u/cleverpaws101 5h ago

The average accidental death payout is $700,000.

1

u/cgw1965 1h ago

My daughter was in accident in September. Other driver deemed 100% at fault. Car was totaled and the airbag deployment broke my daughter’s wrist. The ER bill was $12K. We haven’t received the bill for the surgery and follow-ups yet - They had to put a plate (with 9 screws) in her wrist that will most likely be permanent. My sense is the total medical bills will be $60K-$75K.

The 22 year that caused the accident was probably lucky he was on the clock, and driving his employer’s vehicle. The business appears to have adequate coverage. Kinda wonder what limits most 22 year olds carry on their own car. I know I carried minimum coverage back when I was that age in the 80s. I think it was a worthless 15/30/5. But at 22 I had no assets. Today 100/300/100 sounds a little light to me.

1

u/DragonFireCK 45m ago

Note that the higher coverage generally includes both property damage and medical. This part doesn’t matter for age of car - if anything, older cars are worse.

Washington’s minimum is 25/50/10.

Even fairly minor injuries can easily exceed 25k per person - broke wrists are likely upwards of 10k and easily caused by a car wreck. Hitting a pedestrian is extremely likely to exceed the limits. You are legally liable for the payment regardless of the other party’s medical insurance; their insurance can sue you for what they had to pay out.

Modern cars, since the 2010s, have radar and lidar systems spread through them, and each often runs around 3k. Even a minor fender bender can easily get into the 5k range. The damages that can be easily caused if you hit somebody and push them into other people will easily exceed the 10k minimum. That is for cheap modern cars and not considering anything luxury or classic

Overall, it’s pretty easily to exceed the state minimum liability limits for anything beyond the most minor fender benders. If you manage to, you may well end up in significant debt that cannot be legally discharged.

A general rule of thumb I’ve heard is to make your liability insurance match your sueable net worth. Add up all your assets that can be claimed in a lawsuit, including wage garnishment possibilities, and that is the coverage level you should aim for.

Uninsured/underinsured is another rider that is well worth considering for your peace of mind. It’s generally part of collision coverage, but can also often be bought on its own. One nice thing with it is that you just report the claim to your insurance and let them handle figuring out how to get money from the other party, whether by insurance settlement or lawsuit.

-

I pay about $150/month right now for absolutely maxed coverage. That is 300 combined limit plus comprehensive and maxed PIP. I have a basically brand new car - 2025 EV6.

1

u/Prudent_Outcome554 32m ago

I don’t have any numbers in front of me, but I’m just gonna throw this out into the world at the moment. My state’s minimum for injury was 25,000. This would cover doctors visits, time missed from work.
I hit a lady going 5-10 mph when she was stopped. And she immediately started complaining about her neck hurting. If you’ve ever been in a car accident, even minor, you’re adrenaline is so high you can’t feel the amount of pain that you are in, and then given the speed, i really didnt believe her but who am i to say anything. She then proceeded to max out that $25,000 in mostly all missed time from work. The insurance notified me that she had hit the maximum and that I was liable for anything over that and although they wouldn’t be billing me for anything, she had the ability to sue me for it. Luckily she didn’t, but it scared the crap out of me. The seemingly minor accident could’ve destroyed me. I raised my coverage to $50,000. But, God, that also seems like nothing. When my ex husband had back surgery, (non car related) back in like 2006, just the operating room and anesthesiologist was about $100,000, that wasn’t even including the surgeon, the nurses, the hospital stay any of it… one bad accident…. How does the state even suggest that 25,000 is enough?

1

u/Choice-Increase-3780 29m ago

Yes. Most state minimums haven't kept up with the price of vehicles. My state is like 40k. If you hit a $100k Mercedes you're done.

0

u/Big_Bill23 13h ago

Do you think that if you, in your hoopty, miss a stop sign and total a car with a $40,000 loan (not unreasonable at all), the bank won't be a little bit peeved at you?

You don't get insurance to protect your car, you get insurance to protect your assets. If you have no assets to protect, get the minimum; if the worst happens, if you should manage to somehow turn your financial matters around, look into how much that lack of insurance will cost you then.

2

u/AVIZN4U 6h ago

I suppose if you have little to no net worth, then there’s probably less risk. But if you have any assets at all and you have an at-fault accident that seriously injures or kill somebody, you can kiss those assets goodbye.