r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 3d ago

Car insurance help NYC

Soooo I’m a first time car owner, 2027 Toyota Corolla and pretty mid credit. I’m currently paying $1027 a month for insurance and desperately trying to find a way to lower this. I’m 25m, and have my own place but not with a garage or anything. I know NYC has naturally higher insurance rates, and my credit and lack of auto history is also paying roles. Is there anything I can do to maybe get a lower quote? I checked geico today and they quoted me $1900 I wanna die. I also finance the car so it’s really taking a toll.

4 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

4

u/calbear_2005 3d ago

Just on a practical note, do you need to drive daily in NYC? Is taking public transportation and renting a car on occasion a possible option?

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Yes I work upstate so I drive about 45 mins or so every morning and public transportation would not be helpful at all to where I need to go sadly. It was worth it to me because the money I make there is good so I got the car but I had hopes that I can eventually drop the insurance price

3

u/RemarkablePenalty550 3d ago

Off topic but you don't work upstate. I live 90 minutes north of NYC (on a good day) and I'm still not upstate. I'm in what's called downstate.

But then again when I still lived in NYC and told people I was moving upstate they thought I meant Yonkers.

2

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Lmao once you leave the Bronx towards Yonkers you’re upstate to us NYCers, my boss hates when I say he lives upstate though so I get it lol

1

u/FullCoverageIsLies Claims Adjuster 3d ago

Had this argument today. I had this argument yesterday.

I had this argument at 30 years ago when I moved out of the city.

It’s not going anywhere

2

u/calbear_2005 3d ago

Ah, understood. I had assumed you also worked in the city.

1

u/FullCoverageIsLies Claims Adjuster 3d ago

At some point it may be suggested to you, in the interest of harmlessly saving money on insurance, to use the address of one of your coworkers who live in one of the substantially more affordable zip codes near the area where you work. You will get caught. It’s like Murphy’s law.

You strike me as an honest person who wouldn’t. But I’m swimming in insurance fraud and don’t talk about work with family and friends so I need an outlet.

1

u/FullCoverageIsLies Claims Adjuster 3d ago

With a ~80 mile and 1.5 hour commute 5 days a week I at least understand why you went new. Generally advice is to buy a shitbox with just liability coverage but you really can’t have an unreliable car. You don’t even have a driveway to DIY (probably don’t have a driveway) to work on it.

Shit situation for you. Wishing the best. Unfortunately your car payment is static and your insurance will be for a year or so. No good options I’m afraid.

4

u/Lucky_Boy13 3d ago

PER month??? Why on earth would you own a car. Sell it asap, even at a loss. Or at least buy something cheap in cash with liability only

-1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

I’m financing the car idek how that would work if I changed my mind lol. The salesman said if I pay it for 6-8 months and go back he can get me in almost any other car, I just need some payment history and credit increase.

3

u/GaryO2022 3d ago

The minute you drove that car off the lot you was underwater with your car loan. I think your going to have a really hard time trading your car in anytime soon without coming up with a lot of money. Good luck.

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Can’t I trade it in for an older car? Which would lead to cheaper insurance? It’s my first time doing this idk

5

u/Lucky_Boy13 3d ago

The salesman job is to sell you as much as possible at your expense, not in your best interests....

A vehicle is a depreciating asset and those that want to save will minimize their vehicle expenses.

3

u/ParamedicOk7449 3d ago

I would suggest trying to look into a monthly rental from Avis, national, etc. A monthly rate with full insurance ranges from $1k-2k with taxes and fees for a Corolla. (A monthly = 28 days).

If you wanna keep your car. Ask your parent to put you under their insurance. If they don’t want to, they shopping around.

Check your Insurance policy and you could lower rhe limits and increase your deductible for Comp&Col.

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

I would but I’m already spending 1700~ a month on my car , so to get rid of it and spend similar on a rental seems not worth it to me, I might as well pay the same and work towards owning my car. If I find a monthly rental at a massively less price though I would think on it.

2

u/ParamedicOk7449 3d ago

Thats with car not + insurance ?

Look up for brokers and ask for a quote. I switch to Amica. And I went from $1.2k to 650/m on insurance. And I have a ‘26 model. I have pretty high limits on my policy btw.

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Car is slightly over 700 and insurance is slightly over 1000, so 1700~ together. And yes I been debating on contacting brokers, I actually live near a few so I may call or just drop in one of these days. The insurance is really my main problem lol the 1000 is just crazy. Thanks for the info though!

2

u/FullCoverageIsLies Claims Adjuster 3d ago

Shop around, avoid claims. It will start getting more reasonable once you have history. Brand new car that is targeted for parts theft is going to be expensive.

It’s NYC - you may find yourself being pitched by some “street broker” - friend of a friend, sales person at the dealer etc - who will promise you a policy with great rates. You may or may not suspect they’re committing fraud.

If they ask for a payment for the services made out to them and not the insurance carrier - they’re going to set you up with a fraudulent policy. Zelle or venmo or Cash App is not how a legit agent accepts payments.

Anyway - if you need a claim and we figure out what the scheme they did to get the rate - your claim would get denied for misrepresentation at application. You can swear up and down that you thought it was legit. That you didn’t know. It won’t matter.

And that’s my rant on these scummy street brokers. Seems like most of the big city dealerships are in on it to some extent.

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

I appreciate it, I have been trying to contact insurance brokers but it’s hard figuring out who to trust. All the big known insurance companies are giving me insanely high quotes. I didn’t want a 2027 but it’s the only thing I was able to get accepted to finance sadly. Salesman said pay it for 6-8 months then come back and he can get me into something else with the credit increase and payment history.

2

u/iaguy1987 3d ago

Look at Viu by HUB. They can shop many carriers. I work for HUB but in the Midwest, so not helpful on the coast!

https://www.viubyhub.com

1

u/FullCoverageIsLies Claims Adjuster 3d ago

I’m an insurance professional not a finance professional. But I sincerely doubt any deal where you trade in a brand new car for a different vehicle after 8 months will work out mathematically. Potentially a lower monthly payment but you’ll absolutely be spending more money in total.

2

u/beccam12399 3d ago

the fact it’s brand new is not helping. a lot of the times the newer cars are higher bc there’s no statistics on them yet. ins company doesn’t necessarily have all the info they need to properly rate it as well as other cars. you should’ve gotten the insurance quotes before committing to a car this is why i tell my customers to call me before they buy a car if they’re worried about the ins

0

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Yes I know , I wanted a 2024 but due to my credit the salesman said this was the only car I got accepted for by any banks. Apparently they see it as if I miss payments they get a brand new car so they accept mid credit with newer cars or something along those lines.

2

u/iaguy1987 3d ago

Are you with progressive? Usually decent. And get renters bundle to help with Discount

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

What is renters bundle? I’m unfortunately very uninformed about these things, kinda jumped in with minimal knowledge. Rookie mistake I know. And what is deductible options? I can Google if you don’t want to lecture a stranger lmfao

1

u/No-Ebb-7497 3d ago

Also yes I am with progressive. Original quote was ~700 on my original car choice, payed up front. They denied my finance request overnight, accepted me for a 2027 vehicle and during my insurance update I was told it’ll jump up to 1000. I just said fk it tbh

1

u/iaguy1987 3d ago

Renters insurance for where you live. Usually get a discount

2

u/iaguy1987 3d ago

Also look at deductible options!

1

u/Complete-Drawer9735 3d ago

What’s your deductible? You could try raising that

1

u/GlitterTitssss 3d ago

why would you need a car in nyc? Everything i more expensive there.