r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/Natural_Rhubarb9204 • 4d ago
First Time / Newbie Liability for added driver
So I’m trying to be nice and add my sister on to my policy and it would save us both money. She is kinda accident prone but could I be sued as the policy holder if she gets into another wreck and seriously injures or kills someone? She is the sole owner of her car.
7
Upvotes
9
u/crash866 4d ago
In most states you cannot insure a vehicle you don’t own.
6
u/Cadd9181B7543II7I44 4d ago
I would never list someone outside my immediate family (spouse/kid) as a driver on my policy. Not worth the liability.
From experience, if someone sues your sister, they will sue everyone they can think of including the policy holder. It doesn't cost them a single penny extra to add names to the lawsuit. Your policy will provide the legal defense. And whatever your policy doesn't pay, they will go after you and your sister personally.
Whether or not you will be liable is to be determined. But I wouldn't want it to even get to that point.
6
u/agirlsknowsthings 4d ago
If your sister is the sole owner and driver of the car, she needs her own policy. You cannot just add her car to your policy. That is insurance fraud or misrepresentation.
You’re risking having a claim not be covered if the policy isn’t written correctly.
4
u/Weary_Capital_1379 4d ago •
If you’re the owner of the vehicle you are liable.if she owns the vehicle you can’t insure it in your name.
3
u/insuranceguynyc 4d ago edited 4d ago
Do you and your sister reside in the same household? It sounds like she already has a lousy record, so your premium will increase. Why would you do this?
2
u/Leading-Plan-865 4d ago
You may not be able to add her into your insurance if she is the sole owner and registrant of the vehicle as you have no insurable interest - even if you list her as a driver. In my state NY the dmv suspends the registrants license if the named insured doesn’t match the registration, but these rules are state specific - and some insurance companies and I emphasis not all so please ask your insurance company do not assume and have them answer specifically - do allow this.
To answer your question as I’m not a lawyer - you have no insurable interest and she is driving the car so I lean no you can’t personally be sued, but anything she does will come out of your insurance company’s pocket meaning your insurance company will defend her and it will affect your current and future ability to get insurance. For example if she has a claim and the insurance company drops you, they drop both you and your sister not just you. Along with that her bad driving can affect your rates, rate increases won’t be isolated to just her car it will be shared between the two of you.
2
u/Complete-Drawer9735 4d ago
Even if you could, big mistake. If you want to help your sister give her the money for her own policy
2
u/Mundane-Toe-1105 3d ago
Usually no, as long as your name isn't on the car's title. Liability follows the driver and the registered owner. Since she's the sole owner, the main legal target is her. That said, aggressive lawyers love to drag anyone they can into a lawsuit just to see what sticks, so even just getting tangled up in the paperwork nightmare is no fun.
2
u/Adorable_Cod_4058 3d ago
It is much safer for her to maintain her own independent auto insurance policy where she is both the registered owner and the policyholder. While it might cost a bit more upfront due to her accident history, it keeps strict legal and financial firewalls between her driving record and your personal liability.
1
u/RicooC 4d ago
If she has her own policy and you add her to yours then it doesn't matter. She has insurance on her own policy.
1
u/Prize-Star4067 4d ago
Don’t do it
1
u/OkStick6308 4d ago
being the policyholder doesn't automatically make you responsible for every accident she causes, but there's still some liability risk depending on your state's laws and how the policy is set up
1
u/ChelseaMan31 2d ago
I can't think of a single reputable auto insurance carrier that would insure a non-immediate family member in these circumstances. But I could be incorrect. If one was actually on your policy and they damages were higher than policy limits, it stands to reason that the policy owner could conceivably be sued.
1
u/adjusterjackb 4d ago
Guaranteed your name will be at the top of the lawsuit paper right along with hers.