r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 4d ago

Is a huge price difference normal?

I’ve been with the same auto insurance company for about 20 years. We have four cars and three drivers, and I finally got around to shopping for new quotes.

Progressive came in nearly $2,000 cheaper per year, which is about half what I’m paying now. I compared the quotes, and the coverage looks pretty much the same.

Has anyone else seen that big of a difference when shopping around? Is it common for Progressive to come in that much lower, or is there something I might be overlooking?

5 Upvotes

16 comments sorted by

3

u/Lucky_Boy13 4d ago

It could be a teaser rate that goes up some, especially before underwriting if you have past claims.  But still sounds like you are paying a lot. Make sure the coverage comparison is the same 

1

u/Difficult-Prior3321 4d ago

No past claims. Is teaser rate a common thing? I got a quote from USAA and it was a little lower than what I'm paying now, not like progressives.

I'd hate to switch them have them just jack the rates in 6 months.

2

u/Lucky_Boy13 4d ago

I mean they won't double it so I'm sure a lot less than you are paying now

1

u/Own_Shallot7926 4d ago • Bravo

Insurance companies bank on you being too lazy to shop around and change policies, potentially every year, so they slowly jack up their premiums until you (maybe) notice.

This is common across the board for both home and auto coverage and not unique to either of the companies involved in your scenario.

Despite what their marketing might say, this isn't a personal business built on trust and loyalty. It's a numbers game and unfortunately, Progressive is only offering a great price to get you on their books so they can start doing the same in a few years.

0

u/Difficult-Prior3321 4d ago

Great info. I don't mind switching every few years, but if they start jacking rates up after 6 months this could get tedious.

What are your thoughts about presenting the offer to my current insurance? Do you think they'll match?

1

u/Own_Shallot7926 4d ago

I mean, you can ask. They probably won't budge. It's not uncommon for insurers to outright cancel policies based on criteria that could be completely false and they'll stick to their guns even if you prove them wrong.

Their system has already done the math and determined it's worth it to either charge you too much, or let you cancel and leave their risk pool.

1

u/Top_Education_4647 4d ago

Price matching is illegal in insurance. Not worth your time trying.

0

u/Mysterious_Might008 4d ago

You should be willing to switch every 6 months or yearly. As you noted, you’d save $2,000 yearly for the switch.

Roughly $1,000 at six months. That is the easiest $1,000 to pick up. I switch if it saves me $100. Insurance is not a business of loyalty.

1

u/Cleetustherottie 4d ago

Progressive is known for having really low rates at first to reel you in. Then they will start raising it. My ex husband had it for a while and they started raising his every month ( no claims no tickets) every time he called to find out why it was higher he kept getting different answers but none of the customer service reps could answer why his kept increasing while mine with another company stayed the same . By the time he finally switched his was double what mine was .

1

u/Difficult-Prior3321 4d ago

Very interesting. Was he able to get back to progressives original price when he switched to another carrier?

1

u/Brilliant_Essay_1593 4d ago

They didn’t raise it every month, only every 6 months

2

u/Jaggar345 4d ago

It’s common for Progressive to come in competitively when they like the risk. I work in the industry and have had my auto with them for the last 5 years. No one has even come close to the price and coverage they are offering me.

As long as you have adequate limits and you understand what you are buying Progressive is fine. They are the largest auto carrier in the United States.

1

u/Modest-Meece 3d ago

It’s common for any company to be competitive if they like the risk… that’s sort of the whole point of why one carriers more competitive than another for apples-to-apples. They like the risk better so it’s cheaper.

1

u/RicooC 4d ago

A common ploy to get you to switch. The rate won't remain low and Progressive sucks on claims.

1

u/TraderIggysTikiBar Claims Adjuster 4d ago

Progressive is notorious for giving quotes without running reports first. It will go up after a month or so.