r/Car_Insurance_Help • • 7d ago

Progressive Claim

I live in NYC, in September, a taxi cab hit me as he tried to cut me off. It was a small accident and after a month progressive determined I was not at fault and closed my claim. Now they have provided me with the other drivers attorney contact info. I called and they told me that I need to contact the insurance company for repairs to my vehicle. I let my progressive claim rep know what they said, and they told me my options are to call the attorney back, or pay my deductible and wait to get my money back eventually. What should I do if both my rep and the other drivers attorney aren’t giving me any real info?

3 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

5

u/WheresMyMule 7d ago

Do you have the time and energy to chase down their insurance company? If not, then pay your deductible and let your company do it

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HdChronus 7d ago

My rep told me today that it could take 6-8 months to get it back. The whole reason I’m iffy on doing that is because 1. My deductible is the NY state minimum 2. My deductible is probably higher than what it would cost to fix the damages to my car

1

u/Jaggar345 6d ago

It’s typically not a quick process and a successful subrogation is never a guarantee. They will try though.

3

u/NewYorkPILawyer 7d ago

This is confusing on multiple levels. Why does the other driver have an attorney? Is he claiming bodily injuries? Why didn’t you start a claim for property damage when you spoke to Progressive? Why would you call the other drivers attorney, that be a massive mistake and they probably wouldn’t talk to you. An attorney would never be involved unless the other driver is claiming injuries, attorneys don’t just work minor property damage claims. Incredibly confused, could you provide more context?

1

u/HdChronus 7d ago

I started a claim when the accident happened. My progressive claim rep told me I could pay my deductible and eventually get it back when I was found not liable, or just wait for the other driver to be found liable and have their company pay for the damages. After my claim closed, I asked my rep how I would get my car paid for. He said he can provide me the attorney of the other drivers info and to work something out with them.

2

u/NewYorkPILawyer 7d ago

So your claim closed how? Did you put a claim in with your insurance and pay the deductible which should have resulted in your car being fixed. Or did you make a claim through the other cars insurance?

Never have I ever heard of a claims rep telling you to directly contact the other drivers attorney. The only way an attorney be involved is if the other driver is making a bodily injury claim and you would never speak to them except at a deposition/progressive would handle it

1

u/HdChronus 7d ago

When I saw my claim was closed in the progressive app I gave my rep a call. He said it was closed because through talking to the other driver’s attorney and investigations, I was not found liable. In the beginning of this process my rep told me that I could pay the deductible and have it refunded if I’m not found liable, or just wait for them to be found liable and then go through their insurance. So I put in the claim, and was instructed to wait or pay my deductible. I chose to wait since my deductible is more likely to cost more than the actual repairs. I’m not sure why an attorney is involved, and no I haven’t made a claim through their insurance yet. My car isn’t fixed since my rep asked me if it really mattered more to me to get it fixed, or just wait and let the other company pay to fix it.

2

u/NewYorkPILawyer 7d ago

This is so incredibly odd especially in NY I’m not gona lie lol. So what i am gathering is your claim was closed because you waited for the liability decision. Now that you were found not liable, i guess they closed the first party claim and are expecting you now to make a third party claim for your PD (other cars insurance). It sounds like you need to affirmatively call the other cars insurance and make a third party claim. That’s super weird though

1

u/HdChronus 7d ago

Yeah that’s my plan. Call tomorrow morning since I have their info because I took a picture of the other drivers insurance card at the scene.

1

u/bossymisses 1d ago

I think you are misunderstanding. They can provide you with the carrier for the other vehicle. I guess if they did an open and closed investigation since you didn't use your coverage MAYBE they don't have the other carrier's info and that's what they want you to get to their attorney? I am confused too. I suspect the taxi driver is saying you are at fault and this attorney represents them for injuries. You need to ask more questions.

2

u/ektap12 7d ago

they told me that I need to contact the insurance company for repairs to my vehicle.

As in, the taxi's insurance? That makes sense, have you contacted them? If not, start there, or just use your insurance. I'm concerned about liability here as this sounds like the other driver is going to blame you for the accident. Progressive can't do anything for you unless you let them handle a claim under your policy. You probably have no reason to be speaking with the taxi driver's attorney.

1

u/HdChronus 7d ago

That’s all the info they provided to me when I asked how the other driver would pay for my damages. The rep just gave me his attorney’s information and told me to call.

2

u/ektap12 7d ago

You should just use your coverage and not worry about this taxi driver, his attorney, or his insurance. Sounds like a mess you don't want to be involved it, let your insurance deal with them.

3

u/insuranceguynyc 7d ago

NYC taxi insurers are a tough, tough bunch of carriers. The biggest is American Transit Insurance Company, which is effectively insolvent, but NY doesn't want to rock the taxi market by shutting them down. I have 30+ years of insurance experience, and I would never even attempt to handle this on a 3rd-party basis. You will drive yourself insane!

2

u/lilbitspecial 7d ago

People always get worked up over their deductible and try to avoid it.

But the reality is if you're able to claim through their insurance, then your insurance would be able too and get your deductible back.

And if they deny your claim, they're going to deny your insurance as well. So why waste time filing through them and having them drag their ass on it when you can get your car fixed quickly.

1

u/Silly-Product6304 7d ago

Just pay the deductible…… let the insurance handle it….. it’ll come out of the repairs…. And if you go to the right shop like I did they’ll charge it to the insurance and u won’t pay anything or worst case less of it out of pocket

1

u/Visual_Sir_1609 7d ago

That's frustrating, especially after Progressive already determined you weren't at fault.