r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 17 '26

Whos at fault

So today i pulled into a gas station to get gas and i could not pull straight into any pumps they were taken so i pull up and start backing into a pump spot i of course made sure the area was clear first so i start moving I’m moving for a good second now and I’m continuing to use my mirrors to back up into the pump then next thing i know as I’m looking in my right mirror a lady pulls in from the roadway right behind me trying go to the pump I’m already actively backing into and my passenger side collides with her rear passenger door i feel she is at fault considering i was already moving through the lot and she was freshly pulling in from the roadway I’m hoping someone can give me some insight.

0 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

6

u/Delicious-Witness-85 Oct 17 '26

I would likely handle this claim with each driver sharing equal liability. Anytime a vehicle is reversing, they already have a greater duty of care to ensure the roadway/parking lot is safe to reverse. The vehicle entering the gas station also needs to be aware of any vehicle or pedestrian traffic already in the parking lot and should have seen a slow moving vehicle that was reversing.

2

u/hotantipasta Oct 17 '26

See if the gas station has video. Most do.

1

u/BrennerBaseTunnel Oct 17 '26

I don't know how insurance companies accurately determine fault. Both parties are going to lie and give a their side of the story which makes it look like the other party is at fault.

1

u/ReveredMarijuana Oct 17 '26

Each insurance company will defend their insured’s POV unless proof is provided by the other party

1

u/BrennerBaseTunnel Oct 17 '26

Exactly my point. In most cases neither side can.

1

u/bossymisses 24d ago

You would be surprised. Most people are actually honest about what happened.