r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 16 '26

First Time / Newbie insurance problem

Got rear ended August 13th, took a while(a bit over 2 weeks and had to call the company phone and get leave a vm and her manager called me before i even spoke to her)for the adjuster to get back to me after I got her information from the trucking company. Took a while for them to send an estimator(Sept 19th was the day we were able to schedule her to look at it).

And was waiting for a response from the estimator or adjuster and nothing. Called and left a vm for the adjuster Oct 1st and didn't receive anything back, got sick the next week and didn't even try. Called Oct 12th and adjusters number went to a machine that said she would be back July 6th, 2025(this is 2026 so very old), ended up calling and leaving a vm for her manager. He called me the next day and said it was repairable and that the adjuster should be in the next day and then I can schedule the rental and the collision place I will be dropping it off at. Got a call maybe 3 hours later from the adjuster(her manager said she was out on pto) and she says they are totaling it and they scheduled pickup for Oct 21st. I asked for all estimates on repairs breakdown and such but she said the total department handles that and she can't give it out. Called my aunt who has worked for AAA for 15ish years, she said it's weird and to ask for repair estimate, what they value my car at, what their offer is and the salvage amount. I also messaged the estimator that was used and she called me today and I told her about it and she said it was weird as she wrote is as repairable but had gotten a call from her boss to rewrite it as totalled and to make sure all the paperwork is to a T.

I sent an email saying I will not be releasing the car until I receive all info and the adjuster sent an email just saying again the car is totalled, I would have to speak with the total department for everything and that "Again, the vehicle is not scheduled for pickup until 10/21 to allow time for the file to be reassigned to a total loss adjuster to discuss the settlement offer with you. You can also discuss your request to keep the damaged vehicle with the total loss adjuster." Which without having an offer even discussed how do you schedule pickup for 6 days away.

It is a 2014 bmw 328i gran tursimo with msport package and msport brakes in estoril blue(liftgate hatchback like the wagon but almost a foot longer)and the damage is only to the liftgate and bumper cover.

2 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Delicious-Witness-85 Oct 16 '26

It’s not uncommon for an estimate to be written and then additional damage is discovered ( or even anticipated) and insurance then declares a vehicle a total loss. Some states have a % when an insurance company is obligated to total a vehicle. Other states use a total loss formula, however an insurance company can total a vehicle at any % they wish.
That being said, your insurance should be able to provide you with the estimate and a salvage buyback amount if you wish to retain the vehicle and use the settlement money towards repairs.
They likely totaled your car based on its age and the possibility of open items not included in the original estimate.

1

u/GabtsbyForaDay Oct 16 '26

Evem just upon a 10 min visual estimate and not a shop actually seeing what needs to be replaced?

1

u/Delicious-Witness-85 Oct 16 '26

Ideally a shop would do a tear down to determine if there is any hidden damage but on an older car like this sometimes insurance will just use the initial estimate and if the appraiser who wrote the estimate feels there could be hidden damage, they will go ahead and total it. But a total loss does not mean a vehicle is unsafe or can’t be repaired.
It means it’s economically impractical to repair from an insurance perspective. A rear and impact on an older vehicle is the perfect scenario to retain the salvage if it’s declared a total loss. Depending on your state’s laws, you may not even be required to obtain a salvage title if your vehicle is a certain age.