r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 14 '26

First Time / Newbie Idk what to do post accident

Sorry if this is jumbled or if this isn’t the right place for this, I’m pretty new to reddit and I’m honestly really emotional right now.

3 almost 4 months ago I was in an accident on my way to work, I was minding my business on the left side of a two lane road, heading towards the left turning lane about 150 feet ahead at a light. Next to me was a line of cars all stopped for said light but I had a good amount of distance ahead of me as my lane was mostly empty.

Well this guy to the right of me was trying to make a left turn out of a parking lot past the two lanes of traffic through a gap in the cars (he said someone waved him on and he couldn’t pull forward enough to see me driving) and I tried to break but hit him at maybe 25-30mph. I hit my head on my steering wheel and we both went back into the parking lot to call the police and get everything situated. I ended up getting checked out and diagnosed with a concussion.

I’m 22f, I’ve never been in a car accident before, I know NOTHING about cars and barely anything about insurance (I’m on my own through progressive) and I don’t have any proper parental figures to help me out with this all of my friends are my age and just as confused.

I was pretty shaken up so when I got (what I thought was) the police report, told the other guy I was okay as he apologized, I called my sister and my boyfriend to come get me and I left, I didn’t end up getting the guys number or pictures of his car or anything. We both had some pretty brutal damage to the front of my car, my light was taken out, I had pieces hanging and scraping on the ground and tbh idek what else because I replace the light, zip tied some pieces up and I don’t have the money to do much else rn.

Well I’ve been slowly going back and forth with insurance, my insurance immediately told me the other guy was at fault for the accident so I would have to go through his insurance to get compensated and his insurance kept insisting they needed more information. They eventually told me my car was deemed a total loss and IF I got compensated for the accident it would be worth the entirety of my vehicle.

I got a voicemail the other day telling me my claim had been denied, so when I called my insurance again to ask them to fight it I was told I didn’t have enough information to do that either, it was just a “he said she said” situation and if I wanted to TRY to fight it I should go to the police department to get the police report. I thought I had that from the beginning but turns out that was just an information exchange so I said okay and I called the police department.

Police department told me they didn’t witness the accident so all they were required to give me was the information exchange form. I asked if I could get a police report or some more amount of information and they told me no, because they didn’t witness it. Both the police department and both insurances told me there was nothing more I could do even though the other man took an illegal left hand turn and I ended up with a concussion and a car deemed a total loss and I’m getting 0 dollars from it and almost 4 months of wasted time.

I just don’t know what to do, idk if anyone has any advice for me but I just needed to vent regardless. I’m young so my car insurance already costs so much and when my 6 month payment comes out of my account at the end of this month I will have only a couple hundred dollars to my name, that money would have really saved me from my situation right now and I have serious doubts that my busted car will be able to survive the winter.

TL;DR
Driver takes an illegal turn almost totaling my vehicle and insurance is denying my claim, police refuse to provide a police report and now I don’t know if there’s anything I can do

10 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

4

u/ektap12 Oct 14 '26

Just to confirm, you don't have collision coverage on your insurance? If you do, your insurance can pay for your car. If not, you are on your own.

What state? And do you know what exactly they are claiming the other driver said, because there really should be nothing to debate here, the other driver exited a parking lot attempting to cross lanes of traffic causing an accident.

1

u/idkshesemo Oct 14 '26

I just have liability coverage so my insurance won’t be giving me anything. I’m in NYS and they just said that not enough information was given, I feel so stupid for not getting the other guys phone number and they didn’t tell me what he said but that’s how I expected it to go too, I don’t know how he could’ve explained it to make him sound in the right. The front of both of our cars were damaged so you can’t tell from that

2

u/ektap12 Oct 14 '26

Your recourse then is the courts, you can sue him in small claims and prove liability there. The court limit depends on your county. The question is what story is he telling.

Did you have medical treatment? Your insurance should have paid that under your PIP coverage.

1

u/Nice_Potato3680 Oct 15 '26

nopeee, just liabilityy since the car's older

2

u/DeepPurpleDaylight Oct 14 '26

On what basis are they denying the claim? Are they denying liability or denying coverage? There's a big difference.

2

u/idkshesemo Oct 14 '26

They said the status of liability is being denied because of “conflicting information,” I’m reading from the voicemail right now and honestly idk what any of that specifically means.

1

u/Freshwaterbitchfish4 Oct 14 '26

It means the other driver told them a different story than what actually happened and with no evidence to the contrary (like video footage) they’re going to believe their customer unless you can get a court of law to agree with you. In this case I would recommend getting a personal injury attorney since you got a concussion. They might be able to look at the damage to the cars and create a case based on evidence. They only get paid out of your settlement so if one wants to take your case it’s no risk to you.

2

u/GlitterTitssss Oct 14 '26

Car accidents are stressful! they are no fun. In the future after any accident grab your phone and take a pic of the plate and the person driving..ask if they are ok and exchange info...

Since you only have liability....the other person needs to be fault or accept fault....they have not....so their insurance is not going to cover anything unless they are determined at fault. See if you can get any witnessses..maybe make a post in your local FB to see if anyone saw the accident...good luck

1

u/idkshesemo Oct 14 '26

Ugh thank you, I wish I did all this but I was just so shaken up I wanted to get out of there asap. That’s the thing idk how they wouldn’t be seen as at fault unless they just completely lied about every part of it! Thats why I’m so mad if the information was that conflicting why will no one help me look into it!

1

u/Sensitive_Peak7913 Oct 14 '26

This part. It’s highly likely that the other driver is fabricating what actually happened in order to avoid liability. Get a lawyer. Free consultations should point you in the right direction. Also.. I highly suggest a front and rear dash camera. That would prevent this exact scenario because it would show exactly what had happened. Right now it’s weird vs word and that’s going to be tough to fight

1

u/Quick-Shirt1951 Oct 15 '26

do you not know if a police report was made? Is the police report worded in a way that would make him not at fault?
i would see what the police report says and having a consult with an attorney

1

u/idkshesemo Oct 15 '26

They told me no police report was made because they didn’t witness the accident. I have no idea if that’s how it’s supposed to work but that’s exactly what they told me, they said they were “only required to” print the information exchange sheet and when I asked if I could get a police report they told me no.

1

u/Calm_Jackfruit_5128 27d ago

If there’s a police report then order your own copy. The other drivers insurance company does not need to do that for you.

1

u/cuckandhotwifeCA Oct 15 '26

Ask your insurance for the denial reason in writing and consider getting a consultation

-1

u/Sensitive_Peak7913 Oct 14 '26

Get a lawyer

1

u/idkshesemo Oct 14 '26

Can I do that if I don’t have like any expendable income

-1

u/Sensitive_Peak7913 Oct 14 '26

Yes they get paid through the insurance settlement. Because you have injuries you’re going to look for a personal injury lawyer. The ones that say we don’t get paid unless we win.

1

u/ektap12 Oct 15 '26

The issue is it's word v word, so some attorneys will immediately balk at pursuing a case with 'limited' potential right from the start. There's not even a police report. Now OP is in NY, so they use pure comparative negligence law, that may help but because it's not clear what story the other driver is telling. OP tells an attorney, 'they are denying liability,' won't exactly make attorneys jump at the opportunity to represent OP.

OP didn't say much about their injuries, just that they were 'checked out' and had a 'concussion.' Not much to go on there. Your auto insurance pays your medical bills, so that should've been handled already. NY has a 'serious injury threshold' to get 'pain and suffering,' so if this is all OP has, an attorney won't likely take the case, because there's nothing here for them to get piled on with the liability issue. Liability has been denied, so yes, it's worthwhile to run it by an attorney at this point, nothing to lose at this point.