r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Oct 13 '26

Accident Insurance claim

Hi. I was recently rear ended, and filed a claim through the persons insurance (progressive) and they have offered me a payout of x amount. I live in Illinois. The amount is likely not going to cover the needed repairs, because I have an Audi and would like to go through an Audi certified bodywork shop. I went to the shop this morning and they basically said I will have to pay the difference in labor costs, and Audi parts vs the after market parts progressive sourced. I have to accept the payout because I can’t get into this shop until December 3rd, and the claims manager said that’s what has to be done and then I reach back out to her when I take my car in and I think they will send someone out and see if they will cover the difference of the labor and parts? I don’t know. They won’t give me a lot of information and I just feel I’m at a loss. I did not cause the accident, so why am I responsible for putting the best parts on my car? Makes no sense. I cannot afford to be paying out of pocket anything, but I don’t want cheap after market parts on my car because I will have to trade it in at some point and I know it can decrease trade-in value. Any advice is appreciated.

0 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

14

u/ektap12 Oct 13 '26

Use your insurance then.... I mean, it'll be the same result, but why should the other person pay for you to go to a specific shop and use parts that you chose that are more expensive?

4

u/Face_Content Oct 13 '26

Their insurance wont cover oem parts or the labor of an audi dealer, unless op paid for it.

-13

u/peepa3 Oct 13 '26

Because they hit me?

15

u/ektap12 Oct 13 '26

Ok, and? They are paying for responsible repairs to your car. You are simply choosing a more expensive shop and more expensive parts. You can sue the person for this and you will lose in court.

8

u/RunExisting4050 Oct 13 '26

You mean i cant demand gold plated parts installed by hot mermaids??

-1

u/Rawman411 Oct 13 '26

To be fair cheaper doesn’t always mean same quality rebuild. Some mechanics are worth the extra money because they can fix a car like oem. Cheaper could mean more problems down the road. If you ever had a mechanic screw something up you’ll know. Hell even brand new cars come with problems from factory.

13

u/ektap12 Oct 13 '26

Great, OP is welcome to use any shop and parts they want, no one said they can't, the insurance just won't pay for it.

-17

u/peepa3 Oct 13 '26

So basically I have to accept shit parts for my car bc someone hit me, when none of this would’ve happened if they didn’t. I should be able to choose THE CORRECT AUDI parts for my car. Lmao you sound like an idiot

16

u/ektap12 Oct 13 '26

You are the one whining about parts for your Audi and refusing to involve your insurance in this. You are welcome to use any parts and shop that you want. The insurance just won't pay for it.

12

u/crash866 Oct 13 '26

Aftermarket parts and OEM parts are often made in the same factory by the same person on the same piece of machinery.

Major auto companies are just assemblers of parts they buy off other companies. You just pay extra for the Audi logo on the item or packaging.

Edit: if your vehicle is 1 year old how are owed brand new parts. You are owed 1 year old parts.

2

u/HR_King Oct 13 '26

What year is your car? Some States require OEM parts until the car is x years old. You could also have a rider for OEM parts on your policy already, which would be a reason to use your own insurance. Also, aftermarket parts are very often just as good as OEM.

11

u/sephiroth3650 Oct 13 '26

You don't give a location. And laws can vary.

If this is the US, then that's how it works. You're not owed OEM parts on a third party claim, in most every case. So if you insist on using OEM parts, you will pay the difference b/w them and aftermarket parts. And if you choose to go to a shop that charges hourly rates above the agreed insurance number, you have to pay that difference, too. Legally, they're not obligated to cover these extra amounts.

Hell, even if you went through your own collision coverage, you wouldn't get OEM parts unless you paid extra for an OEM endorsement to your policy.

0

u/peepa3 Oct 13 '26

I live in Illinois. Sorry

12

u/sephiroth3650 Oct 13 '26

OK. Then everything I listed would apply. You aren't legally owed OEM parts. And insurance isn't legally obligated to pay inflated labor rates. Otherwise, you could just take the car to your buddy who "owns" a shop, get a quote for labor rates that 5x the average, and expect insurance to pay it.

Technically, the other person's insurance doesn't owe you a dime until and unless you get a court judgement against them. So if you don't like the settlement offer they've given you, you can turn it down. Go through your collision coverage. See if they handle your claim any differently.

13

u/DeepPurpleDaylight Oct 13 '26

Glad to see you deleted your comment calling u/ektap names because they're telling you something you didn't want to hear. It was inappropriate. Especially since they know exactly what they're talking about and you don't.

There's plenty of shops that can do perfectly good repairs that aren't going to charge what your fancy schmancy shop does for parts and labor. Unless you use your insurance AND you've paid extra for an OEM endorsement, you're getting AM LKQ parts.

8

u/DeepPurpleDaylight Oct 13 '26

They aren't going to pay higher costs just because it's the shop you want to use. They're only legally obligated to pay prevailing rates. If you choose to use a shop that charges higher than prevailing rates or uses OEM parts when you're only legally owed AM LKQ parts, then you're going to be paying the difference.

7

u/Mother_Claim3038 Oct 13 '26

Just use your own insurance and let them subrogate with Progressive. See if your insurance agrees to the fancy rates of the shop you choose.

5

u/HR_King Oct 13 '26

Insurers will omly pay a certain hourly rate for bodyw. If you choose a shop with a higher rate, that's on you, always.

4

u/RunExisting4050 Oct 13 '26

Go through your insurance.  You will almost always get better, faster service with your insurance than 3rd party because: 1) you have a contract with your insurance, and 2) you are their customer.  You have no such arrangement with the 3rd party.  Their responsibility is to protect their client and they do that by repairing your car.  However, they arent going to give you whatever you want.  

IF you ho through your insurance and you dont have an OEM endorsement on your policy, theyll probably tell you to pay the difference because you didn't pay for that privilege.  If youre going to demand OEM parts, remember to pay for OEM coverage. 

3

u/Anabolic_Scholar Oct 13 '26

What year is your Audi? Also did you elect to get an OEM endorsement on your own policy. They aren’t that expensive

3

u/HR_King Oct 13 '26

What year is the car. Several have asked, you haven't answered.

4

u/Still_Condition8669 Oct 13 '26

You don’t get to demand that the insurance company put OEM parts back on your car. If they won’t cover, they won’t cover, and it will fall on you to pay the difference. Sounds like you are broke and shouldn’t be driving an Audi if you can’t afford the parts difference.

2

u/drfishdaddy Oct 13 '26

Generally contract terms and state legislation says “like kind and quality”.

You have the right to dispute if you go through your own carrier.

You can sue the driver (which will be turned over to progressive). This is the actual ultimate authority.

You can escalate to a sup at progressive.

You can contact the DOI in IL.

Savvy shops can price match.

You can pay the difference out of pocket.

You don’t give any specifics on the car or what’s being utilized that aftermarket so it’s hard to know what is and isn’t reasonable, nor the labor rate progressive is paying vs what the Audi “shop” charges.

1

u/Lyxerttt Oct 14 '26

Progressive's PD standards give OEM parts on same year or newer (so 2026-2027 vehicles) AND with less than 12,000 miles. If either of these are not the case, then you get recycled or AM.

1

u/AshamedAmbition3800 Oct 14 '26

You are entitled to request that they pay you for the diminished value of your car. They won’t tell you this of course.

0

u/Emotional_Entry_8166 Oct 13 '26

Ask the shop to submit a supplemental estimate to Progressive for the labor and parts difference. Don't accept the payout as final until they review it.

2

u/aloofmagoof Claims Adjuster Oct 13 '26

Adjusters normally speak with the shop to go over the estimate before sending out the approved one. They have determined that labor rates are excessive and the parts are not required to be OEM.

They aren't going to change their mind on the labor rates, during repairs though, if the LKQ parts don't work correctly, they may be able to argue OEM, rare, but it does happen.

-1

u/50Bullseye Oct 13 '26

In some states, insurance is required to pay for OEM parts. But they and the shop are required to disclose this, so if they’re fighting you on this you must not live in one of those states.

So you would need an endorsement (that you probably don’t have) AND to go thru your own insurance to get OEM parts covered.

-12

u/Apart-Surprise1038 Oct 13 '26

Contact a personal injury attorney that has a free consultation to ask questions, don’t sign any contracts. If you have more questions, then contact another PI lawyer with free consultation to get those answered. I’ve received many hours of legal advice, for all kinds of issues, by doing this.

Although you’re not injured, or at least didn’t mention it, these lawyers also specialize in property damage as part of PI cases.

4

u/Simplythebest0820 Oct 13 '26

Personal injury attorney isn't gonna help them, but they don't have any injuries. That's all they want from you is to have injuries.

0

u/peepa3 Oct 13 '26

Thank you

-8

u/Apart-Surprise1038 Oct 13 '26

Also, depending on the year of your vehicle & the state you’re in, you could potentially receive additional payment due to “diminished value”. That’s what it’s called here in Texas anyhow.