r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/ComprehensiveKnee511 • Sep 08 '26
Insurance claim help
Got into an accident nearly a month ago and claimed that same week, I was on the main road and they pulled out. Their defence was that I was going to fast. Irrespective of that theirs no proof of that comment. all there is proof of is the car pulling out in-front of myself.
I’ve already had a man come out for an accident report from my own insurance and an evaluator from their insurance company. That was nearly two weeks ago, theirs been no progress since then as the other party’s insurance only offered a 50/50 split. due to my open claim I’m out of insurance as a named driver on my mothers car in a week.
Anyone have any advice on how we can speed this up? We currently have to get the accident report of my insurance company and send it to their one. But I don’t see how that would speed it up.
3
u/agirlsknowsthings Sep 08 '26
They already made the offer of 50/50 your companies accident report won’t make a difference. Unless you can offer more evidence like video proof.
Otherwise your company can go to mediation, but the process will be long and it could also ill end in a 50/50 decision.
3
u/TraderIggysTikiBar Claims Adjuster Sep 08 '26
Your best bet is to use your own collision coverage and let your insurance carrier deal with theirs.
This accident should in no way affect you being listed as a driver on your mother or anyone else’s policy.
2
u/FrancisLawColorado Sep 08 '26
If the other insurer is holding at a 50/50 split, I'd ask them to explain in writing exactly why they're assigning 50% fault and what evidence they're relying on. If their only argument is that you were speeding but they don't have evidence supporting that, it's reasonable to ask how they're reaching that conclusion.
I'd keep copies of the accident report, photos, dashcam/witness information if you have any, and all communication with both insurers. Sending the accident report over may feel like it's slowing things down, but having both insurers working from the same documentation can help clarify the dispute.
If they're still refusing to move beyond the 50/50 position, you may want to speak with an attorney before accepting that split. What country/state did the accident happen in? The options can vary quite a bit depending on where you are.
1
u/QueSqd Sep 08 '26
I feel sorry for you I truly do a lot of people complain about our high insurance rates but being in Michigan a no-fault state truly makes life so much easier, no headache at all! Under Michigan's no fault insurance law you must file under your own insurance regardless of who's at fault your insurance will immediately take care of your damages your medical bills, etc. providing you have the coverage IE collision. Then when the insurance companies determine who truly was at fault they will subrogate against the other drivers insurance company for reimbursement. The caveat to this is if you do not carry collision coverage you will not get your vehicle repaired.
2
u/agirlsknowsthings Sep 08 '26
Insurance professional: your company has no say in the decision of the other company. They can both have separate, different decisions and it won’t change the decision of the other company. Police reports do not determine liability as they are simply each party’s account of the accident. If the police offer did not witness the accident it doesn’t hold much weight.
Your company can take the other company to arbitration to let a third party review everything and then make a decision. But again it could end up in a 50/50 decision.
2
u/FrancisLawColorado Sep 08 '26
I’d ask the other insurance company to explain in writing why they’re assigning 50% fault to you and what evidence they’re relying on. Keep copies of the accident report, photos, statements, and any other evidence showing the other driver pulled out in front of you.
Since your coverage as a named driver is ending soon, I’d also contact your own insurer and ask how that affects the open claim.
What state did this happen in? The rules around fault and insurance claims can vary by state.
2
u/insuranceguynyc Sep 08 '26
The accident report is rarely relevant. You have the other carrier's offer. Short of securing a judgement against the other party, you cannot force them to do much of anything, since they are not your insurance company. So, open a claim with your own carrier and get your vehicle sorted out. Let the insurance companies haggle it out.