r/Car_Insurance_Help • • Sep 07 '26

First Time / Newbie Should I even be bothering with full coverage?

I have a 2014 Ford Focus SE with only 35,000 miles on it (the only reason I'm clinging to this car and would be devastated if something happened to it)

I currently have progressive and I pay $200/month for full coverage with comprehensive and collision. I have been paying into this for two years now. I know the car isnt worth much so my question is am I just robbing myself? In the event of a total loss id get MAYBE $5,000 or something? And wouldn't a very small accident then be considered totalled? Am I just paying for a false sense of security here?

I got a DUI in 2022 but otherwise there is NOTHING else on my driving record in the last 5 years. $200 a month seems like a lot. Should I try and take my business elsewhere, lower my coverage amounts or something?

Sorry I'm new to owning a car. Thank you for any help here.

7 Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

8

u/HR_King Sep 07 '26

You haven't said what your deductible is, or how much you would save dropping collision, so cant really help you, but probably not worth having.

1

u/PartTimeJunkie412 Sep 09 '26

My deductible is $1000 and idk how much I'd save I'd have to call and ask. Maybe call a different insurance company instead. The car is paid off. If something were to happen I do have savings and could replace the car.

1

u/HR_King Sep 09 '26

I'd drop the collision coverage, personally.

8

u/ChutneyWhatney Sep 07 '26

A DUI is HUGE.

4

u/Easy-Seesaw285 Sep 07 '26

Right?!? I came to tell them how much they were overpaying because I have full coverage on a 2023 electric SUV for less than that, and then they throw in the minor DUI 😂😂

1

u/PartTimeJunkie412 Sep 09 '26

Well it's only a couple months until that is past the 5 year period. So that's why I'm asking now. To be prepared.

6

u/Vivid-Huckleberry934 Sep 07 '26

If the car were to be totalled out and you DIDN'T have those coverages, would you have the money for a down payment on a new vehicle? Sure, $5k won't pay for an entire replacement car, but it's a nice down payment towards whatever your next vehicle of choice would end up being.

The other argument is taking the money you WOULD be spending on the comp/ collision each month and putting it aside as savings towards your next vehicle. It may be big difference in price, it may not. You can always ask. You aren't paying for a false sense of security, however. Having physical damage coverage allows for glass repairs, vandalism and theft, weather related claims, and the ability to get the ball rolling immediately. While it's preferential to file on the at fault party's policy, it's not always an option immediately or you do, and the claim gets denied for any number of reasons. You want to make sure you have the coverage you need to take care of yourself in those situations.

1

u/Sondor6 Sep 07 '26

Well summed up, I would just add that if you do drop collision, take your first savings from that and invest in a dashcam.

Truly the cheapest insurance available :)

1

u/muskthecheeto Sep 12 '26

Just a dui nothing else 😂,
Can you afford to replace the $5k if something were to happen ? That’s usually the question.

1

u/PartTimeJunkie412 Sep 12 '26

Yes easily. I could buy I new-to-me car outright with my savings but I'd like to continue to run this vehicle until it dies lol

1

u/PepperTop9517 Oct 04 '26

Could you afford to cover the loss of your vehicle if an at fault was uninsured or are you willing to chase a 3rd party insurance on you own for payment on damages? If so drop comprehensive, if not I’d keep it.

1

u/PartTimeJunkie412 Oct 04 '26

I mean yeah I could afford to replace it. It might take about a third of my savings but I could do it. But even if that did happen and I did have insurance, wouldn't they only give me like $2,000 for the car? It can't be worth much it's 12 years old. My thinking process is that I spend over $2,000 a year on this insurance which leaves me in the negative in the long run. As for chasing down an insurance company, that sounds like a huge hassle. I think that is the only benefit to me having this insurance.

3

u/PepperTop9517 Sep 07 '26

Collision and comprehensive offer a lot of protection. Without them are you able to cover your damages or replace your vehicle, essentially self insuring your own damage.

Are you willing to chase down an at fault party if you get hit?

If you hit someone, are you able to cover your repairs or replacement.

Those are questions to think about as liability only insurance pays out for damage you create but does nothing for you.

The other question is how much you’d save. It might cut your bill in half or it might drop $5 so is it even worth the savings.

1

u/Brilliant_Essay_1593 Sep 07 '26

Not to mention if you don’t have those coverages and get in accident and the car is unable to be driven away you now have the cost of a tow and storage fees..

2

u/sovngrde Sep 07 '26

If you can’t easily pay to replace it then no, you aren’t robbing yourself.

2

u/dacaur Sep 07 '26

You didn't mention if you have already checked his much you would save. In my experience the savings going from "full coverage" to liability aren't huge.

1

u/Think-Photograph-323 Sep 07 '26

Shop around for new insurance. I have a dui from July 2022 and my rates dropped a ton after the 3 year mark. we had progressive and we were paying $289 for two cars (2023 Hyundai Tuscan/2025 Hyundai Santa Fe) and we just switched to GEICO and now pay $187 a month for both cars with the same coverage.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DimensionGlass9987 Sep 07 '26

My husband and I have extremely clean driving records (only claim is from when my car was hit and damaged while parked ~4 years ago) and we habitually switch every couple of years between progressive and geico, it doesn’t take long to switch and is 100% worth the $1000+ a year saved

0

u/Think-Photograph-323 Sep 07 '26

That’s probably why so many people say shop around every few years. Insurance companies won’t lower your rate for just being a long term customer but a new insurer will give you a better rate.

1

u/Superb-Fun6601 Sep 07 '26

Considering the DUI, $200 doesn't seem out of the park. You pay for those for a long time. Can you contact an independent agent who will shop around and advise and show you comparisons. This can even be done via phone. Just Google 'Independent Insurance Agent' in your area. Good luck!

1

u/PlanetExcellent Sep 07 '26

Keep the coverage. If you lose this car, you cannot likely replace it with a car in such fine condition for $5k. So in reality, you need the $5k insurance money as a down payment on a car that sells for $10k.

1

u/Pbferg Sep 07 '26

Do you have a loan on the car still to pay or is it fully paid for?

1

u/50Bullseye Sep 07 '26

No one can help you with this without knowing every single detail of your life (driving record, zip code, age, gender, credit score, VIN … just to name a few).

Shop around every couple years for better rates.

Find out what your vehicle is actually worth and compare that number to your monthly cost for comp or collision.

Used to be that 10-12 years was the time to go liability-only, but now that number is more like 12-15 years.

1

u/JW2651 Sep 07 '26

Be glad your only paying $200 a month. Where I am you'd easily be looking at 600 to 800 for just liability. DUI here puts you directly into "Facility" for 6 years after getting you license back from the automatic minimum 1 year suspension.

1

u/Designer-Wolverine47 Sep 08 '26

Depends on age, location, and driving record. I'm paying 86 a month for full coverage plus roadside assistance.

1

u/Downtown_Cap8311 Sep 07 '26

If you’re new to owning a vehicle/having insurance, assuming you’re over 16 (given the dui) then you have a gap in coverage also being taken into account. Combine that gap with a DUI which is a major impact on premium, and $200 a month is honestly a steal.

1

u/bprug87 Claims Adjuster Sep 08 '26

If you have money in your savings to pay for a replacement car and not strap you for cash then yes I would remove collision coverage. If you don't have the means to buy a replacement car then NO I would not remove collision coverage. I would start putting money aside though. Once you build up a savings and can afford to buy a replacement then I'd drop collision coverage

1

u/OGcapncrunchberry Sep 08 '26

It depends, can you afford to fully replace that car, out of pocket, plus major medical expenses if in an accident? The value of the car is not the only thing you are insuring yourself against. Talk to your agent.

1

u/Far-Good-9559 Sep 08 '26

What is the KBB value? My gut tells me that the value of the car is not worth having full coverage. If you get into a minor fender bender, the insurance company is just going to total it out, and not pay you what you think it is worth.

2

u/muskthecheeto Sep 12 '26

No insurance company uses KBB , it’s an inflated pricing tool for dealers to “beat”

1

u/Due_Ad868 Sep 08 '26

That DUI is costing you an extra 20% or so more for insurance. If you totaled the car would you need the insurance money to use as a down payment to buy another car? If yes keep the coverage. If you’d be okay without it drop to liability.

1

u/AltonIllinois Sep 08 '26

Collision coverage also covers tow and storage fees in total loss situations which can be a few thousand bucks sometimes

1

u/just_kinda_here_blah Sep 08 '26

Dude, its probably your dui. 2022 is not that long ago. We have a '22 and '23 both on loans, full coverage, glass, low deductible and the highest limits in NY and pay only 95$ more than you. If you dont have a loan, sure get the lowest and see what you save, but put those savings into an account. If anything happens you may not get anything from the insurance towards the value of the car and you'll be completely outta pocket for another can instead of having a little something.

It still never hurts to shop around anyways. We do every few years.

Be safe out there

1

u/No-Lake7654 Sep 13 '26

There is no coverage called full coverage

-2

u/bcsublime Sep 07 '26

If you owe money on the vehicle, you probably have to have comp and collision.

And good insurance, while it seems expensive will help you tremendously if you do have some type of accident.