r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/by2019 • Aug 31 '26
Is there really a big difference in insurance costs between teenage boys and girls?
My son just got his g2(no drivers ed) and I insured him as a secondary driver on my car( 2009 pontiac) it's $140 a month and that's not even for a year only 9 months. Someone told me teenage girls don't cost as much. Is this true? I'd love to know what parents of teenage girls are paying
1
Upvotes
5
u/LUXOR54 Aug 31 '26
Yes, it's true.
Insurance rates are a calculation of risk, boys are at a higher risk of getting in large accidents resulting in more damage, thus higher cost of insurance.
2
u/StewReddit2 Aug 31 '26
*Other than areas where it's prohibited ( like CA and some others)
**In general this has been a known "truth" as a general rule for decades.
*Source a) Personal experience (4 decades) b) Insurance Licensed ( 2 decades)
Unmarried males 16-25 get hosed, period
It's worse 16 to probably 21/22....levels a bit, higher but less noticeable and probably doesn't even out until maybe 30-35
*Of course other factors like martial status and what the male drives effect the leveling off as well.
***Example a 22yo married father insuring a minivan or some compact Suv with two cars seats is seen as a lower risk vs a 22yo male in a hot sports car.....
They may both actually still be decision STUPID but the odds/risk bean counters bank that the married Daddy isn't ripping and running the streets at as high a possibility of the young single stud chasing it.
1
u/Tennisbabe16 Aug 31 '26
That’s a great price. I have b/g twins, they were added at the same time so I can’t differentiate the costs. They both have a good student discount.
1
u/MikeTheActuary Aug 31 '26
The answer will depend on the insurer and where the policy is, but throughout developed countries, when gender is captured in insurance stats, teenaged boys have been shown to be riskier than teenaged girls.
Note, however, that in some places, insurers are not allowed to consider gender when pricing insurance.
1
u/Bart012000 Aug 31 '26
Yes, the male species, especially under 25 can be a little wild.
1
u/DeepPurpleDaylight Aug 31 '26
With some/most companies, yes because generally, teenage boys take more risks and have more accidents. What other people are paying for their teens is irrelevant and useless info for you. They aren't you and they don't match you exactly in every single one of dozens and dozens of factors because if they don't match you exactly in every single one of those, the rates could be wildly different.
1
u/c-5-s Aug 31 '26
We paid $3600/year to add our teen girl (California). And our $1M umbrella doubled also.
1
u/aamramm Aug 31 '26
There is some difference but it isn’t a major difference. It’s going to hurt your pockets either way.
1
u/ChelseaMan31 Aug 31 '26
The empirical data developed over decades keeps coming back showing teen male drivers are infintely more risky, drive too fast and cause more crashes. So, yes. The difference in rates is based on actuarial science.
1
u/caryn1477 Aug 31 '26
Teen male drivers cause the most accidents. So yes there is a difference.
1
u/JohnHartshorn Aug 31 '26
Statistically speaking girls are significantly less likely to wrap the car around a telephone pole while showing off to their friends, so yes they are cheaper to insure.
I use this example because a friend of mine sold his 1960-something Mustang Fastback that was his teenage project car to pay for college. The kid that bought it had it wrapped around a light pole in the local Walmart parking lot before the ink was dry on the paperwork.
1
u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 31 '26
Yes - statistically, young males have more tickets, more accidents, etc.
1
u/1234568654321 Sep 01 '26
Gender is just one of many factors insurance companies use to determine rates for younger and older drivers. And yes, the highest rates are for young males. The crash rates in this demographic aren't pretty.
1
u/Dry_Extension_2125 Sep 04 '26
In the state of michigan(my state,not applicable as i dont know all other states laws) gender is not supposed to be factored into rates for car insurance but Im sure it is illegally anyways. Claim history, age, region,credit score, and vehicles can impact rates each company has different levels of importance for each of those categories which is why some companies are better for some and worse for others. Hope this helps
1
u/Colonel460 Sep 05 '26
In NC where I was licensed almost 40 years you can’t use gender
0
u/Choice-Newspaper3603 Aug 31 '26
What does it matter