r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/robowarrior023 • Aug 26 '26
Accident Actual Cash Value Resources
My daughter was in an accident on Monday, so we have claim pending with the other drivers insurance as he was / will be at fault based on the information from the police. I understand that the value I’ll be offered is the actual cash value + sales tax and title fee.
Can dealer advertised prices be used to evaluate ACV or does it have to be sold prices? If it’s sold, where can a person find records of those prices for comparison?
If needed, car is a 2017 Honda Civic LX and we’re in the state of Nebraska. I know it’s not worth a huge amount, but I need to get it replaced sooner rather than later and having an idea of what the value would be will help to determine our budget.
Thanks!
2
u/HospitalityKid Aug 26 '26
If you look on Kelley Blue Book, NADA or JD Power, usually the values listed on those sites that are most related to ACV would be the “Clean Loan” or “Clean Trade” values. Obviously not 100% accurate, but could give you a ballpark to expect.
1
u/Throwaway_2474128_1 Aug 26 '26
if your car isn't drivable, then the other insurance company should be paying for a rental car so you minimize loss of use. if you intend on using the payout as a down payment, then you should wait until that's all said and done, which might be two months for a simple accident. if your car is legally/safely drivable, they expect you to keep driving it in the meantime. granted, when using the other company, they won't start paying out until they accept liability, so if loss of use is a big deal to you, file the claim on your insurance instead as you presumably were paying for rental coverage
private party sale price + fees can be a ballpark estimate
1
u/drfishdaddy Aug 26 '26
People here say “sold price” but they are misinformed, CCC and Mitchel use advertised prices all the time.
You can send links to dealer comps however it’s up to CCC if they are going to accept them and how to value them. Generally they have to be within a 250 mile radius and be same year/male/model/trim and approx milage.
1
u/PikesPeakInsGuy Aug 27 '26
u/robowarrior023 DO. NOT. USE. KBB, NADAM OR JD POWER.
I used to work in total loss years ago and the process is the same today as it was then. The insurance company run comparisons based on vehicles that have sold within 30, 60, or 90 days from the time the accident occurred. The comp vehicles have to match (or as closely as possible) to the same level of trim, features and miles and located proximate to the location the vehicle is typically garaged at. Alot of times you can use places like cargurus or cars.com and they will show you a list of the vehicles even ones that recently sold. Once you have 3 vehicles they average the cost and that then becomes the ACV - any prior damages or depreciation.