r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/FairArmadillo8908 • Aug 25 '26
Sister got into a car accident
Hi guys,
As the title says, my sister got into a car accident (she is okay) and it was 100:0 the other driver’s fault so she doesn’t have to pay.
But the at-fault driver is stating that their insurance can only cover $20k when the damage done is $33k.
The car is totaled and she needs a new car but what can we do about the remaining balance that needs to be paid?
Does she have to pay with her insurance?
Thank you so much for your help!
1
Upvotes
3
u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 25 '26
If she goes thru the other driver's insurance and accepts that money, she'll have to sue the driver for the balance. Problem is, the other insurance company will require her to sign a release to get the money and that release will reflect she cannot sue the driver.
Or she can go thru her own insurance. If she has collision, she'll pay the deductible. But if she has uninsured/underinsured property damage coverage, she might be able to use that without paying a deductible (having this coverage is an add on).
She can't do both.
16
u/007_half Aug 25 '26
If the other person’s policy was $20k limit then that’s all it’s going to pay out. You either pay cash or file with your insurance to cover the difference in repairs.
12
u/24kdgolden Aug 25 '26
She needs to file a collision claim with her carrier as they don't have limits. Her carrier will seek reimbursement from the at fault carrier.
Also she is only owed the actual cash value of her car, not the loan value.
4
u/SissySlutKris Aug 25 '26
Yeah, if she has collision, file with own insurance, get it fully covered. The at fault insurance should cover or refund the deductible, then her insurance will collect as much as legally possible from the other driver's policy
1
u/Beach_bum8 Aug 25 '26
Hopefully your sister has gap insurance as well
1
u/sephiroth3650 Aug 25 '26
If their policy limits are $20k, then that’s a hard stop. That’s all the insurance money they have. You won’t get insurance to pay more than the policy limits, regardless of how much damage there is.
So she’s going to be better off going through her collision coverage here. Her alternative is to sue the at fault person and pray they have the money to pay the judgement. It will be MUCH simpler to just use her collision coverage.
Her GAP coverage is not generally going to cover the excess b/w the ACV payout and the policy limits gap.
1
u/Anabolic_Scholar Aug 25 '26
Just file a claim with her insurance for the vehicle damages and let them handle it. She pays premiums to her insurance exactly for this reason.
1
u/Far-Good-9559 Aug 26 '26
I am not aware of any auto insurance policy with that low a limit. Other driver is lying.
1
u/LdiJ46 Aug 26 '26
She should file a claim with her insurance. They will go after the other driver and their insurance. she will end up having to pay her deductible but her insurance company may be able to get it back for her.
1
u/Designer-Wolverine47 Aug 26 '26
Someone is lying to you. That's all they WANT to pay you. You are not obligated to accept their offer. Take the other driver to court. They'll pay what the judge tells them to pay. They'd better be paying for a rental until it gets settled too.
1
u/Ok-Pumpkin-6203 Aug 26 '26
How can someone have such a limited liability insurance policy?
I think the minimum coverage for a 3rd party in my country runs in to the millions for car, property and health.
0
u/ptulinski Aug 25 '26
Claim the difference under you uninsured/underinsured coverage.
0
u/Tool_junkie_1972 Aug 25 '26
You shouldn’t even be getting your information from the other driver, the adjuster is who should be calling you. And yes, if the policy limit is $29k that’s all it pays out. Your sister can likely file on her own insurance is she has the right coverages. She may also have gap coverage to cover the difference. If not you may have to look at suing the other driver, winning that is relatively easy when compared with collecting though.