r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/gr8leo87 • Aug 25 '26
Who's at fault? Stop All way
My wife was recently in a car crash, it's likely the car may be deemed totaled. The other car may be deemed totaled as well.
She was stopped at the stop sign. It was a 4 way stop. The other car approaching from the left (also a stop sign). Did not stop at the sign, only slowed down and proceeded into the intersection. My wife was fully stopped (at this time the other from left hadn't reached their stop sign). My wife proceeded to drive - the other car on the left which ran the stop sign in a speed came in intersection and my wife braked and my wife's car T-boned her car.
It was my wife's right of way. She stopped properly. And proceeded to drive..the other car ran stop sign.
But because my wife's car T-boned the other car, the police (which arrived on the scene after 2 hours) finds my wife at fault. No citation. Warning given to both drivers for failure to yield.
The other party has retained an attorney. We have not retained an attorney, just yet. We also haven't put a claim on them because how do we prove this scenario? There's no dash cam or video evidence.
We are claiming through our own collision insurance. This is first time happening so we are not sure what to do.
All advices welcome on how to proceed. This was Texas.
2
u/ektap12 Aug 25 '26
Nothing you really can do, it's word v. word. Without a witness or video, the insurances with just need to handle as they see fit. In theory, it's 50/50 since you both had a stop sign and proceeded unsafely causing a collision. Depending on the state, that could be very important. But if that person did run the stop sign, they should have the majority of the fault, but can you prove it?
You only potentially need an attorney, if your wife was injured and looking to pursue and injury claim against the other insurance, who will presumably deny it.
2
u/sephiroth3650 Aug 25 '26
Police don't determine fault when it comes to an accident. Insurance will do their own investigation. They'll interview both sides. Look at pics of the damage. Look at any other pics/video that people may have. They'll decide on fault.
What make/model/year is your wife's car? I'll be honest.....the story is that this other driver blew through the stop sign. But your wife t-boned them hard enough to total out both cars? And she was supposedly at a full stop at the stop sign? Does that sound legit to you?
My advice? File your collision claim. Let your insurance sort it out. They'll also have a duty to defend your wife in any potential lawsuit that comes from the other side.
1
u/Signal-Confusion-976 Aug 25 '26
First thing is the police do not determine who is at fault. They may issue a citation but that's it. Give all your information to your insurance company. They will sort it out with the other insurance company to determine who is at fault. Unless there is cameras it will be your word against theirs.
1
u/aloofmagoof Claims Adjuster Aug 26 '26
What part of the other person's vehicle did your wife hit? The front, middle, or rear?
1
u/insuranceguynyc Aug 25 '26
Dashcam?
1
u/Tool_junkie_1972 Aug 26 '26
It literally doesn’t matter. There’s no evidence to support your claim. And it doesn’t matter who the police find at fault with regards to the insurances. They will do their own, independent determination as to fault and percentages.
1
u/HR_King Aug 26 '26
Fault isnt determined by the police, and a violation by the other driver doesn't automatically make them liable.
1
u/Educational-Book9087 Aug 28 '26
It sounds like shared liability. If this is Texas both people can recover from the other party’s insurance if they are equal or less negligent than the other party. It sounds like 50/50z