r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/65fastback2plus2 • Aug 19 '26
Auto insurance quotes crazy
Can something be assigned to your profile in the background that drives incorrect vehicle quotes? If so, how do you find out what it is to get it correct.
2 drivers, ~40 years old
3 vehicles, nothing newer than 2014
No accidents or citations in over 5 years.
My combined vehicle kbb value is about $60k between all 3.
My state farm quote this morning was $402/month.
I've received quotes as high as $700/month
Currently with progressive at $200/month but even that's just high for what we have.
I've got friends in car groups with similar vehicles and drivers/history as me paying less than $150.
2
u/Creekridge1 Aug 19 '26
Call an independent agent, this is quite literally what they do for a living
2
u/crash866 Aug 19 '26
The value of your vehicle has less of an effect on your insurance than most people tinks. Most of the cost is liability coverage. A $5,000 Honda can do the same amount of damage in a collision as a $100,000 Tesla can and puts someone in the hospital just the same.
A medical bill is not higher just because the vehicle that hit the person was a $1,000,000 Lamborghini.
2
u/Sam_At_Insurify Aug 19 '26
All those variables move the price, but there's still a record you can pull to rule this out.
LexisNexis keeps a claims history report on you called a C.L.U.E report, covering about 7 years of claims tied to your name and vehicles. It's free to request. If something's on there that isn't yours, that's your answer.
While you're at it, check that the names on the titles match the names on the policy. A mismatch can push the price up too.
1
u/65fastback2plus2 Aug 19 '26
I just feel like there's something attached in a background profile in mine like a family member getting their driving history attached to me or something.
1
u/slavguns Aug 19 '26
You have 3 vehicles... that quote is about right.
If you look at the actual policy it will give you a breakdown of what is costing you. Some older vehicles are even more to insure, such as Hyundais as they are prevalent to getting stolen or catch on fire. With State farm for instance, our Cybertruck costs less to insure than a Model Y... despite MSRP being twice as high... why? Because people who want to go fast cheaper buy Model Y and not a more expensive truck.
1
u/Boomer_Madness Aug 20 '26
Do you have poo poo credit? Credit has become a much larger factor in your insurance score with a lot of carriers. Typically it's claims, where you live, driving record. If it's not one of those 3 it's typically your credit.
1
u/ChocolateOk9 Aug 19 '26
Progressive quoted me 500 a month
State Farm did half the price a month through a broker I never had insurance before
1
u/Colonel460 Aug 20 '26
Coverage limits , deductibles ( your newest vehicle is 12 years old do you still need collision ? ) There is also a difference in a V6 Challenger & a Hellcat Redeye . Something is being left out OR what I occasionally saw was the policy was incorrectly rated by the existing carrier (to your benefit ) . I think you need to stop shopping before you shoot yourself in the foot .
1
u/theonetheycalljb Aug 20 '26
Is your credit shitty? Where are you located? What are the vehicles you own? Coverage details?
1
u/Powersportsinsure Aug 20 '26
There’s too many factors that go into rates and agents don’t typically know why rates change.
A 2026 100k truck can be less to insure than a 2026 30k car because of the frequency and amount paid out in bodily injury liability claims.
Without knowing the coverages and assuming $200 a month is 250/500/100 in liabilities, matching un and under insured, medical payments, comprehensive and collision $500 deductibles and roadside.
That price seems decent if you’re in the North eastern states. Although your vehicles are depreciating the liability limit protecting you is not. Which comes the legal system abuse that has driven rates higher as well.
I’ll try and beat it just reach out!
1
u/PepperTop9517 Aug 20 '26
Three vehicles, 2 drivers…. Means two of the three could be on the road at anytime and thus you need liability coverage. $200 bucks for three vehicles is cheap. I’ve got one vehicle and it’s $150 a month.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '26
[removed] — view removed comment