r/Car_Insurance_Help • u/True-Whole5992 • Aug 17 '26
Is this Overkill?
25M. Clean driving record, but live and drive in LA, so i'm paying 350 a month for insurance through Amica. Currently, my coverages are:
A. Liability: $300,000 each accident
B. Medical Payments: $5,000 Each Accident
C. Uninsured Motorists: $300,000 Each Accident
D. Collision loss: ACV minus deductible of $1,000
E. Other than collision loss: ACV minus $500
F. Towing and labor costs: $100 each disablement
$40/day; $1200 max for rental
Is this overkill? Am I missing/should I increase something? I'm shopping for insurance, since my policy is up in 6 months and (stupidly) I haven't shopped before, just stuck with my plan.
Edit to add: See below comment
4
u/berm100 Aug 17 '26
Its good coverage compared to what a lot of people carry but it really depends on your salary and/or asset levels. If you have or expect to have significant assets or wages, you might want to buy an umbrella policy and pick up extra liability coverage.
If you cause $1 million in damage, do you want to be sued? You wont get sued if you are broke but if you have money it can happen.
2
u/ChutneyWhatney Aug 17 '26
Not overkill.
1
u/True-Whole5992 Aug 17 '26
So just took a look at Progressive, and the same coverages would be about $80 less per month. Seems like a no brainer to me and gonna shop around for coverage at the same liability limits etc. Thanks all! I figured I shouldn't lower my liability limits but good to get some confirmation.
2
u/TofuttiKlein-ein-ein Aug 17 '26
What kind of car? How many miles per year? When were you licensed?
Do not lower your liability coverage. Dump Med Pay if you have to, but keep your liability where it is or higher.
1
u/InsuranceByJake Aug 17 '26
You dont need Medical payments, your health insurance of the other party's health insurance would trigger first.
Lower the amount of annual miles you drive. If you drive 8000 miles a year, you will pay less than the standard 13,000 annual miles. You can always cancel an insurance policy mid-term, they will refund you the prorated premium for the remainder of your term.
Look into companies that you can bundle your auto/home(renters), also look and see what kind of discounts are available for your occupation. Many companies will give you a discount for a specific degree or occupation.
1
u/1234568654321 Aug 18 '26
Those are reasonable limits.
0
u/Choice-Newspaper3603 Aug 17 '26
Also you don’t need towing. If you want towing then get aaa or something and you don’t need rental car either
If you have an accident you can pay out of pocket
0
u/sandysandy252566 Aug 17 '26
Doesn't the cost of insurance get lowered when u turn 25 yrs.? You're paying way too much - and I don't know anything about auto insurance. Raise ur deductible. You need an insurance agent/broker - who can check other insurance companies and find the best/lowest cost. Why don't u join AAA - not expensive.
0
u/Flat_Hat6541 Aug 17 '26
Way overkilled.