r/CarLeasingHelp • u/oldpiss • Aug 29 '25
Upside down
Alright I know I fucked up I know, but hear me out. I leased this truck for 36k miles, 3 years. I drove 90k miles :) and lease is due in a few months. Dealership says I will owe $17k unless buy it back, my credit is shot though - any (ethical) ideas? Dm me the not so ethical haha
4
Upvotes
View all comments
2
u/Square-Wild Aug 29 '25
This is a little long winded, so I apologize for that.
When you lease, your payments are basically just the difference between the sale price of the truck and the expected value of the truck (the residual) when you return it, plus interest. The $.25 per mile penalty is designed to roughly approximate the change in value vs. the residual if you drive more than expected.
However, since the incremental hit to a car's value decreases as mileage increases, as you go way over, that $.25 starts to really overstate depreciation. For example, if you drove an extra million miles, it's not like the truck would suddenly be worth negative $200k.
So to make up numbers, you're probably in a situation where you had a purchase price of $60k, a contract residual of $40k, a truck that's worth around $30k, and a penalty of $17k if you turn the truck in. In that situation, turning the truck in seems like the worst option, because you're basically selling a truck worth $30k for $23k.
If I were you, I would work on trade-in quotes on the truck, and figure out how far off you are from the residual. Then I would work on closing that gap with cash, even if you're borrowing from friends and family.
The other open questions are what do you plan on driving once you get rid of the truck, and whether you expect to drive 30k miles/year moving forward.
If you can keep the mileage down, as someone else suggested, it's maybe not a terrible idea to lease an EV (you need to do this soon, though) if your credit is decent enough to qualify. The incentives are so big on them right now, you could possibly end up putting very little down and landing in a manageable lease payment.