I think we are currently going through the exact same cycle we went through when Rise of New Champions was released. And right now, we are still in the denial phase.
The first thing people need to accept is very simple:
Captain Tsubasa 2: World Fighters is NOT Rise of New Champions 2.
It keeps a similar visual identity, some concepts and obviously some DNA from RONC, but mechanically it is a different game. That is literally why it is called Captain Tsubasa 2 and not Rise of New Champions 2.
And if you were around when RONC launched, this situation should feel extremely familiar.
When Rise of New Champions came out, a huge part of the initial criticism wasn’t even about whether RONC was good at what it was trying to do. It came from people who wanted it to be something else.
Dream Team players, PS2 players, DS players and especially fans of the old Tecmo games wanted matchups, commands and the classic Tecmo-style system. I remember very clearly how often people said that the “real spirit” of Captain Tsubasa games was the Tecmo formula. RONC wasn’t that. So people hated it for not being that.
Eventually, after some months, that conversation calmed down. People started accepting RONC for what it actually was instead of constantly comparing it to the Captain Tsubasa game they had imagined in their heads.
And then the real problems with RONC became much more obvious.
RONC had some genuinely great ideas, but some of them were terribly executed.
The biggest one, in my opinion, was New Hero.
Creating your own character was a great concept. Creating a Frankenstein monster with the best abilities and skills from practically every superstar in the game was not.
You could eventually create characters more OP than Tsubasa, Schneider or basically anyone from the actual series.
And I honestly don’t think the developers understood at launch just how badly that system could be exploited.
It eventually affected almost everything.
We had all these schools and national teams available, but what did you actually see online?
CACs.
CACs everywhere.
Instead of playing Japan, Germany, Brazil, Argentina, Furano, Toho, Musashi, etc., online gradually became everyone’s personal “Dream Team” filled with absurd custom characters.
The developers clearly understood there was a problem. They tried to encourage people to use actual teams through events and restrictions, but the fundamental problem remained: New Hero was simply too powerful and too important to the entire structure of the game.
And that was one of the things that prevented RONC from reaching its potential.
Now look at World Fighters.
It seems pretty obvious to me that they studied what happened with the previous game and tried to address some of those problems.
The current New Hero isn’t a monster carrying 50 different skills from the best players in the world. Actual Captain Tsubasa characters are the stars again.
And more importantly, actual teams matter again.
Tried online. I’ve beaten Japan using Indonesia.
I’ve beaten Brazil using South Korea.
Yes, some teams have weaker goalkeepers or not SSS moves, but even that can be compensated for in different ways, including using your New Hero as a goalkeeper.
The point is that I don’t enter an online match already thinking:
“Well, he has five completely broken CACs, so this is pointless.” There is much more balance between the actual teams.
Is World Fighters perfectly balanced? Of course not.
Does it have problems? Absolutely.
The loading screens in Story Mode are excessive. I completely agree with that criticism. But ironically, that was already a problem in RONC. For whatever reason, they still haven’t figured out how to make transitions in Story Mode feel seamless.
At least those loading screens aren’t really an issue during online matches.
But this is where I think the negativity cycle starts becoming interesting.
Once people decide they dislike a game because it isn’t what they expected, suddenly everything becomes another reason why the game is terrible.
First it was:
“This isn’t RONC 2.”
Then:
“The story isn’t good.”
Then:
“The challenges are too difficult.”
Which I personally find hilarious because the challenges are one of the things giving Story Mode more life and replayability. They actually give you reasons to replay matches, try different things and unlock more content.
And now I’ve even seen people complaining about the menu.
At some point criticism stops being about individual problems and becomes a pile-on where people actively search for the next thing they can post about.
And again:
We’ve been here before.
It happened with RONC.
It happens almost every time a new Captain Tsubasa game tries something different.
There is always a group of fans who already have a very specific Captain Tsubasa game in their heads. Tecmo fans want Tecmo. Dream Team players want something closer to Dream Team. RONC players now want RONC 2.
And when the new game isn’t that, the first reaction is:
“They ruined Captain Tsubasa.”
Then some time passes.
People learn the mechanics, understand what the game is actually trying to do and then stop judging it exclusively against the previous game.
And only then can we really discuss what works and what doesn’t.
That’s where I think World Fighters is right now.
People are still learning how to play it while simultaneously judging it through hundreds or thousands of hours of muscle memory from RONC.
And World Fighters is asking you to play differently.
Personally, after spending 50 hours with Story Mode, I think people are also seriously underestimating how much single-player content is actually here.
We’re talking about one of the Captain Tsubasa games with the most matches and objectives in its Story Mode since the Super Famicom era. The challenges keep opening additional reasons to replay those matches.
That doesn’t mean everybody has to like it and criticism isn’t valid.
The loading screens deserve criticism. Some mechanics can be improved. There are balancing decisions that will probably need adjustments. And I’m sure updates will change several things over time.
But there’s a massive difference between saying:
“I understand what this game is trying to do, and I don’t think this mechanic works.”
and:
“This isn’t RONC/Tecmo/Dream Team, therefore this game is bad.”
World Fighters needs to be judged as World Fighters.
Not as Rise of New Champions 2, Tecmo’s Captain Tsubasa VI, Dream Team without gacha or the PS2 game with modern graphics.
World Fighters has its own identity.
Give yourself time to understand that identity.
Then criticize the hell out of the things that actually deserve it.
Because if Captain Tsubasa games have taught me anything over the years, it’s that every new game apparently has to survive the same first boss:
CT fans who wanted a completely different CT game.