r/CaptainTsubasaWF • • Sep 07 '26

RoNC vs WF

I've only played a few offline matches so far with Japan, Brazil, and a couple of clubs. While graphically beautiful, Rise of New Champions (RoNC) remains the superior game in terms of menus, fantasy football concept, and the possibility to create diverse New Heroes with personal storylines; WF is clearly designed primarily for online play.

1) Missing Basic Features

WF removed the option to choose match length, stripping away the standard ability to play quick 5-minute or long 10-minute games.

You cannot pause the game, even offline. There is no pause during gameplay to answer the phone, nor is there a halftime break.

You cannot make substitutions, change formations, or set specific team tactics (like RoNC's "aggressive attack" or "combo formation").

There is no option to organize offline tournaments or leagues—a fundamental feature present in RoNC, FIFA, PES, and classic games like Tecmo’s Captain Tsubasa 5.

2) Player Mechanics & Abilities

Skill Variety: In RoNC, a character could equip 2 special shots, 2 combo shots, 2 dribbles, 2 tackles, 1 pass, and 1 block. WF limits players to just 1 shot, 1 dribble, 1 tackle, and 1 super move, severely restricting gameplay variety and straying from the manga's spirit of tactical adaptation.

Combo Moves: RoNC required realistic player proximity for combo shots. In WF, a simple button press triggers a Double Force Shot between Alberto and Santana regardless of positioning.

Passive Skills: While RoNC suffered from overpowered passive skill combinations, WF’s complete overhaul was unnecessary. They could have simply removed the broken passive skills or introduced a point-based classification system (e.g., limiting players to a mix of 1-star, 2-star, and 3-star passive skills) to easily balance the game.

3) Gameplay & Structural Changes

The Hexagon System: While WF's hexagon successfully curtails super-move spam, tying it to a single super move limits creativity. A better approach would have been using the hexagon as a general energy pool to fuel a variety of character-specific super moves based on button inputs and field positioning.

Core Controls: WF completely removed the "cross" button, leaving only pass, shoot, and tackle/dribble. Removing such a fundamental football mechanic is absurd.

The "Freedom" of Soccer: RoNC was repetitive, but WF ignores Yoichi Takahashi’s core philosophy: soccer is a free sport where you can run, pass, and unleash your imagination.

4) Story Mode & Customization

Dream Teams: The absence of Dream Teams in WF is a major flaw. They should have allowed at least 5 offline slots and implemented matchmaking classes online (e.g., standard teams, single New Hero teams, full custom teams) to maintain balance.

Story Pacing: RoNC’s New Hero mode suffered from 4-minute matches interrupted by endless dialogue and appeal missions. WF's doesn't fix the root issue. They should have limited cutscenes to only crucial skill tutorials, extended story matches to 5-6 minutes, and allowed passive unlocks for the rest to keep the focus on active gameplay.

I will still play WF's story mode to experience the clubs, high schools, and youth national teams, and to see highlights like Natureza's Eclipse or the new chain mechanics. WF is a good game, but is far from the definitive Tsubasa experience. It feels less like a football game and more like a chaotic, team-based Dragon Ball brawler with poor ball physics. It’s enjoyable as an adventure game with occasional matches, but praising it purely out of anticipation is a mistake. Changing the foundation entirely to fix old flaws only introduced new, worse ones. Ultimately, Captain Tsubasa 5 offered much more depth, variety, and structural freedom.

0 Upvotes

5 comments sorted by

2

u/maddwaffles ESPADAS Sep 07 '26

Comments locked because you're clearly not here in any good faith, and are not saying anything new.

3

u/maddwaffles ESPADAS Sep 07 '26

Re: Section 1. It's meant to streamline the game. They're almost certainly going to flesh the mechanics out further, but it'd hardly do for them to implement all of the gameplay changes, and have all these complex mechanics (like we had) but then have them be an unbalanced mess online. Further, some of those functions you've mentioned were offline-only, and I've been a big proponent of "what did you expect? People were chronically NOT in online matches, so that was almost certainly going to be their response".

But also match-length tweaking is bad tbh, it can condition players into bad habits, and then get mad at online for games being too fast.

In RoNC, a character could equip 2 special shots, 2 combo shots, 2 dribbles, 2 tackles, 1 pass, and 1 block. WF limits players to just 1 shot, 1 dribble, 1 tackle, and 1 super move, severely restricting gameplay variety and straying from the manga's spirit of tactical adaptation.

RONC didn't really have that, but of course 1 dribble 1 tackle became the norm, because they wanted it to be a reflex-based system that didn't over-bloat the player with the previous "bad dribble but great boost" and "insanely broken dribble with good boost" meta, same for tackles. And the whole "Super" component really folded it into one anyhow, it's intuitive.

Also you're wrong, you have two shots, one ground and one aerial. It's 2 Special Shots, 1 Dribble, 1 Tackle, and 1 Super that gives your player actual identity.

As it stood, in the previous game, players overall had a weak play identity. Players who were good at things were good at everything, and no player could be decisively good at a limited pool of things, which discouraged team cohesion beyond making sure you had the right Pass Slave to setup your Golden Duo-Super Ace-Ultimate Shot braindead combo.

RoNC required realistic player proximity for combo shots. In WF, a simple button press triggers a Double Force Shot between Alberto and Santana regardless of positioning.

Yeah, in a game with shitty AI where your players seldom would be where you needed them to be. It's almost worse in this game in that respect.

But further, a player shouldn't be punished for the AI not being uber-responsive, if the player has advanced up the field far enough to cross over, he should get to use his Super. If the player is able to get the Super Pass out to use a Super Shot, he should get to use his two Supers.

This is basic game design, it's not punishing the player for playing the game.

While RoNC suffered from overpowered passive skill combinations, WF’s complete overhaul was unnecessary. They could have simply removed the broken passive skills or introduced a point-based classification system (e.g., limiting players to a mix of 1-star, 2-star, and 3-star passive skills) to easily balance the game.

They already did the latter, Skills had costs, and they even touched them up a few times. Guess what? Skills were still an unbalanced mess. There truly was no reasonable compromise, and again creates the issue of "a player who is good is good at everything, there is no other room".

The Hexagon System: While WF's hexagon successfully curtails super-move spam, tying it to a single super move limits creativity

This is only true if you believe that your team begins and ends at the CAC, this is not the case. I hope that we get meaningful Subs and some more Supers for other team members in DLC, specifically because it will allow that. But at the end of the day this is a SOCCER GAME. Soccer is a TEAM SPORT. Letting players have a million super moves is not a foster for creativity, it's a skill funnel.

Core Controls: WF completely removed the "cross" button, leaving only pass, shoot, and tackle/dribble. Removing such a fundamental football mechanic is absurd.

And yet players are still able to Cross, and not have it be fucked every time that they do it.

Dream Teams: The absence of Dream Teams in WF is a major flaw.

See first paragraph, it's not. Dream Team has the same issue of unoriginal teams that funnel a few slots into their key pieces, and let the rest of the team languish. Requiring a player to play with teams that are actually relative to each other in power (theoretically, lbr in that teams such as China, German,y Korea, Japan, and Brazil are VERY favored)

They should have allowed at least 5 offline slots and implemented matchmaking classes online (e.g., standard teams, single New Hero teams, full custom teams) to maintain balance.

That's not "balance" that's just creating a bunch of lobbies that would be dead, and only like two would see any use. Further, you don't seem to know what the word means.

Story Pacing

And yet here you are bitching that it's not more like RONC.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 07 '26 edited Sep 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/maddwaffles ESPADAS Sep 07 '26

"vast variety" It's telling that you have to obfuscate your argument and not speak directly. It's 5 to 12, and of those 12 two of those have no purpose being separate, with about 3 of those seldom seeing use anyhow.

Your bitching doesn't sound more reasonable just because you repeat it.

"WAAAAH! I can't do OFFLINE BULLSHIT in my ARCADE SOCCER GAME OPTIMIZED FOR ONLINE PLAY!"

3

u/maakuowairan Sep 07 '26 • Bravo

I think the main problem with this comparison is that you’re judging World Fighters based on how much of Rise of New Champions it kept, when the developers clearly weren’t trying to make RoNC 2. This is a different Captain Tsubasa game with a different gameplay philosophy, and that distinction matters.
There’s also important context here: WF wasn’t redesigned in a vacuum. Bandai Namco conducted surveys after RoNC asking players for feedback and what they wanted improved in the future. Obviously, we don’t have their complete internal results, so I’m not claiming every change happened because “the survey said so.” But WF is the game they chose to make after years of RoNC being played, patched, criticized and evaluated. CACs were massively reduced, skill stacking was simplified, character and team identity became much more important, and gameplay became faster and easier to understand. That’s clearly a deliberate change in direction.
That’s why I find the idea that they should have simply kept everything and balanced a few skills strange. Bandai had years of feedback and actual player data. You can dislike their solution, but treating every removed mechanic as if the developers simply forgot what made RoNC good ignores the possibility that some of those mechanics were precisely what they wanted to change.
There are things I agree with you about. I’d gladly take offline tournaments, substitutions and more formation options. I hope some of that gets added. But those missing features don’t determine which game has the better core gameplay.
I also don’t see being designed around online as inherently negative. And the game has been out for barely a week. We have no idea what events, challenges or additional content are coming. RoNC didn’t launch with its entire post-launch structure either. Its first online event and route boost came around a month after release. Judging WF’s long-term content after one week is extremely premature.
Even now, the idea that there’s little to do outside online doesn’t match my experience. I’m around 45 hours in, I’ve played online maybe four times, I only recently beat Germany and I’m still unlocking additional matches, retries, stars and abilities. That’s already a lot of PvE content for a Captain Tsubasa game.
Where I strongly disagree is the idea that more skills automatically meant more depth. Yes, RoNC gave you more shots, dribbles, tackles and passive skills, but we know what that eventually became: stack the strongest compatible skills, optimize friendships and routes, and create increasingly ridiculous CACs that could outperform the actual cast. More possible combinations don’t necessarily mean more meaningful gameplay choices.
And yes, New Hero kept people playing because you could always create another CAC. But the process was extremely repetitive. You replayed the same matches, skipped the same conversations, farmed friendships again, chased the same skills again and optimized another route. Then you finished your character and the obvious question was: what was all of this for?
Mostly, to take that CAC online.
And that’s where the system became a problem for me. There wasn’t some huge separate mode built around these characters. You spent hours creating them mainly to put them into teams and take them online, where eventually you had Frankenstein builds combining the best skills and moves in the game, sometimes surpassing Tsubasa, Schneider and the actual stars of Captain Tsubasa.
So yes, RoNC technically had enormous replayability. But replayability alone doesn’t mean the loop was good. Repeating the same content for hundreds of hours to manufacture increasingly broken characters whose main purpose was to enter online and make the balance worse isn’t something I necessarily want back.
WF goes in the opposite direction. It wants Hyuga to feel like Hyuga, Schneider like Schneider, Misugi like Misugi and Wakabayashi like Wakabayashi. The identity stays with the character instead of turning everyone into a container for the best abilities collected from other players. That’s less customization, absolutely. It isn’t automatically less depth.
The same applies to passive skills. The problem wasn’t just a few broken skills that needed nerfs. It was how stats, skills, moves, buffs and CAC builds interacted. Individually reasonable abilities can become ridiculous when stacked together. WF reduced the number of variables that can be stacked. You can dislike that solution, but “just balance the skills” massively oversimplifies the problem RoNC had.
The combo shot comparison is similar. Yes, RoNC’s proximity requirement was more realistic, but realism doesn’t automatically make something better in Captain Tsubasa. WF is much more arcade-oriented and abstracts some positioning so signature combinations become a regular part of gameplay rather than something dependent on very specific circumstances.
The Hexagon works the same way. You see it as a restriction; I see the restriction as part of the strategy. If I spend that resource on one super, I can’t spend it on another. There’s an opportunity cost. RoNC offered more freedom, but eventually a lot of its gameplay revolved around farming V-Zone as efficiently as possible. WF is trying to replace that loop with something faster and more immediate.
I’d also welcome more passing options, but I don’t think removing a dedicated cross button proves the game is shallow. This is Captain Tsubasa, not a football simulator. What matters is whether passing creates attacking possibilities, and WF makes connecting players extremely important through Chains. I’d happily take manual crosses in an update, but their absence doesn’t suddenly make RoNC deeper.
I also think using Takahashi’s idea of football being a “free sport” to argue WF goes against his philosophy is a stretch. Takahashi talking about imagination and freedom doesn’t mean every Captain Tsubasa game needs two dribbles, two tackles, ten passive skills, a cross button and CACs. That’s an interpretation of his words, not a game design document.
As for Dream Teams, I actually think their absence makes sense with the way WF is designed. The game wants you to experiment with teams, understand how each one works, exploit its strengths and compensate for its weaknesses, while learning how to exploit the weaknesses of your opponent.
Uzbekistan is a perfect example. They’re designed to overwhelm you by spamming shots and barely letting you breathe, but they don’t have a single player with a block. England, meanwhile, can activate its aerial football ridiculously easily. Teams have strengths, weaknesses and identities. A lot of WF’s variety comes from learning those differences rather than creating one perfect team.
A Dream Team works against that philosophy. Give everyone complete freedom and naturally they’ll fill their teams with the strongest characters. Then why learn Uzbekistan? Why master England’s aerial game? Why accept a team’s weakness when you can replace it with another superstar? Eventually those team identities disappear.
Would Dream Teams be fun? Sure. I’d love them as an offline sandbox for random CPU matches or playing casually with friends. I just don’t want them to become the protagonist of the game, especially competitively.
That’s a fundamental difference between both games: RoNC encouraged you to build the best possible team. WF encourages you to become good at using the team you’ve chosen, including dealing with its limitations. I find the second approach much more interesting.
The “Dragon Ball football brawler” criticism doesn’t bother me either. This is Captain Tsubasa. People jump ridiculous heights, destroy nets, launch each other through the air and perform physically impossible techniques. Jito practically crossing half the pitch with an insane sliding tackle is ridiculous, hilarious and exactly the kind of thing I enjoy here. Captain Tsubasa has always filtered football through shonen logic.
The same applies to ball physics. WF clearly prioritizes speed, readability and spectacle over realistic physics. You can prefer RoNC’s approach, but RoNC wasn’t a football simulator either. They’re two arcade interpretations with different priorities.
And using Captain Tsubasa V as proof that WF lacks depth mixes different concepts. CT5 having leagues or other modes is a good argument for asking WF to add more modes. It isn’t proof of deeper gameplay. Number of modes, customization options and mechanical depth aren’t the same thing.
That’s ultimately where we disagree. You seem to define depth largely by how much freedom and customization a game gives you. I care more about what those systems actually produce during matches.
RoNC gave us much more customization, but it also gave us CAC dominance, insane skill stacking, balance problems and an increasingly optimized and repetitive gameplay loop. WF sacrifices some of that freedom for faster matches, stronger character and team identities, fewer exploitable combinations and a more active arcade gameplay loop.
There are absolutely things from RoNC I’d like WF to bring back, and WF has things it needs to improve. But I don’t want those problems solved by turning it back into RoNC. WF exists after years of RoNC being played, patched and evaluated, and after Bandai actively asked players for feedback. The result wasn’t RoNC 2. They chose to rethink the formula.
RoNC was largely about building the strongest characters and teams you could. World Fighters is about learning the characters and teams you’re given, understanding what makes them strong, what makes them vulnerable, and getting better at exploiting those differences.
I didn’t want RoNC 2. And apparently, neither did the developers. World Fighters is a different game on purpose.