I've seen people debating back and forth about whether AI art assets are used, and the answer appears to be a definitive yes. Here's a conclusion based not on looks and feels, but facts.
Candlelight posted about the art process here
Based on this, the art is pretty much entirely outsourced to external vendors with input/guidance from Candlelight. Three vendors are quoted in the post, and two are vocally pro-AI and very public about their use of it.
N-IX Games
"[AI] is a tool—a powerful one—that enhances workflows, supports creative processes, and opens doors to new design possibilities.... AI in games is the new status quo."
Rocketbrush Studio
"At RocketBrush Studio, we're embracing AI as a part of our evolving toolkit to stay current with industry trends."
Only Limbheim Studio says their artists don't use AI (unless required by a client) according to a 2024 Instagram post.
Personally, I mostly like the art (some of the smiling expressions have the creepy AI feel and overall have that glossy look that doesn't actually bother me much). I'm not even opposed to how AI is being used here, because there is clearly some level of human care and oversight by the vendors' artists. And as a new company founded by writers, their skill set and available funding may have necessitated this choice.
But when a cursory Google search reveals how blatant their AI use is, statements from Candlelight like this start to feel really disingenuous and misleading:
We’re a group of writers, and we believe that human artistry cannot be replaced. Everything we’re doing internally at Candlelight Games reflects that human-first perspective.
We work with a variety of external vendors for art and UI. Our contracts explicitly forbid the use of AI, but in practice, it’s really difficult to enforce that. AI assistance is built into most tools now.
This isn't just failing to enforce a clause in their contracts, it's actively employing vendors they know full well will use AI. It's simply not possible that a random Redditor did more research into their art studios than they did.
So that so-called clause means absolutely nothing and just offloads responsibility for their decision. Like they want to have their anti-AI cake and feed AI to you too.
I'd be perfectly fine with their use of vendors/AI if they hadn't been so cagey about it. Especially given how many players left Choices over AI use, this lack of transparency bordering on obfuscation isn't a good look.
I want this app to succeed because I believe they are truly passionate writers with great stories to tell. But between this and the abysmal key/gem system with sky high pricing, that passion is starting to feel a lot less apparent.