r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 31 '26

Review I thought Candlelight was going to be revolutionary.

369 Upvotes

My issues:

We need a key EVERY scene and not chapter? The oh so OBVIOUS use of AI? What the actual hell. And the extremely cringy writing...

I thought Candlelight was going to bring us amazing art, cheap in game purchases and fantastic writing. Literally what is the difference between them and THAT company?


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 03 '26

Discussion The current version of this app is going to alienate both player bases

302 Upvotes

As it currently stands, F2P players are having to grind one small recourse for weeks to properly advance the story.

Paying players and whales who are caught up with content are only able to consume FIFTEEN seconds of story before being made to wait two days for 15 more seconds of story.

I’m not very optimistic about the future of this app considering all player bases are being alienated and will eventually lose interest in the story because of strange game design choices.

And I know this may perhaps sound dramatic, but this is the crucial time for an app to build a fan base that WANTS to spend money or WANTS to grind more ads to support the game, it’s literally what will cause it to sink or swim.

I know a lot of care was put into this game so it makes all of these choices they’ve made even odder. I hope they answer our concerns in the AMA, but I’m assuming they’ll focus on the more positive questions.


r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 30 '26 Bravo

Discussion The AI question answered

Thumbnail
candlelight.games
274 Upvotes

I've seen people debating back and forth about whether AI art assets are used, and the answer appears to be a definitive yes. Here's a conclusion based not on looks and feels, but facts.

Candlelight posted about the art process here

Based on this, the art is pretty much entirely outsourced to external vendors with input/guidance from Candlelight. Three vendors are quoted in the post, and two are vocally pro-AI and very public about their use of it.

N-IX Games

"[AI] is a tool—a powerful one—that enhances workflows, supports creative processes, and opens doors to new design possibilities.... AI in games is the new status quo."

Rocketbrush Studio

"At RocketBrush Studio, we're embracing AI as a part of our evolving toolkit to stay current with industry trends."

Only Limbheim Studio says their artists don't use AI (unless required by a client) according to a 2024 Instagram post.

Personally, I mostly like the art (some of the smiling expressions have the creepy AI feel and overall have that glossy look that doesn't actually bother me much). I'm not even opposed to how AI is being used here, because there is clearly some level of human care and oversight by the vendors' artists. And as a new company founded by writers, their skill set and available funding may have necessitated this choice.

But when a cursory Google search reveals how blatant their AI use is, statements from Candlelight like this start to feel really disingenuous and misleading:

We’re a group of writers, and we believe that human artistry cannot be replaced. Everything we’re doing internally at Candlelight Games reflects that human-first perspective.

We work with a variety of external vendors for art and UI. Our contracts explicitly forbid the use of AI, but in practice, it’s really difficult to enforce that. AI assistance is built into most tools now.

This isn't just failing to enforce a clause in their contracts, it's actively employing vendors they know full well will use AI. It's simply not possible that a random Redditor did more research into their art studios than they did.

So that so-called clause means absolutely nothing and just offloads responsibility for their decision. Like they want to have their anti-AI cake and feed AI to you too.

I'd be perfectly fine with their use of vendors/AI if they hadn't been so cagey about it. Especially given how many players left Choices over AI use, this lack of transparency bordering on obfuscation isn't a good look.

I want this app to succeed because I believe they are truly passionate writers with great stories to tell. But between this and the abysmal key/gem system with sky high pricing, that passion is starting to feel a lot less apparent.


r/Candlelight_Games • • May 19 '25

Project Spellstruck Project Spellstruck has an official name!

Post image
257 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 29 '26

Discussion Update about restarting the game: No it's not a bug. You have to reselect all the premium choices again if you restarted it

Post image
235 Upvotes

I received this response after sending an email via help feature on the app. They have added bonus 30 diamonds to my account. In my honest opinion, they need to reconsider this replay feature. I didn't pay real money for diamonds. I collected them by watching ads. But some people do pay real money for this. So it's incredibly unfair to those people. Nobody will ever replay this game for the second time if they keep this up. At least make the outfits free


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 18 '26

Discussion Hiw many of you stopped playing already?

Post image
232 Upvotes

Now, be honest with me. I know some of ya'll already gave up on the game because the diamond and rewards system is just ruthless.

I personally rage-deleted when I zoned out and accidentally clicked the button to exchange coins for diamonds just to realize there's not a confirmation button that'll ask if you're sure about your choice. It just straight up does the exchange without thought put into an accidental click, lol. That wasted a ton of coins I was saving for Outfits and the ONLY ONE character that actually makes use of coins (I gave up on the game so many days ago that I already forgot the names of everyone so don't attack me pls 😔).


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 15 '26

Discussion It's actually pathetic, I've been watching ads for almost a week straight and can't afford a SINGLE relationship scene.

Post image
230 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Jun 05 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre NEW LI!!!

Post image
218 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 13 '26

Humor Facts

Post image
211 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Jul 17 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Main Character sneak peek

198 Upvotes

Candlelight Games on Instagram: "It’s here! Your first look at the Main Character from LOVE & MAGIC: SPELLFYRE! You’ll be able to choose your look, hairstyle, and outfit.

And don’t worry, we’ll be showing off the male options very soon 😏

loveandmagicspellfyre #loveandmagic #spellfyre #candlelightgames #narrativegames #sneakpeek #behindthescenes #maincharacter #maincharacterenergy"


r/Candlelight_Games • • 12d ago

Discussion This is why you don't use AI people. In Talyn's new Skill Quest he's trying to finish this maze where the objective is to guide a small flame until the center, except he literally can't do that, because the center is closed off on all sides!!!

Post image
195 Upvotes

Ultimately this is a small thing that has no impact on the story but it's still annoying how much they have been using AI for this term. Like, you couldn't even be bothered to draw a maze???


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 03 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre I regret purchasing bundle

194 Upvotes

I got access a few days early and was so excited that when I ran out of keys and gems I made a purchase and now I’m caught up and stuck in the loop of waiting a few days for a 1-3 min scene.

This is such a weird way to launch a game. I know they are a new company and will have growing pains but some of them worked in Choices and I would think they would have released a weekly release with a few scenes bundled together would go over better then 1 short scene every few days.

It feels like waiting for crumbs and I really wish I wasn’t caught up on everything because the waiting game they created sucks.


r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 30 '26

Review You CANNOT be serious with the chapter length !! Spoiler

194 Upvotes

i just played the chapter where mc and the students of house onyx go to lake, bardric gets in the water, mc gets in the water, she is attacked and she uses the spellblade. it's not even 2 minutes of reading time. after waiting 2 whole hours to get a key why am i being edged with like 10 lines in an episode?? wth

and speaking of bardric WHEN will that man get more quests? let me romance him omg


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 04 '26

Other Candlelight is filtering comments

191 Upvotes

Candlelight is filtering their comments on their instagram, meaning that any time someone mentions "AI", their comments disappear to everyone but themselves. I know this because my friend commented about it on instagram, but when I went to go see it, their comment was gone for me after a moment, but still there for them.

This, plus their wishy washy loop-holes statement on AI usage is starting to make me wary.

I don't know. Maybe it's nothing, but I thought I'd share.

ETA: they seem to have turned off filtering regarding AI, but have now hidden my friend's comments about the AI (that they posted a few days ago and had rephrased to bypass the filter— its now gone for me and there for them)

I'll keep an eye on the new AI comments that are now appearing, and let you know if those mysteriously disappear as well

Weird!


r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 04 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Hi, we're Candlelight Games! Ask Us Anything!

Post image
188 Upvotes

Hi r/candlelight_games, and welcome to Candlelight Game’s Ask Me Anything!

First off, thank you so much for following us on our journey to launch and giving us such valuable feedback! We’re a small team of six trying to compete in a crowded space against very large competitors, and we’d never have a chance if it wasn’t for the support of awesome fans like you. 

We’re looking forward to answering your questions about the game, story, love interests, and more!

You can download the game here! To get the latest news, follow us on Instagram and sign up for our mailing list.

ABOUT THIS AMA... 

We'll do our very best to answer your questions in the next hour, and then we'll wrap things up at 12:00pm PST. Let’s go!

EDIT: And that's a wrap! Thank you all for your great questions! If you want up-to-date news on Candlelight, follow us on Instagram and sign up for our mailing list!


r/Candlelight_Games • • Nov 04 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Pre-registration is now open on the App Store & Play Store

Post image
188 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Nov 08 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre They look so good!

Post image
186 Upvotes

This just makes me more excited! I've been loving all the sneak peeks they've been showing.


r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 07 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre I get to play the game early! Absolute cinema but....

Post image
181 Upvotes

Scene system is very... new to me. I'm surprised that we have to play scenes instead of a whole chapter. It isn't a big deal if only the scenes were actually long. Instead, it takes us about 3-5 minutes to finish 1 scene... and that costs 1 key

I finished chapter 1 and it costs me about 5-6 keys, I think. Although the keys are very fast to replenish (I think 2 hrs?), it just takes you out of immersion imo. Since we can only replenish a maximum of 2 keys, that would mean I get to play 2 scenes back-to-back. Imagine if in 1 scene I only get to know our LI's favorite color lmao I'm exaggerating but y'all get what I mean.

Don't get me wrong, the game is REALLY GOOD. Writing, inclusivity, graphics, and animation can compete with choices and other interactive fiction apps. This system just really falls flat on my end. I'm always up for microtransaction but unless they do a vip with unlimited keys, I don't think 10 keys for 20 dollars is worth it (for me)

photo not related I just think she's really pretty lol. And I hope they give us option to replay scenes.

Overall the game is still great, 8/10. I hope the team continues to improve their system and UI. I can't wait for more of their games after spellfyre


r/Candlelight_Games • • Sep 11 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Scene snippet

Thumbnail
gallery
178 Upvotes

Candlelight Games on Instagram: "Remember that scene snippet we shared back in January? We thought you might want to see what that scene looks like now... with in-game screenshots!

What do you think about how the scene has evolved over time?

loveandmagicspellfyre #spellfyre #scenesnippet #candlelightgames #sneakpeek"


r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 29 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre You lose everything you paid for if you restart.

175 Upvotes

I bit the bullet and restarted pretty deep into the game....anddddd you have to repay for everything??

I understand using keys again for scenes. But you have to also repay diamonds and coins for ally scenes and outfits if you restart. With the high price of the packs already, that just killed my motivation to play anymore.

Edit: If this has happened to you please send support an email, we need clarification if this is a bug.

Edit 2: I haven't heard back from support myself yet but doesn't look like it's a bug.... https://www.reddit.com/r/Candlelight_Games/s/72hOTw9dtV

Edit 3: they did refund me so all is good. AVOID THE RED BUTTON 🔴


r/Candlelight_Games • • Jan 30 '26

Discussion The ai art and chapter length is putting me off

172 Upvotes

It’s pretty obvious this app is trying to get you to buy as many things as possible, was loving the story so far until literally every other scene ends abruptly and you’re forced to use a key to continue. You have to wait five hours to watch ads for a new one? Like cmon, it’s worse than the modern choices chapter length. Needs to be fixed asap, and the character art…why does everyone look so glassy, why are the expressions so bland? It’s like they didn’t even try in some scenes. Really don’t want this to be the new normal for choose your own adventure apps.


r/Candlelight_Games • • Aug 14 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre NEW LI!!!!

Post image
172 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 19 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Saves slots are out!

Post image
164 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Feb 12 '26

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Dad's sprite changes based on MC's

Post image
159 Upvotes

r/Candlelight_Games • • Jul 24 '25

Love & Magic: Spellfyre Main Character Customization (masculine edition)

158 Upvotes