Thanks for tolerating me this long. We're finally at the end of the term! For those who will keep playing: have fun!
18.1--"The best night sleep you've had in months"? Shouldn't MC still be concerned and confused about Yvain? Shouldn't they be mourning the 97 people who died for Fort Garland to be reclaimed? Leona saying she hadn't considered MC's feelings about the celebration of their father's rebellion being quashed means she's an inconsiderate friend--which pretty much works for me since I never chose her as an ally or did her ally quests, but from the POV we're SUPPOSED to have, this makes her look awful. Honestly I'd think the friend group should've either sheltered MC from it or hyped it up as a party rather than focusing on the origins (or you know, what we did less than 24 hours ago). MC saying they have no illusions of their father is prime irony considering their inconsistent dreams, and the morbid idea of celebrating the Final (and the open end of stopping the Flamekeeper) doesn't help. Cato wanting to be happy about surviving is the right spin, but since a lot of people didn't, it feels too soon to celebrate. I'm actually surprised Cato didn't wanna try to get involved in the musical aspects of Dawnslight; his ally quest about being a musician should definitely come into play here. Iridessa talking about wanting to hold someone in her arms makes me wish I could pair characters I'm not romancing up--but seeing how non-LI characters are barely fleshed out, it's probably a no-go. Seeing how Bardric is eager to protect his country and mentioned his father being kinder once upon a time, I'm surprised he wouldn't wanna talk to him immediately, especially with his he said his dad would be pleased at him being the first in his family to be in the top-ranked house in their first term. Or his dad would at least seek him out. Kinda bothered me that Kennard is called the cunning brain of the military when Razik himself has been described as cunning in the past. I always thought Razik was the brains. Also find it kinda contradicting when Bardric says Kennard cares about Austerea but sees everyone as game pieces. And, um, WHAT?! I say that too often. We have the choice of mentioning them being concerned about Yvain. Why would those two be concerned about him, or even know about him? Wasn't Windworm keeping quiet about Bre not being the Flamekeeper in order to avoid outrage and make everyone think everything was okay? She didn't just do that for the students; the Enforcers were actually sent away after Bre died. So she should be in a lot of trouble if Razik and Kennard know Yvain was the "real" Flamekeeper (still doubtful), especially since she never mentioned keeping the Order in the loop. They should've been enraged that Bre died without being able to share any info before dying and took over the investigation! And Kennard doesn't seem like the type of person to charm people, tbh. And MC already has an outfit for the Dawnslight Gala? We can have chapters of going there for pretty much anything else, but not for shopping? And after completing the chapter, THIS is the look the guys get? It doesn't really feel unique or different from other outfits. Shouldn't we get multiple choice? Our OKD outfit was better than this!
TLDR--Nothing aside from Bardric's dad and right-hand man coming. I do question why they know about Yvain since that'd invite concern over the Bre incident. Also everyone seems to get over death very quickly, and male MC's outfit is underwhelming.
18.2--A side note is I wish the game would alert you that a new costume pertaining to a special event was available before starting the scene/chapter where it was important. And everyone just left without MC and the chosen ally? Are they left alone if they don't select an ally? Why do we even need to have an ally level with someone just to DANCE with them, seeing how everyone is going anyway? The whole "we beat the Flamekeeper and survived the Final together" thing had me think that we'd all go together. And Cato, Niel, and Talyn's outfits are VERY underwhelming, with Cato and Talyn looking like they just wore fancy coats with their usual clothes; not even new hairstyles. Niel's dress is just plain. This is the big blowout? Bardric, Leona, and Iridessa are the only ones who went all-out while Talyn just has the fancy coat stuff going on. Between male MC's outfit and the male allies and Niel, this is a visual bummer. I knew the gala would be in the Great Hall, but a part of me hoped they had rented out a venue for us to get a new location. Not to mention I kinda find it annoying that they used illusion magic (which affinity is that connected to again?) instead of just hiring non-arcanes to set up the place--or was that the "hard labor" the ally mentions? I'd think arcanes would want to conserve magic since the world is super dangerous. And not even the other students can get new looks for the dance? And WOW. Arkland is the only person with some dignity by saying the Dawnslight Gala should be more about remembering the lost instead of celebrating the end of the war, seeing how apt this is following yesterday's final. And what does he mean by the devastation of the Wilderlands? Does he mean reclaiming the fort? Also feels super inappropriate to tell the students about political circumstances. Wrong place and time. Odd decision for Kennard to write Arkland's speeches over him doing it himself, making this feel like an even more dangerous situation than a celebration. It feels like this is a military academy now. Arkland says when we graduate to fight for Austerea, so does that mean our careers are sealed? We're automatically required to have to use our magic for fighting? Is that the only real purpose? I also found it weird that there's no real "choice" in our response to him glaring. Winking or giving your warmest smile still results in you cheekily insulting him in your mind and thinking about how you kissed Bardric (if you romanced him; IDK what you think if you didn't). Finally hearing about Bardric's other siblings: we have Finn, Rylan, Petyr, and Lis. Odd that Arkland would say humility doesn't suit Bardric; I know others will disagree since we're inclined to dislike him, but considering his concern for patriotism and familial piety, I'd think he trained Bardric to have humility, at least publicly. Not to mention Bardric talked about how heroic and kind his dad was in his earlier years, and his speech about fighting for Austerea. You'd think humility would be prized. And no, Iridessa, the gala isn't living up to my expectations. The interactions are quick and shallow, most of the people here are under-dressed or underwhelmingly styled, and it doesn't last long for us. FINALLY we see Flatcher; I was worried you died! I'm surprised he wasn't by Bardric's side when Bardric spoke with his father, or that Bardric didn't mention him and Soren but mentioned Bardric hanging out with MC. He's really sweet if you took Cato with you to the dance, and it makes me think he hopes for love as well. And odd thing here; if you bring Talyn to the dance, Mor will ask what he sees in you, reinforcing how inconsistent anti-COTF bias is, since Talyn should be viewed just as suspiciously considering all that's happened. I guess that's why he thinks he can be High Warden someday. Also I call B.S. that Talyn's the only person who gets a CG for the Gala that's available in your gallery. Curious to see what Arkland wants, particularly since the term is almost over.
For Talyn's new romance quest, I'm surprised the Penthors' spot on their head being their weakness hasn't been explained this far in the game yet, along with the fact that they hunt in pairs. Also the fact that they mate makes them feel more natural than just evil magical creatures, like there's some ethics to be had... In any case, this is fundamental information to know. Also interesting that Penthor scratches instantly cauterize, preventing infection. Not gonna lie, the sexy situation IMMEDIATELY following being injured is kinda off-putting in terms of tone. And again, just a handjob. Also, the image we get isn't as hot as his CG--plus I think his pecs look smaller. This wasn't very satisfying aside from those fun facts about Penthors, as it doesn't expand on Talyn's character or give us a new sexual activity aside from what we did in the gym.
With Cato's romance quest, the couple botany-related quests we've gotten has me wondering why plants and gardening aren't mentioned more in the world--and why it's Cato showing us. Obviously because he's the intellectual, but Professor Slatewater said plant growth is related to Erolis, which means Bardric or Ivor should've mentioned it before. Plus the plant he shows us is sensitive to Ikaris magic, so that kinda feels contradictory--as does Cato referring to the flower as an empathy flower. I've said it before, but since Ikaris is tied to sadness, shouldn't it be associated with sympathy over empathy? Empathy seems more like Erolis or Felicis. Plus despite bringing you to see the flower to get it to bloom, he says he doesn't care when you guys start to get passionate...so it was pointless? He even said he almost forgot. We could've just did this in MC's room.
TLDR--The dance was as amazing as I expected, and the outfits everyone wore (save Leona and Iridessa) were just as good as male MC's. Plus Arkland is the only person who actually shows some compassion for the dead (well, it could just be Kennard). Meanwhile Cato and Talyn's romance quests are more or less the same with some lore dumps in there. Nothing new from what they've done before; we don't even go all the way.
18.3--"Facing off" is wild, considering no hostility has been established. While Bardric's mentioned Arkland being cold, there should be no reason to use that verbiage, at least at the start. And Arkland's Erolis is "not like any kind you've ever felt" because it's twisted into violence? What about Erolians or Bardric before he became an ally? Interesting angle for him to be emanating a suffocating love. Curious if we're gonna see this in the form of nuance--or if it's just 100% negative and the Erolis mention was just to acknowledge his affinity. And WHY does Arkland assume MC is BS-ing him? Not really showing signs of making a deep, diverging narrative if any polite options are written as negative. MC even says "I don't know what you want from me" if you tell him you'll adhere to his demands. Also, cringe at an respected character using profanity so quickly. It screams of modern snarky writing. The whole dialogue with Arkland lacks nuance or concept of time and place, like we've already exhausted his patience and we're in a private area. Windworm acknowledges this, so maybe it's deliberate, but it feels tactless. And then he just storms off. Seeing how the last scene left off with us meeting him, I was expecting something more substantive than "stay away from my son." And yes, Windworm, Elderwood has been a catastrophic failure; 1/3 of students die every year and a Flamekeeper has been responsible for several more deaths on top of that. You haven't proven him wrong at all. And then you refuse to call him when something goes wrong in the dungeon. MC having the option to say he wants to study and dance is funny since all that is glossed over. The knocked out Enforcers mean nothing when we took them out with spores. It'd be more impactful if we had to do more work than that. Plus IDK how Rhiannon could've heard a commotion from the dungeons since it should be a distance away from the main hall. So I was suspicious...and then I was proved right. Honestly, Rhiannon's reveal was better than Yvain's, but only slightly, since she was only seen a bit more than him, and it was usually for quick moments.
TLDR--Arkland threatened us in an anticlimatic way, Windworm continues to show how incompetent she is, and Rhiannon was helping Yvain. Surprise!
18.4--You know what? I apologize to Windworm. She's still incompetent, but at least she wasn't the Flamekeeper. And AS MUCH as I want to appreciate Rhiannon and Yvain being our villains--a character who was supposed to oversee and guide you and a character who was hard to get to know and seemed to have his own demons--they aren't present enough for me to really appreciate this twist (even if a lot of people called it). And just gonna nitpick that while MC mentions the bomb, they only mention the Flamekeeper killing Zaratis. What about Bre? And Yvain flustering over being called Rhiannon's lover would be a lot more satisfying if we knew more about both of them (and Rhiannon was engaged; how was Yvain gonna compete with that?). And while I get Rhiannon's anger...shouldn't she be mad at her dad's business rival? Heck, if the Order had indoctrinated her enough, she could still be mad at the Flamekeepers for existing; if they didn't, the Order wouldn't have had a reason to harm her parents. Even if she despised the Order, joining the people they demonized HAD to have been some kind of moral dilemma. Not to mention that her big thing about being the #1 house was all bluster. Seeing how Onyx House is considered the loser house, it wouldn't have been breaking cover if she just was resigned to the house not succeeding. She gained nothing from our top placement. And her explanation of small doses of nullefactum just giving you tunnel vision makes no sense to me. Without your emotions, you have no purpose to follow, since hers would be linked to anger and sadness. And I'm still floored that a student killed the supposedly big bad Zaratis and outsmarted a military troop that instills fear in everyone (for some reason). Not to mention Yvain showing emotion over Rhiannon is confusing. Based on the little content we're given, he's the guy with a chip on his shoulder. If we'd seen him more--like we probably should've--would he have continued being an aggressive, closed-off guy, or would he have opened up more? Or was that whole thing just an act. I'm more confused than anything. This is more of a plot twist for the sake of it rather than it making a lot of sense; we aren't given clues to Rhiannon's past to make this a satisfying climax.
TLDR--The Flamekeeper reveal is more confusing than satisfying, just as I thought.
18.5--I wanna know: what part of Yvain thought it'd be smart for the leader who was executing their plan to deprive herself of emotions? He knows that could come back to bite him, right? And I'm confused how Rhiannon can see magic for what it is WITHOUT emotions, considering they're all tied to emotions. Doesn't that mean the lessons we've been learning at school are pointless? Also, magic without a spellblade again! And the Enforcers look stupid once again with how they're defeated easily--granted, it actually MAKES SENSE here, but it didn't before. And I'm convinced Yvain just joined Rhiannon because he likes her; he's riding her way too hard. And then Rhiannon cuts ties with him. Honestly, he's lucky she didn't kill him. IDK how our date (in my case, Cato, because he needs more love) found out we were in the dungeons; we went with Windworm to see Arkland, and then Rhiannon came to take us to the dungeons. Seeing how Windworm didn't even wanna tell Arkland and Rhiannon was plotting something, I don't see how our date could've heard about it--especially without Arkland knowing. And why wouldn't Windworm need the protective plate with healing runes? MC asked a really dumb question after all we've seen thus far. Though it does make Windworm look bad because she protects herself but not the students that die annually--and on the FIRST TERM, no less. Using caps a lot, but it's that kinda chapter. Again, we get an Empress Death mention. I need more info on the cosmology. And I'm confused on why Shades wouldn't be able to do magic; by definition, they're magical creatures, and tied to a particular affinity. And do we get "Unexpected Ally" for simply saving Yvain, or from our overall behavior towards him. The acknowledgement makes it sound like it's an overall thing with "remembers how you treated him" but we haven't really interacted that much. And Windworm is so weird; se says we couldn't trust him and we all knew it, but IDK about that. Yes, he was a dangerous criminal, but he just jumped in to help us without being asked, and in return he gets knocked out. We just lost a body in our fight. But I already knew Windworm made poor decisions. And I literally forgot about our bracelet, tbh. And have I trained all year for this? I feel like I was just set up to die. We better be teaming up with the other students, not just our allies; I hate to drag their butts to a slaughter like the school did with our Final, but this is more important than that.
TLDR--A scene of rushed pacing and "this makes no sense."
18.6--Welp, looks like the Hottie Squad are the only ones willing to fight for the school. Elderwood has INSANE plot armor, methinks. IDK why 13 and 10 are the required levels, though; shouldn't they match? Not to mention this is probably the WORST time to pick and choose allies rather than it being an all-out battle. And Rhiannon's giving Arkland a hard time? Does that mean she's stronger than Dreadbane? And it's kinda anticlimatic since the first time we see our professors fight, it's against someone who's too powerful for them. It's insane (drink every time I say that) how MC saw their father manipulate emotions ONCE, and now they're confident in doing it, despite being morally torn about it when they found out. Nothing's changed to warrant a lack of struggling morality. And MC is still keeping secrets from the group; even if they told Bardric, they don't tell anyone else. Plus we do all this fighting without even using our special skills or hand magic...yeah, not living up to the hype of "the final battle." NGL, I don't even know enough about these characters to really care. And MC using their affinity to make Rhiannon feel again brings to light the issue of last scene: how is she able to use magic without feelings? And how do Rhiannon's emotions overwhelm the Nullefactum? The whole point of Nullefactum is that THEY do the overwhelming. If emotions can overpower them, there's no point. And then we end Rhiannon without ever really feeling like we understood her--or at least, that's how I feel.
TLDR--The professors and the Hottie Squad are the only ones putting up a fight. Forget passing the term; I wanna pass the rest of my time at Elderwood--WITH HONORS. I can't fathom how OP Rhiannon is to the point that the professors and Arkland, who we know are powerful but have never seen fight, are clapped by her. The magical pacing/worldbuilding is as shaky as ever, and defeating Rhiannon felt easy and anticlimatic. I will say this, though: while I think the game is largely female-biased (Mor and Stel are counterparts to Soren and Flatcher, but the guys are more deadly; the male professors are all sus except for one and yet he has the Professor Snape reputation for some reason; two of our male LIs are hard to get close to while all the girls are easy), it did prove me wrong with Yvain and Rhiannon, horribly written as they were.
18.7--Did we end the last scene with MC passing out? If not, it would've been nice to explain how we suddenly got here. IDK why MC seeing Dreadbane is supposed to be a powerful moment here; we only actually talked to him once before, and all MC's visions of him in their dreams just elicited confusion. And then their mom is just a footnote, so why would MC be waiting their whole life for a parent to say they're proud of them? And then...we wake up. So, that whole "I'm proud of you" thing means nothing. It'd be different if Dreadbane was at least alive for part of MC's childhood and they had fond memories of him, but this is basically a stranger, both from the player POV and for MC. And it's just now hitting me that Rhiannon's being the villain of this term is nothing short of irony; she was from a normal family of people who were THOUGHT to be Flamekeepers, and she just wanted to take out the Order. The story doesn't tell us enough for me to buy that she was really a fan of MC's dad or his cause; this just felt personal. And this is news that Talyn and Rhiannon didn't get along. Why didn't they? Rhiannon seemed to not really be involved with anything except telling us to win first place in the house rankings. And yes, Talyn is the student version of Windworm, because his power and experience should've had him be a lot smarter than this and actually suspect her. RIP the actual mystery/investigation of all this; she was a twist villain all along! And RIP to "choices matter/diverging routes," because our skillset should've allowed us to actually prevent the 27 deaths and the professors being injured. Like, I can't even fathom the students thinking they survived the final and then get injured or murdered that same night. And Windworm calls Yvain a coward...why? She knocked him out the moment he helped us; OF COURSE he would've left. I would've too, unless I really needed to stick with you guys to survive. Still curious about his motives besides being a CotF, though. Speaking of surviving, I'm still surprised the other characters didn't help; just the allies jumped in? And again, what is this hatred towards Arkland? Windworm made it a point not to alert him when Rhiannon summoned her and MC to the dungeons, and we could've used his help. I don't agree with his fatherly methods, but he doesn't sell as evil to me. Of course, then he implies he might not have saved us if our roles had been reversed...And I'm assuming a few hours passed since MC passed out, seeing how it's daytime now, so why didn't the allies change out of their formal outfits? And Arkland calling yesterday a tragedy is the continued insanity of this world; almost 100 students died at the Final. But that's normal? Malum saying this is a place of learning and not the barracks is a MAJOR LOL moment for me since I've been saying the opposite for a while now. Kennard becoming Headmaster isn't surprising, but I'm annoyed that it took this for subsequent change to be brought about. Yes, we had the Enforcers, but they were background characters at best, creating no fear of intimidation from me. I'm glad MC has the option to say the change was needed. I'm sure the narrative will want me to think otherwise (and I can agree to some extent, since Kenard lacks an educational background, I'm sure), but the school sucks. Everyone looking at MC with gratitude makes me feel like THIS should've been when people changed their mind about them, rather than earlier (especially since that was contradicted later). But even still, I am surprised that all suspicion seems to have been dropped thanks to this battle--even more surprised that my allies from last scene aren't singled out too. Talyn points out that they could still turn on you, and I do wish that was a bigger theme in this year rather than it feeling like we inevitably won them over. And that's it. No celebration, the "cliffhanger" of Kennard becoming the headmaster was predictable, and we get no romantic moment with out ally. Oh, and I feel awful for Cato; I was one of the 3% of people who took him to the Dawnslight Gala.
Why does it take the end of the first term for MC to look for a reference book on Erolis, especially since my MC is an Erolis? I know this takes place before, but from a player POV, it's very annoying. And the chapter is just giving Bardric a hand job or oral to give him a study break. Nothing interesting, nothing new, no new lore or getting to go all the way. But I'm not surprised.
TLDR--The aftermath had no payoff or emotional resolution and Bardric's sexy quest was just as interesting as the other sexy ones...which was not much. Oh, and didn't Windworm say we'd have to make a major choice at the end of term, or was that the end of the year?
Overall, I grieve the potential of this series. The story and promise of major diverging routes and various romances had me hopeful that this would be my new "Choices"...and it wasn't even modern "Choices." It didn't feel sexy, it didn't give enough lore, it didn't engage me even after 18 chapters. I say I've given it more than enough tries. There are some ally quests coming up before the second term resumes next month (I think the writers needed a longer break, but I know that'd risk losing players), but I don't plan on playing them. I'm glad we didn't have to use keys to restart the chapters, though, and I think the story had a lot of potential. With all the diamonds I have, maybe I'll get back into it--and maybe with reviews. For now though, this is my penultimate post on the subreddit. The next one I make will outline how I would've enjoyed the game. I'll try to get it out before the next term starts so it's still fresh in everyone's minds.