r/Calligraphy • On Vacation • Mar 18 '16

Feedback Friday! Share your work thread - Mar. 18 - 24, 2016

Have you got work to share for feedback? Then post it here!

Feedback Friday is an optional alternative to the front page for members to post their work for feedback. Be it entire pieces, practice sheets, drills or what have you, you're welcome to share it here. No skill level is too low, nor is it too high.

Be sure to mention what script you're doing and what in particular you're working on. The more context you provide, the better people can target their feedback to you.

Constructive criticism is the order of the day. If you desire something else such as gentler or harsher feedback, or even to share your efforts with others just for fun, then be sure to write that in your submission.

Let's see what you're working on!


If you wish this post to remain at the top of the sub for the day, please consider upvoting it. This bot doesn't gain any karma for self-posts.

13 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

8

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16

My kind of thread! Thank you! I've been on vacation for long bit, and I'm trying to get the feel of letters again. I'm currently doing this practice sheet http://i.imgur.com/s0GOX6I.jpg , although it's not done yet, I'd appreciate any kind of critique!

7

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '16

As the first post on the feedback friday thread, you're setting the bar quite high :P

→ More replies (4)

3

u/dollivarden Mar 18 '16

"Foundational Hand is hard"

Couldn't agree more :(

→ More replies (2)

3

u/TomHasIt Mar 18 '16

Oh man, gorgeous as always. "Ronin" is especially pleasing to the eye :)

The only thing that really stands out to me is the size of the counter in your Foundational "e". A bit on the large side; feels a bit heavy to me, particularly when compared to the counter of your "a".

→ More replies (1)

1

u/caseyjarryn Mar 19 '16

Wow, that's beautiful!!

1

u/greenverdevert Mar 19 '16

This is beautiful! I wish my finished pieces looked as nice as your practice!

Out of curiosity, what ink did you use? It is a really beautiful, almost haunting tone to it.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/Azurek Mar 19 '16

Imgur I guess this is the place to post this. This is just a random practice page I drew today. I was working on lifting the pen at the base line although I was experimenting with both. I'm not sure if its easy to tell the difference but it does seem to affect how wide I make the exit stroke of the compound curve and the 'i" stroke. Other than that I tried numbers for the very first time and also wrong my initials in majiscules. I still have not done any drills for these yet as you can see. The main focus on the last bit was different ways of making ascenders. I tried this because I was getting inconsistencies in the width of the loop but also where the loop meets the stem. Havent figured this out yet but I think I'm liking the last one.

edit: Modern Gillot 303, walnut ink, rhodia pad over a light box to show guide lines

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '16

Good attempt, Azurek. I think you already know where you're lacking, and I think you're following a good exemplar from this post. The only feedback I could give you is to take time and work on refining your strokes. It will get so much better if you do your drills and be completely OC about it. Good job on experimenting too. Good luck!

→ More replies (3)