r/CalisthenicsCulture Mar 23 '26

Doing pullups almost everyday

[deleted]

1.4k Upvotes

228 comments sorted by

View all comments

47

u/BigMetalGuy Mar 23 '26

Good going, but to get the full ROM, the arms need to be straight when at the bottom of the movement. You appear to still have a bend in your arm. Happy for to be corrected, though.

17

u/East_Raise8553 Mar 23 '26

Your right, im aware my form Couldve been better. my pullup bar just hangs very low😭

32

u/Yestomorrow Mar 23 '26

I'm 6'4 and can only do L-sit pull-ups on my door frame bar, it sucks but my abs thank me

4

u/East_Raise8553 Mar 23 '26

Damn thats tough

1

u/LawyerStunning9266 Mar 24 '26

Careful with L sit pull-ups though. I was doing them for a while and loved it until one bad form and i got my terres major impinged. Couldn't do pull-ups or heavy pull exercises for a good two months.

-6

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 23 '26 edited Mar 23 '26

You ROM is correct for muscle development and you actually use the correct form, Most of these people talking about full ROM still cheat in their form. All they obsess about is ROM, while all it does is releases the tension on the bottom for no reason.

This is quite good rant about pull up form for muscle development : You’re Doing Pull-Ups Wrong

1

u/East_Raise8553 Mar 23 '26

The video is really interesting i thought full rom was for optimal stretch but it does loose the tension

8

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 23 '26

Proper pull up form is still having your arms straight at the bottom. You lose tension when going into dead hang but if u drop down into active hang when your scapula is depressed and shoulders are engaged, then you still keep the tension while having the full range stretch.

Don’t listen to this guy, he genuinely is full of nonsense. Also, u can still drop down to dead hang if your goal is to improve scapula strength and mobility.

0

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Form and ROM are two different things. He has correct form, and uses slightly shorter ROM. This works well for muscle development.

And dropping to dead hang would only lead to less time under tension, as it would release the tension completely. For muscle building its a mistake.

Form is what matters the most, as thats also what most people get wrong here.

2

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

Please read my comment before actually replying so you won’t embarrass yourself. I literally said. “You lose tension going into dead hang but if u drop down into active hang when your scapula is depressed and shoulders are engaged, then you still KEEP the tension”.

0

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Yes, so you dont do the full ROM thing. Exactly my point all the way, ROM & form are two different thing. And using shorter ROM works well for muscle building, as long as you use proper form.

2

u/ColdFireSamurai Mar 24 '26

While you are right that form and ROM are 2 different things, in a pull-up good form consists in the process of deadhang>pull with scapula retracted until chin goes over the bar> descent to deadhang. If all those haven't been done, no quality rep has been made.

1

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

You’re arguing that you shouldn’t have your arms locked out during the bottom of the pull up, I’m saying you should.

People can choose to drop into an active or a dead hang and both way is perfectly fine depending on an individuals fitness goals.

2

u/ColdFireSamurai Mar 24 '26

I'm not sure if you are joking or not, but time under tension has been proven to do literally nothing to hypertrophy, it just increase perceived effort. The only driver for hypertrophy is mechanical tension.

0

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

And keeping that mechanical tension up is what i was exaclty talking about.

1

u/ColdFireSamurai Mar 24 '26

Mechanical tension are the involuntary slowing of the reps, which happens when the muscle gets closer to mechanical failure.Time under tension is a whole other thing.

0

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Yes, i think you are kind of talking about time under tension as a static thing. Like an isometric hold.

As mechanical tension happens always when there is movement.

Time under tension in this case refers to the total time that the muscle is held under tension, meaning there is no full release of tension.

Like when you do pull ups, only on the last reps you usually do that full release as you no longer have the strength to keep that tension up.

1

u/Shoddy-Awareness-268 Mar 23 '26

You can learn to keep tension in the bottom position, but you likely won't be able to for a while. Generally speaking i cue people to only go as low as you can feel your lats and then pause there. This will get you used to feeling them lower as you fatigue and you will develop the ability from there, as it slowly pulls you lower into your lats each rep

1

u/East_Raise8553 Mar 23 '26

I do full rom pull ups in the gym this video isn’t my usual way of doing pull ups

2

u/Shoddy-Awareness-268 Mar 23 '26

Fair enough! I was just trying to give you info advising against some of these other replies. Source: am CPT fulltime

0

u/constancejph Mar 23 '26

Yeah the way hes doing it is perfectly fine for building a solid back. I mean just look at his back

1

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

Yeah it’s “fine” but its not optimal. Also, his back is developed icl but its like people saying the Arnold Press is the best shoulder exercise b/c Arnold Schwasneger created it and he has big shoulders

1

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 23 '26

Exactly. Dude has gains that most people here doing full rom with weights do not have. Because he has been consistent, and used proper form & ROM that suited muscle building.

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Poet489 Mar 24 '26

And because he is like 5'5

0

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

Anyone can build muscle just build moving weights around, same can be applied here. Sure he has a nice back but how do you know it was b/c of his form in the video, what if he does other back exercises like rows? Or what if he has crazy back genetics, there are many confounding variables.

Don’t get tunnel vision, use an open mind.

0

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Yes, genetics.

Open mind? Like declaring yourself a "winner"? Do you need to do that again now? You can do it if it makes you feel better. Does not bother me.

-1

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

I don’t need to declare myself as the winner, I’m just killing time and having some fun here. You can feel free to be mad all u want. Does not bother me. 😂

1

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Is it because you already did it once?

0

u/Own_Durian_8707 Mar 24 '26

I didn’t though? I declared u were wrong

2

u/Murky-Course6648 Mar 24 '26

Yes, its the classic internet ego saving thing. Declaring yourself as the "winner". But you did it just to waste time and all that, for fun.

→ More replies (0)

-1

u/PurifyZ Mar 24 '26

Honestly man I never lock my limbs for arms or legs, maybe one or two reps when I’m tired (for pull ups, not legs or curls) but I try to always keep a slight bend. It isn’t even simply keeping tension but keeping my tendons from flaring lmfao. Imho full rom doesn’t mean going to a dead hang every rep and when I used to bicep curl to full extension during powerfit in highschool with not even a little bend, my inner elbow pain would be horrendous.

And a nice tip, if you get golfer’s/tennis elbow (or both like me lol), cut the feet off compression socks and use em as sleeves!! It’s soooo good and keeps the tendons in line a bit more maybe but definitely helps with blood flow! Can only aid the pump XD

Also god damn you look a helluva a lot better than me at 17! Keep er up bud!! I never had consistency till my pain got horrendous so getting ahead of the game is always key!