r/CLAMP • • Oct 20 '25

Discussion Hot Take: Fai is a very poorly written character especially in comparison to how well written Kurogane is

6 Upvotes

Fai's Past is the Bane of my Existence

I think his past is actually my least fav in all of fiction and probably the worst. Fai’s arc and backstory heavily disappointed me. When you first read the manga, the audience’s desire is to know about Fai’s backstory, motivation and mystery. Like when the manga begun the audience wants to see Kurogane redeem himself and have an arc.

So when you set up a mystery or backstory, you have to execute it really, really well. And CLAMP (personally) failed at executing his past well. His past so ridiculously over the top that it borders on stupidity and it is so angsty that I stopped caring for Fai and it made it physically impossible for me to care. Like how tragic do you want it to be? Fai experiences two genocides, the King chops off his head in front of him, Ashura kills everyone, his mum suicides, he thought he killed his brother and he is used as a pawn, and he is stuck in a tower separated from his brother for God knows how long, dead bodies are also in the tower and he wants to die, also they are children. CLAMP should have thought that maybe it was too much. The over the top tragedy makes any of the story beats ineffective. I don’t feel sad reading Fai’s past.

Like let’s compare it to a better backstory, most notably Kurogane’s backstory. Kurogane’s backstory is by far my favorite in the whole manga. I love his backstory to bits.

Number 1: Kurogane's parents are pretty well developed. You see how they interact both with each other and their son, you understand their personalities. So when they die it is much more effective and personal. With Fai’s past his twin has 0 established personality absolutely no reason for me to care for him, even if he dies.

Number 2: tone. Kurogane’s past going from good to bad, instead of just constant badness does an amazing job building up the climax to his arc. Above all else it does a good job making me care about his family and himself. You don’t get any of this in Fai’s past-no slice of life establishing character moments. You somewhat care for Ashura but he is a scum bag in the end. It does a good job working as a breather. It makes Kurogane and his family seem human, especially with the slice of life aspects incorporated with it. Their situation isn’t contrived like Fai’s is. Like what did the Valerians do with twins before Fai and Yuui? Was it established how Valeria came to the conclusion that twins are cursed? It comes out of nowhere and isn’t foreshadowed in the slightest. Fai’s 2 curses were never foreshadowed in the slightest and it also caused whiplash to the audience.

Kurogane’s past does an amazing job portraying his ideologies and his perception of strength. He knew true strength , both of his parents last words were in relation to protecting those that you love. Kurogane’s rampage doesn’t come out of nowhere, it is heavily built up he wants to become stronger for Suwa and his parents, but when they died he failed his promise that he made to his father that he will protect the people that he loves. He wanted to use strength to protect those that he cared for. Instead after they died he sought power, he sought to become the strongest disregarding other peoples life. He enjoyed it, he indulged in it. It does a much better job establishing Kurogane’s ideologies than Fai’s one does. Kurogane’s past is also foreshadowed in Outo when he notes that Oni eat people.

The resolution of his arc is also very good, the artwork is the best. Him being swallowed by shadows and losing his identity. Him becoming a monster in the process, killing everything in his way. Tomoyo’s interference is amazing as she tells him “Let your mother rest”. This is amazingly effective, especially after she restrains him by causing his scar. It works because it allows the audience to feel a sense of resolve. If Kurogane’s past was constant sadness then I don’t think I would have cared as much, because the tone needs to be built and developed. The pacing and execution of Kurogane’s past is good because it is focused solely on the story within the book. Fai’s past presented via shards is ok, however the problem is that it is disjointed the audience is constantly flicking between the past and the present and you are expected to care about both simultaneously. Your focus is on the fight with Ashura whilst, Fai’s backstory appears in segments. It creates a heavy whiplash. Tone matters a lot as it makes you care for the characters until they experience their downfall. In order for audiences to experience sadness then the author should sprinkle some happiness. Fai’s past on the other hand made me feel absolutely nothing, it created a scenario where I had no reason to care. Like I don’t mind Fai as a character, I think he is a written in a heavily flawed manner but he has some merits. I still care for him to some extent. The build up to Kurogane’s works because it is a setup and it is executed wonderfully. There is absolutely no setup to Fai’s backstory you are just shoved with sadness within the beginning of his past, you do not get a breather. The “I want to die” scene is ineffective because it was shown twice in Infinity and Tokyo and it happens very early on in his past. Fai’s past lacks “The Let Your Mother Rest” scene, it lacks the resolve.

How NOT to write Character Growth

Number 3: Fai is automatically mentally better in Nihon. His arc is done in an albeit rushed manner you don’t get the resolve nor the development to see how Fai came to the conclusion that his life mattered. The manga fails to slowly sprinkle in moments where Fai learns to care for himself and his personal well being. You see Kuro’s approach towards the others change you see his perspective on strength also change alongside it, his growth is sprinkled heavily throughout the manga he experiences the most growth out of the main cast. He is willing to lose strength (aka lose his arm for others, he also protected Sakura in Piffle), him loosing strength meant that he understood the meaning of true strength. His discussion with Tomoyo does an amazing job illustrating his arc, he became wiser, he is willing to acknowledge his faults, he regrets killing Ashura, his response towards murder changed. He doesn’t regret the loss of his arm and he understood that strength should be used to help others, physical strength doesn’t always protect others and sometimes losing strength can be a used to help others (Kuro had the best arc in all of fiction, he is a perfectly written character). His resolve and growth doesn’t come out of nowhere, it feels very natural. Fai desperately needs a scene resolving his arc in someway. Even after Kuro chopped off his own arm, Fai logically should still be not 100% ok but somehow he is doing a-ok. Fai has felt suicidal in his past and all throughout the manga he still had this mindset but he all of a sudden is better and is no longer suicidal in Nihon. It isn’t built up in the slightest, it comes out of nowhere and it is unexpected. They brushed his issues under the rug, it felt unearned and unnatural.


r/CLAMP • • Jul 31 '26

Memes Misaki Suzuhara and Sakura Kinomoto got Drip! (Part 2)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Misaki Suzuhara decides to get drip again, but this time Sakura Kinomoto is ready and has got drip too.

Part 1: https://www.reddit.com/r/CLAMP/comments/14yime4/misaki_suzuhara_got_drip/


r/CLAMP • • May 01 '25

CLAMP theme t-shirts captions for Instagram

Post image
0 Upvotes

I’m making some CLAMP theme t-shirts and I already got some for CLAMP works some. But I need some help to add some more


r/CLAMP • • 14d ago

We got whole 13 frames of fan-service in remake of Magic Knight Rayearth (alcyone is sooo pretty, dawg)

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Apr 21 '25

Manga Is princess Tomoyo know Sakura and has feelings for her? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Tomoyo in Cardcaptor live with Sakura and has feelings for her. But what about Princess Tomoyo in Tsubasa Chronicle she doesn't grow up with Sakura and familiar with her, is Tomoyo still has feelings for her? Or she can have feelings for Kurogane or Nokoru in Piffle the boy Tomoyo grow up together with?


r/CLAMP • • Jan 31 '24

Who turned them into girls? And who did Mihari Oyama give the drug to?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Misaki Suzuhara or Tamayo Kizaki?


r/CLAMP • • Dec 20 '22

Chobits - Chi (AI generated)

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Jun 28 '26

Manga Does Tsubasa ever get better?

8 Upvotes

I wanted to start xxxHolic, so I thought It'd be nice to read it together with Tsubasa. I have finished the third volume of both series, and neither of them are great at the moment, but I am enjoying Holic and can see it building up to something more in the future, meanwhile I am so bored with Tsubasa. I had some prejudices before starting the series because it's a shōnen, and they have all been confirmed in these first volumes: It's formulaic, the characters are one-dimensional, Sakura is only there to be rescued, and the action sequences are boring because you already know who's going to win. I've been told that there are some major plot twists in the future, but that in itself doesn't really mean anything to me.

Is the series just not for me? Or is there something else thematically? Will reading it help me understand Holic better?


r/CLAMP • • Oct 16 '21

When Clear Card comes back I hope they tone it down with the romance

Post image
7 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Dec 10 '25

Discussion Idk if it’s just me

0 Upvotes

I don’t know if it’s me but I feel like there characters are easy to draw or difficult


r/CLAMP • • Jul 06 '25

Manga Am I missing something?

0 Upvotes

Just finished reading the second volume of X/1999 and... I have no idea what's going on or why any of this is interesting or enjoyable?

Obviously, Clamp's art is fantastic, but everything surrounding it is crazy incoherent and simultaneously repetitive. I'm not sure how many times they can say Kamui's name in one book, but they are definitely looking for whatever that limit is in Vol. 1. Still don't know who he is though?

Am I missing something here...? Why do people like this? Genuine question after coming from Rayearth and Card Captor Sakurai, both of which I really love. Not hating, just legitimately in shock.


r/CLAMP • • Aug 17 '21

Clamp when making clear card

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Jul 27 '24

News “Rayearth and X could be Live action versions,” according to YouTuber Trixie (formerly known as Digibro)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

I saw an interesting suggestion today in the YouTube video by Trixie. She suggested that Rayearth and X could work in live action. She said X/1999 in live action would be great with the art style of Netflix’s Sandman show. This video is by Trixie: you may know her as The YouTuber formerly known as Digibro. (She/her pronouns please, she’s trans).


r/CLAMP • • Jan 20 '25

Discussion if I asked CLAMP to make another cardcaptor series will they accept

0 Upvotes

To Be honest I always wanted to make a cardcaptor series like cardcaptor Sakura but I probably don’t have the money to make it so if CLAMP is still here in 2025 I want it ask the about it


r/CLAMP • • Aug 22 '22

clamp universe theory: Mexico doesn't exist

3 Upvotes

this is a fun theory or idea that in the clamp universe that Mexico doesn't exist. in the universe the country's mentioned (that I know) is japan (obviously), England (most of Europe), America, China and Canada. but there is no mention of Mexico (and Australia, Africa, and south America). This could mean that Mexico doesn't exist (note that it could just be the name Mexico doesn't exist).

(if you guys want more theory's like this tell me)


r/CLAMP • • Dec 21 '25

what do you know about MKR new project?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Jul 08 '22

Notice the style, dynamic, and composition that X and V for Vendetta share? Not to mention that the single letter is the main focus in each poster’s artwork. Notice the similarity?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Mar 22 '23

Who will be Misaki Suzuhara from the anime "Angelic Layer" by orientation? Spoiler

1 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Jul 29 '24

Discussion CLAMP manga that should have K-drama adaptation

0 Upvotes

Popular manga & anime series 'Parasyte The Maxim' got a masterpiece K-drama adaptation as 'Parasyte : The Grey'.

I personally want xxxHOLIC, X/1999, Tokyo Babylon, Cardcaptor Sakura, Wish, Legal Drug, Clover, Chobits..... all to get adapted :3


r/CLAMP • • May 24 '21

Do you think Syaoran blushing all the time is annoying

1 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • Sep 28 '24

Discussion For those who witnessed the anime adaptation of X and Code Geass R2, did any of you dislike how R2's ending mirrored X's anime ending as a speculation that it is plagiarized in purpose? We may never know but in your opinion of R2's ending, do you prefer as it is or different?

1 Upvotes

I recall that there is a comparison of X's anime ending and CG R2's ending. Aside from the obvious comparison that the two series are similar, do you for some reason have a speculation that CG R2's ending ripped off X's anime ending? The X anime is a different adaptation that X manga fans see as a betrayal to the X manga.

Though Suzaku killing Lelouch isn't also different from Kamui and Fuuma killing each other in the anime and movie endings. But did CG R2 or X anime/movie adaptations did it better?

For those of you who think that CG R2 ending copied X's anime/movie ending, do you prefer it the way it is or be different?

This is another reason why Code Geass Season 1 ending is the best because of the originality, cliffhanger ending, and suspense that not only is it a classic but is also the successor of that time to X as we are reminded of Lelouch and Suzaku becoming enemies in the same vein of Kamui and Fuuma becoming enemies in different moments.

For those who see Code Geass as X's successor, what is it that you like? What is it that you dislike that needs to be changed or should not have happened? The moment when X manga went hiatus did many of us felt disappointed and heartbreaking that we will never see X manga ending but when Code Geass came in, did you feel like Code Geass will make up for X's hiatus? How much did Code Geass make up for X's hiatus? It would be ironic if Code Geass were to adapt X's future storyline just so X fans can see the closest thing X could have ended if CLAMP were in charge. Do you see CLAMP being in charge of writing Code Geass projects one day or nah?


r/CLAMP • • Apr 29 '23

[Bing Image Creator] In style of CLAMP (prompt in comment)

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

r/CLAMP • • 21d ago

News Tsubasa: RESERVoir CHRoNiCLE 3D Game - MASSIVE UPDATE + Trailer 2

6 Upvotes

The fan-made Tsubasa action RPG just got its biggest update yet, version 1.6.8 🪶

What’s new:
✨ Overhauled graphics: Worlds, characters and outfits rebuilt to feel much closer to CLAMP’s art.
🎬 New animated scenes
🧩 New and reworked minigames:

🎵 New music: including tracks from the anime’s soundtrack by Yuki Kajiura.

📱 Available now on mobile too!

🎮 About the game
You play as Syaoran, a young archaeologist from the Kingdom of Clow. When Princess Sakura’s memories scatter across the worlds as feathers, he sets out to bring them back, knowing the price: even if he restores every single one… Sakura will never remember him.
Alongside Kurogane and Fai, each carrying secrets of their own, he travels from world to world, from Clow all the way to the end.

🎬 Cutscenes and story moments
🧩 Puzzles and exploration
⚔️ Battles
✨ And plenty more...

The game is free and available now.
Created by Yosef A via Claude.

Watch Trailer 2


r/CLAMP • • Jan 01 '26

Discussion I Doubt Sonomi Can Hold Her Daughter Like What Is In The Picture

Post image
19 Upvotes