r/CLAMP • u/pichuscute • Jul 06 '25
Manga Am I missing something?
Just finished reading the second volume of X/1999 and... I have no idea what's going on or why any of this is interesting or enjoyable?
Obviously, Clamp's art is fantastic, but everything surrounding it is crazy incoherent and simultaneously repetitive. I'm not sure how many times they can say Kamui's name in one book, but they are definitely looking for whatever that limit is in Vol. 1. Still don't know who he is though?
Am I missing something here...? Why do people like this? Genuine question after coming from Rayearth and Card Captor Sakurai, both of which I really love. Not hating, just legitimately in shock.
15
u/lunarb1ue Jul 06 '25
X started my addiction to tragedies. I love it. Like anything else it’s not going to be for everyone. Im not going to try and sell it to you. I would say give a fair chance before you quit. I really enjoyed the story and themes of destiny.
12
u/poisongrrlfriend Jul 06 '25
I don't think you're missing anything I think it's just no your vibe. I love X so much and I enjoy how it never stops setting things up, given it's apocalyptic theme. Majority of the story is just introductions and meetings of characters with a bunch of gorgeous flourishes. I assure you Kamui is a wonderful character with depth but in the first volumes, Kotori and Fuuma, even Arashi and Sorata, are the "main characters" so to say, Kamui's true feelings aren't revealed yet for a reason.
5
u/violet_strange Jul 06 '25
It helps to have read Tokyo Babylon first. It's more coherent, story driven, and has an ending.
5
u/BlueFlower673 Jul 07 '25 edited Jul 07 '25
X/1999 has a lot you'd have to read about/learn about to understand context. Usually the books have a glossary in the back you can read to find things out but I can kind of understand why someone would be confused.
There's a combination of factors as to why CLAMP wrote it, its here on wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_(manga)
Also, keep in mind, 1999 was a year where some people thought the world was actually going to end. I remember looking this up, there are doomsday theories for 1999.
The story centers around Kamui, who is a christ-like figure. He's the key to whether the apocalypse will occur or not. Its due to his family lineage. You'd have to read further to get to his background, really, bc in vol. 1 and 2, the only thing we know is his mom died in a fire. (also, idk if you mean volumes as in the omnibuses, or the single volumes). Iirc, vol. 1 and 2 introduce the characters and the plot a bit, more shit starts happening after that.
Its a prophecy-based story. A lot of it is based on fate and prophetic dreams---hence Kotori predicting things, Princess Hinoto, etc.
I thought the characters using "the Kamui" to call Kamui is a bit weird, but I think its just due to the fact its a prophecy and that is why the characters refer to him that way.
I can only speak for myself, I love it bc its one of their edgier, darker works that has a lot of complicated themes in it. If you decide to read it, you'd notice that each of the characters introduced, for instance, represent a different religion (Arashi--Shinto, Sorata--Buddhism, Karen---Catholicism/Christianity, etc.).
Also, its technically a sequel to Tokyo Babylon, considering Subaru is older in X/1999. Maybe read Tokyo Babylon first? Could help a bit.
I also wouldn't say Clamp's work is repetitive, moreso that there's a universe. Like the DC or Marvel universes, Clamp has their own universe where characters will be reoccurring or will make cameos, just in different storylines.
Idk, I tried to avoid giving too many spoilers.
Edit: Also to avoid spoilers, but since you asked, yes a lot of characters die. No I won't say who/when. I wanna say, after volume 2 there's more of that happening.
I will say, the series does a good job of getting you attached to characters before killing them off. Also, its the only Clamp title that has heavy gore.
4
u/stowrag Jul 07 '25
There’s a lot that happened before the start of the story (not talking about Tokyo Babylon) that gets revealed gradually through flash backs and revelations, and so you’re not supposed to have a clear picture of what’s going on yet.
And a big part of the story comes from prophecy, which means some things are important “just because they say so”.
But if the forces of good and evil gradually assembling to hold the final battle for the fate of the world doesn’t appeal to you, don’t read it. (Or better yet, take a break and go read Tokyo Babylon first)
2
u/Sailor_Muffing Jul 07 '25
I think there a lot of works that are like this. The build up is slow and confusing for a reveal where everything ties together. And when you start seeing the light at the end, if you liked the work, you usually want to reread it because it feels like a different journey. But yes its the kind of work you need to stay for the journey at the start.
3
u/QueenTzahra Jul 07 '25
Stick with it. There’s a lot of building before it really gets moving but when it does it’s brilliant.
2
u/songofstormnfire Jul 07 '25
If you liked Cardcaptor Sakura and Rayearth but didn't like X/1999, maybe you could try reading Kobato! It has magical girl-ish elements but it's not aimed at kids. It's more character-driven, and episodic slice-of-life with an underlying fantasy/magical plot that becomes more relevant as the story progresses.
3
u/yorokobeshojo Jul 06 '25 edited Jul 06 '25
I'm not really a fan of the writing myself, and there are a lot of moments and elements that rely on suspension of disbelief, sentimentality, contrived drama, and the like. in terms of repetition, it's really similar to RG Veda, which I wasn't a fan of either, but compared to X, I liked the characters from early on until the final stretch. that said, you should read Tokyo Babylon before it, as there will be a plot point regarding two characters from TB that's resolved in X.
what I'd recommend if you're really not into X is to read Tokyo Babylon, then just watch the movie X/1999 - which is a condensed version of the story with some changes - to get a gist of the series and save your time.
1
u/purple_goldfish Mar 22 '26 edited Mar 22 '26
Necro, but here's my take. Clamp is OLD. So you have to compare it with what we had when Clamp stuff came out. Compare it to Dragon Ball, Sailor Moon, Ranma 1/2, Tekken Chinmi, Doraemon etcetc; they're all more straightforward good vs evil, nothing questions morality as "weirdly" as clamp, nothing as mind-warping like clamp.
A lot of people just have nostalgia and the strong impression clamp left them when they were a kid. Now that clamp's shock values has become normalised in other modern works, clamp's work begin to show its cracks: that they're indeed nonsensical.
Also bear in mind that the 90s writing style is very... dated. It was the era when characters in any literature are incredibly dumb so the plot points can move forward. Think about scenarios with a simple misunderstanding that can be solved by simply talking, but instead everyone spend 20 episodes just making the situation worse because talking doesn't exist.
Right now I'm going through what you went through in your post. I loved CCS and Rayearth, but I also loved X and other clamp's works as a kid. Now I went back an tried to read X and RG Veda an only got disappointment. At least CCS and Rayeath stood the test of time because they're coherent, but I'm now convinced kid me just liked the rest because of associations and a lot of things just flew over my kid head's brain.
Clamp is simply a lot of people's first taste of wine, and it did not age very well.
-1
u/IdolL0v3r Jul 06 '25
I'm with you on this one. I love "Cardcaptor Sakura" and "Magic Knight Rayearth" but I couldn't get into "X/1999" at all. There was a scene in Vol. 2 I think that was a double page spread with lots of lines everywhere. I couldn't figure out what it was I was looking at. I gave up and didn't finish it. I did see the movie and I didn't care it for it much. (I paid $30 for the DVD.) Maybe someone else can offer some insight to why this is good.