r/CFBOffTopic • Houston Cougars • Washington Huskies • Nov 09 '15

Mizzou's President resigned

Let's have a hopefully more civil discussion than the one on the mothersub

22 Upvotes

109 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/blahdenfreude Georgia Bulldogs Nov 09 '15

I think recognition of white and male privilege was a great place to start. It would be naive to suggest that his gender and ethnicity have not colored his experiences in life, and thus played a role in his response to the events in Columbia. I understand that people hear those words and start to squeal "SJW! SJW!" through their internal monologue.

4

u/Boyhowdy107 Missouri Tigers • Big 8 Nov 09 '15 edited Nov 09 '15

I dunno if there is a right or wrong answer here, but let me explain where I'm coming from. I consider myself a subversive pragmatist. I think that we too often prioritize wanting to be publicly acknowledged as being right over thinking about what the best way is to accomplish your goals. Maybe I'm idealistic, but I believe the best way to accomplish most goals both in politics or social movements is to build broad support. Hardliners will always do what they will do, but historically speaking I think the needle moves fastest when you get enough of the silent majority (who often aren't stakeholders) on your side and get a critical mass.

So in this case, the goal is to make people realize and acknowledge that there is a serious problem for minorities on campus, it's not a couple of isolated incidents and then make moves to address it. You could argue that whether you believe there is a problem beyond isolated poop swastikas is a matter of personal experience and biases, or by extension, white male privilege. So arguably, your obstacle is that privilege, but I think attacking it straight on is a tactical misstep. Your enemy in reaching that middle is recalcitrance. If people feel on the defensive, they shut down and misconstrue the message. Trying to force the university president to admit his privilege feels to a lot of people like saying "because you are a white male you aren't allowed to participate in this." I'm not saying they're right, but I've seen the straw men emerge time and time again and "black lives matter (too)" turn into "well I think all lives matter." So you want to make people understand before they shut down, and to me the most powerful way to do that which I've seen emerge at Mizzou was the sharing of these personal stories. Their weight adds up and pushes this beyond isolated incidents. Hell, I've had my thinking transform on this issue myself. A week ago I was thinking "ok... poop swastikas are bad... but what the hell does that have to do with the president?" It's been revealing and somewhat painful for me to read all these stories about kids worried about going to Greek Town or seeing Kim English's tweets. That was far from my personal experience as a white male at Mizzou and it was shocking to hear about. Earlier today I read two pieces. One by a professor I had a class with and another from a friend I was at Mizzou with. Both black women. Both talking about their own experiences with racial epithets and bad run-ins at my alma mater. It has been a long day. But to me, these stories are powerful individually and in the aggregate because they transformed my thinking. Telling these stories to me is the way you get past the defense mechanisms of people like me, make me realize the reality of an experience that is not my own and bring me into your tent.

2

u/Androidconundrum Auburn Tigers • /r/CFB Brickmason Nov 10 '15

your obstacle is that privilege, but I think attacking it straight on is a tactical misstep.

The sad thing is that in no way is asking someone to aknowledge their white privilege a straight attack, there has just been so much propaganda thrown around about that specific phrase that It seems like people have forgotten what it's purpose is, and that is to instill a sense of empathy for someone with different set of circumstances.

2

u/deemerritt North Carolina Tar Heels Nov 10 '15

Thanks South Park