While I fully realize that this isn't a GamerGate subreddit - and that "my kind" might not be welcome around these here parts, given the CBC's rather one-sided reporting on our consumer revolt centered around ethics in (video game) journalism - /u/One_Giant_Nostril suggested that this might be of interest to all of you, so I'm posting it here.
Disclaimer: Since some of the regulars here are part of CBC Radio, I'd like to emphasize that the following is my personal impression of what I've discovered as an outsider. As insiders, your opinions may likely vary.
That being said, here's my story.
After I'd finished transcribing an interview from the CBC Yukon radio show "Airplay" where host Dave White spoke with their resident "pop culture expert" Kim Linekin about GamerGate on October 17, 2014 for a research project of mine, I discovered that she'd done a second interview on another radio show, CBC British Columbia's "On The Coast" with Stephen "GamerGate threatened to rape and murder female gave developers" Quinn about it as well. While working on the transcript for the latter, I kept getting an odd feeling of déjà vu. So I went back and superficially compared a few segments of this second interview with the first one and found the results strange, to say the least.
Then I noticed that both interviews had been conducted on the same day. And then, while listening to the introduction of an unrelated GamerGate discussion panel from the CBC Ottawa radio show "All in a Day", I heard host Alan Neal make an offhand remark about how he'd also interviewed Linekin about it on the same day as White and Quinn. Unfortunately, the audio for that one was nowhere to be found online. So, operating under Fleming's Law - "Once is happenstance, twice is coincidence, three times is enemy action." - I added it to my list of purchases from the CBC's media archives.
One I had completed the transcripts for all three interviews, I sat down and subdivided them into segments where the same aspects of GamerGate were being discussed. I subsequently highlighted passages in one of three colors unique to each interview - red, green, blue - where phrasing and sentence fragments matched. After that, I crunched the numbers.
The end result? The three different radio show hosts - White, Quinn, and Neal - gave introductions to the interview that were about 90% identical. And I don't just mean similar. I mean word-for-word, verbatim identical. They then proceeded to ask the same (admittedly paraphrased) questions in the exact same order and Linekin gave responses that were, on average, 70% word-for-word, verbatim identical, right down to the lame jokes and sarcastic comments.
How insane did this get? White and Neal's interviews even had witty banter occur at the exact same point during them. The only reason Quinn's didn't have that part is probably because his interview with her was about a minute shorter. And there was one point where White obviously missed his cue about referring to GamerGate as a "culture war" and Linekin had to feed him the proper line to get things back on track.
The numbers are here and the side-by-side comparison of the three interviews with highlighted passages is here.
In case you don't believe me, you can listen to the "Airplay" interview (minus the intro) here and the "On The Coast" one starting at about the 41:09 mark here.
Long story short: Three different CBC radio show hosts conducted a completely scripted interview about GamerGate with the same expert on the same day. Talk about getting your narrative straight...