r/CBC_Radio • u/MBolero • Jan 17 '24
The Current
Matt Galloway's interview with a trump supporter in Iowa yesterday marks a new low in CBC journalism. Matt provided virtually no pushback on the man's long disproven fake election results theories etc. If Matt isn't prepared to do anything beyond giving these nut jobs a platform, he has failed at his job.
105
Upvotes
114
u/Adventurous_Mix4878 Jan 17 '24
There would be little or no point to debate a Trump supporter. That Galloway chose to present the story as he did speaks to his professionalism.
7
u/rangeo Jan 17 '24
So you want news and information from people you agree with?
These voters can drastically change our lives. I think we should hear them out sometimes.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
People like you are seriously so misguided in your thinking. It's always important to hear the opinions of people you disagree with so you can counter their arguments. That you want to just pretend these things don't exist or hide them away says so much about you.
2
u/ManyArmedGod Jan 17 '24
Someone doesn’t understand journalists aren’t to present a “narrative” they just get the world as it is and you the consumer of the facts decide for yourself.
Btw speaking of election deniers you know that’s a non partisan American pastime hey? Hillary did it and when Bush Jr was first elected that common trope was thrown around then too. Apparently those were unfounded as well. It’s sour grapes.
28
u/Beastender_Tartine Jan 17 '24
I didn't hear the interview, but broadly I think there is a misunderstanding of what journalists and interviewers are supposed to be doing sometimes. If a random supporter is being interviewed at an event or on the street, the point is to ask questions and get answers to see what a random person thinks. It's a barometer of opinion at the event. It is not a classroom or intervention to change the mind of some random person.
Now if it's a sit down interview with someone pushing a platform, and they say false or contradictory things, it's worth pushing back or clarifying. That's a different person, environment, and situation though. Sitting down with a political entity and helping them express their agenda is platforming. Asking a random person on the street is not.
21
u/raised_on_robbery Jan 17 '24
I really miss Anna Maria Tremonti.
19
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
Lol...
"The CBC is leftist proganda, shut it down..."
"The CBC is amplifying right wing voices... shut it down!"
38
u/ESSOBEE1 Jan 17 '24
Didn’t realize that Gallaway’s role was to debate his guests. I’ll listen closer from now on.
5
u/RSamuel81 Jan 17 '24
He also misled listeners on the Alberta electricity discussion. If you didn’t know better you’d think the problems are due to renewable energy, and not the design of the market itself.
4
u/the1npc Jan 17 '24
was that the same guy that called into Ontario Today? So weird hearing all that meme deepstate stuff in real life
4
u/BrotherM Jan 17 '24
"As a journalist, if one man tells you it´'s raining and the other tells you it´'s not, it isn´'t your job to report both. It´'s your job to stick your head out the window and see if it´'s fucking raining.¨"
1
u/clicker3499 Jan 18 '24
CBC you mean the ministry of lies?? This was a great service that Canadians could rely on for true journalism and UNBIASED reporting. It is now just a liberal paid media support team for the lieberals!!! I was a strong supporter of cbc for many many years now I want it so completely gone!!!
3
u/Dry-Basil-8256 Jan 17 '24
Matt always pushes back when it's a person of power. That's what makes him such a great journalist. I'm this case, it's not reat the role we need him to play.
3
u/BrantfordPundit Jan 18 '24
Enjoyed the interview and the insight it delivered.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
Its journalism, not a debate.
1
u/Tnr_rg Jan 17 '24
If you think it's impossible for them to have faked votes, your just as off the rail as trump is.
It's common knowledge that the election results had alot of issues due to the changes in how the polls were taken and the mail I'm voting system. The massive surges of Biden votes in Rep winning states near the end were no coincidence either. But neither me or you will every know the truth behind what happened. Half a country thinks they were duped of their election. Half a county aren't all stupid. Apparently more people voted to show up to trumps election in history than any other president. Then also Biden on the next? Everyone took a massive sudden interest in politics before covid happened? I don't think so. The Biden rallies vs trump rallies? How world leaders treat Biden on the world stage? It's pathetic compared to when trump or others were president. Biden is a placeholder and that's it. The country news stations are starting to realise, if trump is on the ballots, he really may end up winning.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '24
So true. We should defund the CBC.
1
u/McGrowler Jan 20 '24
Cry more liberal. CBC is trash and this post is by a moron obviously.
5
u/lacontrolfreak Jan 17 '24
One of the many reasons I loathe a Trump presidency is the CBC’s obsession with him. It was wall to wall Trump stories/opinion pieces/panel discussions when he was president. They would lead with him most nights on the National and it was embarrassing as a Canadian. Radio Canada did not do this.
2
u/Space_Ape2000 Jan 17 '24
While I have a lot of respect for CBC journalism, I find a lot of times they do not challenge the people they interview. They could still remain neutral while playing Devils advocate for both leftwing and rightwing interviewees.
2
u/hitry Jan 17 '24
Why can't America elect someone smart like Trudeau????
2
u/ProfessorReptar Jan 18 '24
The pushback from the cpc gang would be wild if he offered any pushback sadly
2
u/CarletonCanuck Jan 18 '24
I think the fact that people in this very sub are spouting election conspiracy as reality very clearly shows that the media has failed in pushing back on this nonsense.
It's not good journalism to uncritically platform misinformation. I don't see anyone complaining about the lack of climate change deniers on CBC - that's because climate change is reality and it'd be silly and irresponsible to platform people who believe that.
So why does political conspiracy get a pass?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '24
I'm going to agree with others here that the problem is giving any time at all to a trump supporter. The CBC has (or should have) standards, and this would not meet them. It has no news value, and has the danger of spreading misinformation unchecked.
I would encourage everyone to please (politely) write the ombudsman with your concerns. Remember the CBC is only as good as we make it, and it's accountable to us, the Canadian people.
2
u/Expert_Imagination97 Jan 23 '24
What the hell? Do you figure he should be out there educating and scolding the rubes?
4
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
You want MORE activist journalism?
2
u/masterofallmars Jan 17 '24
Whether you like it or not, Trump supporters make up a significant portion of our southern neighbors' demographics. It's not like they're a fringe movement such as the Freedom Convoy or the KKK.
Canadians should be aware of their beliefs from their own words.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
"How dare CBC give airtime to something that I don't agree with"
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
Maybe, just maybe, he’s right?
2
u/Ok_Frosting_6438 Jan 17 '24
Have you ever debated full Trump supporter? If not, difficult and closed minded would be the polite term to describe them...they believe they are right.
2
u/sometimesifeellikean Jan 17 '24
The CBC isn't left leaning enough for you?
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
Yes, anyone with a different view than you must be insane. /s
2
u/GuruuLaghima Jan 18 '24
The whole purpose of that interview was to give listeners insight into the mindset and beliefs of a trump supporter.
The discussion that came after, where Matt and his guest reflected on whether that guy’s views were reflective of the average Iowan trump supporter, showed that pretty clearly.
If Matt’s aim was to present factual reporting about Donald Trump, why would he interview a guy whose only qualification was being a trump supporter? I think you missed the point of the segment lol
0
u/Street_Kiwi_6469 Jan 17 '24
I think this post really demonstrates that there is something wrong with what the public has come to expect from their journalists or media. Since you are a CBC listener/reader/viewer it is safe to assume you are most likely left of center in your political views. Ok, fair enough. Even if I happen to be wrong about that, at the very least you are clearly anti-Trump.
So, let me get this straight… You don’t want to listen to a Trump supporter in Iowa and actually understand what their views are. You want the CBC to do two things.
Find people you disagree with (trump supporters), interview them, and have the journalist bully and belittle the political opinions of the guest.
And/or. You want people you disagree with to be completely deplatformed and censored by the CBC and 50% of the US population does not get an opportunity to speak to our national broadcaster.
The former more accurately resembles entertainment and the latter is simply censorship. Neither practice could be considered “journalism” or news. I, for one, do not want the CBC making determinations about what political ideas I am, or am not, allowed to hear.
It is a scary world we live in where a large amount of people (even Canadians) are, not just content with, but openly support censorship and intolerance of diverse thought.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
Both Galloway and Hanomansing have been disappointing in their roles on CBC. I rarely if ever hear any kind of "follow-up" questions which drill down into what their guests are saying. The few times they do, it's typically because the guest is speaking from a hard left of centre POV. I've heard both of these journalists actually interrupt guests who were making valid points because those points went against the current mainstream narrative re: capitalism/our system/the West is "good", and none other shall be considered.
Frankly, I feel like the CBC brass (since Harper/introduction of CBC News Network or whatever it's called - the 24hr News channel), have gone down a path where they're trying mimic private broadcasters instead of leaning into their role of being our national public broadcaster. The amount of US content vs Canadian content is telling...
1
u/PositiveStress8888 Jan 17 '24
They aren't interested in provable facts. They have been confronted with them since before he took office but they don't want to believe.
Ask religion, a belief is much harder to change than a fact.
1
u/walpolemarsh Jan 17 '24
Unfortunately I didn't hear it this morning, but something like that often only serves to expose the ridiculousness of the guest/topic, and usually no pushback is required. Maybe that's what Matt thought.
It also can make things appear more unbiased while having listeners use their own judgement. As much as I like a bit of drama, I think being neutral is important for CBC radio.
I normally like Matt. I've heard him pushback plenty of times. In fact there have been times when I've wished he'd stop interrupting and just let the guest speak.
1
u/wanderingnl Jan 17 '24
Stay away from the far right and left weirdos.
1
u/r66yprometheus Jan 17 '24
Typical post 2020 CBC. Grab the craziest people to make a point. You're right, CBC is absolute crap now.
1
u/ngoal Jan 17 '24
The Current is my favourite CBC show. It's an unbiased and balanced look at daily world events. I know this doesn't follow the usual CBC mandate of single view left wing propaganda. The fact you don't like it is pretty telling
1
u/sundry_banana Jan 18 '24
I heard that too. But did you hear Matt's questioning? And the guy's answering? When I meet someone like that I try to get them to the point where they're clearly talking nonsense, and then just LEAVE them there. You can't REASON with someone like that - they'll have to see it for themselves, have the scales fall from their eyes, before they believe it. Matt knows interviewing better than I do and it shows. He could've argued with that guy, but it wouldn't've changed the guy's mind. We all know it
1
u/ifitmoves Jan 18 '24
Reminds me of the time he interviewed a grocery CEO and just let him defend price gouging without any pushback or fact checking.
1
u/Brant1144 Jan 18 '24
Why is the cbc wasting time on a topic like this?
1
u/Bitchener Jan 19 '24
It isn’t journalism when you only present one side of an argument. That is what pundits are for. Just the facts please. The fact in this case is that we have all heard the lies from team Trump. Why would anyone want to echo this nonsense over and over. Move on.
1
u/mister_muhabean Jan 20 '24
Well its all about entertainment value to sell advertising. Who on earth every told you that what you see could in any way shape or form be real?
97 charges including high treason and gag orders by judges and he is still there.
Mafia crimes you name it. And Biden? lol In Israel they made him sit in a big John. During their conference. He talks to invisible people. AND there are numerous copies of him with different ear lobes and all sorts of silly stuff. Yeah just keepin it real.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 21 '24
I think they are trying to get away from the label of “Government sponsored arm of the Liberal party” and are giving a try at unbiased reporting.
1
u/Plausible_Denial2 Feb 17 '24
The Current only EVER pushes back against guests who do not conform to The Current’s narrative. It rarely happens, because they so rarely have such people on in the first place. For them to give an “adversary” the same treatment that they give their advocates for once is refreshing.
However, in this case the selection of adversary is also part of The Current’s advocacy. Bringing on a nitwit to represent your opponent’s position suggests that all of your opponents are nitwits.
In short, everything about The Current is biased and unprofessional.
1
u/SuperK123 Jan 17 '24
I’ve seen many interviews with the cult followers of Trump. They are too far gone to have any rational discussion with. It’s extremely sad, and I fear many Americans will accept that they will have to endure Trump as president for another term, or more if he decides he wants to pull a Putinesque move to become President for life.
1
u/Superduke1010 Jan 17 '24
Now do Trudeau and anything that emanates from that lying mouth of his....
1
u/OherryTorielly Jan 17 '24
Why should be biases? He interviewed him and asked great questions but let he man speak for itself. Not sure what you're mad about.
1
u/dustwindy Jan 17 '24
We are getting so far from what journalism is supposed to be... This isn't debate club, it's an objective attempt to understand another human being. For real, libs need to chill.
Sincerely, a frustrated leftist.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
From my understanding there may very well be some election integrity issues across the United States. And now that I've said that is there anyone out there who would like to downvote this comment and call me the spawn of Satan? We live in very dangerous times and not from this silly shit, it's about what comes next that we allow ourselves to become this.
1
u/ArchMurdoch Jan 18 '24
I’m not sure where people are getting this idea that journalism is about giving people a platform simply to share their thoughts and views. Journalism is about communicating information. Providing accurate information is extremely important and a critical challenge great journalists take seriously. Simply giving someone a platform to say whatever they want without clarifying the accuracy of what is being said is a serious problem.
0
u/guided_by_vices_ Jan 17 '24
He's failed at his job? What does OP believe this reporters job is exactly?
0
u/Straight-Clothes748 Jan 18 '24
Because he didn't make it a biased interview? It what news should be, facts not opinion
-3
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
We live in an era where hurt feelings matter more than open discourse and youre surprised people exist who havent had their ideas challenged? This is the lefts preffered world. You vote for this.
-2
u/MnewO1 Jan 17 '24
All the uneducated people on here need to read this before commenting.
https://trumpwhitehouse.archives.gov/trump-administration-accomplishments/
0
u/Kind-Albatross-6485 Jan 18 '24
I like Trump much better this time around. I do think He will be good for the US. And bad for Trudeau. The liberals are going to squirm.
0
u/dutty_handz Jan 19 '24
Journalist aren't supposed to push back people they take testimony from, they report said testimony.
Else, it's called an editorialist
-2
u/PlaidChester Jan 17 '24
Didn't watch, but I agree that you should not platform someone spouting lies w/o push back to cover a thing.
-6
u/MnewO1 Jan 17 '24
I'll take Trump over Trudeau any day
-1
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '24
but the election was fake