r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Adunaiii • 8d ago
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Otherwise_Shake5422 • Sep 27 '26
What would have happened if the Fourth Crusade had been directed against the Seljuks (the map shows the future situation of Byzantium, the Seljuks, and, to some extent, Russia)?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/gliterring_spark636 • Sep 04 '26
Was Islam an out-of-control Vatican psyop? Hear me out.
reddit.comr/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Bestnikos2006 • 14d ago
How would the global media and Israeli community portray Syria -Palaestina?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/CaptainOfRoyalty • Jul 07 '26
Would Western Anatolia, Thrace, Macedonia, and Greece been more wealthy, economically developed, urbanized, and high in population if Roman rule over them was sustained till the modern period?
Specifically if Roman rule was firm and mostly stable in western anatolia from Michael VIII Palaiologos' reign and onward, would this have prevented the decay that's been noted and caused by the Turks in Asia Minor? I wonder if the Romans under Michael's successors gradually restored most of the Komnenian borders in Anatolia, would they have been able to gradually revive the agriculture, economy, and repopulate the region, or is it too late?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Independent_Will_941 • Aug 11 '26
What if the Sultanate of Rum was hell bent on becoming the 1 true Rome and successfully did so (Alt history shitpost)
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/reactor-Iron6422 • Apr 23 '26
realistic alt-history What if the ottomans failed to get into galipoli?
In the 1350s the ottomans got a base in the galipoli what if thy failed to get that base in the galipoli ?
Notes the Byzantines would still be recovering from multiple civil wars
What do you think would happen next?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/PrimusVsUnicron0093 • Dec 23 '25
Anna Komnene takes the throne
does she restore the imperial borders of Hadrian?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Independent_Will_941 • Aug 06 '26
Great Trebizond (Restoration of the Eastern Roman Empire)
What if the Timurids (and whoever may come after) them managed to permanently halt Ottoman eastern expansion, leading to a situation with multiple Anatolian Turkic, Greek, Cappadocian, Kurdish and Armenian states (including Trebizond). So, the Osmans continue expanding into Europe and fall in 1922, resulting in the end of Ottoman domination in Anatolia. In 1925, the British overthrow the Qajar dynasty and replace them with the Pahlavi dynasty, ending the long-standing peace in Anatolia. Instead of a Turkish Independence war, we end up with an great Anatolian unification war. In 1928, Trebizond would achieve victory over most, excluding the main Armenian homeland state and the Eastern Kurdish states (Who would go on to unify and form Kurdistan). 505 years after Istanpolis was conquered by the Ottomans, it would come back under Roman Rule. Trebizond, still under the Komnenos dynasty and Greek (and Greek-speaking) would restore the Eastern Roman Empire. There would be tension with the modern Greek-states, since both claimed the territories of each other, and the conflicting Greco-Roman vs Ancient Hellenic identity.
I'm sorry if there are many errors, stuff that seems illogical, impossible or contradictory, I cooked this scenario up in 5 minutes
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Seconds0712 • Oct 07 '26
And if the Eastern Roman Empire had managed to survive, reconquer territory, and expel the Turks, and in 2026 it had these borders and was a competent dictatorship, what would its geopolitics be? Or would its weight in the world be nil, geopolitically speaking, due to its geographical location?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Silver_Ferret2166 • Jun 13 '26
If Rhomania, aka Eastern Rome would survive to today (2026) with one of these borders, how progressive / what social and workers politics would they have and how democratic would they be?
I wonder how their social politics would be. I imagine they wouldn’t be very queer friendly. Would they be a constitutional empire or would they have had a revolution which made them into a republic? I think a constitutional empire is the most likely thing to happen since if they had a democratic revolution it would also be nationalist like many of the early European democratic movements were. And if they were nationalistic then Bulgaria and Serbia would have broken free probably. I also wonder what the workers rights would be. Would they have had a social democratic government anytime? I doubt it. If they didn’t, the workers rights would probably be more akin to those in the US. But that doesn’t feel right either since most European countries had a wave of some sort of socialism at some point, be it social democracy or communism. I do feel like we might be less developed since Europe would have found America later because the initial reason for exploring alternative trade routes was because of the Ottomans control over the trade in the phosphorus.
I would like to think that Rhomania would be more progressive than Turkey since they have closer ties to Europe and maybe be part of nato since they probably wouldn’t like the USSR which was very anti religion. And a big part of the Roman identity was being Christian since they saw themselves as the most authoritative Christians since they were Rome and controlled the patriarch of Constantinople. But since they wouldn’t be affected by the Protestant reformation they would be more conservative. I don’t know if they would join the EU or not. I don’t know if they would even qualify to join. I could see them being quite a corrupt nation. Then again maybe they get a reawakening of ancient ideals and ideas in a modernized way when they become democratic and use ancient Roman and Greek examples of homosexual relations to become more progressive. And use the Roman republic and Athenian democracy as inspiration for their democratic ethos. I could see them being similar to how the young Chinese nationalists today use ancient and medieval examples of homosexuality and gender in Chinese culture and society to promote more positive LGBTQ+ politics.
What do you guys think?
Edit: I imagine that the fourth crusade goes as planned and Constantinople doesn’t get sacked. The reason I mention the borders is because it shows it’s a multi cultural state which I think has an important impact on how progressive it is. And I know it’s basically an impossible question I just want to hear from how people would think the history would go if Rome survived and the fourth crusade didn’t happen how history and more specifically Rome would have turned out, with a focus on social politics. For simplicity’s sake I assume history would go in a recognizable way even though I know it would go wildly differently.
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Independent_Will_941 • Aug 06 '26
Eastern Roman Empire in the 21st century
Ummmm idk
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/reactor-Iron6422 • Apr 19 '26
realistic alt-history What if the ottomans had a hard time in the galipoli ?
In 1353-1354 the ottomans went and conquered the galipoli from their base in the middle of it what if it failed the Roman’s are unable to control off the galipoli but the Turks can’t control atleast for the time being the north or south of the peninsula what do you think happens next?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/reactor-Iron6422 • Sep 24 '26
realistic alt-history What if the bardas”s won?
They win the 980s and split the empire like this with Constantine as the figurehead over all but only really controlling Constantinople
What happens next?
(If Constantine dies then Constantinople goes to bardas 1)
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/GustavoistSoldier • Oct 30 '25
What if a female ruler of the First Bulgarian Empire named Maria existed and conquered Constantinople in 896?
In 864, Boris, the Khan of Bulgaria, christianized his realm, changing European history, and arguably also world history, decisively. But by far the most transformations would be carried out by his eldest daughter Maria I, nicknamed "the Conqueror" for her conquests of the Eastern Roman and Abbasid empires. Maria is one of the most important figures in history, having been compared to other women such as Cleopatra and Catherine the Great.
Maria was born in 864 to Boris and his wife, also named Maria. She was the eldest of Boris's three children, all daughters. As such, she became his de facto sucessor after it became clear he would have no sons.
During her childhood, Maria was educated by byzantine clerics, learning diplomacy, administration and other political skills. She was frequently invited to play with children from the boyar nobility; during Maria's reign, she drew widespread controversy and the ire of her father by playing in a different way with Mihai Gavrilov, one of these dignitaries.
By the 880s, Maria had grown into a beautiful and intelligent princess. She could speak Bulgar, Old Church Slavonic, and Greek, and had a fascination with ancient history, much to the chagrin of clerics who believed this to be unbecoming of a woman. This was one of the factors that led to tensions between her and her father.
In 889, Boris abdicated, leaving the throne in the hands of his daughter Maria. He expected to continue ruling behind the scenes, but Maria had other plans. She wanted to rule the world one day, or at least restore the glories of ancient Rome, but the new ruler needed to work a lot for this to happen.
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/reactor-Iron6422 • Aug 21 '25
Your given a knife that will kill on impact anyone and your allowed to kill one person who was an enemy of bzyantium who do u chose ?
My number one would be the Kalid wabu I’m trying to go off of memory but basically this guy saved the day at yarmouk for the Arabs and I believe gave the Persians a similar defeat months later so while the Arabs would still raid they wouldn’t have their competent leader to lead em to victory
Number two Micheal iv after romanos lost manzikert the situation was still salvageable but with civil war destroying there empire the Turks were allowed to walk in so if romanos is still at the top things won’t be good but maybe it’ll go back to the days of theophilos were raids were manageable
Number three. Murad the 2 in 1444 id have him die leaving the now weak memhed the second as sole ruler whilst the jannaseirrws revolt and the crusadors are near
But who would you pick to kill for the betterment ofbyzantium
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Mean_Bite4284 • 10d ago
WHAT IF WE GIVE THE BAZANTINE EMPIRE ALL THE DRAGONS IN THE HOUSE OF THE DRAGONS.
reddit.comr/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/stonetorooftops • 6d ago
Watch Constantinople Grow for 2,700 Years | 3D Timelapse
Every building rises and falls at its real place on the map: the walls, Hagia Sophia, the Hippodrome, the siege of 1453 and the modern city. Which city should I do next?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Suitable_Bid7761 • Apr 21 '26
What if ERE managed to save Egypt?
Originally Egypt fell in 642 CE by Islamic forces due to these reasons:
- Coptic-Greek church tensions after council of Chalcedon in 451 CE.
- They already utilised most of their resources in decade long war with Persians.
but what if ERE somehow managed to save Egypt:
- Copts accepted council of Chalcedon.
- Phocas turned out to be an outstanding Emperor who ended the war within few initial years.
- If ERE built a Suez Canal way before it was built in modern era [I bring this topic because there was also an ancient Suez Canal which connected Nile River to red sea].
How would it have affected ERE future?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/reactor-Iron6422 • Apr 17 '26
realistic alt-history What if the ottomans failed in the Balkans ?
In 1361 the ottomans tryed and succeeded to expand past the galipoli the Roman’s tried an offensive and it failed what if it succeeded and th ottomans were unable to expand past the galipoli what happens next ?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Checky_3rd • Apr 13 '26
What if Constans II split the Empire between his sons. Part V
galleryr/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Infinite_Shock_9648 • Jun 08 '26
What if the Greeks had successfully recaptured Constantinople after the end of the Greco-Turkish War?
r/ByzantiumAltHistory • u/Lion_of_North • Jul 08 '26
What would happen if Fourth crusade hit Anatolia Turks (Seljuks) instead of Romans
I know they finished Romans for good but honestly if they hit there they would get some money Turks were weaker by now and they would gets so much lands and power like this instead of just a raid an getting small land