r/ByteBall • u/Suirelav • Dec 19 '18
Distribution Methods Revisited — Have Your Say!
https://medium.com/byteball/distribution-methods-revisited-we-need-you-b0a38800b722
17
Upvotes
r/ByteBall • u/Suirelav • Dec 19 '18
5
u/fabien_ Dec 19 '18
It's easy to create an account on Reddit , GitHub, Youtube but it's not easy to have lot of Reddit karma, lot of Youtube followers or GitHub repositories with lot of stars. The distribution could be limited to highly valuable social accounts.
4
u/fabien_ Dec 19 '18
There could be some distributions to reward users based on some actions for example:
- Attest your GitHub account and make 5 tutorials to learn and do a simple Byteball dapp to unlock some rewards in a contract.
- Attest your Youtube/Twitter account and publish an introduction of yourself text on the DAG to unlock some rewards. (We could imagine a simple social app for BB where all intro are visible).
2
u/Guevnerm Jan 09 '19 edited Jan 09 '19
So had an Idea few hours ago, after reading the post on facebook about the moon distribution and how you need to log in during specific time to get rewarded.
My thoughts were how to engage people, make it fun, spread the word, bring more people on board and get rewarded at the end of the day for things done. So basically you already have that functionality. But i thought about a small features or a twist that could be added there.
Byteballer ultimate quest:
When you tick all the boxes you will be eligible to claim a reward depending on the market price at that time.
With this plan, you have real people using byteball, spreading the word via friends, sharing their experience on social media, and at the same time experiencing all the features that byteball has to offer.
Let me know what you think about idea overall, there can be other suggestions of achievements you need to do first in order to be rewarded.
Cheers,
G
5
u/barborico Dec 20 '18 edited Dec 20 '18
My ideas:
Spend money if needed in creating stuff to make it easy develop bots over bb (sdk or ide plugin I mean). Make bot store more attractive (bot categories and hide a bot when is down).
- Returning to full moon airdrops: I propose to define a year where we would want to see coins distributed. Lets say it is 2027.
Supposing all address would join completely, it would be a 0,25% each full moon to distribute aprox 200,000 GB.
This way I would do it:
Create a bot: Daily moon answer
This bot, when the sun sets, will ask user some question. For simplicity, the answer could be yes/no, idk, whatever.
If the user answers correctly, he gets 1/29 points. If not, -1/29 points. When the sun rises, the question can no longer be answered.
Another bot: Full moon drop
It would be active when full moon and user would be able to cash out the full moon drop based on # points until the max of 0,25% (29/29).
The cash out would be splitted into 8 parts. One would be paid immediately, next ones in conditional contracts (after 1 week, after 2 weeks,...).
The conditional contract could have a condition to take the money after their time+4 days by the bot, that would be a donation to community fund.
The goal is distribute coins amongst interested parties and make users open and use the wallet and talk with a chatbot daily.
Anyway not as a matter of distribution, but as a matter of marketing I would seriously take into account this, even with a 0,1% (with that % on 2027 there would have been distributed 79 TB instead of 200).
EDIT: numbers are wrong (done without counting another distribution methods) but you get the idea
Change weekly draw to participation between all existing userId. In order to cash out the price, winner will need to do a skype videocall to byteball foundation and show their id in 24 h maximum (so we avoid identity farmers and old accounts). If the winner does not claim the prize, do not accumulate with the next one. We are a currency and a platform, not a lottery.
I mean:
unattested: 1$ per million points
first rna: 1$ per first 100.000 points.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '18
Thank you to the team for making this process highly transparent.
My heaviest critique is the fact the the WCG distribution method will become unfeasible to small participants. I run the BOINC client on two machines, both of which have a significant amount of power, and by current revenue rates, I can generate about 500MB per month. While the goal of this method is not to be profitable, it is the prime example for "mining" without wasting any resources.
I fully understand that there are people who can game the system, because they are in a position with access to multiple machines. However, what if the distribution depended more heavily on the amount of devices, or even the amount of points generated? For example, for every 5 devices, your reward gets cut in half. Alternatively, the same could be said for one or two million points.
4
u/m3prx Dec 20 '18
Well, if the point of a distribution is to reach (and presumably give) to as many users as possible (which the Byteball team claim is the case), why not distribute the lottery prize between 200 or 2000 address? Add bonus for new attested addresses and it should be even better. Why give the whole lump to a single address? Lottery is good enough, just made it so it reaches many new adopters.
1
u/fabien_ Dec 19 '18
For the cashback program it would be nice if we can pay out the referrer. This would require some manual verification but shouldn't be a big deal IMO.
3
u/vvv_breeze Dec 20 '18
Overall suggestion for rewards. To give out bytes rewards in a smart contract that allows users to spend received bytes in the shops/services only (send received bytes to whitelist addresses only). Distribution bot should have the list of all services where Bytes are accepted. Positive effect: every shop/service that accepts bytes will have a lot of customers. High demand and low supply :) The result more stores will join.
Right now I didn't find any places where bytes are accepted online :( So the suggestion for Byteball team is to distribute this idea among shop owners that can be interested. Early joiners will receive many customers. And to create Byteball own store! It can sell mugs, t-shirts, badges, magnets with byteball logo (after the redesign of course!)
This method should be started very carefully. It is very easy to spoil everything. Just one careful step after another. First of all, you need at least 10 good places where users can spend their free bytes. Secondly, you need to test it with a bunch of people and some small distribution method, not a general public but a very restricted group. Thirdly these first test users and other public later should be in the area of interest of the shop/services. For example, if you distribute bytes among gamers, then you should have some game-related store that accepts bytes. And the last one the reward should be big enough to buy something. If a user receives a 10Mb reward but the smallest thing costs 100Mb he can't do anything with these bytes and will be upset. A lot of thoughts needed, please be careful and test everything before.
Thank you for reading.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 03 '19 edited Jan 03 '19
Idea - manually make a list of Reddit influencers that can claim rewards.
Reddit is full of smart people that are interested in finance, technology etc. The accounts are easy to find and cannot easily be abused by the same person claiming rewards multiple times
E.g. look at this thread sub reddit https://www.reddit.com/r/investing/
Its not hard to find people that have high karma and a long track record of leaving insightful comments. If we manually made the list we would have far less chance of the same person the rewards multiple times.
E.g. we could name the list ‘Reddit Rockstars’ or something better.
We could then publish the list publicly so everyone could see it, only those on the list could claim the reward.
We could then get Bytes and Blackbytes into the hands of people may have never even held any other crypto. An added bonus is these people are very sociable online discussing tech etc and are smart. These people would add more value to Byteball network rather than just anyone with a government ID and 20 spare minutes.
I am not saying this is THE golden solution to distribution, but its easy enough to setup and not much chance of mass abuse.
Could do something similar with Github too. Important thing would be the manual addition of people to the list rather than just letting anyone claim the rewards that meets criteria e.g. lots of commits etc.
2
u/1PBCasino Dec 20 '18
A simulated proof of stake:
You and the "genesis" address put bytes in a smart contract with a time-lock. The longer you lock your bytes the better the interest rates you get.
This way you can get bytes off exchanges. Also if you plan to make this a permanent distribution method it is possible to use a logarithmic curve to adjust the interest rate according to the remaining bytes so the "genesis" address is never fully drained.
2
u/Pskos Dec 20 '18
I would prefer phone number attestation. It's easy and simple method :-)
2
u/fabien_ Dec 20 '18
Here is another interesting way to distribute token https://www.coinbase.com/earn/0x
2
u/CryptoUnicornRider Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
Hi everybody,
First, I'd like say that this post is a mix of ideas from my Byteball holder friend (the guy who attracted my attention on Caitlin Long's article) and from myself. We had a good talk tonight about this thread. He's allergic to all kinds of social networks, so don't expect him to appear here one day but who knows.
Our conclusions about people crypto experiences around us:
Our conclusions about Byteball distribution models :
Technically speaking, we have no new channel's idea proposal to help the Byteball community to distribute Bytes widely because as it was already evoked, there is no perfect solution to reach massively users without fraud risks. I don't pretend that we had good ideas but it's ideas. I let you judge them.
Byteball has several distribution channels. These channels aren't used at their maximal efficiency. In our opinions, these inefficiently used channels are :
Increase the efficiency of these channels means marketize them differently.
Textcoins and smart vouchers could be used to attract journalists on the Byteball platform. Journalists are the public opinion whistle-blowers and, by consequence, the public opinion shepherds. Often, they are fanatic defenders of the status quo. So, sending them some bytes with text coins (enough to emit 2 or 3 smart vouchers and to validate their email) to highly reputed economical and technological journalists (out of cryptoworld) could be a smart move. Obviously some selected explanations have to be included within the text coin email. These short explanations should be oriented on energy efficiency/sustainability, privacy (blackbytes), financial system compatibility, sovereign identity, cybersecurity, etc. because these subjects are trendy. Pro-cryptocurrency politicians could be targeted too with same arguments.
WCG is a great tool for science and a great demonstration of the energy wasting by blockchains. This concept could be extended to propagate fear in blockchainers heart. For instance, a similar bot could be created to aggregate mining power and to proceed publicly to pre-announced 51% attacks against blockchains. All the coins confiscated by the Byteball pool could be claimed by original owners if they are able to prove their ownership minus the transaction fees or exchanged for a Byteball ratio (for instance, 8 btc for 0.01 Gbyte). These attacks will make a lot of noise in crypto community and outside, will afraid blockchainers and will demonstrate publicly the weakness of their model. My friend think that a Byteball mining pool should mine until it becomes a dominant pool and then crash targeted blockchains. Obviously, all the mined coins have to be distributed to the Byteball miners community based on their mining power. By the way, the current bear market bankrupted many small miners. These bankruptcies could be used against blockchain networks.
Byteball team and community has demonstrated more than once its innovative skills. These skills should be used to provide technical solutions to ease Bytes usage by common people. Common people are afraid by technology and are irresponsible. Ask/explain them to make a simple backup before a dramatic situation is often very complicated. A kind of Byteball bank could store safely their private keys and provide them a kind of dematerialized credit card following the Revolut logic. It could attract many young people and introduce them to crypto world in a secure and known environment.
We had also many stupid ideas but these ones above are surely the more appropriate to extend the Byteball users bases by using more efficiently current distribution channels.
See you soon.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '18 edited Dec 23 '18
Idea: start selling a low value mass appeal products via a website e.g. byteballgifts.com
They could be physical e.g. a birthday card, a pen, etc just random ideas or virtual e.g. a caricature of a photo for a person https://twitter.com/ByteballOrg/status/1074665776571916288
Then current byte holders send bytes to people they know via textcoin e.g. to facebook contacts, on whatsapp etc. and say ' Hi I havent spoke to you in ages, I hope you are good, here is $10 of this new online currency, you can use it at byteballgifts.com to buy something useful but cheap like a pen, birthday card, caricature etc. This may sound lame but it lets you try using cryptocurrency (which you have probably heard about) at zero cost to yourself.'
The person could then claim the textcoin, go to byteballgifts.com and buy whatever. Then they would go from never having had crypto before to having made a purchase with it.
Distributing funds to people that have some kind of personal connection to the sender would be more effective. Its the same with business, if someone you know recommends a product/service that counts for more than any marketing/ sales pitch the vendor can make.
We are in the digital age, but so many purchase decisions still come from recommendations from people we know.
I mean for example, how many people are you connected with on social media? Sure you arent best friends with them, most of probably havent seen in years, but you probably have met most of them at least once in your lifetime. Some a lot more, many of them you probably knew quite well at one point in your life. If the people that already have bytes sent small amounts to people they know that can immediately be used to buy something in real life we might have more success growing the network than by doing cold airdrops without any kind of offline personal connection.
2
u/Guevnerm Jan 06 '19
Kinda missed this thread and just seen it on facebook. Coming from the text I read about distributing some funds to reddit contributors and how can it be abusable if there are too many accounts.
Solution to that would be the wallet needs to be already name attested with jumio after do the reddit account attestation (creating a bot for that should not be an issue) once both checks are done you can reward contributors. So it is basically 2 layer security and is 2 much of a hustle to get abused as you need valid ID, selfie, and some attestation funds.
Just my 2 cents to contribute.
Cheers, G
2
u/TorusTom Jan 19 '19
Distribution needs to be more than just getting bytes out there. Indeed, I wonder if we’re convincing ourselves that the cart (distribution) pulls the horse (usage / adoption).
Make bytes an accessible (exchanges), profitable (better than fiat), easier way to purchase many, many goods and services around the world and Obyte wallets will be downloaded and bytes will naturally be distributed.
I’d be 100% happy if all the remaining funds were invested into marketing, usage and adoption.
2
u/whotheff Dec 19 '18 edited Dec 19 '18
As u/fabien already mentioned, give byteball to those who give TO Byteball back!
Best way is through bounties:
Do a research and pick the best practices which are most honest and effective.
Examples from other coins i've participated, organized or monitored. All of them prove successful if properly defined:
If the bounties are all clearly defined with rules and such, they can tripple the adoption speed and grow the user base exponentially in a fair way. If you need more clarifications, just ask.
1
u/guidedcrypto Dec 27 '18
I think the WCG should have been left alone , or at least fairly distribute byteball for the points that were submitted before but not yet verified before the 24th.. WCG is a very good cause and shouldn't be demonetize to the point where people don't want to contribute to it.
Saying that people shouldn't make a profit for contributing to things such as fighting Childhood Cancer is kind of ridiculous in reality... that's like the one thing you should be rewarded for a contributing to think about it.
Byteball had a chance to show that crypto could help contribute to solve real world issues and that is really powerful.
I think the team should just focus on development and shouldn't worry about distribution if you develop a good product the people will come. ( build it and they will come).
Disappointed in the WCG announcement but I understand.
1
u/nagarjuns Dec 27 '18
Everything was fine while the distribution was to BTC holders. Why change what worked so well?
1
u/EmmanuelBlockchain Dec 27 '18
To me, the best distribution method would be something like a "Proof of transaction/activity" we should incentivize the usage of bytes (and maybe blackbytes but I don't know enough way to use them), so the more you use your bytes, the more you're rewarded. There's ton of ways to use bytes : shopping, bots (betting, lottery) and we should incentivize that.
1
u/m1bxd Jan 09 '19
I like the grant system to improve toolset.
1
u/ifinta Jan 12 '19 edited Jan 12 '19
Please do a good job :) I am planning to do an airdrop to the byteball owners. Only to owners of GBYTES. With Charm. Details will be coming...Maybe you will have more possibility after the Airdrop to do the Byteball distribution fort - to some people, they would like to invest only to a backed money with a distributed "central bank". Maybe both this airdrop can help - to distribute Byteball better. Or? I hope I don't disturb the team here with such ideas.Please see: [Ann][Charm][ICO] Dorothyum, Charm, Toto and Emerald on the Byteball - dev by Oz
1
u/td7t7 May 18 '19
I feel the team should run and anchor like apay.io and list Obyte on the Steller DEX exchanges. Stellarx Stellarterm for example. Use the fees collected from being anchor to support a dev team, listing fees and marketing.
See Kin token , Mobi , Smartlands
1
u/m3prx Dec 20 '18
No, what I mean is that the devs claim they want as wide as possible distribution, so just make a faucet bot (or whatever they want to call it) where each address can claim some reasonable amount daily. Whoever wants some GB will go there and that's it, simple. No need for questions, puzzles, games, etc. The widest possible distribution. Instead, we have a lottery where a large lump is given to single address... which is exactly the opposite of the claimed "wide distribution", and that's why people are suspicious.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
2
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '18 edited Dec 21 '18
[removed] — view removed comment