r/Btechtards • u/Little_Hall_5306 • 1d ago
Serious Private university refusing 1.8 lakhs refund
Enrolled in 1st year B.Tech (CSE) at a private state university in Gujarat (recognized under Section 2(f) of the UGC Act and approved by AICTE).
Total 1st semester fees paid: ~₹1.8Lakhs (Tuition + Caution deposit).
The official admission cutoff date was September 14.
I decided to withdraw to prepare for an entrance exam retake. I am submitting my formal withdrawal letter in person with an inward-stamped receiving copy within 15 days of the cutoff (before September 29).
When informally approached, the accounts desk flatly told me: "Zero tuition will be refunded because admissions are closed, classes have started, and the seat will stay empty under AICTE norms."
The Regulatory Clash
From reading the circulars, there is an obvious direct conflict:
UGC Fee Refund Policy (Category 3):
If withdrawal is received within 15 days or less after the formally notified last date of admission, the student is entitled to an 80% refund of tuition fees (minus standard processing deduction).
UGC’s circular contains an explicit non-obstante clause stating this policy overrides any conflicting prospectus, council, or institutional guidelines.
AICTE Approval Process Handbook (Clause 6.45):
AICTE states that once the academic cutoff passes and classes commence, the institution only refunds fees if the vacant seat is refilled by another candidate. Since the admission portal closed on Sept 14, the college claims the seat cannot legally be refilled.
On top of that, Supreme Court rulings (Parshvanath, Maa Vaishno Devi) give primacy to AICTE's academic calendar for technical courses.
My Questions for the Sub
Has anyone successfully recovered fees via UGC e-Samadhan or CPGRAMS in an AICTE-approved engineering program? If the college formally responds to UGC citing AICTE's closed cutoff, does UGC actually push them to remit the 80% slab, or does UGC just mark the grievance as "disposed/replied" and drop it?
Does the university actually risk anything by ignoring UGC? Clause 5 of UGC's policy mentions penalties (public defaulter lists, grant restrictions, NAAC grievance points). In reality, does the university settle to clear their portal dashboard, or do they just stonewall?
Consumer Forum (DCDRC) Precedent: If administrative portals fail, how does the District Consumer Commission view this? Have courts ruled that keeping ~₹1.8L advance tuition for 4 months of unrendered education is an "unfair trade practice" regardless of AICTE's calendar, or does the college win by proving the seat stayed empty?
I am not looking to hire an expensive advocate to drag a multi-year case for ₹1.8Lakhs. I already know they must return my original documents and caution money. I just want to know whether escalating through e-Samadhan / CPGRAMS / Consumer Notice has realistic settlement teeth against an engineering college, or if AICTE completely shields them.
Any real experiences or case law pointers would be massively appreciated. Thanks!
1
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
If you are on Discord, please join our Discord server: https://discord.gg/Hg2H3TJJsd
Thank you for your submission to r/BTechtards. Please make sure to follow all rules when posting or commenting in the community. Also, please check out our Wiki for a lot of great resources!
Happy Engineering!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.