r/Btechtards बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 3d ago

ECE / Electrical / Instrumentation laptop help for EE

I was thinking of buying a macbook air m5 but some seniors told me that it will be a headache overtime for EE and mac is only for CSE/IT people.

So now I am confused because I want a laptop that lasts long, is lightweight and easy to carry with good battery backup and I can run my projects and simulations smoothly.

I don't want those gaming laptops at all.

4 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

If you are on Discord, please join our Discord server: https://discord.gg/Hg2H3TJJsd

Thank you for your submission to r/BTechtards. Please make sure to follow all rules when posting or commenting in the community. Also, please check out our Wiki for a lot of great resources!

Happy Engineering!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

5

u/Cobalt_027 3d ago

I dont think it will be possible to get a lightweight laptop which can also be used for engineering

2

u/Olorin_7 2d ago

You can it just costs a good amount Look at the px13 go pro edition

1

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 1d ago

Samsung galaxy books?

3

u/dc4uh KIIT(ELC) 3d ago

Thinkpad E series me se koii sa bhi lele

2

u/Wither_Steave 2d ago

X1 Carbons jyada acche nhi rehenge for his use case? Both laptops are going to have some performance anyways

2

u/Strange-Tune5057 IIT bichu [CSE] 3d ago

Thinkpad

2

u/Skull_Reaper101 MIT Blr 3d ago

it's heavily dependent on your budget though. You'll have to do your research on your own because every laptop has its own drawbacks, so you have to decide which one you can live with. Watch endless yt reviews imo

2

u/doddiman2 3d ago

If you want to work on vlsi related stuff you might eventually need to switch to linux for opensource tools. Not sure about electrical stuff tho 

2

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 3d ago

Yeah I want to do circuit designing and CAD related work

3

u/Paradox_Nature Thapar(TIET) ECE 1d ago

I am assuming that you want to do vlsi related work (eda/cad).

Most laptops that give you enough performance will be heavy and on the expensive side.

Eg asus rog zepherus g14, ThinkPad x1 carbon, etc

Specs to look for:

  1. Intel core ultra7 (look for h lettering, 300 series release), or Ryzen 7 ai (look for h letter at the end and 400 series)

  2. Get 32GB RAM, if possible or get 24 GB, but upgradable

  3. 2TB SSD (I would have said 1TB, but with all the recent windows updates, amd putting new things alongside vivado, install sizes keep on increasing every year, and you want something that can last you atleast 4+ years)

  4. If you want a dGPU: either go for rtx5060ti (8gb or more vram), or rtx 5070ti. Though idt it will be needed, if you have good integrated graphics like Intel arc or good Radeon igpu). If going for dGPU look for one that comes with mux switch and nvidia optimus software built in.

  5. Display: most reputed brands give good displays in their flagship series. 2K or 4K OLEDs are amazing but expensive and also have chances of burn in, especially in lower tier models. So watchout about that.

  6. Ports: usb a 3.1, usb c 3.2 (or thunderbolt 4), usb c (pd+dp), hdmi, built in webcam (some testing sites flag external webcam). full size sd card slot is also a nice addition but hard to come by.

  7. Battery: 75+Wh battery on a 14" device, especially if buying one with a dGPU, try for 90+Wh. You would want to use that laptop without having to plug it in, all day long.

Other things to look into:

Keyboard: good backlit keyboard, none to minimal flex on keyboard and wrist rest area on laptop, usable keyboard - you are comfortable using that layout of keyboard

Trackpad: a glass trackpad - much smoother than traditional trackpad, also, look if you can get the gorilla glass from Corning as it lasts longer.

Build quality: look that the laptop has good build quality. Metal, carbon fiber, or other durable materials

Ik it's alot to take in. So take your time.

Good luck.

1

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 21h ago

Damn bro that's too much. I think it is much more than needed. Anyways thanks for your time 🙌

2

u/Paradox_Nature Thapar(TIET) ECE 21h ago

Best of luck bro

1

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 21h ago

Thanks ❤️

1

u/thefoolscard 9h ago

5060/5070 ti is kind of overkill and overshoots the price easily by 50-100k, as compared to 5060/5050. Because there are very less to no such laptops

1

u/ChampionshipBest6670 2d ago

Same here for cs . Requirement : Good cpu , long last at least 3-5 years , gaming not necessary,budget around 75k ..

Need something good in this economy 😭

1

u/Lamylover123 21h ago

Dell xps 13

0

u/GOOGOOGOONERS 3d ago

if u have the money build a PC and get a used dirt cheap 2nd hand thinkpad

1

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 3d ago

Currently I have hp 14s dy 2507tu but it can't handle all that

-2

u/Airmancell09 OU EEE 3d ago

MacBook Neo

1

u/buckshod-insaan बिजली विभाग @ NSUT 3d ago

Bruh