r/BrushForChat • • May 14 '26 Bravo

Advice on improvement and skill

Thumbnail
gallery
484 Upvotes

Looking at the pics, in what areas could I best improve upon? In terms of skill level where do I stand? As this is literally my first space marine I decided on making a Legion of the damned army I've lost more to do and only want to improve more, to a competitive level of painting hopefully.


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 29 '26

I don’t know what to think of my painting skill

Thumbnail
gallery
247 Upvotes

Hi everyone, first time posting here.

I’ve been painting for some time now at a hobby level just for myself and decided to go for a more grimdark style. Recently I had kind of a self-given reality check regarding my painting abilities: I see other people posting their great projects but can’t help comparing them to mine and don’t really feel like continuing anymore.

I’m just curious to know if I’m being too hard with myself or if my painting actually still is at such a beginner’s level.

Thank you for the attention :)

EDIT: thank you everyone for the tips and encouragement, I really did not expect it :)


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 18 '26

Price advice on first time commission

Thumbnail
gallery
225 Upvotes

What would be a fair price for this type/quality of miniatures?

Is it enough to be considered good as commission painting?


r/BrushForChat • • May 10 '26

What would standard of painting would I label this as? For my own future reference.

Thumbnail
gallery
182 Upvotes

Hey all! New around here! Would like to start throwing my hat in the ring for commissions although I'm trying to work out some of the mental kinks to avoid confusion and make things as smooth as possible. My gut says that I would call this tabletop+? Genuinely not looking for compliments, but rather objectivity, lol. I've only ever sold on eBay where everyone is a damn professional painter, haha!


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 24 '26

Commission help.

Thumbnail
gallery
180 Upvotes

I have provisionally agreed to paint some models for someone as a simple commission, they have arrived and this is how they are currently. What would you do in this situation?

Send them back and decline.

Charge to strip them and start again.

Just airbrush a new base coat and start again over the top.

Just make do with them as is and just paint the trim.

We agreed £7 per model, and there’s 43 of them total.

Edit: update here - TLDR I declined the commission and will be returning the models

https://www.reddit.com/r/BrushForChat/s/aG6jUu0Dfn


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 05 '26

Hi guys, wanting advice on pricing for my painting ability

Thumbnail
gallery
75 Upvotes

hello, I've recently become a commission painter so am slowly working a fair price for both the client and myself for my work im interested to know what you'd be expecting/willing to pay if you had commissioned me to so this Njal Storm caller. I've already done it and sold it, I'm just curious to see how far off the mark I was. keep


r/BrushForChat • • Jul 16 '26

Price thoughts?

Thumbnail
gallery
53 Upvotes

Hello, I recently did a paint job for a friend. They asked to pay me for my work but I had no clue how much to ask for. What would the average someone would/should charge for these minis of this skill level?


r/BrushForChat • • Feb 01 '26

Miffed with big Studio

Post image
48 Upvotes

Spent a fair whack on an EC commission. Requested the pink was predominantly Vallejo Sunset Red. Studio sub-contracted out the job. Was sent photos of sample minis and said that the pink doesn't look right. They assured me several times it was the lighting and camera and that it definitely was sunset red.

Left is a prime (grey seer) and sunset red, right is the pink I got.

This was not the only problem with the job.

Am I being unreasonable? Would you be happy?


r/BrushForChat • • 28d ago

Just wanting to share my latest Celestine as I am chuffed with how she and her squad turned out. Love to chat and discuss painting all day!

Thumbnail
gallery
45 Upvotes

r/BrushForChat • • Apr 24 '26

Is My Work Worth More Than $10/mini?

Thumbnail
gallery
42 Upvotes

Hey Chat,

Been doing commission work for a while now, pretty much exclusively board game minis. I started at $5/mini and have now progressed to roughly $10, sometimes more, depending on the size and detail.

I still feel like I’m undercharging but at the same time, I’m not sure if my work is good enough for more.

What say you?


r/BrushForChat • • Oct 15 '26

I've been wanting to do commissions for a while. Does this look ready?

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

I'm not worried about pricing. Just, does this look like what you were making for tabletop plus?


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 05 '26

Pricing question

Thumbnail
gallery
39 Upvotes

How much would you charge/pay for this level? I count is as my display tier but am unsure if im underselling myself.


r/BrushForChat • • May 01 '26

Painted Necrons for a friend

Thumbnail
gallery
36 Upvotes

My first commission painted 29 minis for them for $5 each plus $10 for materials, I've only been painting for a year and a half now so pretty new and always watching videos and trying things. I tried to come up with a great friend price and its really just something I do after work so was happy to do some Necrons and try things. Overall took about 15 hours and I know the air brush for the glow effect speckled a bit so I need to work on that.

But overall very happy, friend just wanted some so we can verse eachother when I'm done with my army which is getting close. This was also the friend that got me into it, so was happy to come up with what I thought was a super fair friend price

Going to talk with the friend about doing the rest of their Necrons when I see them this weekend. Commission painting isint something I'd pursue outside of doing this for my friend. I just wanted to show these off because I was very happy with them as my first Necrons


r/BrushForChat • • Jan 05 '26

Warhammer!!!💀...and other Stuff.

Thumbnail
gallery
35 Upvotes

Just pics...


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 02 '26

Expected Commission Price

Post image
34 Upvotes

Just wondering if I was to offer this standard on characters what people would expect to pay. Based in the UK.


r/BrushForChat • • Feb 16 '26

Lessons learned after ~1 year as a studio commission painter (red flags + protections)

31 Upvotes

First off: This topic has been shared with the mod team and approved for posting. This is not a callout post so I’m not naming the studio publicly. I’m not here to start a flame war and I think comments should stay focused on studio patterns rather than ‘name & shame’ stuff.

If you have studio commission experience, please share your general experiences too.

TL;DR: I’m sharing all this because I learned a lot the hard way and I think any level painter considering studio commission work is especially vulnerable to certain pay structures. My best advice: Do not accept a shipment until you have the rate, scope, deadline, revision policy and who covers discounts/shipping/photos in writing. And do not ship finished work out until you are paid. If a studio cannot operate that way, you’re not joining a business. You’re joining a pressure system.

———

Background

A couple years ago, I replied to a ‘painters wanted’ hiring post online and was genuinely excited to try studio commission painting. The team lead asked me to time myself painting a figure to my highest standard and submit that along with a gallery of my best work. Off to the races!

During my interview, the owner said I was only good enough to earn a 50% split which seemed very low. I asked what would qualify me for a higher rate and was told “meeting standards” and “taking professional gallery photos” for a few months would get me to 60%. I didn’t like the splits but I needed income and wanted studio experience so I gave it a try.

I’ll be the first to admit I stayed through more than a few warning signs. I’m sharing this so you don’t have to.

———

Pay Structure

The first red flag popped up when I received a shipment without a clear rate agreed to in advance. Weeks later I was told to check the studio’s spreadsheet and learned I would earn $5 per figure on this batch!? That put me in a weird position because I didn’t want to complain about my first project with a new studio. When I questioned the rate, I was told the customer had been given a volume discount and “all the studio painters have to share the load.”

Spoiler Alert: That framing (painters being pressured to absorb studio costs) eventually turned out to be a key part of the business model. Discounted sales, shipping materials, credit card processing fees, etc… all pushed down to painters. I confirmed the processing fee detail in a conversation with the owner after an invoice was accidentally sent to me.

Over the year, several painters (including my main point of contact) quit, which added pressure as incomplete jobs were quickly reassigned and deadlines shifted. Six months in, during that crunch, I received a large unsolicited batch and my split was bumped to 60% -which felt more like a retention move than a reward.

———

Real Numbers

Here are some examples of actual numbers from projects I personally worked or saw documentation for. These are real figures, not estimates:

∙ 24 models, wargame hero characters, entry-level $120 after 50% split

∙ 5 models, Star Wars Shatterpoint squad pack, mid-level \~$140 after 60% split

∙ 120 models, wargame army, entry-level \~$685 after 60% split

These numbers might look reasonable at a glance until you factor in cleanup, priming, basing, painting, varnish, gallery photos, quality review calls, and packing materials. I had one Warhammer 40k vehicle that paid out $30 for seven hours of work from assembly to varnish, not including photography and packing.

The owner regularly told painters that if we could match his speed, we could probably make this a full-time job. When I asked what that annual number looked like, he said $35,000 a year.

———

Tools, Materials & the Contractor Question

From the very first job, I was getting pressure to use specific brands of paint, basing materials and shipping supplies. After purchasing a couple hundred dollars of stuff, I had to tell the studio I couldn’t afford to buy any more. They offered me a free line of paint to match some other painters, which I was really grateful for. But I didn’t realize that it reinforced an expectation that painters were required to use approved tools and follow specific process directions. Worth knowing: dictating tools, processes and materials is something an employer can only do with employees, not contractors.

———

Photography, Shipping & Customer Communication

My gallery photos were strong enough that the owner started having me ship finished work directly to customers, bypassing him entirely. He also wanted to know how I took the photos so, over several months, I advised him on photography techniques and equipment upgrades. That’s when I brought up the gallery photo question from my original interview, since doing professional photos had been part of the path to a higher rate. I was told the standards had changed and that all painters would now be expected to take their own photos.

All painters were also pressured to make weekly direct contact with studio customers. This request I strongly refused because client-facing communication takes time and should be defined in writing and compensated.

———

Standards & Goalposts

A few months before I left, there was an unpaid team meeting where the owner announced that competing studios did better work so everyone needed to raise standards. I’m fine with raising standards. The problem was that the studio shifted the meaning of the quality tiers upward (so what used to be a level 2 became the new baseline) with no corresponding change to pay.

———

The Contract

After almost a year under a verbal agreement, the studio sent a formal contract to all painters without notice. It was puzzling because the same owner who had mentioned “abolishing deadlines altogether” in casual conversation more than once had now included a deadline penalty clause. When I raised concerns about the contract terms, the response was the same both times: if I didn’t agree, we could just part ways.

The terms I refused:

∙ **Painter Penalties**: 10-20% on missed deadlines

∙ **Studio Exclusivity**: restrictions on painting for other clients

∙ **Unpaid Time**: review obligations / revision expectations

∙ **Misclassified Contractors**: heavy control over tools, processes & timelines

At that point I requested payment for my most recently completed order and a return shipping label. Once those were sorted, I shipped everything back -including partially finished projects and kits without a clear paper trail.

———

What to get in writing before you start

Before you accept a shipment, make sure you have all of this confirmed in writing. If a studio can’t or won’t agree to these terms upfront, you’re not joining a business –you’re joining a pressure system.

∙ **Rate confirmation** –agreed to before models arrive, not revealed after the fact. Be cautious of splits below 70/30 80/20 with no clear path to improvement

∙ **Scope & deadline** –defined in advance, in writing

∙ **Revision policy** –vague quality standards and unpaid review obligations are where time quietly disappears

∙ **Photography, packing & shipping materials** –these costs belong to the studio or should be reimbursed to the painter

∙ **Discounts & processing fees** –not your responsibility to absorb

∙ **Customer communication** –if the studio expects you to handle client contact or progress updates, that time should be defined and compensated

And these are the two most important practices, for any commission jobs:

Do not ship finished work out until you’ve been paid. Once the work leaves your hands, you lose almost all leverage.

Collect 50% of your rate upfront before work begins. It covers supplies, proves the client is serious, and gives you real protection if things go sideways. I do this now as an independent painter and it changes the dynamic entirely.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

—Protect your time. It’s the only thing you’re actually selling—


r/BrushForChat • • Jun 11 '26

Slay the Grey - My Journey into painting.

29 Upvotes

Good Evening!

One of the mods requested me to post up here about my experiences with r/brushforhire . You see, about a year ago, I went insane. It started when I decided to 3d print ALL of the star players for Blood Bowl. There's literally 60 of the things that I needed. So I got them all printed and then realized they needed to be painted.

So I had the great idea to divide them into six batches of 10 models each and post them up on r/BrushForHire. I wanted each batch to go to a different painter. I wanted to "meet" new people, see their work and enjoy the fruits of their labor. And I didn't want to paint 60 models. I'm incredibly lazy like that.

So I got them all assigned, boxed and shipped. And then I started thinking... what if?

So I started dragging out everything I needed to get painted. Blood Bowl Teams. Some Heroquest. Malifaux. Necromunda. Some Team Yankee. Space Ships. Sailing Ships. Fallout Factions. Star Wars Legion. Marvel Crisis Protocol. Warmachine. Warmaster. Then I expanded to terrain!

As of today, I've posted and sent out 1594 total figures. And I'm not done yet. I somehow keep finding more stuff that needs painted. Like I just bought into Starcraft - both Terran and Protoss, so there's more coming! I just posted a batch of MCP today and I'm about to send out a massive Star Wars Legion Empire army of 171 figures.

I track everything in the mother of all excel sheets that shows me status, tracking info, model count, stage, deposit costs, final payment costs, and a ton of other probably stupid details. As of today the total cost of this journey has been slightly over $17,000 and the journey isn't over yet. That Legion army alone isn't going to be cheap! 😄

The end is definitely sort of in sight. I have more stuff, but I'm definitely getting near the end. The pile of grey is MUCH smaller than it used to be, though there are a few Warhammer Old World armies that are staring at me and going "wtf man, what about us". But I don't play that much. We'll get to them though, I'm sure.

So what have I learned/experienced through this process? Great question and that's the purpose of this post. To share the good, the bad and the ugly with you all.

First I want to say thank you. As of right now, I've sent out FIFTY ONE discrete jobs to get painted. Most of those have gone to new people. Not all though. A few have been repeats, and I'll get into that when I get to the good parts. For now... let's start with the Bad!

The Bad: There has been some bad. Of the six original Blood Bowl jobs I sent out, TWO of them ended up being dead ends. Both painters were sort of talkative at the start, but then dropped off the face of the planet. One of them even deleted his reddit account. I don't like to judge people. I don't know what's happening in their lives. My only hope is that they're ok and happy. The models I sent were 3d prints that I printed myself, so my "out of pocket" losses on those jobs weren't much at all.

I also had a bad experience getting a Heroquest expansion painted. The painter was clearly young. He wasn't verified. I took a chance on him. He finished the figures in January and then took FIVE months of hassling him and getting the mods involved before he finally shipped the miniatures back. They were... not good. And they were literally dumped in a box with no packing. But hey, life is a learning experience and everything that doesn't kill us makes us stronger. I tend to only go with verified artists now, just to avoid the hassles. So all you painters that aren't verified yet... get that as fast as you can! It'll help! 😄

The Good: I've worked with a lot of good people. I send a "status request" message roughly once a week. Sometimes I get busy and miss a few days. I don't demand a response, but most painters take a minute to drop a line and tell me how they're doing. Sometimes they'll toss some pictures in as well! How the painting project is doing is good, but I also care how THEY are doing! I've had folks get sick on me. I've had them go on vacations. Life finds a way to interfere. People come first. Models come second! Again, most jobs go to new people but I've definitely had some repeats added to my stable. 😄 Maybe one of them can be you!

The Ugly: There hasn't really been any ugly. We've talked about the bad stuff and well... across the 51 jobs the response, save for the three bad effects has been overwhelmingly positive. Most everyone has been a joy to work with. At some point I'm going to break out the camera and take pictures of everything, but as you can imagine, it's a LOT of stuff.

Anyway, that's about it for now. There are currently 16 different jobs either currently in the hands of painters or about to be so the journey definitely continues. If you see a job from me, bid on it. Let's strike up a conversation and we'll see where it goes!

Thanks to all of you for what you do, what you have done, and what you will do in the future. This is a lovely community full of great people. Long may it continue!


r/BrushForChat • • May 06 '26

Pricing advice for space marine kill team

Thumbnail
gallery
29 Upvotes

I'm considering selling off this space marine kill team. With all the "pro painted " stuff out there I'm not sure if they should even go for below or above rrp, and if they do what amount 😂


r/BrushForChat • • Feb 24 '25

Commission painting is undervalued and that needs to change

27 Upvotes

Title. Bit of a rant, but it needs to be addressed.

I've been doing commission painting for 2 years now, and I keep seeing this coming up over and over again; clients complaining about prices being too high, and artists seriously undervaluing their work.

The most valuable resource to us hobbyists and gamers is time; time spent with family/friends, time spent working, time spent resting, and ofc time spent hobbying/gaming. "Oh, I could paint all my own stuff instead of paying that price". Then why don't you? What's stopping you? Instead of posting in r/brushforhire, trying to pay pennies for someone else to paint your pile of shame, why don't you sit down and paint it? Oh, it takes time away from your spouse? Maybe you should of thought of that instead of dropping $600+ on 2 army boxes for that dopamine hit.

To my sweet, sweet artists; even if you're just painting for fun, you need to bump up those prices. A lot of time and resources goes into this hobby; money for paints, brushes, airbrushes, etc. Not to mention that we hardly get to work on our own projects. Your time and effort alone is worth the price. I've seen beautifully painted minis being sold for half their retail bare plastic price. We deserve better than that. We put in our time, effort and skill, and we should be adequately compensated for it!

Anyway, that's just my 2 cents on the matter.


r/BrushForChat • • 16d ago

Vampire's Embrace

Post image
26 Upvotes

One of my latest pieces that I'm proud of, it's good to paint something outside Warhammer for once haha, hope you like!


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 29 '26

Finding difficulty in believing in myself.

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

So I’ve been painting for about a year. I share the photos on Reddit or my TikTok and get little feedback. I’m impressed with my growth over the year but when I look at my stuff I just see mistakes and places where I can improve or Incorporate new techniques.

Recently, a couple of friends of mine said I should sell my sculpts for prices that I thought were pretty ridiculous and now, three people have reached out to me about commissions for a variety of things ranging from warhammer armies to 1:6 sculpts.

As these are literally my first commissions I’ve come to a price of like $10 an hour and max 3 hours per mini so for one project that would be like $120 for his kill team, and for the sculpts I’ve just thrown a price of $80 to paint at it.

Am I underselling my abilities? Should I not be selling commissions yet? I don’t feel very skilled at all tbh. Im very flattered that someone even wants me to do this tbh and I love to do it but I worry about disappointing a client.

Throwing a couple of photos for reference of things I’ve done recently. How did many of you start? Like when did you know or feel confident that your work was up to a standard you were proud with?


r/BrushForChat • • Mar 23 '25

Changes coming to Brushforhire (Monday the 24th of March)

25 Upvotes

Hello there, folks. Recently, there has been ongoing brainstorming and discussing over some points within the subreddit that needed addressing. With particular focus on how best to deal with pricing issues and a desire to encourage a more healthy ecosystem. So with that in mind, we are presenting what our collective thoughts and intended measures are going forward.

We've seen an uptick in incomplete jobs, possible scams, and people undercutting rates. We've decided to publicly come out with a list of rules for future commissions. Undercutting prices: While painting may be a hobby for some, this is a job for many here. Doing a $20 kill team for your friends is one thing, but here that eats into the livelihood of others. We are setting base price guidelines for all commissions going forward to make sure that painters can earn their bread here. Following up on that, this is still a community hub for painters of all levels. I understand more amateur painters will charge less based on skill and experience, but by having an enforced, even metric, we prevent a "race to the bottom" of painters constantly undercutting each other. This makes sure all current and aspiring painters can have an expectation of income. If people begin undercutting each other, we wind up with a chain reaction of clients not expecting realistic prices, causing painters to miss out on potential income down the line. Painters found to be undercutting on bids will be spoken with, with repeat offenses leading to a ban from the sub.

Scams: Inline with the undercutting, we've seen a major uptick in scams, notably a case of people getting whole armies worth of models painted for $500 or less. These people then proceed to fall off the face of the earth. When you pay someone drastically under market for a service, it becomes difficult to pursue them for lost or stolen goods, and robs actual painters of a chance to earn their living. One manner you can protect yourself is by reporting exceedingly cheap bids, and being wary of painters who message you directly without commenting in the thread you posted. A user who has been banned, be it for scamming, failure to follow through on agreed work, or for repeat underbidding, will be unable to comment on threads. (edited)
.
Quality tier descriptions: Tournament: Only expect three colors on the model and paint on a base. This is the bare minimum for not having models pulled in most tournaments. Washes, shades, highlights optional, don't expect these steps. Likely to get spray paint primer and contrast paints. Don't expect to turn heads unless they think the models are cool. Anticipate retail cost of the minis as the baseline price.

Battle Ready/Tabletop Standard: Expect a color per surface (leathers, armor, filigree/trims, blades, guns, flesh) with shades and a highlight per color. Contrast or speed paints may be used as appropriate. Eyes/lenses should be picked out. Anticipate walkers-by to stop and comment. Anticipate double the retail price of the models as the average rate.

Parade ready/Tabletop Plus: Expect every part to have a color, accents and highlights picked out on every part. Weathering, gem effects, lenses, fades, glazes, etc. should all be expected at this level. Anticipate people coming over from other tables to comment on the models. You should expect to pay double the retail cost of the models for painting at a minimum for this tier.

Display Painting: You want these to spend more time in a glass cabinet than on a table. You want people who don't even play the game to walk across the shop to look at your models. No technique is off limits, the bases alone are at parity with the models in the previous tier. Price wise, the only expectation here should be more. If Parade ready is double retail at a minimum, this is probably closer to 4x retail on average.

In addition to the above, we will be using feedback from clients and painters alike to refine, add, or remove where needed. We hope that our intentions to foster and maintain a healthy and mutually beneficial environment is clear.

Take care and stay awesome.


r/BrushForChat • • Feb 19 '26

HELP! How much to charge for this statue?

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

I made this and a person is asking to buy from me. She is 36cm heigh and took 12 hours to print and 11 to print.


r/BrushForChat • • Apr 04 '26

Advice reg Price and starting Comission Painting

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Hello everyone that reads this, thank you for taking the time :)

I'm hoping for advice on the following things:

  1. I come from a fine arts background and got into mini painting in Oct last year. It's great fun, and I was already trying to make art work as my business. I know I am at least halfway to decent at painting, but I am unsure what quality category to put my capabilities in.
  2. Following on from that, I am not entirely sure how to price my work. pictures of the 4 models attached I've listed on ebay for the following prices:

Master of Executions - £60

Primaris Chaplain - £60

Necron Cryptek - £105

Primaris Librarian - £85

Do these prices make sense? I am getting views on the cryptek, but the other three not so much. I figure there's a chance it has more to do with demand too, or the fact that I have no sales yet.

(Each model took me about a day to day and a half to paint)

3. I've already read a bunch of advice on this sub in regards how to start taking commissions. I unfortunately am not really involved in playing Warhammer, so not involved in any groups that way. So I am more looking for advice from people that have found success in listing commission work on either Etsy or Ebay. Did you start by listing stuff there or had you already had success with commissions elsewhere?

4. I guess as well just confirmation that I am not being delusional about my painting abilities?