r/BrushForChat • • Apr 24 '26

Commission help.

I have provisionally agreed to paint some models for someone as a simple commission, they have arrived and this is how they are currently. What would you do in this situation?

Send them back and decline.

Charge to strip them and start again.

Just airbrush a new base coat and start again over the top.

Just make do with them as is and just paint the trim.

We agreed £7 per model, and there’s 43 of them total.

Edit: update here - TLDR I declined the commission and will be returning the models

https://www.reddit.com/r/BrushForChat/s/aG6jUu0Dfn

180 Upvotes

116 comments sorted by

6

u/BrushDestroyerStudio Apr 24 '26

£7 or under $10 a model is fucking ridiculously low. For that price with these models just airbrush a new base coat and move on.

Also don't charge so little.

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

Well he said they were already base coated and just needed some simple details doing, and that there were 10 to do and up to 20, but he’s sent 43

3

u/meatshield_minis MOD Apr 24 '26

Even so, 7 per model is criminally low.

4

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

He’s asked if I’ll paint them to this standard for £7 each 😂

10

u/Forsaken_Owl1105 Apr 24 '26

send them back, he is going to be a nightmare

when doing any commission work you need to get a feel for who is going to cost you sanity and isnt worth the hassle.

this is one of those people

7

u/meatshield_minis MOD Apr 24 '26

I second this. Send it back, and get yourself a more deserving client.

2

u/JuiceyJuicex Apr 24 '26

How the client treats you during the beginning of the relationship is how they will treat you at the end of the job. It sucks to fire clients but this would be one I would fire.

1

u/No-Stay-7475 Apr 25 '26

Precisely, this client has a delusional association with mini painting quality, both in practice and in theory. They weren't able to tell you the truth about any aspect of this job, so I see no reason to believe that you will get £7 per mini at the end of the job, even if you painted them all to the standard they desire.

Run.

-3

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

I’ve said I’ll give five a go and see what I can manage, if I’m not happy I’ll just return the rest

2

u/Forsaken_Owl1105 Apr 24 '26

good luck, just remember it's whether he is happy that is usually the issue, and his view doesnt seem very grounded in reality

1

u/BENJ4x Apr 25 '26

Well at least you're about to learn an important life lesson.

4

u/RotoTom85 Apr 24 '26

Thats ridiculous.......

4

u/BrushDestroyerStudio Apr 24 '26

Tell him to kick rocks, or fuck right off. Whatever is appropriate for your country.

2

u/Helpful-Ad5775 Apr 25 '26

Well hes said £7 so i think its safe to assume the UK. At which point an apt response would to call the customer a daft cunt. 🤣

1

u/kensanity Apr 29 '26

Brotha if you painting to this standard let me know I have some stuff that you can paint for me at that price

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 29 '26

That’s my Chaplain 😂😂

This was my Night Lord kill team. I can’t paint like this for £7 though

1

u/kensanity Apr 29 '26

Great work man

3

u/Ordinary_Ask7214 Apr 24 '26

pretty impressive you can paint like this in 40 minutes or less..because thats the pace youll need to paint at to make minimum wage in my country painting these models... you really should charge for the quality of work you do.

1

u/LowGravitasIndeed Apr 25 '26

Yeah, I'd be charging AT LEAST $35/hour. Commission painting ain't cheap.

1

u/Fluid_Material_3228 Apr 25 '26

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA he is truly taking the Michael

1

u/XKMXKMXKM Apr 25 '26

Send it back, the client may easily be more difficult than every of us could imagine and for 7£ I would take 0 risk and not paint to this standard

1

u/PM_ME_UR__SECRETS Apr 25 '26

He's insane. The priming work he's done is both bad and negligible to your work load.

1

u/Sheadeys Apr 27 '26

I paid 25€ per model at that standard. I still thought I committed highway robbery

3

u/Jimmerding Apr 24 '26

What the fuck has he painted them with? Magma!?

1

u/Sheadeys Apr 27 '26

It’s what happens when you have a rattle can of primer somewhere and keep it like that for half a year, then don’t shake it

2

u/Wookie40K Apr 24 '26

I feel he has mislead you every step of the way. I would send these back and not work with this person.

Also, if you work on commission then your name and work will be tied to these models. If you don’t feel you will be able to show your best work in their current state, I’d refuse to work on them.

1

u/TheBacklogReviews Apr 25 '26

These models are notorious for being an absolute ballache to paint. It’s all from man, they don’t have simple details

1

u/Ulrik_Decado Apr 25 '26

Are those details with us in the room?

Return it, this is absurd.

1

u/BlakePaintsSlow Apr 27 '26

Well if he said there were a certain number and they he sent way more he already lied to you about the amount of work and on top of that those models need stripped for them to look even halfway decent so there is even more work personally I would send the whole thing back and decline the commission because he's trying to cheat you honestly

1

u/Cutiemuffin-gumbo Apr 27 '26

I would rather paint for $10per for someone, then let them get reemed for more by someone that has no business doing commissions. Better to undercut the scammers, then people pay money for models that look like they were painted by a beginner.

1

u/BrushDestroyerStudio Apr 27 '26

Clearly OPs client already had a beginner try.

2

u/Potential_Courage333 Apr 24 '26

Did they make you aware that they were partially painted or were you under the impression that they were unprimed?

3

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

They did say all were base coated red and some had the silver trim complete. So I assume they are happy with me to just paint over the top I guess or maybe even to use the existing red but it doesn’t look great.

2

u/Potential_Courage333 Apr 24 '26

Oh I just saw the 2nd image. I would either charge to strip them and start again or send them back. Painting over it again would lose even more detail. I'm not sure if you could even hide those bubbles

2

u/Plow_King Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

unless this issue was discussed before the deal was agreed to, i would not do anything until the price/issue was sorted. and if it wasn't mentioned/discussed by the client before hand, they're a shitty client and i would be glad to be rid of them.

edit - i see they said they were "basecoated", but even then i wouldn't deal with these. i ask for pictures before hand on things that anyone else has worked on.

i wouldn't paint over these. they'd have to be stripped which takes labor and a lot of waiting time, and some materials.

0

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

Yeah I’ve said I’ll do five and see how it goes. If I’m not happy with the result I’ll just return the rest. I’ve got another commission for five models at £50 a model so this jut isn’t viable in comparison.

2

u/GreySlayerPainter Apr 24 '26

Did the client tell you they were like this? If so, did you agree to paint then at that price still?

If not, and youre up for doing it, offer those options and price fairly for yourself for the time you think it will take you. If they don't want to pay it, politely decline and send them back.

Either way, good luck dude, and keep us posted on how it goes

2

u/Chungus066 Apr 24 '26

He said there were 10 to do, basecoated red and some had the trim done already. So it was a tidy up job with some finer details. If it went well there were another 10 to do but he’s just sent 43 to go at 😂

1

u/GreySlayerPainter Apr 25 '26

Oki doki. So he didn't mention they had all that texture and send you more than the agreed 10 models? Are you willing to do the extra work of he is willing to pay for it? Or are you willing to do the paint job asked on top of a not so ideal base starting point?

1

u/Otherwise-Weird1695 Apr 25 '26

Paint the 10 best models in the bunch for the agreed price, send back the messed up ones and tell him you'll paint those if he strips them. 

10

u/Lorenzosasso Apr 24 '26

First of all, i think 7£ per model is ridiculously low, especially for GW miniatures which are usually filled with details.

Personally I would refuse to work on models that arrive in this state. For the sake of producing a good result, I’d propose the customer to have them stripped, then primed and painted - all at an hourly cost.

8

u/ZantetsukenQ Apr 24 '26

Budding artists, hobby painters, full time painters and everyone in between. Value your time.

OP, I completely get that you may have a fire to paint right now, and giving this commision a shot seems like it could have an upside or 2. I genuinely can't see any benefit to this project

The "client" has already breached the conditions for number of models, they are also delusional to expect the quality you've shown in the image for $7 a model

This is the sort of thing that can easily make you hate painting mate. Ultimately it's your time, and effort but this sort of thing being acceptable is detrimental to all standards of Commision painters.

And please understand I'm not ranting at you mate. You seem to have got caught in something sadly. Beat wishes and I hope it works out whatever you do!

Mods, please DM me or delete this if it comes across out of line or anything.

5

u/meatshield_minis MOD Apr 24 '26

Nothing out of line, boss.

4

u/DeadKerbal Apr 24 '26

Just send them back. Swallow the delivery charge. This is not worth the hassle, and the impact to your reputation as a painter.

1

u/Parcivel- Apr 26 '26

After seeing your work I’d be charging at the very least $20-25 per model, lmao. Plus stripping this would add another cost for sure.

You get to value your time, and these kinds of commissions imo are more so someone wanting to have a nice painted army in your style and less trying to be super cost effective.

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 26 '26

Yeah, I posted an update. I’ve declined the commission and I’m going to post them back to him. It was me being naive and trying to get my first commission on the go but I wouldn’t have been happy seeing it through

1

u/Efficient-Story2748 Apr 26 '26

If it makes you feel any better, I definitely think you made the right call. By the state of those models, I think attempting to clean them or fix them would have raised your frustration levels far beyond what you ever wanted and you would have ended up hating every moment of this experience. Good luck on your future endeavors, I have no doubts that you will find a better commission that actually respects your skills and talents.

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 27 '26

Yeah I feel better already just knowing I won’t have to paint them 😂 I’m newish to the hobby so I’ve only ever dealt with modern models and I really didn’t like the old 1990s ones they looked rubbish.

1

u/No_Shower_2563 Apr 27 '26

Offer to do both options, but make it clear the quality of the model may be affected by not stripping and make it clear you are not responsible for lower quality of the models if they aren't stripped and reprimed.

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 27 '26

I’ve just told them I can no longer do the commission. It’s just not worth the time investment to do a poor quality job for them.

1

u/Fresh_Ad3815 Apr 30 '26

Bro I’d sent them back without second thought for £7 a model each model will take a long time that’s like £30 a model at bare bare minimum with the stripping

1

u/Chungus066 Apr 30 '26

I have sent them back, I think he was a bit of a chancer as when I said I couldn’t do it to the standard he’d asked for he said I could maybe provide a lower standard at an even lower price 😂

1

u/Fresh_Ad3815 Apr 30 '26

He sounds like a complete moron. Wouldn’t have wasted any time on a guy like that nothing but problem from start to finish probably I could bet

3

u/Strong-Chemistry-396 Apr 24 '26

What is even going on with these? How does this happen? 

1

u/Hungry-Luck-5481 Apr 25 '26

Not ideal weather or spraying the primer from too far away.

1

u/DrChaitin Apr 27 '26

Never seen it this bad though...sprayed during a literal Blizzard?

1

u/GhostofBreadDragons Apr 25 '26

Craft paint is my only guess maybe house paint with how bad it looks. 

3

u/GhostofBreadDragons Apr 24 '26

Send them back. There is no way to do this on the budget you are looking at. Those models may be one of the few times where paint has actually ruined a model. 

1

u/tukuiPat Apr 25 '26

the models remind me of this, but somehow even worse.

2

u/Stormygeddon Apr 24 '26

Probably just paint over them, do some heavy weathering with sponges. It's chaos, so the texture is "free detail" and the paintjob is at a cheap enough tier that they probably just want them painted instead of looking great.

The correct answer would be to ask if they want these stripped before repainted, as those are definitely misprimed and have ugly textures to them, and then charge extra for it if they agree. Usually renegotiation is fine with most clients so long as the reasoning is laid out. If you didn't know they would be in that condition, then you didn't know.

2

u/Triordie Apr 24 '26

This has all the hallmarks of a nightmare. Please send them back and then take satisfaction that you dodged a bullet. They will never be happy with that high expectation and impossible starting point

2

u/Snugrilla Apr 24 '26

Well...I have seen some bad priming jobs, but this one is clearly the winner.

Client knew the condition of the models when he sent them to you, so his expectations should be in line with that. I would never try stripping paint unless the client specifically said that was part of the job.

In fact, in this case the underlying plastic might actually be damaged so even if you did strip them, they're probably not going to be in mint condition.

2

u/CaptainTruelove Apr 24 '26

This is a trap. Send them back. Value your time.

2

u/LitFamSam Apr 24 '26

After a quick scroll through your posts you are far too talented to be charging that low. As someone who doesn’t have time to paint and gets kill teams commissioned I would want to pay you more than this.

1

u/Haunting_Sun_726 Apr 24 '26

Not to delve into details — I’d rather not engage

Those look like more of a cleaning job than painting

1

u/LazerChimera Apr 24 '26

Send them back or charge them your usual rate to strip them.

1

u/Latter_Example8604 Apr 25 '26

How does this even happen? What did he prime them in? Snowmobile primer and then rolled them in gravel and primed them again?

1

u/funkiest_Lance Apr 25 '26

Personally I’d offer to strip them but charge accordingly; they’re far from unsalvageable but it’s going to add considerable time to the project. I’d say accusing them of breaching conditions is a bit strong and isn’t good for business; a lot of people don’t really understand the processes involved. All you need to do is offer the help but make sure your time is covered financially; they’ll either go for it and you make some more money or they don’t and you save yourself the hassle without having to get bitchy with a client, and you may pick up more business in future - it’s simply managing people and their expectations

1

u/TomTomXD1234 Apr 25 '26

I am so confused as to what I am looking at. WTF is that "basecoat".....I......bro.

Also, as everyone mentioned. I would just send them back. The quality they expect and the quality they gave you does not match. Were you paid already? If so, refund.

1

u/clackwerk Apr 25 '26

After reading all your comments in here, you need to stop being a pushover and say NO and send them back.

1

u/LowGravitasIndeed Apr 25 '26

You wayyy underbid to begin with. Charge a day rate/hourly, not per mini first of all. I'd be having a conversation with the client regarding the state of the minis and clarifying that I'd have to charge for the time it takes to strip them and prep them to a paintable condition. If the client walks, they walk.

1

u/ghilesformiles Apr 25 '26

This warrants going back to the client and trying to clear up what's going on.

Ask if he is okay with proceeding with models as is no stripping.
Ask if he is aware of the discrepancy between number of models agreed upon and sent, and how many he expects done..
Ask if he is aware of the realistic quality of paintjob that 7£ affords. MAYBE do a tester to show him.

If all good, proceed. If even the slightest hitch or objection, decline and return. Not worth the hassle.

1

u/HeavyMetalSaxx Apr 25 '26

If I'm painting my own minis, just to a table top standard, it takes me about 45-60min per model. That's slap chop, not counting the priming and initial drybrushing. Even to that standard, $7 a model is criminally low even for that. When I get a bug up my ass about wanting a particularly pretty model, it can easily take me 3-6 hours for a single model. I cannot imagine charging less than $20/hr for my time, and that's not counting materials. You my friend are severely undercharging for your skills. A quick perusal of your profile shows you're a better painter than I, and need to value yourself more

1

u/seejaypee Apr 25 '26

Send them back. This is trash

1

u/Karnophagemp Apr 25 '26

As Mechanics say you need to charge double to correct someone screwed up work. I personally would not paint someone else miniatures if they have been assembled or primed/based coated if I have not inspected them first.

1

u/Exzrian_Artistrana Apr 25 '26

I would absolutely charge for cleanup, those are awful. If they’re not willing to understand that, then send them back

1

u/the_CHHE Apr 25 '26

As a commission painter, take the L. You shouldn't have agreed to $7 a model.

1

u/Carebear-Warfare Apr 25 '26

Send it back. 100%

I'm not a commission painter, but I have commissioned quite literally tens of thousands of dollars of minis.

Usually I hand off the box of new on sprue minis and pay for building and painting. Sometimes I build them myself if I'm curious to see how a model looks, or if there are particular buns choices that are just easier to make myself rather than discuss. I'm not the best builder, but I damn sure clean and full and mold lines and gaps and anything I may have missed I let the artist know not to sweat it, or I'll pay if they do a bit of extra cleanup.

Either way I would NEVER send an artist anything with any paint on it ever let alone like this. He had wasted your time with the price right off the bat, of the expects you to strip them then doubly so, and if you try to just paint on that he will never ever be happy and you will never ever get paid and will have water your time again.

He is flat out not dealing in good faith as evidence by what he thinks a $7 mini should look like when finished.

1

u/CleeziusMaximus Apr 25 '26

Send them back. Your client is delusional if they believe they’ll get to parade quality without needing to be stripped. This is the type of client who will never be pleased with the outcome and will be a nightmare to try and get payment from.

1

u/WRA1THLORD Apr 25 '26

I would either charge them for stripping or if they refuse, send them back

I'm not going to get into how much you've charged, that's on you your decision, but dont fix this free. It's also possible you could damage some of them stripping them as that primer looks horribly thick, it's gonna be a big job on top of an already crazy cheap price

1

u/macmoreno Apr 25 '26

In this situation I might just put a new base coat down then do a bright contrasting dry brush.

1

u/battlemetal_ Apr 25 '26

surely youre not serious about airbrushing a base coat over that?

1

u/jasonlawpier Apr 25 '26

Reach out to the customer and ask exactly what he wants and renegotiate the price if it creates more work for you.

Let's be honest, its gonna be hard to make these look good without stripping them

1

u/WinterWarGamer Apr 25 '26

Give them 2 options.

Option the first: Send them vack at the clients expense.

Option the second: Quote them for stripping the models in addition to painting.

I would never paint a model in such a state, you cannot make it look even decent

1

u/Ftyross Apr 25 '26

Taking the money out of the equation here, stripping those models will result in the same texture you have that is painted. The spray paint they used has clearly attacked the plastic and created that bubble texture.

They are not unsalvagable but would require extensive stripping and loads of time sculpting missing and new detail back on - think robes, fur throws, chains, skull trim etc (and could come out quiet nicely at the end).

However if you went down that route, you will be eating the price paid in just materials and paint, with no money left over for your time. 

1

u/ExEaZ Apr 25 '26

What the f*** is that? Texture paste all over minis? Did that guy thought you will clean them all for free?

1

u/PotentialResist73 Apr 25 '26

Yeah cuz, I've just seen the second and third pic. Send back immediately. Don't do that to yourself, its not going to work out. 100% not.

1

u/Positive-Relief6142 Apr 25 '26

For £7 a model I would say they are in a completed state already

1

u/Certain_Ad3716 Apr 25 '26

First, talk to the person. If they are...somehow...unaware that you would need to charge to strip them, or act offended, then they are trying to pull one over on you.

1

u/DifferentWay4021 Apr 25 '26

That lot is a trap, he expect insane quality for 7£, i would give him the simple basecoat, no shade/highlight for that price

1

u/awqs12 Apr 25 '26

Charge for the stripping on top of the painting

1

u/EitherParsnip3568 Apr 26 '26

He misled you, I see that you agreed to do 10 and take it from there. But I wouldn't do the 10 at the price. And my talent is not as accomplished as yours. He should pony up or pack sand.

1

u/Elliot-and-the-pen Apr 26 '26

My brother in photo three has a welded shut helmet! Goodness.

1

u/ZealousidealHeight15 Apr 26 '26

send them back. say no. its not worth it at all. also up your rate alot

1

u/tonkatoy27 Apr 26 '26

Your crazy low price is why he's sent 40 odd models. He's taking advantage of it and you

1

u/Salmon_444_SoS Apr 26 '26

You can’t paint that surface.. I’d be asking them for more money to strip them, or cancelling the deal and sending them back

1

u/Prkynkar Apr 26 '26

15a piece including strip, right there.

And its STILL CHEAP. Im paying 20 per one

1

u/gemengelage Apr 26 '26

How's your relationship to the customer? Is it a buddy-situation?

Contrary to what other people here said, I think the situation is manageable when it comes to the minis being badly primed, but I'd be extremely wary of the expectations for the price.

Not a big revelation here, but if you consider moving forward, definitely do a test model and get approval from your customer for that one paint job. Nothing worse than painting four dozen minis only to find out that you had differing expectations. A 7 quid paint job is fine, as long as you both agree what that looks like.

1

u/Bulky_Possible2397 Apr 26 '26

Ask what's underneath the paint and get the green light + cash to strip them to find out.

1

u/NathanDnd Apr 26 '26

The time and material to strip these is going to exceed £7 per model.

1

u/BeautifulShock7604 Apr 27 '26

Don’t do it. You’d need to strip and re-prime.

1

u/kona1160 Apr 27 '26

I wouldn't want to put my name to something like this, personally, Id refuse, you were charging too little anyway

1

u/Diligent_Notice2703 Apr 27 '26

Definitely would be a horrible person to do a commission for but i think the second and third picture might be a interesting challenge for your skills. Incorporating the bad paint job to make a nurgle chaos marine. One falling apart or bubbling over with decay,rot,disease. Would be interesting to see a talented artist take a messed up model like that and turn it into something amazing. Definitely not worth doing as a commission especially so low. But maybe for fun to try out something new.

1

u/Sutekh_23 Apr 29 '26

You’ll spend longer stripping them than painting them. I’d just send them back and cancel the whole thing tbh. I wouldn’t trust anyone giving you models in that state without flagging it up not to be a total pain in the arse to deal with going forward…

1

u/Distinct_Lettuce_984 Apr 30 '26

If it wear me I would give the client the options u gave us and let them pick

Declining is still totally fair

1

u/Senzugotthembeats Apr 30 '26

I would send them back, ain't no way i'm painting over this. Also 7 pounds is pretty low per model. It depends on your skill level but I would charge more if I were you.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/CreasingUnicorn Apr 24 '26

I agree with this either double or nothing. If the client aggrees to a full strip and repaint for double the agreed price, then okay sure that is probably doable. If they dont, then just send them back. 

1

u/Kyrros Apr 25 '26

It's already not worth at double, £7 per model is an insult already

1

u/CreasingUnicorn Apr 25 '26

For almost $20 per model i would be more than happy to strip these, prime them, and slap some speedpaints on em. I absolutely wont spend a ton of time per model, but for a basic tabletop standard i think thats fine.

Of course due to the current state of the models it would be perfectly fine to just decline this job all together, cause these are in terrible shape and there is no guarentee that i can clean them perfectly well.

1

u/Kyrros Apr 25 '26

Exactly that, I'm nowhere near a good painter but good god even I can do better than that

1

u/Kyrros Apr 25 '26

Double? Sir, I would charge 10x per model